Emily's Songbook: Music in 1850s Albany is a facsimile edition, with an extensive scholarly commentary, of the bound songbook of Emily Esperanza McKissick, a resident of Albany, New York, in the mid-nineteenth century. This edition offers an in-depth view of the musical life of the American parlor in a typical smaller city. Although its contents reflect the tastes of a specific female amateur performer-teacher, they go far beyond Albany to represent middle-class musical preferences throughout the United States. By reproducing the entire contents of her personal volume of published sheet music and providing several essays about this music, the editors treat readers to both the raw musical material and solid, up-to-date scholarship to aid in interpreting it.
Four editorial sections of varied lengths and purposes precede the 272-page reproduction of Emily's collection of sheet music. Emily's songbook is the personal property of Mark Slobin, which he labels a “binder's volume,” and he apparently instigated this study.Footnote 1 Slobin lays out the purposes behind his and the three other essays: to describe Emily's collection as an “agent of social circulation” in the context of her times, and to compare it to avenues of dissemination and music consumption today. In reference to this latter concept, it is striking to see words like “Internet” and “iPod” in this volume, and thus be reminded of how incredibly different things were then. Slobin sees in both Emily's day and today “a confusing array of new media wreck[ing] havoc on settled ways” (5) through targeted marketing, the development of product loyalty, and well beyond. Slobin suggests that Emily was following the fashion by having her favorite sheet music bound into a book, just as someone today might create a playlist on iTunes or share one's musical tastes via Facebook. Slobin's frequent use of the term “orality” may explain the inclusion of this book in the publisher's Recent Researches in the Oral Traditions of Music series. A-R Editions also publishes the Recent Researches in American Music series, which may well have been a more logical place for this volume. However, the intended effect of this opening essay is to go beyond the printed page and consider the social situations in which Emily and her friends, family, or students used this bound volume.
In his essay “Who Was Emily McKissick?,” James Kimball delves into Emily's Scottish ancestry and relationships with her siblings and close friends. Despite the ample genealogical data presented, Kimball confesses that “for the next twelve years [starting 1844], we have very little specific information on Emily” (8), in other words, between her eighth and twentieth birthdays. Although she was certainly of the middle class, if not somewhat upwardly mobile, it is clear that we cannot learn intimate details about Emily's life, such as might be expressed in letters or a journal. Fortunately, the young Emily made handwritten annotations on some of the music she collected, which hint at her relationships with family and friends in mid-century Albany. (She later moved to Buffalo.) Seizing on this information, Kimball offers some possible explanations. That Albany was burgeoning in the 1850s is amply illustrated with plates 12–19.Footnote 2 And the great variety of public musical occasions celebrated there is impressive—bands playing on July 4th, choirs and organs sounding in churches, touring soloists like Jenny Lind appearing on stage, minstrel troupes coming to town, and street music, as described in the Albany Evening Journal, 2 September 1853: “Onward we move . . . passing numerous fruit stands and some straggling musicians with hand organs, tambourines, fiddles and harps, until we meet the motley group collected around the store . . . and we will therefore conclude by advising all to go and see the play” (10).
Kimball concludes with descriptions of the local theaters, and museum and other performance venues, and gives biographical summaries of the major musical figures active in Albany at the time. It is by inference mostly that Emily can be placed in this rich musical world. She was there and likely a participant, yet little direct evidence places her in specific musical venues or situations, or documents her interactions with Albany's musical luminaries. (Their biographies take up more than a third of Kimball's essay.) How grand it would be to have found Emily's private box of news clippings, theater tickets, and personal journal entries!
Katherine Preston provides an excellent interpretive accounting of the repertory in Emily's bound volume in her well-documented study “Music in the McKissick Parlor.” Preston defines the parlor as an important emblem of middle-class America, contextualizing Emily's collection in terms of gender, social class, and musical tastes. She discusses the availability of parlor music and where and how Emily purchased it. This is followed by an informative breakdown of repertory by genre, such as love songs, instrumental selections, folk-like pieces, minstrel songs, and operatic selections. Not only does Preston define each genre, but she also discusses to what extent Emily's collection includes more (minstrel material) or less (instrumental music) than normal for similar American binder's volumes. Her final assessment is that Emily's collection is mostly typical, but I can't help note the comparative lack of songs about temperance and abolition. Was Emily perhaps not as socially conscious as others of her time?
Deane Root's essay works outward from the specific pieces in Emily's songbook. Root opens with a discussion of the way sheet music can be examined as primary source material, providing two summary tables organizing some or all of the pieces first in terms of their availability through local publishers and secondly by date. Then he moves on to summarize individually and in order each of the forty-six songs in the volume. He addresses the relative popularity of these works (a few are quite rare) and points out specific details of interest, such as the fact that the very first piece in this binder's volume, “The Sontag Polka,” was extremely popular and widespread, and that it referred to the highly regarded European soprano Henrietta Sontag, who visited the United States in 1852. Root notes that the copy of “The Star-Spangled Banner” in Emily's collection didn't seem to show much use, and Preston had noted before that this is the only patriotic piece in the collection. Does this mean Emily was unpatriotic? I doubt it is that simple.
The visual appearance of each piece of sheet music reproduced in this volume is largely similar. Most include a cover with varied typefaces in several sizes, often with an illustration. The many songs in the volume are in strophic form that accommodates several verses, and they have relatively simple keyboard accompaniments. The beauty of thumbing through the pages of Emily's songbook is particularly apparent if the reader first reads the introductory essays, and thus freely imagines the musical world so well described by Kimball, Preston, and Root. These pages were purposefully bound together in Emily's songbook, and their significance for her then and for us today is in their grouping. Much as the novelist leaves many details to be filled in by the reader's imagination, so too does Emily's songbook.
This volume therefore touches upon some very important points in the story of mid-nineteenth-century American music: the impact of touring virtuosos like Jenny Lind, the presence of minstrel troupes, and the feminization of the parlor, for example. That Emily's tastes extended to piano duets and songs with multi-part choruses suggests that her parlor was at times busy and full. (The chorus to song 21, “Emma Dale, sung by [the] Sable Melodists,” is in six parts.) It would be fascinating to know more about Emily's later years as a teacher in Buffalo; for example, to what extent were the musical styles of the next generation changing?
My main criticism of this volume is the darkness of all the music images and some of the plates. Even if these images only survive on time-darkened paper, why not digitally lighten them for ease of use today? After all, they were once in pristine condition. The main purpose of this publication, I believe, is the presentation of Emily's complete songbook in facsimile, and I found it difficult to work with for this reason. The main strength of this book lies in its inclusion of both primary and secondary source materials. The reader can thumb back and forth between the essays and music book itself, and actively participate in interpreting the music. The organization of this volume is clear and the section headings are helpful. The frequent citations define this as a scholarly book that can be used in performance. Nothing jumped out at me as even remotely stretching the facts or their interpretations. Although informative on its own, sheet music provides an incomplete trail for the historian wishing to understand the Americans who used it. But Emily's Songbook: Music in 1850s Albany advances our ability to flesh out the significance of parlor music practice and is thus a notable contribution to the study of nineteenth-century American music history.
