This Routledge handbook on diet and nutrition in the Roman world, edited by Paul Erdkamp and Claire Holleran, is certainly not the first companion to appear on food in Classical Antiquity.Footnote 1 But while those earlier volumes were more focused on the socio-cultural, religious, medicinal, and culinary aspects of food in the ancient world, this manual is the first to center so explicitly on dietary variation (as shaped by status, age, gender, ideology, geography, etc.) and its nutritional implications (where and how did diets improve?).Footnote 2 It is also the first book to deal exclusively with the Roman world, which makes it long overdue, in my opinion. The most enriching facet of the handbook, however, is the editors’ clear and consistent choice for a holistic approach to these matters. This multidisciplinarity is necessary because all sources are, in the end, distorted in one way or another – e.g., the elite male focus of the literary evidence, the uneven coverage of archaeological research, the varying survival rates of botanical and faunal remains, or the complex correlation between bioarchaeological markers and diet – and no dataset by itself can give us the nuanced and comprehensive picture of the Roman diet that we historians and archaeologists seek to reconstruct. A composite approach is also required to ask more ambitious questions that go beyond the strict (if seminal) study of individual and collective eating habits, as food and nutrition are closely intertwined with wider demographic and economic processes that determined the course of Roman history. These are then the main topics and developments in the field to which Erdkamp and Holleran aim to provide an authoritative guide.
The introduction is clear in foregrounding these aims, and expertly sets the stage through a succinct overview of past food studies and a lucid vision of how the individual chapters as a whole serve to build this new, pertinent approach to Roman nutrition and dietetics. To this end, Erdkamp and Holleran have assembled 23 leading scholars (including themselves), who in as many essays address the following 5 themes: “Evidence and methodology” (6 papers), “Food and drink” (7 papers), “Peoples and identities” (5 papers), “A forum on energy, malnutrition and stature” (3 papers), and “Food on the market and in politics” (2 papers). My review will deal with each in turn.
Evidence and methodology
The book starts with a section on the many ways and means for studying the Roman diet, as there are texts (K. Beerden), images (S. D. O'Connell), artifacts (L. M. Banducci), plant remains (A. Livarda), animal bones (P. Halstead), and human dental and skeleton data (C. Bourbou). All contributors do a fine job in introducing the reader to the various categories of evidence and their analytical procedures, even if some attain more coverage and detail in their arguments than others. A few quibbles on chapter level are worth addressing. First, one might regret Livarda's patchy focus on the Roman era in her discussion of archaeobotanical data – only pages 61–62 deal explicitly with Roman plant assemblages – but, as pointed out by Livarda herself, this is mostly a matter of limited data availability, especially for the Mediterranean. Still, I had hoped to find a reference to the groundbreaking BRAIN initiative (Botanical Records of Archaeobotany Italian Network), a new database of archaeological sites in Italy with pollen and macro-remains, as this represents exactly the type of integrated approach that Livarda considers necessary to move the discipline forward.Footnote 3 A similar remark could be made regarding Bourbou's review of stable isotope studies – including a recommendable piece on the possibilities and limitations of this kind of data (83–84) – which ignores some important recent workFootnote 4 and above all the appearance of IsoArch, a web-based platform for isotopic data from the Greco-Roman world.Footnote 5 Having said that, stable isotope analysis is a rapidly expanding field in Roman archaeology and I suspect that these hiatuses are mostly the result of the long production process of the book. I frowned a bit more upon Banducci's firm dismissal of the large-scale use of wood in the production of artifacts for eating and drinking, contrary to what happened in the pottery, glass, and metal industry. Data biases simply do not allow for accurately assessing the importance of wooden vessels in urban and rural households, especially among the poor, and even more so in the heavily wooded northern parts of the Roman Empire. Then there is also the poor quality of the illustrations in the volume, and nowhere is this felt more strongly than in O'Connell's overview of the visual media (paintings, mosaics, sculpture), which would have benefited immensely from more and better images.
On balance, however, the section as a whole is a competent survey of the available source materials and, just as importantly, a useful and undogmatic guide on how to investigate them: with an eye for their original meaning and function (distinctly so in Beerden's treatment of textual genres), always alert to their inherent biases (at the forefront of Halstead's essay on zooarchaeology), and best integrated with other classes of evidence. This first part therefore lays the methodological groundwork for much of what is said on food and beverages in the following sections.
