On discovering that the past two years have given us our first—not one, but two—book-length studies of the composer, choral director, and educator William Levi Dawson, one could be forgiven for wondering what took the field of musicology so long to recognize this remarkable musician. But as we read these two volumes (one from the University Press of Mississippi and the other from the University of Illinois Press), we are left with a feeling of gratitude for these important additions to an altogether too thin literature. The authors, music educator Mark Hugh Malone and musicologist Gwynne Kuhner Brown, have given Dawson the attention he has so long deserved and have carefully laid the groundwork for further investigation into his life, music, and impact.
To be clear: Dawson has never been lost. Tuskegee University—the institution Dawson attended and whose music program he led—honors his legacy each year with the William Levi Dawson Institute for Classical and Folk Music. He has received honorary degrees, and cities have dedicated days in his honor. His music, especially his arrangements of Black religious folk songs, is still performed regularly and has influenced generations of composers in their approach to these living reminders of the violent, painful, and sometimes joyous U.S. journey. Yet, beyond a handful of important journal articles and several summaries of his career in surveys of Black music, Dawson has been, far too often, erased from the history of U.S. music.
At least three factors have led to this neglect. First, to state it plainly: William Levi Dawson was a Black musician, and the racism that defines musicology, the academy, and performing arts organizations has largely smothered his entry into the canon. Second, his contributions have not always fitted neatly into that canon. Much of his compositional output centers on arrangements of spirituals, which Dawson called “religious folk songs of the American Negro.” Although these arrangements continue to be performed by student and professional choirs, choral music, as a whole, has received considerably less attention than large-scale symphonic composition. Finally, whereas Dawson’s Negro Folk Symphony (1934), holds a notable place alongside William Grant Still’s Afro-American Symphony (1931) and Florence Price’s Symphony in E minor (1933) as being among the first large-scale orchestral works by Black composers to be performed by U.S. orchestras, Dawson never returned to this mode of composition and his story has thus often been framed as one of unfortunate loss. “If only he had continued to write for the orchestra,” music history seems to say, “then perhaps we’d have paid attention.” These two books go a long way toward correcting this unjust neglect.
Born in Anniston, Alabama, in 1899, a young William Dawson left home in 1913 to make his way to Tuskegee, where he came under the powerful influence of the institution’s founder, Booker T. Washington. There, he played trombone in the Institute’s band and toured with its vocal quintette. But Tuskegee could not contain the ambitious Dawson. After earning his diploma in 1921, the young musician set out in search of further education. He took composition and orchestration lessons at Topeka’s Washburn College, became the first Black student to earn a bachelor’s degree from the Horner Institute of Fine Arts in Kansas City, and went on to receive his master’s degree in composition from the American Conservatory in Chicago. Along the way, Dawson launched a remarkably varied professional career, serving as band director at Kansas Vocational College, leading ensembles at Kansas City’s Lincoln High School, and playing trombone in both a dance band and the Chicago Civic Orchestra.
In 1930, Tuskegee lured Dawson back to Alabama, where he would join the faculty and transform a department of music into a full-fledged school. Dawson gathered around him an extraordinary faculty, including the pianist Hazel Harrison (the first fully U.S.-educated musician to solo with a European orchestra) and Abbie Mitchell (who had already appeared in Clorindy, or The Origin of the Cake Walk and would soon create the role of Clara in Porgy and Bess). With this team, Dawson could ensure that Black composers and African-American musical genres remained central to Tuskegee’s musical curriculum.
Most notably, however, Dawson led the Institute’s choir, which quickly established itself on campus with daily rehearsals and weekly performances. After attracting the attention of Samuel “Roxy” Rothafel at the end of 1932, the director and his singers were in New York for the opening of Radio City Music Hall. This performance was soon followed by a birthday concert for President-Elect Franklin Delano Roosevelt, a Carnegie Hall debut, and a visit to the White House. Public acclaim resulted in six months of weekly radio broadcasts. At the same time, however, the Great Depression was choking the school’s enrollment. Although limited touring resumed after the war, and the choir did make regular radio broadcasts and even appeared on Ed Sullivan’s Toast of the Town, the School of Music was downgraded back into a department, and Dawson departed in 1955. He would spend much of the remainder of his life on the guest conductor and clinician circuit, leading choirs and orchestras, and working with students across the country.
