Film and American studies scholar Lauren Rabinovitz begins Electric Dreamland with a promising thesis: that the birth of the amusement park and cinema, both ultimately products of electrical technology, in the years after 1896, gave expression to a new culture of modernity teaching all Americans how to adapt to and enjoy new technology and a new bodily freedom that broke with Victorian norms. This general theme, of course, is well known to all who have read John Kasson's Amusing the Million: Coney Island at the Turn of the Century (1978). Yet Rabinovitz attempts to take this argument further by showing that the cinema and the amusement park were not primarily urban, much less New York, phenomena (created in Coney Island and in Manhattan). Thanks to the ubiquity of railroads and the expansion of electric trolley cars, there was scarcely any turn-of-the-twentieth-century American not exposed to these new entertainment technologies. And, instead of following Kasson's lead by focussing on the rides and beach culture at Coney (and comparing them to the repressive work world and Victorian social life of New York City), she introduces three little-explored sidelights of the amusement park experience, aligned with her interests in the visual: the thrill ride movies of Hale's Tours, the amusement park postcard, and silent film comedies featuring Coney. The result is a short, solidly scholarly book that will interest film studies specialists and broaden the knowledge of historians of leisure and consumer culture.
She describes succinctly the variety and geographical range of both the amusement park and the early cinema, documenting, for example, the history of Chicago's six parks and the role of segregation in their crowd management. She links Tom Gunning's concept of the “cinema of attractions” (pre-1908 films' celebration of motion and the visual spectacle) with the bodily thrills of the roller coasters and other motorized rides. The visual and the bodily sensation were combined in the scenic railroads and dark rides. Following Kasson, she describes how the slides, blowholes, and other attractions allowed late Victorians to break the rules of sexual propriety, and she provides some unfamiliar details of the spectacles of bodily display – freak shows and exotic dancers and “villages,” as well as firework and disaster shows with cross-references to contemporary films. Echoing Kasson, David Nasaw, Kathy Peiss, and other social historians, she concludes that “urban wonderlands” offered Americans an escape from and tamed their fears of their mechanized age in leisure that ultimately was contained and controlling even as these sites promoted identification with “American nationalist values while spatially and structurally maintaining social divisions of race and class” (64).
Her work is more original in her detailed study of Hale's Tours, a spectacle combining scenic films with the audience sitting in “train cars” that created the visceral illusion of travel. Drawing on Susan Stewart's oft-quoted work, she shows how amusement park postcards portrayed spectacular scenes as a person might see them, presenting the gigantic (illuminations, elevated perspectives, etc.) as a collectible miniature. Her final substantive chapter on Coney Island comedies reviews film studies debates about slapstick comedy and details classic films (featuring, for example, Roscoe Arbuckle and Marie Dressler, and how they cope with the indignities of the rides).
The linkage between technology and the body, and the shock of the new, have often been the terms used to shape analysis of this period and these two entertainment modes. I was disappointed, however, that this book didn't really take us very far beyond this literature. The later chapters (that read like stand-alone academic articles) did not build on the promising opening chapters that suggested a real break from the academic constraints of both the social history of leisure and film studies. For example, the social uses of the postcard and the relationships between the social meanings of the thrill ride and the Coney Island comedies could have been developed. The review of the social-historical literature is helpful to nonspecialists, but it is somewhat spotty (ignoring key texts on the design of the parks by Woody Register, studies of the freak show by Robert Bogdan, and comparative studies on the amusement park by John K. Walton, for example). The conclusion, comparing Coney with Disneyland, is sketchy and a more fruitful approach would have been found in a more systematic exploration of the central thesis that gets lost in the later chapters. Still, this work will meet the needs of many readers seeking an introduction to her twin themes (and it does us the service of including detailed lists of American amusement parks and related films not found elsewhere).
