The Atlantic World and Virginia emerged out of a conference held in Williamsburg in March 2004. The purpose of the conference and the volume is to commemorate the four hundredth anniversary of the settlement at Jamestown. This is an unusual commemorative volume, as it aims not to develop a narrative of Jamestown or to make a pilgrimage to democracy's birthplace, but “by approaching it from current historical perspectives on the encounters, collisions, and collaborations of peoples and political entities in North and South America, Africa, and Europe in the period surrounding contact between the inhabitants of Tsenacommach and Englishmen” (p. x). The volume contends that “Virginia's story only becomes intelligible when seen as a small, and not always significant part of an Atlantic history” (p. 25).
Following an able introduction by the editor, which defines an Atlanticist perspective and reviews the existing literature, the 18 essays in The Atlantic World are divided into five sections. In the first, Daniel Richter, Joseph Hall, and James Rice explore the Native American experience during the era of European invasion. The second section strays far from Virginia to examine the movement of people around the Mediterranean as Muslim and European influence spread in sub-Saharan Africa. Section three focuses on the colonial enterprises of the several European states engaged in colonizing the Americas. In section four, Andrew Fitzmaurice, David Harris Sacks, Benjamin Schmidt, and David S. Shields explore the ideas driving England's colonial project. The final section again focuses on Virginia in an effort to define the colony's role in the Atlantic World.
While this volume has its strengths—the attention to Native peoples who are too often neglected in Atlanticist scholarship—economic historians will be disappointed, for the volume demonstrates once again that those who shout about their interdisciplinary approach often have a narrow view of the scholarly enterprise, one that excludes disciplines that take a rigorous quantitative approach to the past. Only one essay in the volume focuses on trade, and none examines migration—strange omissions because trade and migration are what tied the Atlantic World together.
These are not the only omissions from this volume. The growth of African slavery, especially the transition from servants to slaves and the rise of racist ideologies, are both subjects that would benefit from an Atlanticist perspective but receive little attention. However, if we accept that the organizers of this project have gone far around the cultural bend, there is much to be learned from this book.
I should also note that the volume lacks coherence. Despite brave efforts by Peter Mancall in the introduction and Start Schwartz in an epilogue to tie it together, readers will often be left wondering what an essay has to do with Virginia. Indeed, several of the essays do not even mention the colony.
Fortunately the parts are better than the whole, and students of the early modern Atlantic will find much of interest in this volume. The essays on Native Americans will certainly interest students of the indigenous peoples of the Chesapeake Bay region, and Paul Boucher and John Elliot provide helpful introductions to the French and Iberian Atlantic respectively. Despite these strengths, I remain disappointed with this book. Perhaps its major weakness is the failure to advance the argument that Virginia's history can only be understood if placed in the context of the Atlantic World. There are several reasons for this. For one, the essays are strangely distanced from the rich historiographic tradition of the Chesapeake region, which gives the authors little chance to show how an Atlanticist perspective illuminates major issues in the history of Virginia. For another, the authors apparently were not asked to address the question of how an Atlanticist approach illuminates the issues they are dealing with. Finally, the volume ends in 1624, a strange choice as it can be argued that it is only after that date that Virginia was thoroughly integrated into the Atlantic World. As a result, in this volume the Atlantic World seems more of a buzz-word than an analytic device. Readers interested in an Atlanticist perspective on early Virginia, would be better served by turning to April Hatfield's Atlantic Virginia: Intercolonial Relations in the Seventeenth Century (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2004).