Each of these books begins by telling a similar story: Dawson’s fierce determination to achieve a wide-ranging and deep musical education and to pass that education onto his students. Both authors recognize Dawson’s skillful ability to place his choir in the public eye and his profound disappointment when Tuskegee was unable to maintain the School of Music Dawson had been recruited to build. After this initial, youthful story, the two authors diverge, focusing with quite different lenses: Malone on Dawson the educator; Brown on Dawson the composer. Of course, these differing approaches are clear from the very first pages: Malone’s subtitle is American Music Educator, whereas Brown’s volume appears in the University of Illinois Press’s series, American Composers.
Organized in five chapters and three appendices, Malone’s book begins with “Dawson’s Early Years and Education: 1899–1930.” He then divides Dawson’s time on the Tuskegee faculty between two chapters: “The Development of the Music School at Tuskegee Institute: 1930–1955” and “The Rise of the Tuskegee Choir to National Prominence: 1931–55.” This third chapter relies heavily on press reports to provide a meticulous summary of nearly every movement made by the choir while on tour. This detailed approach is typical of Malone’s book. Indeed, his work on Dawson started in 1979 when he conducted the five interviews with Dawson that would form the heart of Malone’s 1981 Florida State University doctoral dissertation in Music Education. Malone would go on to a distinguished career as a choral director and administrator, but upon retirement, he returned to Dawson, whose papers had become available at Emory University’s Stuart A. Rose Manuscript, Archives, and Rare Book Library. Although Malone engages with rich secondary literature, as the first person to write deeply on Dawson, much of his story comes directly from the composer or through his papers. Malone’s reliance on primary sources allows him to dive deeply into the details of Dawson’s career and his reception in the press.
After completing his biographical survey, Malone’s final two chapters cover “Dawson the Composer” and “Dawson the Pedagogue” from 1921 to Dawson’s death in 1990. Each of these chapters takes an expansive view to explore the composer’s thoughts on musical nationalism, racialized music, and the importance of music in Black education. Malone, of course, does not ignore the Negro Folk Symphony. Its gestation, along with the composer’s 1952–1953 trip to Africa and the resulting revision of the work, are all covered in fascinating detail. But alongside this story, Malone also takes the reader through Dawson’s vocal compositions and arrangements, his travels as a clinician and conductor, and the honors bestowed upon him. The book concludes with more than thirty images of programs, images of memorabilia, and photographs of Dawson and his ensembles. Finally, Malone includes three appendices: (1) a roster of compositions, (2) a list of awards and honors, and (3) a compilation of letters, speeches, and interviews by and about the composer.
Brown begins on a similar path, but quickly takes a different tact. Her first chapter covers Dawson’s early life and education, and her second condenses Dawson’s twenty-five years on the Tuskegee faculty into a single chapter. The major events, tours, and disappointments are all covered, but we get less of a blow-by-blow account and a greater level of insightful analysis. In place of biographical detail comes the heart of this remarkable book: two chapters on Dawson the composer, one focusing on his vocal music and the other dedicated to his instrumental output. I cannot stress how important, original, and creative these two chapters are, and for reasons that will soon become clear, I will address them in reverse order.
Even before this volume appeared, Brown had contributed a great deal to our knowledge of Dawson’s music, most notably through her article “Whatever Happened to William Dawson’s Negro Folk Symphony?” which appeared in this journal in 2012. This article was followed by her critical-performance edition of Dawson’s Negro Folk Symphony, which was issued by G. Schirmer in 2023 and premiered by the Philadelphia Orchestra (the same orchestra that first performed the work nearly ninety years earlier).
It is no surprise then that Chapter 4 of William L. Dawson focuses on this work, Dawson’s most substantial instrumental piece and a piece Brown knows inside and out. Her chapter covers the genesis of the Negro Folk Symphony from its inception in the mid-1920s to Dawson’s introduction to Leopold Stokowski in 1932 to the 1934 premiere under Stokowski’s baton. Brown covers the reactions of critics as well as the handful of other performances the work received in the 1930s. She covers Dawson’s trip to Africa (in the following chapter) and his subsequent revisions to the symphony. But most remarkable is her analysis of the work itself. Her movement-by-movement lens allows us to hear how Dawson’s symphony engages with Antonín Dvořák’s New World, Ludwig van Beethoven’s Eroica, Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky’s Pathétique, original material, and Negro folk songs in a way that functions, in Brown’s analysis, as a “musical repair of the break in the human chain wrought by the transatlantic slave trade” (92).
