In the second decade of the twenty-first century, a book on architecture that debates the meaning of modernism, nearly a half century after its peak, might be considered a bit out of sync. Yet Beyond the Supersquare makes a persuasive case that the legacy of modernism remains with us and it is still worthy of our attention.
The volume contends that Latin American design culture tends to eschew traditional visual arts in favour of an alliance between architecture and design. This alliance, anchored within the modernist period, has important consequences which are studied in this edited collection, originating from a three-day conference (and exhibition) at the Bronx Museum of the Arts in 2011.
Merging art and architecture, the volume's contributors argue, draws out the critical, edgy and socially conscious side of designers, from concerns with housing the poor, embracing the primitive and the organic, and respecting place/ecology, to ensuring that great visual art finds its way into modernist buildings or adjacent public spaces. These works are meant to challenge the status quo of unplanned industrial growth and real-estate speculation, or explore better ways of building into nature. In the words of William Moorish, who penned the foreword, the book's content aims to generate ‘a system, a field, and a political landscape, not just a moment of didactic reflection’ (p. viii).
How should this ‘political landscape’ now be characterised? Editor Antonio Sergio Bessa speaks of the ‘fallacy of a modernist utopia’, which according to him was evoked in the symbolism of Brasília, the first great modernist capital built in 1960, which created both a new geographic centre for a nation, as well as a ‘world stage’ to celebrate modernity in Brazil (and Latin America). Of course, that act was laced with contradiction and irony: Brasília's iconic master planner, Lúcio Costa, intended the urban design plan to be open and to promote citizens’ freedom, yet the city subsequently became a space that also facilitated state control. It is this dilemma that drove artists to challenge the ‘clean aesthetics of modernism’ (p. 4) with multifaceted interpretations.
Bessa's introduction, and the next two essays in the book set the stage for the eight case studies that follow. First, Alejandro Hernández-Gálvez, writing about modernist architecture in Mexico, ponders whether the post-revolutionary design movement's overarching focus on Mexican national identity made it both a cliché and a limiting style. Hernández-Gálvez builds his essay around a group of young Mexican architects who became part of the 1930s debate on the future of Mexican architecture. He describes a surge in interest on designs of housing for the poor, but also a search for ‘authenticity’. Some designers, like Juan O'Gorman went so far as to reject architecture altogether, at least for a time, turning instead towards art. The collaboration between artists and architects in Mexico, often termed ‘plastic integration’, became central to Mexico's modern architectural identity. This is a theme repeated in other essays in the volume.
Perhaps the most provocative essay in the collection is María Durán Calisto's ‘Modernism and Contemporary Art in Latin America’. Calisto argues that the artistic element in architecture allows designers to take greater risks and explore controversial themes. She offers a number of subsequent observations (‘hypotheses’ in her words). The most striking is her argument that modernist architecture in the southern hemisphere is inherently tied to the ‘favela’ (shantytown), since most modern construction was built by cheap labour and it was those workers who spontaneously created the squatter settlements that epitomise the landscape of modernist cities across Latin America. Modernism's designers south of the border were inherently driven by ‘social aspiration’, which took the form of either ‘high’ or ‘low’ art (the latter in the form of vernacular self-built housing and the former as innovative buildings for the public good). This inherent dialectic is a critical issue which Latin America's modernist architects struggled to resolve.
The remaining eight chapters explore these notions via specific architects within individual nations. Javier de Jesús Martínez, for example, writes about Henry Klumb, a German national who worked briefly with Frank Lloyd Wright who then came to Puerto Rico and was a key figure in its post-1950 design legacy. His work on the new University of Puerto Rico at Río Piedras was part of a national programme of economic reconstruction and modernisation on the island. Foreign modernist architects’ impact in Latin America is a theme that emerges in various chapters, though it is not explicitly analysed. That might have been an intriguing path of inquiry.
The large-scale, concrete modernist ‘university-city’ is a phenomenon repeated across Latin American cities. In her essay ‘Secret Lines’, Hannia Gómez writes about Venezuela's massive Ciudad Universitaria in Caracas, another iconic modern architectural feat used to celebrate Venezuela's petroleum boom and emergence as a major centre of modernity. The architect Raúl Villanueva trained in Paris and became a Corbusian enthusiast. He designed soaring concrete structures, and drew on the ‘secret lines’ of the art/architecture dialogue by commissioning works from many leading visual artists of the era, such as Alexander Calder, Jean Arp and Gertrude Goldschmidt (Gego). Gego's wire-like environmental sculptures seem to literally echo Gómez's metaphor of ‘secret lines’ in modern urban spaces filled with highways, railways, ports and other linear connectors.
Other chapters bring to light similar stories across Latin America, where modernist designers worked on the frontiers of art and architecture. In Havana, Eduardo Luis Rodríguez describes post-revolutionary architecture inherently tied to public art and sculpture. In Brasília, João Filgueira Lima (Lele)'s curving memorial to anthropologist Darcy Ribeiro is a sensual, sculpture-like building, often referred to as the Beijodromo (Kissingdrome). And, in São Paulo, transplanted Italian architect Lina Bo Bardi's Museum of Art São Paulo (MASP) building inspired Ligia Nobre to write about the poetic experience of an interior exhibition hall that challenges our Western sense of ‘linear time’ by creating an ‘entangled’ space where the visitor feels liberated, rather than trapped inside a staged experience.
The chapter by Julieta González, on Juan Downey's ‘invisible architecture’, is a fitting final essay, since it speaks of someone who was more of a conceptual artist than an architect. Downey's important contribution was to grapple with questions that too many modernists left unanswered: the interconnection between changing technology, communications and the built environment.
This volume would have been even stronger if the editors/organisers emphasised and deconstructed a selection of themes, including the poetics of art/design frontiers, high vs. low art, architecture and the environment, and the impact of foreign architects. Since the collected essays, apart from the first three, are generally specialised narratives, often about one or two designers in one city, and a single building or project, the reader may not be able to grasp the larger significance of the book's collective messages. Indeed, a concluding chapter might have tied these loose ends together. The volume could have also been enriched by more illustrations, or, at least, larger black-and-white images. These would have added greater depth to the visual art/architecture narratives. That said, this is a lively and readable volume that Latin Americanists interested in art, architecture and cities will want to have in their libraries.