Food and drink
You can always count on J. Donahue for an authoritative take on the manifold vocabulary and setting of Roman meals. Here, he offers a persuasive (if rather short) illustration of how much eating and drinking actually took place outdoors, especially among the urban lower classes. His transitional chapter opens the door to the bulk of this second part, which is devoted to a review of the main components of the Roman diet: that is, cereals (F. Heinrich), pulses (F. Heinrich and A. M. Hansen), olives (E. Rowan), wine (W. Broekaert), meat (M. MacKinnon), and fish (A. Marzano). The most rewarding papers of the bunch are those written by Heinrich and Hansen, who through their focus on biochemistry, taxonomy, and nutritional aspects contribute much to a long-due reappraisal of cereals (as a varied and healthy staple) and pulses (as a potentially important dietary supplement). The study of macro- and micronutrient properties in olives and olive oil (135–38) is also the strongest part of Rowan's chapter. Despite not being a specialist in the field, Broekaert explains well the nature of Roman wine consumption, and rightly stresses the large number of other, often bypassed beverages that existed in the Roman world, among which were many grape-based drinks, beer, milk, and water.Footnote 6 One could surely extend this argument, and explore the caloric and nutritional values of, for example, the large number of ‘artificial wines’ made from fruits, vegetables, flowers, herbs and shrubs listed by Pliny.Footnote 7
As usual, Mackinnon delivers a sound examination of the place of meat in the Roman diet, as evidenced in the textual and animal bone record, but I would have liked to see a more prominent discussion of the contested importance of beef (and cow milk) consumption. The focus is now very much on the traditional (overestimated) role of pigs.Footnote 8 Food availability and dietary variation in relation to status and location is a core theme of the section, and the key role of (bio)archaeology herein is best demonstrated in Marzano's closing essay on seafood. She advances an interesting argument on the contribution of oysters and mussels to the diet in the Roman north (Gaul and Britain) (172), but regrettably does not delve deeper into the nutritional effects of her claims (mollusks are full of protein, vitamins, and minerals).
Overall, relatively little attention is devoted in this section to the specific caloric contents and volumes of food consumption (exceptions are Rowan, 135–38, and Broekaert, 144–45). This is unfortunate, as such inquiries can add much to our understanding of daily eating habits and dietary proportions.Footnote 9 Such minor remarks set aside, however, all chapters ultimately make for a thorough and balanced appraisal of the various kinds and qualities of food that people had access to in the Roman world.
Peoples and identities
The next section continues to explore the diversity of the Roman diet, as influenced by gender, age, geography, and ethno-cultural background. The chapters in this part can roughly be divided into two groups. On the one hand there are those that question how being female or non-adult (C. Laes), Jewish (D. Kraemer), or Christian (E. Raga) made a difference in terms of what people ate. For all of these categories, the evidence on food regimes is scanty and almost exclusively textual in nature. This largely explains the more traditional, descriptive approach that links these essays in method and style. Also, what can be said about their respective diets is much biased by the perspective of our sources: dominantly male and often Roman-centric. This inevitably makes these papers more about what these groups could not eat rather than what they did eat, and perhaps more contemplative and abstract than one would like. Still, the perseverant reader will find much intellectual stimulation in the authors’ masterly reflections on how societal hierarchies (for women and children), as well as religious, communal, and personal attitudes (e.g., for those Jews who refused to eat pork, or dine with their neighbors; or for Christians who dismissed the culinary pleasures of food) shaped the daily meals of many people in the Roman world. Admittedly, with respect to infant feeding practices and the diet of early Christian communities in Rome, I expected a somewhat deeper (and more critical) interaction with the recent results in bioarchaeology, at least for a contemporary handbook on diet and nutrition.Footnote 10 It is also unfortunate, in my view, that Kraemer considerably weakens his own case by stressing how the diet of many Jews must have been virtually identical to what everybody else ate (e.g., 208, 213, 215–16). Then why bother? Regardless, all three chapters succeed well in setting the conceptual stage for future (science-based) archaeological research into the diet of these subgroups.Footnote 11
The two remaining papers, on the other hand, are territory-driven, and discuss the extent to which Roman expansion outside Italy and the western Mediterranean also meant culinary Romanization or dietary acculturation (or ‘creolization’, as some prefer to call it). T. Kaszab-Olschewski skillfully blends the documentary and archaeological evidence into a cogent narrative for central and northern Europe (but a map indicating the places and peoples discussed would have been helpful). In an elaborate chapter (the longest of the volume), she shows how the advent of the Romans – and especially the inauguration of military service for native men – led to a progressively ingrained mix of old (e.g., beer, lard, butter, milk) and new (e.g., wine, garlic, olive oil, poultry) culinary practices between the 1st and 3rd c. C.E. This process co-occurred with a (partial) transition from indigenous subsistence strategies (e.g., collecting wild-growing plants, fruits, and nuts, and hunting) to a more intense and systematic exploitation of the environment (e.g., horticulture, mass fruit cultivation, fish farming). Then again, her framing of local viticulture development by Domitian's vine edict from the end of the 1st c. C.E. (203) is questionable, as it is unlikely that the law was ever carried out.Footnote 12 Besides, there is now substantial evidence for vineyards to the north of Paris from the mid-1st c. C.E. onwards.Footnote 13
