The historiography of the American Empire remains haunted by a fundamental paradox: despite a robust and steadily-growing research output on the nation's imperial past and present, its settler colonial foundations and enduring legacies often remain shamefully obfuscated, intellectually belittled, and sidelined into pockets of highly specialized research. Repeated calls by experts in Western or Indigenous history to apply the analytical insights and interpretative potential of settler colonial studies to broader interpretations of U.S. history have so far produced little enthusiasm.Footnote 1
The two books under review depart from this analytical amnesia and provide sophisticated and empirically saturated examples of how the settler colonial paradigm can fruitfully be employed to clarify major interpretative issues in the historiography of the American Empire and the Progressive Era. These studies complement each other in their efforts to better understand how settler colonial practices and worldviews not only influenced post-1898 empire-building abroad but also shaped the development of the progressive state at home through transnational learning and intercultural transfers.
In Prairie Imperialists, Katherine Bjork examines how military service on the Western frontier shaped the worldviews, repertoires, and practices of three U.S. army officers between the 1870s and World War I. In this deeply researched analysis of the careers of Hugh Lenox Scott, Robert Lee Bullard, and John J. Pershing, Bjork convincingly connects continental and overseas imperial thrusts through networked biographies in support of her thesis that “Indian Country—doctrinal and discursive—has been at the center of American imperial expansion and nation building for two and a half centuries” (4).
The book's ten chapters skillfully situate the analysis of frontier military careers in a broader societal context and highlight the cultural dynamic for racialized marginalization and violence. In the formative years of their careers, Bullard, Scott, and Pershing all interacted with indigenous polities across the Western frontier. They participated in punitive campaigns, commanded indigenous troops, practiced surveillance techniques, and accumulated militarily valuable ethnographic knowledge.
Much of this military socialization and field experience proved useful after the defeat of the Spanish Empire in 1898 and the acquisition of new imperial frontiers. It eased officers into their new roles as colonial administrators in Cuba and served as a shared reference frame characterized by the frequent projection of trusted racial templates on the new colonial subjects. According to Bjork, “In assuming their new colonial role in Cuba, the Americans did not merely take over the Spanish approach, they also had another frame of reference: the history of their interactions and observations of native American peoples as they encountered and struggled with them for control over the shifting frontiers of domestic empire” (136).
This mental framing of the tropical frontier within a set of coordinates derived from continental conquest intensified in the Philippine Islands. The three officers spent substantial time in the archipelago where the United States fought a series of connected colonial wars against a northern independence movement and advanced the conquest of the Muslim south. The study convincingly outlines how Scott, Bullard, and Pershing translated key practices of their frontier experience from techniques of punitive warfare to intelligence gathering and the creation of indigenous support troops to the distant islands. Pershing summed up their perceptions from his post in Zamboanga on Mindanao when he wrote in April of 1900 about his encounter with Filipinos: “They are really Indians” (151). While the book concludes with the three officers’ role, activities, and reflections on the 1916 U.S. invasion of Mexico, the story could easily be carried forward into the interwar period and America's colonial occupations in the Caribbean Basin. “Indian Country,” as Bjork observes, remained an enduring obsession until today's so-called war on terror.
The in-depth exploration of intra-imperial careers constitutes an impressive research accomplishment that students of the American Empire have been waiting for ever since Walter L. Williams first outlined the analytical potential of seeing continental and insular colonialism as interconnected phases of empire in a tantalizing article nearly forty years ago. While Williams's article has been frequently cited, few historians have so far provided further evidence for this perspective on the paradigmatic relevance of the frontier experience to the administrative, judicial, economic, military, and social engineering contours of overseas empire-building.Footnote 2 Prairie Imperialists sheds new light on these conceptual linkages between continental and overseas expansion and identifies conceptual angles for further research into intra-imperial biographies.
