Between 25 July and 5 August 1927, a series of recording sessions held in the former Taylor-Christian Hat Company building in Bristol, Tennessee resulted in what country music historian Nolan Porterfield has described as “the big bang of country music.”Footnote 1 Overseen by Victor Records producer Ralph Peer, the “Bristol sessions” were not the first to capture what came to be called country music,Footnote 2 but the result was a landmark series of recordings that documented Appalachian musical life and launched the careers of two of early country music's most celebrated acts, the Carter Family and Jimmie Rodgers. The sessions have taken on almost mythical status, despite the fact that Bristol was just one stop on a two-month, $60,000 trip that took Peer through several major southern cities and yielded many important recordings of blues, ragtime, gospel, ballads, topical songs, and string bands.Footnote 3 Although portions of these sessions have been reissued on compact disc by the Country Music Foundation, RCA/BMG Heritage, and JSP Records,Footnote 4 no label had ventured to reissue all of the surviving recordings until 2011, when Bear Family Records teamed with scholars Ted Olson and Tony Russell and reissue producer Christopher King to create a sumptuously illustrated and richly researched five-disc box set that gives these landmark recordings the presentation they deserve.
The Bristol Sessions not only includes every surviving recording from the 1927 sessions, but also includes the complete recordings from Peer's 27 October–4 November 1928 return visit to the city, for a total of 123 sides by more than thirty acts. These recordings document the full spectrum of Anglo-Appalachian music making in the mid-1920s, featuring musicians from five states (Kentucky, West Virginia, Virginia, Tennessee, and North Carolina). Included among these recordings are hymns, moralizing compositions, dance tunes, play-party songs, and comedic hillbilly sketches. Vocal numbers predominate, and listeners will appreciate the range of vocal styles, including duet singing of husband-wife team Jim and Flora Baker (“The Newmarket Wreck”), the plaintive solo stylings of Jimmie Rodgers (“The Soldier's Sweetheart”), the powerful straight-tone singing of Alfred G. Karnes (“The Days of My Childhood Plays”), and accompanied and a cappella sacred singing (Ernest Phipps & His Holiness Singers and the Alcoa Quartet, for example). Listeners unfamiliar with early recorded country music might be occasionally distracted by pitch control and voice modulation issues that arise in many of these recordings, but they serve as important reminders of the ways in which professional standards for recordings and recording artists have changed over the years.Footnote 5
Stringed instruments abound in these recordings—no surprise in light of the region's rich string band traditions—with various combinations of guitars, fiddles, banjos, steel guitars, and even ukuleles accompanying the vast majority of the vocal performances. Many of the recordings feature fiddle obbligatos alongside vocal melodies, as in the four-part hymns sung by Ernest V. Stoneman & His Dixie Mountaineers in which the occasionally out-of-tune fiddling of Kahle Brewer and Uncle Eck Dunford is reinforced by Irma Frost's quiet parlor organ.Footnote 6 Instrumental virtuosity is seldom featured in these recordings. One rare exception comes with Virginia harmonica player Henry Whitter's contributions, including “Henry Whitter's Fox Chase,” which evocatively depicts the sounds of hounds on the hunt. That Whitter had been recording professionally for nearly four years prior to the Bristol Sessions is especially evident in his careful dynamic control of the potentially rambunctious harmonica.Footnote 7 More typical instrumental playing can be heard in the West Virginia Coon Hunters’ two dance tunes, which offer a repetitive and rather simplistic version of the tune on the fiddles that combine with the driving clawhammer banjo of Joe Stephens, the ragtime-influenced strumming of banjo-ukulele player Vernal Vest, and Fred Belcher's guitar playing to provide the perfect dance accompaniment.
The Bristol Sessions presents the recordings chronologically, offering listeners a valuable play-by-play account of this important event. As a consequence of this sequencing, it becomes clear that the intended stars of the sessions were not the Carter Family or Jimmie Rodgers (who only cut two sides on the penultimate day of the Bristol sessions), but Ernest Stoneman, who, along with family and friends, recorded eighteen sides over two of the first three days of the 1927 sessions.Footnote 8 Furthermore, the inclusion of multiple takes belies any notion that these performers were anything but consummate musicians; note, for example, Blind Alfred Reed's two attempts at “The Wreck of the Virginian” on the second disc, in which the second take differs little from the first. Finally, the 1928 sessions included here feature subsequent sessions by many Bristol Sessions acts—including Karnes, Phipps, and the Stoneman Family—as well as six remarkable sides from the Stamps Quartet, one of the leading early gospel quartets.
This collection would be an invaluable addition to our understanding of early country music for the recordings alone, but the liner notes—actually, a 120-page book—offer a great deal of insight into the broader cultural and musical contexts of the sessions. Introductory essays recount the circumstances of both sessions, as well as the long-term impact that they have had on cultural tourism and preservation in Bristol and the surrounding region. Expanding on the research of the late Charles K. Wolfe, brief biographical sketches of each of the musicians who recorded in Bristol are provided alongside reproductions of rare photographs, concert advertisements, and sheet music excerpts.Footnote 9 The third section—and the only part of this project that falls short—offers lyrical transcriptions of each of the vocal pieces collected here, but, as the editorial note at the beginning of the section indicates, the producers chose not to trace these songs back to their original composers or investigate print sources that could offer still more insight into the complex cultural milieu of the predominantly Appalachian musicians who recorded in Bristol. The notes conclude with Richard Weize and Tony Russell's thorough discography, organized to parallel the chronology of the sessions themselves; full-color facsimiles of Victor's session logs also provide valuable access to the primary sources.
As is characteristic of most Bear Family releases, the sound quality of the remastered recordings in this collection is exquisite, presenting these eighty-five-year-old recordings with the richness and warmth of the original releases.Footnote 10 Moreover, Christopher King and Malcolm Vidrine's expert transfers from the original metal parts and discs have eliminated much of the noise that could easily have marred these remarkable recordings.
The Bristol Sessions, 1927–1928: The Big Bang of Country Music stands as an important contribution to the study of country music, and vernacular music in the United States more generally. Although the Stoneman, Carter, and Rodgers sides have been anthologized in other Bear Family collections and several of the Stoneman sides were recently collected in 5-String Productions’ Ernest V. Stoneman: The Unsung Father of Country Music,Footnote 11 the effort made to present the Bristol Sessions in such a richly contextual manner deserves high praise and has resulted in a collection that will serve as a valuable resource for years to come.
