The editors of The Hurt(ful) Body, Tomas Macsotay, Cornelis van der Haven and Karel Vanhaesebrouck, open their compilation of essays with a sixteenth-century text by an Anglo-Dutch priest who recounts how Catholic ‘martyrs’ were tortured to death by Protestant ‘heretics.’ According to the editors, the priest describes how bodies were ‘grilled, opened up, dismembered, decapitated, eviscerated, hanged and even eaten’ (p. 1). It might be difficult to come up with more excruciating ways to die than those the era devised for the spiritually recalcitrant. Put another way, when confronted with the prospect of being sawn in half by a stiff rope or forced to eat one's genitalia, starving to death starts looking rather attractive.
Pain – whether real, imitated or suppressed – is the focus of The Hurt(ful) Body. This collection probes questions such as: in what instance is the regard of suffering cathartic or sublime? Does the sight of extravagant or muted pain produce greater sympathy? And to what extent can hurt be communicated in the first place, let alone ‘shared’? To address these questions and more, the book's eleven chapters (accompanied by the editors’ introduction and an epilogue by Javier Moscoso) take a historicized and interdisciplinary view on the representation of embodied suffering in pre-industrial Europe, and how audiences may have responded to those images. The editors therefore describe their project as offering a dialectical approach to the body in pain: understanding it from the perspective of both the sufferer and the viewer, while maintaining a focus on the affective bonds between them.
The chapters are divided into three sections: Part 1 highlights the theatrical performance of pain; Part 2 examines the impact of observing another person's suffering; and Part 3 explores how the method and perception of cruelty were influenced by its institutional framing (i.e. maritime punishment, public execution and stock trade discourses), taking special interest in Foucauldian ideas of disciplinary power. The editors acknowledge that the three sections overlap; hence the parts should be understood as ‘lenses’ rather than distinct categories, enabling ‘the reader to approach similar problems by taking a different perspective on the same historical reality’ (p. 4).
Part 1, ‘Performing bodies’, opens with an essay by Christian Biet on violence and martyrdom in French religious tragedy from the 1580s to the 1630s. Biet challenges the view that after medieval morality plays were banned in 1548, French dramatists were uninterested in Christian tragedy until its ‘revival’ in the 1630s. Instead, Biet emphasizes how ‘martyr tragedies’ partly developed from the Old Testament plays of the early 1600s, which featured excessive violence and special staging techniques to amplify the epic battle between Good and Evil. Similar to the biblical productions, martyr tragedies exploited both staged and rhetorical scenes of brutality designed to shock and entertain, but also persuade viewers of the need for Christian sacrifice. Biet further considers whether the ‘less devout kind of theatrical pleasure’ in other people's suffering ultimately destabilized the pious reflection intended by these performances (p. 32). Continuing in a somewhat different vein, Stijn Bussels's and Bram van Oostveldt's essay on seventeenth-century Dutch representations of Herod's Massacre of the Innocents explores how ‘hyperrealism’ in art was sometimes eschewed. Drawing from Aby Warburg's concept of Denkraum (‘thought-space’) from a later period, Bussels and Van Oostveldt argue that writers and painters experimented with indirect ways to depict slaughter (in this case of infants), not to make less powerful art but as a way to create a ‘space for reflection’ (p. 65). In other words, a mitigated cathartic experience allowed audiences to better grasp a work's underlying message, since attenuated violence does not risk overwhelming the senses.
Whether viewers want to look at – or away from – the hurt body is elaborated in Part 2. ‘Beholding pain’ is the volume's biggest and most compelling section, where essays consider the varying degrees to which one derives pleasure from the agony of others. John Yamamoto-Wilson examines its transgressive dimension in an analysis of female erotic delight, configured as her literary gaze, in the rejection of male suitors. Hence Yamamoto-Wilson finds ‘a developing protomasochistic discourse’ in early modern poetry and romance (p. 132). Tomas Macsotay reads tormented bodies in eighteenth-century French painting against the period's reception of Epicurean thought, arguing that for writers such as Diderot, Epicureanism was not understood as aimless pleasure seeking but as ‘the irrepressible human need for comfort (volupté)’ (p. 143). French followers of Epicurus thus celebrated images of intense suffering as a new type of materialist, secular comfort, ‘an antidote to the illusory consolations of divine Providence’ (p. 160). Aris Sarafianos's discussion of Edmund Burke's theory of the ‘painful sublime’ is a standout in this weighty volume. In Burke's reassessment of sympathy, he makes the case for actual tragedy over (in his own words) ‘the comparative weakness of the imitative arts’ (p. 173). His contemporaries were further appalled by his contention that sympathy for a fellow person's misery could be understood as a sensible, bodily pleasure. Some decades later, Sir Charles Bell's detailed medical illustrations of real-life injured soldiers exposed the limits of Burke's thinking. According to Sarafianos, Bell's drawings of devastating bodily trauma resist any easy assimilation into Burke's formulation of the sublime, whether as objects or subjects.
Part 3, ‘Institutions’, perceives the hurt body within different public settings. Maria Pia Di Bella sketches the juridical procedures for those condemned to die in premodern Palermo (Sicily), calling attention to the perceived link between punishment and spiritual redemption. Gender scholars may be particularly interested in this chapter since it touches upon the convictions of women as well as men accused of nefandum (homosexuality). Frans-Willem Korsten examines the representation of maritime punishment in the seventeenth century, arguing that the various forms which the penalty took reflected the period's debates over theodicy. And Inger Leemans takes a novel look at pain in relation to financial crises, specifically representations of the volatile and violent stock trade in the Dutch Republic. Leemans writes that speculative exchange was understood to ‘hurt on nearly all possible levels of the human mind and body, while causing pain to the trading community, the Dutch households and in the end to the nation as a whole’ (p. 280).
The other engaging chapters which round out this collection are Karel Vanhaesebrouck's analysis of the performance of pain by European colonizing bodies in French theatre, Jonathan Sawday's superb reflection on the challenges posed by understanding the pain of others, and Nicolás Kwiatkowski's discussion of the forced witnessing of atrocities during the Irish rebellion. As Javier Moscoso's epilogue makes clear, the volume takes an expansive view of the body in pain – not just as ‘neural processes’ but mental and emotional activities as well (p. 300). While this approach is certainly welcome, more attention at times to the corporeal aspect of hurt would have been appreciated in a volume which calls attention to embodiment. Lastly, because there is significant overlap between the book's sections, a different organizational scheme – for example, dividing chapters by types of painful experience (spiritual, sensual, juridical) – might have better illuminated the essays’ contents. These minor concerns notwithstanding, the collection brims with archival discoveries, and scholars interested in the cultural history of pain, pain management, affect, performance, art and aesthetics will find The Hurt(ful) Body a timely addition to the bibliography of the period.
