In the past few years, there has been increased scholarly interest in the role theatre played in shaping black identity during the Harlem Renaissance. However, few theatre historians have looked at what role religion played in encouraging early twentieth-century black playwrights to challenge distorted and essentialist views of blackness and black folks. In Staging Faith, Craig R. Prentiss reveals how black playwrights dramaturgically used religious life to respond to race and class disparities in urban black communities. These playwrights had varying responses to social issues such as urban migration, violence against black bodies, and racial uplift. Prentiss contends that investigating the impact of religion on black playwrights and their artistic response therein will provide historians with greater insight into the relationship between black identity and cultural expressions in early twentieth-century black society.
Prentiss establishes postmigration class division as a major point of contention for early twentieth-century black playwrights seeking to encourage rural blacks in urban cities to adapt to life in the North. Prentiss contends that this rupture in social class is caused by divisive cultural practices that hinge on maintaining a black identity that is rooted in urban black elitism. Religion becomes a recognizable foil to Progressive Era black playwrights who are college educated and count themselves as part of the urban black elite. As he pursues this claim throughout the book, Prentiss provides readers with a context on why many black playwrights recognized but rejected black religious life.
His analysis begins with how white playwrights used religion to characterize black culture, characterizations that still harm black folks today. Prentiss notes that white playwrights such as Eugene O'Neill, Paul Green, and Marc Connelly saw themselves writing about African Americans in a positive way. Although it was never their intention to essentialize or mock black culture, white playwrights characterized black religious practices as supernatural and exotic, and black characters as simple, overtly pious, and cultish. Other critics have explored this area of contention, but Prentiss contributes something significant to this scholarly discussion by revealing that black playwrights encountered similar generalities in their own attempt to articulate racial uplift. Black playwrights often responded to the expectation of black and white audiences, and painted essentialist notions of black religious life with a broad stroke in their scripts. According to Prentiss, however, “their scripts often spoke directly to African American audiences about religion's place in black life, even while at times satisfying the expectations of white audiences with the music, expression, and cadences of an approach to religion that these [black] authors were often simultaneously undermining” (37). In each chapter, Prentiss recognizes early twentieth-century black playwrights' urgency to raise the consciousness of black and white audiences as a double-edged sword. On the one hand, these playwrights saw religion (primarily Christianity) as a hindrance to black equality, while on the other they dramaturgically used the appeal of theology to reveal fallacies in black religious life as well as black social progress.
Throughout the book, Prentiss highlights several ways theological and antitheological discourses are used as dramaturgical approaches to encourage white and black audiences to recognize the complexities of black life. Black playwrights such as Angelina Weld Grimké, Georgia Douglas Johnson, and Regina Andrews wrote antilynching plays that reflected a growing dissonance between how some Christian African Americans perceived themselves as God's chosen people, liberated from slavery, and the violent reality of daily life. Prentiss reflects on how these playwrights acknowledge the existence of God as corporal, yet ultimately suggest that God is ineffective or unwilling with regard to healing the suffering of African Americans. In these plays black identity is at the precipice over an abyss. The looming terror and doom that befalls black characters of faith reflects the ideologies of black playwrights. A disconnect between faith and reality is played out in real life as some early twentieth-century black playwrights propagate education as the one true God, embracing humanism over religion. The book includes several photographic portraits of black playwrights that cast an eerie presence across the pages when viewed alongside Prentiss's analysis of their plays. Their faces express the struggle to accept a God they no longer believe in and to live in a society that profits ill-intentionally from their cultural experiences.
Prentiss delivers a remarkable analysis of early twentieth-century black religious drama. It is a much-needed addition to the existing scholarly work being done in multiple disciplines on critical black discourses. For theatre studies this work is especially exciting, as it shows how early twentieth-century black playwrights used religion as a dramaturgical tool for progressive racial uplift. Prentiss's chapter on black playwrights who supported Christian theodicy in their texts seems more like an afterthought: he devotes one chapter to this topic compared to the three chapters on black playwrights who wrestled with Christian theodicy. Nonetheless, this analysis is a must-read for theatre historians and black studies scholars alike.