The issue of how foodways changed under Greco-Roman rule in the eastern Mediterranean is usually labeled as ‘dietary Hellenization’, and W. Clarysse expertly lists the various foods and drinks that were at hand within this context in Roman Egypt. He certainly packs a lot of information (mainly from the papyri and ostraca) into a succinct contribution, and in places offers intriguing glimpses into the sort of proto-fusion cuisine that emerged in the process – e.g., the millennia-old technique of flatbread baking stuck against the inner side of a cylindrical oven (219),Footnote 14 or the practice of drinking undiluted wine (220) – but he gives little thought to broader pathways of change under Roman influence, such as the gradual substitution of beer by wine (220), the expansion of olive cultivation (221), or the level of salted fish consumption (226).Footnote 15 Research biases and lacunae in our sources are, no doubt, partly to blame, but also space restrictions that impede a more in-depth treatment of these subject matters. On a final note, in both Clarysse's and Olschewski's text, rice and pepper are only mentioned in passing (193, 195–96, 218–19, 226–227), but there is much more to say about the role and distribution of these imported exotics within the Roman Empire.Footnote 16
A forum on energy, malnutrition and stature
In the fourth part of the volume, K. Killgrove, G. Kron, and M. Flohr explore what human bones can and cannot tell us about Roman lifestyles and food regimes. Osteological research into health and nutrition commonly relies on three bodies of evidence: paleopathology (the study of skeletal and dental markers of injury, stress, and disease), biochemistry (the use of stable isotope analysis to reconstruct the human diet), and postcranial morphology (in this case, the length of long bones to estimate stature, which in turn is a good indicator of physical well-being). Despite some recent progress, classical bioarchaeology, as it stands, still suffers from a lack of (published) data and resources – a long-lasting legacy of the discipline's antiquarianism roots – and this very much limits the current playing field to Imperial Rome, Italy, and a few areas in temperate Europe. The interpretation of human bone data is also multifaceted, and therefore complex. Oral pathologies such as caries, calculus (dental plaque), and tooth wear all have a proven link to eating habits, but other health-related (e.g., oral hygiene, standards of living) and environmental factors (e.g., fluorine in water sources positively affecting caries), as well as biases in data preservation and collection, contribute to differences in the frequency of these conditions. Linear enamel hypoplasia – i.e., horizontal defects in tooth enamel – is known to develop during childhood under prolonged physiological stress, but this can be in the form of both malnutrition and illness. The same goes for cribra orbitalia, a common form of porotic hyperostosis that manifests itself in cranial porosities in the roof areas of the eye orbits. This osseous defect is the result of chronic anemia (a low red blood cell count), which can be caused by nutritional deficiencies (more specifically a lack of iron), but also by overall sanitary conditions (Killgrove highlights a possible link with lead exposure) or infectious diseases like malaria.Footnote 17 Again, there is clearly much potential in measuring carbon and nitrogen isotope ratios stored in human bone tissue, as these reflect an individual's average protein and energy intake in the last decade of his or her life (Killgrove, 249–52), but Bourbou's discussion earlier in the volume (83–84) shows that this connection, too, is not unbiased.
Perhaps the most contested matter is the reconstruction of stature from long bone lengths. Several regression equation methods to calculate stature from long bones exist – each with a different set of formulas – and this lack of standardization in analytical approaches has instigated much debate on the accuracy and compatibility of many published results (Killgrove, 252–53; Kron, 260–61). This should encourage researchers to simply report long bone measurements, rather than derived body heights, but this kind of raw data remains frustratingly inaccessible for the Roman world.Footnote 18 Apart from these methodological issues, however, and even with more and better data at our disposal – which we unquestionably need in order to (statistically) strengthen and broaden our interpretations (Flohr, 275–78) – there is also disagreement over how far this kind of evidence can take us. Killgrove correctly stresses the capability of the skeletal material to expose those lower classes in Roman society that are mostly absent from literature and funerary epigraphy (cremation was preferred over inhumation by the elite) (246). For Kron, this opens the door to the existence of a large and prosperous Roman middle class (262–67).Footnote 19 Flohr is more skeptical, and rightly so, and he draws attention to the fact that our datasets still tend to favor Rome (an exceptional metropolis) over the rest of the Empire, town over countryside, and collective over isolated burial (275). There remain crucial gaps in our knowledge.
