No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 August 2004
Shahla Haeri would like to know why Muslim women who are accessible and visible in their own societies remain invisible in the West. Why have they failed to capture the interest of anthropologists, the media, and the public, in contrast to veiled Muslim women? Dismayed that despite the growing academic literature on Muslim women much of it still focuses on the veil and peasant women, Haeri seeks to document the lives of professional Pakistani women. While anthropologists have become more self-reflexive and critical of their relationship to their subjects over the past few decades, Haeri challenges them to rethink their focus on the subaltern. Deliberately focusing on educated and professional women of similar status to herself, she proposes a new ethnographic model, “shared ethnography,” which she demonstrates through her interviews with six Pakistani women, a methodology emerging from dialogues and collaboration with her subjects. Seeking to make professional Pakistani women visible, the title of the book, No Shame for the Sun, refers to women out in the public sphere, unabashed and in the sun, despite the multiple structures that render them invisible—be they veils, gender-role expectations, or academic discourses.
Shahla Haeri would like to know why Muslim women who are accessible and visible in their own societies remain invisible in the West. Why have they failed to capture the interest of anthropologists, the media, and the public, in contrast to veiled Muslim women? Dismayed that despite the growing academic literature on Muslim women much of it still focuses on the veil and peasant women, Haeri seeks to document the lives of professional Pakistani women. While anthropologists have become more self-reflexive and critical of their relationship to their subjects over the past few decades, Haeri challenges them to rethink their focus on the subaltern. Deliberately focusing on educated and professional women of similar status to herself, she proposes a new ethnographic model, “shared ethnography,” which she demonstrates through her interviews with six Pakistani women, a methodology emerging from dialogues and collaboration with her subjects. Seeking to make professional Pakistani women visible, the title of the book, No Shame for the Sun, refers to women out in the public sphere, unabashed and in the sun, despite the multiple structures that render them invisible—be they veils, gender-role expectations, or academic discourses.
Haeri uses the Introduction to set forth her objectives and Chapter 1 to situate herself as an Iranian Muslim feminist scholar and ethnographer in relation to her subjects and to contextualize Pakistani history, politics, and culture. What is particularly interesting about Chapter 1 is that we learn about Pakistani women through the lens of an Iranian woman. The reader gets more than expected: a comparative look at gender in two Muslim countries, Pakistan and Iran. Haeri spends some time explaining the role of honor (izzat) in Pakistan and how it operates as a fundamentally gendered cultural principle. The concept of honor is key to understanding the conflicts and challenges Pakistani professional women face as each inadvertently violates traditional notions of honor.
Chapters 2–7 are each devoted to one of her six interviewees. Haeri begins each chapter with a brief introduction stating how she met the woman and the circumstances in which the interviews took place. The bulk of the chapter presents the narrative of the woman unfiltered and without interruption. Haeri saves her commentary for a few pages at the end, in which she briefly addresses some of the themes from the narratives and contextualizes them within anthropological and feminist frameworks.
Each chapter has a title that identifies the main conflict in the interviewee's life: Identity, Violence, Legitimacy, Marriage, Kinship, and Religion. Chapter 2 is about Quratul Ain Bakhteari's life, wrought with conflict regarding her identity as defined by her parents, in-laws, and culture as a woman, wife, and mother and her own desire to have an independent life and make a difference in refugee communities in Pakistan. Although she is repeatedly kicked out of the house by her husband, she manages to earn a master's degree and a Ph.D., and to pioneer community-based sanitation systems in refugee camps and home-schooling systems in villages for young girls. Rahila Tiwana's life (chap. 3) is marked by violence. As a political activist and student leader with a branch of Benazir Bhutto's Pakistan People's Party, she was arrested and tortured in police custody. She denies that the torture she endured involved rape to preserve not only her family's honor but also that of Bhutto and the Pakistan People's Party.
Ayesha Siddiqa (chap. 4) moves between two posts: one as a young feudal lord with many servants in her village, where she is often sought after for advice, and the other as a civil servant in the city where she is often not taken seriously as a woman in a position of power. Kishwar Naheed (chap. 5) is a prolific, contemporary, well-known, and controversial poet. She is controversial for challenging the male literary tradition and appropriating the ghazal, a lyrical poetic style used by men to express love. Choosing whom she will marry against her parents' wishes, and expressing women's desire in her poetry, she is ostracized for violating her family's honor. Sajida Mokarram Shah (chap. 6) also faces dishonor and ostracism for rejecting the cultural practice of widow inheritance that requires her to live with her husband's brother after her husband's death. The final narrative comes from Nilofar Ahmad (chap. 7), a Sufi feminist whose interpretations of Islam challenge traditional ideas and hierarchy.
Haeri does not present a simplistic argument against the dominant perception of oppressed women in Pakistan by representing their lives as full of success and free from constraint. Instead, the narratives demonstrate the complex ways in which women negotiate agency amid multiple constraints to become influential scholars, activists, and poets. Their narratives disrupt the dominant understanding of how patriarchy operates through dominant men who oppress women and bar them from the public sphere. For example, each interviewee discusses her upbringing and relationship to her parents. Some had domineering mothers who insisted on upholding the patriarchal tradition and passive loving fathers who encouraged them to pursue education, thus complicating the notion that men alone uphold patriarchy. The narratives are inspiring and give true insight into women's agency as they each craft their own accomplishments in the public and domestic spheres despite extreme conflicts and objections from their community and families.
The narratives are interesting not only because of what they say about women's lives growing up in Pakistan after partition, but also because we get to read them in their entirety, without interruption. This is a refreshing change from writing that presents selected quotes from interviews to illustrate particular themes or support an argument (including my own). Haeri's comments draw important points from the narratives, which readers can compare with their own conclusions. This structure makes the book a wonderful text to use in the classroom, as the unfiltered narratives will certainly provoke much discussion and debate.
If you are teaching courses on Muslim women and seeking to move away from the stereotype of the veiled oppressed Muslim woman, this book is perfect. It illustrates that women can have an array of experiences living in the same society; highlights the interaction between culture and religion, moving away from the notion of a monolithic Islam that is oppressive to all women; and demonstrates that Muslim women can be and are active participants in the public sphere. I look forward to adding this text to my syllabus on Muslim women, and I recommend it to those who teach South Asian studies, women's studies, anthropology, and Middle East and Islamic studies.