This book's intriguing title derives from a conversation between the author and Alberto, one of many acquaintances in Santo Domingo, the capital of the Dominican Republic. ‘There was no better way to put to language the seductive lure of the commodity than as a Narcissus-like engagement with a mirror,’ Steven Gregory writes. ‘This book proceeds from Alberto's deft metaphor and examines the dissonance between what transnational capital promises and what it delivers as this tension is lived, interpreted, and acted upon in the everyday lives of working people’ (pp. 4–5). Drawing on ethnographic fieldwork in the towns of Boca Chica and Andrés, near the capital, Gregory assesses the local impact of the Dominican Republic's transformation from a predominantly agricultural economy to one increasingly reliant on international tourism and export manufacturing. His analysis centres on the rise of multiple informal economic activities, especially sex work, by Boca Chica's residents who strive to survive on the margins of all-inclusive tourist resorts. The author is particularly interested in the precarious situation of Haitian immigrants in the Dominican Republic. In his field site, Haitians earn their living primarily as construction workers, domestic employees, itinerant traders, and, within the tourism industry, folk painters and hair braiders. Throughout, Gregory is concerned with how Dominicans and Haitians construct their racial identities, in a country where most people of African descent classify themselves as indio (literally, Indian, but usually referring to brown skin colour).
Informed by Marxist political economy, the author adopts a highly critical perspective on the worldwide expansion of tourism. Not only has tourism failed to create sufficient jobs for Boca Chica's residents, it has excluded most from formal economic activities such as hotels and restaurants. Consequently, both men and women have been forced to improvise jobs as street vendors, craft workers, snoops, touts, masseuses, manicurists, prostitutes, pimps, motoconchos (motorcycle operators) and other self-employed workers. Gregory is equally disapproving of neoliberal economic reforms, such as the structural adjustment policies promoted by the International Monetary Fund. Such policies have only exacerbated gender, racial and class inequalities in Boca Chica and other tourist enclaves. In particular, they have sharpened the socioeconomic and spatial differences between the zona turística (especially the beach areas) and la comunidad, at the expense of the latter's welfare.
In 2000–01, the author lived for several months in Boca Chica. Various passages of the book provide insights into his research methods, especially his role as an anthropologist and his unconventional relations with his research assistant, Milquella Reyes, as well as interactions with Dominican and Haitian informants, European tourists, and American expatriates. His own ambiguous identity as an American middle-class visitor of uncertain racial status (as the son of a black father and white mother) elicited diverse responses. In one of the author's funniest anecdotes, he was asked to play the role of a Canadian tourist in a locally produced telenovela (soap opera), La negrita y el turista (‘The Little Black Woman and the Tourist’). Meanwhile, some Haitian informants thought he was Haitian because he could speak Kréyol. To avoid being confused with a tourist, Gregory often ‘tried to look like an anthropologist’ by carrying ‘a clipboard with me and wear[ing] long pants and a dress shirt with two pens prominently displayed in the pocket’ (p. 12). He was never entirely successful in persuading people that he was a college professor, as they alternatively labelled him a Puerto Rican tourist, a free trade zone worker, a journalist, a public official, and other mistaken identities. Such imputations helped him understand popular categories of race, ethnicity and gender.
Firmly grounded in the author's field notes, The Devil in the Mirror suggests numerous connections between macro-structural forces such as transnational capitalism and micro-structural conditions such as the spatial organisation of the local community. Occasionally, I felt a disjuncture between what Gregory's informants told him and how he inferred the broader significance of their words and actions. For instance, the author claims that ‘many women who were involved in sex work did so with a critical understanding of the interplay among political economy, gender, and sexuality’ (p. 162). Aside from the academic language employed by Gregory, I doubt that most Dominican sex workers could articulate such linkages explicitly. I sensed a similar gesture in the analysis of everyday incidents, fragments of conversations, and casual observations. It is difficult to accept or refute many of the author's arguments because of the loosely structured, informal and qualitative character of the evidence. Still, the book's rich ethnographic material, thought-provoking interpretations, and engaging writing style make reading it worthwhile.
I would recommend The Devil in the Mirror as a compelling indictment of the perverse human effects of globalisation. Gregory's work carefully documents the valiant efforts of ordinary people who actively resist social forces beyond their control, especially transnational capital, international tourism, and a laissez-faire nation-state. Moreover, the book denounces neoliberal policies that have devalued local currencies, degraded the price of labour, and attracted foreign investment at the cost of dismantling public spending programmes for the poor. As Gregory shows, structural adjustment policies have increased unemployment, underemployment, poverty and inequality in the Dominican Republic. That is one of the reasons why, despite rapid aggregate growth of the Dominican economy, many people continue to migrate legally or illegally to the United States, Puerto Rico and elsewhere.
In 2005, the author revisited Boca Chica, only to confirm that the building of a much-vaunted megaport facility at nearby Punta Caicedo had not revitalised the area's economy. Instead, ‘many of the people with whom I worked in 2000–2001 were unemployed or had otherwise suffered from worsening economic conditions and escalating social violence’ (p. 237). Again, the recent experience of the Dominican Republic illustrates the paradox of substantial economic growth without improvement in the living conditions of most of the population. As Gregory notes, ‘in this key respect, Andrés-Boca Chica was a microcosm of the wider Dominican economy’ (p. 238). To return to the beginning, The Devil in the Mirror accomplishes its main task of revealing the unfulfilled promises of transnational capital for the working classes.
