Governing Spirits is a fascinating, thought-provoking and deeply researched analysis of the politics of supernatural spectacle in Cuba and Puerto Rico in the first half of the twentieth century. Reinaldo Román examines a series of episodes in each country, beginning with two Cuban spiritists, Hilario Mustelier Garzón and Juan Manso Estévez, in the first decade of the twentieth century, and ending with the appearance of the Virgin to thousands at an impromptu Puerto Rican shrine over several weeks in 1953. (The Conclusion and Introduction include brief discussions of the more recent chupacabras phenomenon.) Along the way, he discusses the Niña Zoila case in Cuba and subsequent scares over brujería, the miraculous spiritist healers La Samaritana and Elenita in Puerto Rico, the itinerant lay-preachers known as the Hermanos Cheos in Puerto Rico, and Clavelito (Manuel Alfonso Pozo), whose miraculous cures were produced via Cuban radio. For Román, what connects these events, which he describes as ‘scattered data points’ (p. 13) in his field of study, is the significance of journalism (initially print journalism, but later radio and television journalism as well) in generating, sustaining and shaping public interest in and official knowledge of them, in a period when journalists were particularly enthusiastic about their role in civil society.
The study is in part a comparative cultural history, charting the divergence of cultural policy and politics in the two islands after 1898. Román shows that the authorities in Cuba were much more concerned than those in Puerto Rico about unorthodox religious practice, and more likely to use state power to suppress it. The Puerto Rican authorities, while not entirely happy about thousands of people frequenting shrines, tended to tolerate such behaviour. Román argues that the difference resulted from the fact that in Cuba ‘the political economy of the republic made the suppression of superstition more pressing’.
As well as contrasts, Román also draws connections. He argues that, in both Cuba and Puerto Rico, the period he discusses saw a shift in state approaches to the spectacular or the miraculous. At the beginning of the twentieth century, both the Cuban and the Puerto Rican states adopted policies of ‘government’, involving the incarceration of religious leaders in psychiatric hospitals and the arrest of their followers. By the 1950s, both states had shifted to what Román characterises as ‘management’, in which governments attempted to organise and thus regularise the reception of charismatic healers and miracles. In Cuba, Batista's government provided an army escort for the pilgrimage of Irma Izquierdo (known as La Estigmatizada) as she walked from Havana to the town of El Cobre. In Puerto Rico, police directed traffic to ensure that visitors coming to see the apparition of the Virgin Mary at Sabana Grande would be able to do so smoothly; journalists agreed that the government had successfully ‘delivered the miracle of order’ (p. 17). And journalists, Román argues, were critical in shifting the regime from government to management. Roman's argument for a change in ruling strategy is for the most part persuasive. Nevertheless, the distinction between these two forms of rule, both of which appear to draw on Foucault's concept of ‘governmentality’, sometimes blurs, as when Román describes ‘the management of suspect religious forms’ as a ‘governing strategy’ (p. 14).
An important argument of Governing Spirits revolves around the significance of new ideas about ‘freedom of religion’, which was officially guaranteed by the Cuban Constitution of 1902, and by the Puerto Rican Jones Act of 1917. In order to guarantee religious freedom, states had to know what ‘religion’ was. This led to multiple efforts to define the boundaries of ‘religion’, and to decide whether Afro-Cuban religion, or spiritism, fell within or beyond them. From the state's point of view, if these illicit religions – or non-religions – were to be repressed, this had to be achieved without disturbing the idea that the new republic or ‘protectorate’ guaranteed religion to all. Paradoxically, the definition of religious freedom as an official policy of the state led to greater delineation of some forms of ritual and worship as outside the boundaries of what was protected.
Governing Spirits covers some ground that has already been analysed by distinguished scholars including Alejandro de la Fuente, Aline Helg, Alejandra Bronfman and Stephan Palmié. Most of this previous work has focused on the brujería panics as part of a wider analysis of the politics of race in Cuba. Román brings something new to the table, however: by integrating his discussions of these same events with analysis of the reception and reporting of white religious leaders, and with comparative material on Puerto Rico, Román highlights both the significance of race and the fact that the field of religion was not organised around a straightforward dichotomy between black and white. Román's detailed attention to journalism adds another significant layer to the story, and all of this makes Governing Spirits an important and engaging book that will be of great value to scholars of Caribbean cultural and political history.