How do we proceed from here? Killgrove believes that Roman bioarchaeology needs to be practiced as a complementary discipline, as many metrics combined can make our analyses much more robust. Kron underlines the need to gather as much ‘background information’ as possible (historical, cultural, environmental, archaeological, etc.) in order to assure correct interpretations. This is also why Flohr urges scholars from different fields to work closely together. But even then, he concludes, the skeletal record is unlikely to offer ready-made answers to our (perhaps too ambitious) questions anytime soon. The distinct format of a forum logically favors selective argumentation over the comprehensive and systematic treatment of a topic – and this approach has its proponents and opponents – but sometimes a good debate is more important than a good solution, and I found this exchange of views and ideas between a leading bioarchaeologist and two ambidextrous historians quite fruitful.
Food on the market and in politics
The book concludes with a two-parter on Rome's urban food policy, and examines how food reached the urban populace (C. Holleran), and what happened when the food supply chain failed (P. Erdkamp). The economic success of a pre-industrial society can largely be measured by its ability to sustain that part of the population not active in agriculture: that is, for the most part, urban dwellers and army men. In this area, the Romans clearly accomplished great achievements,Footnote 20 and Holleran lucidly uncovers the unique set of mechanisms – and the specific motivations behind them – that the Roman state made use of to bring this about. She argues that subsidized food provisioning channels such as the free grain dole and the alimenta (an Imperial scheme to support children in many Italian towns) had little to do with charity (eligibility was based on status rather than need), and more to do with the creation of a loyal following (especially for the army) and the consolidation of the emperor as a caring paterfamilias. Nonetheless, in doing so, the state indirectly influenced the buying power of many people, and so likely helped in creating a bigger market for other foodstuffs and products.Footnote 21
How far did the state go in controlling and mediating the private food market? It certainly fostered the activities of merchants and traders by creating the basic infrastructure (storehouses, roads, harbors, ports, etc.) and context (a solid administration, protection against piracy, tax breaks for shippers, etc.) that made mercantile food and non-food circulation easier, but there is little scholarly certitude on more direct interventions. Some evidence exists for the taking of regulation measures such as price fixing, rationing, and stockpiling – also by local authorities – but these seem more ad hoc responses to crises and shortages, or actions motivated by political (and financial) agendas, rather than constituting parts of a commercial food policy. As Holleran states about halfway through her chapter, the matter remains unresolved, but students interested in the synergy between state-regulated trade and private commerce in the Roman world will find much inspiration in A. Tchernia's ‘interlocked trade’ model.Footnote 22
Perhaps unsurprisingly, the poor and marginal members of society were generally not the concern of emperors and local elites, and these groups were most vulnerable to famine and hunger, especially in times of bad harvests. While rural households at least maintained some (if finite) control over nature by means of prevention and coping strategies (298–99), urban dwellers had to rely more on stable food access, and the less affluent among them were easy victims of disruptions in the supply channels and rising prices. As Erdkamp cogently shows, the surviving accounts of famines in the Roman world contain sufficient detail to appreciate the potentially dramatic effects of food insecurity – e.g., the consumption of harmful plants, cannibalism, and the risk of dying from ensuing epidemic diseases, even for the wealthy – but they are far too impressionistic to study the demographic consequences of such events in any detail (302–5). He understandably looks for answers on related mortality and fertility trends in the better-documented cases of later periods – a key modus operandi in ancient history at which Erdkamp excels, although I doubt whether everyone would agree with his choice of medieval England as a valid historical comparison – but he sees few opportunities in the osteological material when it comes to gauging the physical effects of prolonged deprivation (for the same reasons as addressed by Killgrove and Flohr in the preceding section). This is precisely the kind of research, then, that could benefit in the future from better-aligned interdisciplinary collaboration.
Except for the minor imperfections already noted, this handbook on diet and nutrition in the Roman world is a fine achievement. Its editors have succeeded in providing a coherent and critical guide to Roman food studies anno 2020, and a convenient methodological toolbox for those interested in joining (and advancing) this dynamic field. Those who still leave unsatisfied will undoubtedly find much to chew on in the copious bibliography at the end of the book.
