Foreign exchange reserves have assumed considerable importance in the ongoing debate over risks to the international financial system and how it should be reformed in the wake of the great global credit crisis of 2008. The worry is that China's accumulation of foreign exchange reserves and the associated global imbalances were a factor setting the stage for the crisis. The worry for the future is that the country's huge volume of dollar reserves and the incentive this provides for portfolio diversification have disturbing implications for the stability of the dollar. One manifestation of the interest that the media and policy makers have taken in this topic is the frequency of references to ‘historical lessons’ that shed light on possible future developments. For example, one finds frequent reference to how the pound sterling was dethroned by the dollar as the leading international reserve currency and to the implications of this historical episode for what might happen next.
Historical scholarship as done in academia and as used by pundits and policy makers is not the same. The historical record is rich and messy, but history as used in the public sphere tends to be simple and straightforward. There is a temptation, which they must resist, for scholars to simplify their research for public consumption. It has been a key working assumption of the Past, Present and Policy series since its launch in 2005 that the notion that history would yield an unambiguous ‘message’ is a non-starter. And this is how this volume started: although many assumptions were made by the press and by economists regarding the way central banks managed their international reserves in earlier historical periods, very little was known of actual trends and practices, let alone data.
The articles in this volume were presented at the third Past, Present and Policy panel. This is also the second set of panel papers published in the European Review of Economic History. The panel meeting was held at the Palace of Saint George, home of the Republic of Genoa's Casa di San Giorgio and site of the 1922 Genoa Conference, which focused on the role of foreign exchange reserves in the post-World War I international monetary system. The editors issued a call for papers containing new data and insights relevant to the theme ‘Foreign Exchange Reserves and the International Monetary System: Genoa and Beyond’. Papers were selected by the PPP steering committee. Successive drafts were presented at the panel meeting and read and commented on by anonymous referees, leading to a ‘pass or fail’ decision on the final draft.
The results contain much new quantitative and qualitative evidence on the management of foreign exchange reserves in the late nineteenth century and between the wars, much of which comes from archival sources. One reason the topic has remained obscure is that the transparency of central banks vis-à-vis their foreign exchange holdings remains incomplete. Published information is extremely limited. For data, it is necessary to resort to the archives.
This work is painful but the outcome rewarding. The result is wide coverage in terms of time and space: until this collection, nobody had any idea about how the Bank of Japan managed its foreign exchange reserves prior to recent decades. No one had a hint that before World War I some central banks engaged in routine repurchase operations aimed at adjusting the liquidity of the money market or that they utilized modern over-the-counter forward contracts. No one knew that the dollar had in fact supplanted sterling as the leading reserve currency not sometime after World War II but already in 1924. The articles here are likely to lead to additional research and an ambitious new agenda for work on international currency competition in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. In addition, however, the profession is now better equipped to address the questions that have been asked and will be again asked in the future by citizens and policy makers.
Berkeley and Geneva, September 2009
Barry Eichengreen and Marc Flandreau
