This concise and innovative monograph challenges a scholarly audience to think about Islamic cities in terms of space—to be more specific, the space created by walls. Instead of approaching the city from the vantage point assumed by most architectural historians, who assess the city's built environment from an aesthetic or social distance, O'Meara argues that his work “inhabits the logic of this architecture by rethinking it discursively from within the culture that produced it” (p. ix). In the premodern Arab-Muslim world, this logic, which he calls “wall thought,” emerged from a legal discourse preoccupied with walls and their dual function as connectors and separators of spaces in an urban environment. One place-specific application of “wall thought” was the medina of Fez, which O'Meara insists on describing as labyrinthine “in the sense of a convoluted network of segmentalized, interconnecting passageways bordered by tall, seemingly impenetrable walls” (p. 2). Although he is aware that in using the term “labyrinthine” he is echoing European scholarship on “the Islamic city” that has been criticized as orientalist essentialism, O'Meara maintains that in the premodern period “wall thought” consciously produced and reproduced such mazelike spaces and, in so doing, accounts at least partly for what has been conceded by even the most ardent critics of the aforementioned scholarship as a “family resemblance” among Arab-Muslim cities (p. 1).
In locating the roots of this “family resemblance” in Islamic law and using the Moroccan city of Fez as a case study, of course, O'Meara is self-consciously building upon, if also revising and refining, the very scholarship on “the Islamic city” that has come under attack for essentialism. Whereas earlier scholars relied on a limited number of works of jurisprudence to make pronouncements about the regulation of urban space according to Islamic law, O'Meara pieces together a much more extensive textual genealogy for “wall thought” among North African and Andalusian jurists, to which he assigns the shorthand title The Book of Walls. This 10th- to 19th-century corpus or “institutionalized discourse,” which included both freestanding works and chapters in larger works, “established a legal aesthetic of urban architectural space, with walls as a principal concern” (p. 30). O'Meara gives some examples of the kinds of cases that comprised this corpus in his analysis, as well as in an appendix, which make clear that the “party wall,” or the wall shared by contiguous homes in a densely populated medina like that of Fez, was the subject of frequent disputes among neighboring property owners and thus an object of preoccupation among jurists.
Not only does O'Meara build upon and revise earlier scholarship by increasing the quantity of legal texts used to study premodern Arab-Muslim cities, but he also refines the quality of such scholarship by diverting attention from outcomes to process. He argues that the juridical basis of The Book of Walls was the linguistically opaque hadith—lā ḍarar wa-lā ḍirār (“no harm or return of harm”)—interpreted through the lens of ʿurf, or local custom. That is, issuing legal opinions on wall disputes involved an interpretation of what constituted “harm” in a particular cultural and physical environment. O'Meara thus complicates the essentialism of the orientalist “Islamic city” by portraying “wall thought” as one of the most flexible of legal discourses; in other words, although the function of urban walls as connectors and separators of different categories of people and space was essentially—Islamically—important, the way in which that function manifested itself (i.e., the actual size, shape, and location of walls as well as the categories of people and space they connected and separated) might be historically and geographically contingent.
Although O'Meara makes a conclusive case for the ubiquity and flexibility of “wall thought” in legal discourse, far more suggestive is his argument that the defining feature of ʿurf for premodern Fez was the concept of shame, spatially manifested in the practice of female seclusion. In the first two chapters of the book, O'Meara examines the dual role played by walls in Fez and other Arab-Muslim cities as separators of differently gendered or sanctified spaces (screens) and connectors of such spaces (thresholds) in the form of doorways, windows, and symbolic portals, such as the mihrab in the qibla wall of a mosque. To do this, he cites examples from Marinid historiography, Moroccan proverbs, and the Qurʾan and hadith that display a recurring concern for domestic privacy and “threshold propriety” (p. 23). Indeed, for O'Meara, the basic structural unit of Arab-Muslim cities was the dār, or enclosed (walled) domestic space, and the concern with privacy and propriety at the level of the individual house should be seen as the model for concerns regulating walls-as-thresholds at the level of the mosque or the medina as a whole. In a similar vein, veiling among Muslim women should be seen as a movable version of walls-as-screens, “a mobile extension of the house” (p. 27).
Later in the work, after establishing the genealogy and juridical basis of The Book of Walls, he returns to this religiocultural concern with privacy, propriety, and gender separation and roots ʿurf, at least in its North African and Andalusian context (although the implication is that it extends to other Arab-Muslim areas), in the concept of shame. Here O'Meara assembles an assortment of theoretical and ethnographic approaches to shame to characterize it, like a wall, as simultaneously separating and connecting. It is the connection between people who share an understanding of what constitutes appropriate—shameful—behavior in a particular time and place that mandates separation (which may be spatial) to avoid other—shameless—behaviors. According to O'Meara, in connecting and separating gendered spaces in Arab-Muslim cities, “external and party walls signify shame” (p. 54). To corroborate this claim, he invokes a genre of medieval poetry known as rithāʾ al-mudun (lamentation for cities). In the examples he quotes from North Africa and Andalusia, a destroyed or decayed city is likened to an exposed woman, wall-less and thus shameless. There is much in O'Meara's discussion of urban space and female seclusion that will be provocative to historians of gender in Muslim societies. Although at times O'Meara seems to generalize from a very few examples, he is innovative in locating shame external to a woman's (or man's) body. The idea of wall as shame opens up promising possibilities for the historicizing of cities and gender (i.e., when a society's understanding of shame changes, so do city walls and the gendering of space therein).
In the final chapter of the book, O'Meara returns specifically to Fez. By comparing tropes in foundational legends for several Arab-Muslim cities, O'Meara interprets the representation of the original demarcation of the perimeter walls of Fez as a textual reenactment of the Prophet Muhammad's demarcation of Medina in the sīra literature as the inviolable space of the umma. Thus, the walls of the Fez medina enclose what could be seen as a macrocosm of domestic (dār) space and a microcosm of dār al-Islām. Recalling the dual function of walls, however, although they symbolize the separation of both dārs, the medina or Medina, from that which is outside or other, they do not close it off entirely. The book's final passage, representative of O'Meara's poetic and evocative style throughout, follows visitors to premodern Fez who, “although they might have traversed increasing degrees of interiority from the city gate to the main thoroughfare, to the side street, to the dead-end alley, to at last entering the house, they yet remained within and without. Opening onto the heavens, the courtyard's well of sky returned them to the entr'ouvert. As in an ever-receding desert, arrival was deferred” (p. 71). The experience of reading O'Meara's slim but dense monograph is, in a way, similar to this description of visiting Fez: challenging, at times suggestive rather than conclusive, but ultimately mind expanding, a “well of sky” and, in the humility it inspires, an arrival deferred.