Biographical networks are equally important to Marilyn Lake's exploration of the transpacific conversations among progressive reformers. Lake advances the thesis that the shared experiences of settler colonialism made American reformers highly susceptible to innovations from Australasia on a wide range of issues such as electoral reform, woman suffrage, labor relations, and child protection. The study constitutes a deeply researched, thoughtful, and long-overdue counterweight to the traditional historiographical focus on transatlantic exchanges in the global outlooks of America's reform movements.Footnote 3
Lake's analysis focuses on intercultural transfer processes that are particularly useful to untangle the multidirectional flows of information and the roles of sending and receiving societies within their respective reference frames. Transfer studies are particularly concerned with the interaction and reception of knowledge across cultural boundaries through appropriation. One of the key challenges in this context is the reconstruction of the communicative process by which relevant and appropriate information is selected and applied within the recipient's cultural framework.
Based on the operating assumption that the shared settler colonial experience encouraged such transpacific conversations on reform in the first place, Lake has mined the biographical records of major players for their transnational activities. She introduces the reader to intellectual tandems of jurists, philosophers, social critics, labor activists, and educators and reconstructs those personal networks across the Pacific as driving forces of productive appropriation. Her analysis of the visit of Australian reformer Catherine Helen Spence to the United States in 1893–94 provides a particularly insightful example of the depth and flurry of interaction between American and Australasian reformers.
Some of the actors held no office, others shifted in and out of government service, and others rose to the top with ample room for political maneuver, such as the notoriously ever-present Theodore Roosevelt. His great admiration for Australasian reforms reflected his racial outlooks on international relations and industrial modernity; it also influenced his political agenda from the 1890s onward to such a degree that his 1912 Progressive Party platform was described by conservative critics as a mere “… rehash of policies long in vogue in Australia and New Zealand” (7).
Sometimes such productive appropriations also produced contradictory results, as in the case of electoral reform. In this context, Australia's advances in combating voting fraud and corruption were widely admired by many contemporaries in the United States. Since the mid-nineteenth century, self-governing colonies in Australia had used official, government-printed ballots that were authenticated by electoral officials and distributed at polling stations. By the late nineteenth century, more than 90 percent of U.S. states had adopted this practice—not exclusively to contain voting fraud, but also to disenfranchise lesser educated voters “… because, as a printed form, the technology enabled states to exclude illiterate and ill-educated voters—notably African Americans and many of the millions of newly arrived immigrants—from exercising the franchise” (77–78). As Lake observes, “Progressive reforms could have profoundly undemocratic outcomes” (6).
Unfortunately, Lake's discussion of child protection measures weakens her important intervention that “understanding progressivism in the framework of settler colonialism helps explain its constitutive contradictions …” (174). In tracing the debates over appropriate strategies to nurture dependent and neglected children by keeping families together, the study explores how Australian “boarding out schemes” informed the development of the mother's pension movement in the United States. In this context, the chapter also interweaves the fate of indigenous children and notes the irony that while reformers in both countries objected to the destruction of Anglo-Saxon families through child removal, such practices remained the standard for indigenous and aboriginal families. While Lake discusses the violence of such forced acculturation schemes, she could have further strengthened her argument about the paradigmatic relevance of shared settler colonial histories by exploring transpacific conversations on such practices in newcomer-indigenous relations.
Finally, the book's exploration of indigenous progressive responses to settler colonialism misses a fabulous opportunity to examine transnational networks of anti-colonial resistance, for example, through an analysis of interactions between the Society of American Indians and the Australian Aboriginal Progressive Association rather than a side-by-side delineation of their respective activities.
Despite those criticisms, Progressive New World provides ample evidence for the centrality of settler colonialism to progressive reform. Read in conjunction with Bjork's analysis of the colonial frontier in military worldviews, both studies substantially enhance our understanding of how “Indian Country” and settler colonial outlooks informed America's empire-building abroad and progressive reform at home. They challenge the traditional chronological segmentation in the historiography of the American Empire, complicate the analytical separation between empire and nation-state formation through a multitude of conceptual overlaps, present evidence and texture for the transnational and trans-imperial contextualization of U.S. history, and provide multiple signposts to guide future research. While paradigmatic adjustments take time, both studies add important weight to the slowly gathering critical mass, designed to end the persistent obfuscation of America's settler colonial past.
