As with his earlier work on the history of the French empire, Eric Jennings' recently published history of Đà Lạt will likely prove to be an inspiration to historians interested in reconsidering European imperialism by delving deeply into the local social and cultural history of the colonial encounter. His previous studies on colonial life under Vichy and on the colonial experience of hydrotherapy did not pioneer historical enquiry into these topics. These studies did, however, spur on scholars of empire in taking them seriously, both in the history of France and of its empire. Very much a part of the so-called ‘new imperial history’, his examination of Đà Lạt's history from its colonial genesis to its postcolonial growth tells a story of the contingencies that hampered the best-laid imperial plans for creating an oasis in the central highlands of Vietnam. Based largely on colonial archival sources, Jennings argues that the realities of the colonial political economy deeply affected repeated attempts to realise imperial visions of an ideal Đà Lat and, thus of an ideal Indochina. Even before French rule was secure, the military and, later, civilian administrators of Indochina had resolved to equip the colony with centres of convalescence that approximated a temperate European climate. Governor-General Paul Doumer seconded personnel to scout for a location at an altitude that matched the science of contemporary notions of the most beneficial spot for a hill station. Alexandre Yersin stumbled upon the plateau that was to support Đà Lạt and thus began the erratic rise of the city in the hills. For every fervent supporter of the hill station in the colonial administration there was another who more soberly assessed the scientific efficacy, the profligacy or the political imprudence of the Đà Lạt cause. Despite being captive to the caprices of colonial politics and society, the hill station nonetheless grew. Promoters continued to champion visions of Đà Lạt as the apotheosis of the colonial racial and social order, while it slowly grew as more and more came to the hill station, despite its critics and despite its seeming inability to live up to expectations. People came for work and for holidays, temporarily and permanently, until Đà Lạt finally achieved its colonial zenith during the early 1940s.
In telling the story of the vicissitudes and tribulations of the city, its promoters and detractors as well as its inhabitants, Jennings' history of colonial Đà Lạt exemplifies the new imperial history both in its achievements and its shortcomings. It provides a sustained examination of the contradictions inherent in the imperial discourses of race and tropicality that lay at its origin and shaped its haphazard development. He importantly stresses the ‘brutal methods’ of forced labour, compelled migration and racial segregation that formed the basis for this colonial ‘utopia’ (p. 59). By telling Đà Lạt's story across that suppositious divide separating colonial from postcolonial, Jennings' study also points to the lingering vestiges of imperial visions in contemporary Đà Lạt. While he asserts that ‘the effects on Indochinese cultures remain to be seen’ (p. 93), Imperial heights will provide fodder for those seeking to understand how the colonial order has enduringly affected the societies of the colonised.
Breaking with his own earlier work and with the standard fare of imperial history, Jennings also makes more use of Vietnamese sources in attempting to account more fully for the place of Indochinese in their own histories. Yet he remains reluctant to declare more forcefully how Vietnamese society was affected by what is, in his account, still a largely French enterprise in the hills, and this reticence stems no doubt from Jennings' own training, preoccupations and competencies. While he makes more use of Vietnamese sources than in his previous work, his story is still most certain when resting on French colonial sources. This is a work of imperial history, and the coloniser continues to take centre stage. In as much as the colonised appear at least ‘briefly’ (p. 122) as agents, this work reflects and promotes a trend in this direction in imperial history. The colonial endeavour remains a European affair — one that Vietnamese and highland minorities are sometimes able to perturb, to mould and to exploit, especially if they are elite — but attention very much rests on the ruthless intransigence of the French colonial regime in Indochina as seen through the attempt at a mountain cure in Vietnam's central highlands.
For scholars outside the tradition of European imperial history, the idea of making the colonised the subject of plans conceived and enacted during the colonial period will seem far less ground-breaking. Indeed, those of us whose attention has long been squarely fixed on the societies and polities of Southeast Asia have long been doing just this sort of history, and many will undoubtedly find this work's continued insistence on the vigour of imperial ideas and ambitions puzzling. Given how ‘imperfect’ the attempt to bring an ideal racial order into existence (p. 93), given the ‘dissonance’ between the ideal-type and the lived reality (p. 113) and given the ‘cracks’ that always appeared in the models that Jennings presumes to have determined Đà Lạt's history: given these problems, one has to wonder if the question of the relevance of imperial visions and ideas hatched in the metropole to the story of Đà Lạt and the European enterprises in colonial southeast Asia has not been begged. In his accounts of the grand hotel of Đà Lạt (pp. 138–57) and of the grandiose plan by the colonial architect Hébrard for the land economy of the hill station (pp. 112–37) — both of which were previously published in largely the same form as articles — it is the poverty of the colonial administration, the indomitability of vested colonial interests and the irrepressible Vietnamese migrants to the fledgling city that frustrate planners and administrators. Yet in conspiring so thoroughly to thwart Đà Lạt's emergence as a simulacrum (p. 93) of home, do these forces not make clear the impertinence of such ‘lofty blueprints’ (p. 3) to the lived reality of the city?
What is far more intriguing is the suggestion that colonial-era conceptions of the city as an ‘oasis’ removed from the turmoil of the plains below profoundly affected the city's growth and importance, giving it a continuing and perhaps undue importance (seen, for example, in its selection as the location for the failed conferences before the eruption of the First Indochina War). It led, in part, to the city remaining relatively tranquil during the Second Indochina War and to this day inflects the city's popularity for Vietnamese honeymooners and holidaymakers. In telling this story of the late-colonial and postcolonial city within a Vietnamese national imaginary, Jennings' account merely sketches the city's symbolism on the basis of the hill station's idyllic French genesis. How Vietnamese came to idealise the city, how Vietnamese of different classes and ethnicities became interested in Đà Lạt, in both senses of the word: that story remains tantalisingly and frustratingly implicit, but little more.