Even more impressive is the previous chapter, in which Brown provides detailed analyses of Dawson’s arrangements of King Jesus Is A-Listening (1925), Ain’-a That Good News (1937/1974), There Is a Balm in Gilead (1939), Ezekiel Saw the Wheel (1942), and In His Care-O (1961). Approaching compositional adaptations of folk materials while respecting both the original creators and the arrangers has tripped up many authors, but Brown’s approach is careful, respectful, and deeply insightful. After hearing how Dawson adapts and depicts the texts found in his source material, captures the spiritual and communal practice of the ring shout and highlights linguistic creativity, it is difficult not to agree with Brown that “Dawson used European compositional techniques not to ‘elevate’ the folk songs into European-style art music, but to make the songs as useful and meaningful for their new singers and settings as they had been for his ancestors in slavery” (58). She continues by explaining that Dawson’s “hard-earned formal training allowed him to fit the songs to these contexts by magnifying their expressiveness, their effectiveness in performance, and their pedagogical usefulness” (58). Brown concludes her volume with a chapter entitled “After Tuskegee,” in which she discusses his research trip to Africa, his decades as a traveling clinician, his stream of awards, and his fight against the copyright infringements that came from the popularity of his arrangements.
When two books covering the same topic arrive so near in time, we are left with an unfortunate question: which to buy and which to read? The easy answer is, of course, both. Both are well priced (at about $25 in paperback), relatively brief (at about 120 pages of main text), and easily digestible. For most readers, I would recommend beginning with Brown’s William L. Dawson. The writing is clear, the analysis approachable, and, most of all, the author reflective. Brown is explicit about her own positionality, and even her Preface, in which she discusses her approach to challenging language, is powerful. My only complaint is really a mere wish: that Brown had spent even more time with Dawson’s folk song arrangements. This is the chapter my students will be reading regularly.
But once finished with William L. Dawson, do not neglect Malone’s William Levi Dawson: American Music Educator. While less engaged with the music itself, Malone weaves a compelling story of determination, luck, and community. In Malone’s telling, Dawson fought first for an education and then for recognition, but he did not do so alone. While racism defined that struggle, so too did a community of supporters: Booker T. Washington, Aaron Douglas, Adolf Weidig, Frederick Stock, and Leopold Stowkoski. Malone also vividly depicts the breadth of Dawson’s musical skill. Here we find not merely a composer, but a singer and trombonist; a conductor of bands, orchestras, and choirs; a performer of both classical and dance music. There are weaknesses, of course. At times, Malone strays too far off topic, as in his lengthy discussion of nationalism and a meandering history of the spiritual. The images are often poorly reproduced, and the appendices feel like afterthoughts. But despite these challenges, there is something magical and powerful in reading a story drawn so carefully from the author’s interactions with the subject himself.
It took musicology far too long, but it is thrilling to finally see this renaissance around a seminal U.S. American musician, William Levi Dawson. As both Mark Hugh Malone and Gwynne Kuhner Brown make clear, Dawson’s world was shaped by the racist structures that limit the American experience. But like Black artists before and since, Dawson refused to allow his own career—or that of his students—to be defined or limited by those structures. At Tuskegee and beyond, Dawson thrived, and it is as joyful as the text in In His Care-O that we now have a published bedrock on which to build further work on this remarkable musician:
One day as I was a-walkin’
Down de lonesome road
Well de spirit spoke unto me
An’ it filled my heart with joy!
Patrick Warfield is Professor of Musicology and Director of the School of Music at the University of Minnesota. His current research focuses on localized musical life during the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, with a special interest in the American wind band tradition. He is currently working on a history of “The President’s Own,” United States Marine Band. Formerly at the University of Maryland, Warfield is also active as a public musicologist, having developed programming with DC area bands, orchestras, and singers.
