“Soon we'll be so developed, we won't even need to eat,” quips a village resident in Emily Yeh's powerful monograph on the contemporary urban transformation of Tibet (p. 163). Similar sentiments—often humorous or bitter—echo throughout this excellent study, which focuses on both the performance and presumption of gratitude towards the “gift” of Chinese state development in Tibet (p. 2). Taming Tibet carefully analyzes conundrums that have puzzled individuals with divergent perspectives on the modern Tibetan condition, specifically why Tibetans are not “thankful” for the rapid economic development that has spread through the landscape over the past couple of decades. This book is essential reading for anyone interested in discourses of development in China since the 1950s.
For those unfamiliar with the region, the preface provides a careful and concise background to its recent history, and answers initial questions about Yeh's positioning (she is indeed well-positioned, fluent in both Tibetan and Chinese). The book is then divided into three clear parts: (1) a historical account of state farm agriculture and the conquering of nature in the new socialist period of the 1950s (“Soil”); (2) the period of post-decollectivization and the growth of the Han migrant population—especially in conjunction with greenhouse cultivation—in Tibet in the 1980s and 1990s (“Plastic”); and (3) the new urban landscape in Lhasa, the building of new homes, dispossession, and relocation in the twenty-first century (“Concrete”). Overall, the book is a well-crafted mixture of ethnographic material, detailed empirical data, and theoretical analysis. The oral narratives of the collective period in Tibet are particularly welcome, due to the relative lack of such material in more recent publications, as is the section's gendered approach, which pays close attention to women on state farms who were given “a sense of purpose in their labor” (p. 91).
Three of Yeh's arguments make particularly valuable contributions. In her central argument, Yeh weaves together an innovative theoretical framework combining Mauss's theory of the gift, critical geographical approaches to development, and Gramscian hegemony. Gifts are always entangled with obligation and reciprocity; thus, in return for the intensification of economic development in Tibet, Tibetans are duly expected to be loyal to the state. Here, Yeh demonstrates how the presumed gratefulness for the gift of development works in a hegemonic way, resulting in tying minority subjects closer to the PRC, a move that is supposed to lead to overall stability (p. 242). And yet, as Yeh shows later, this gift can be rejected or negotiated through the cultural politics of work and leisure.
Second, the book emphasizes the profound spatial inequalities of living in contemporary Tibet. State-driven territorialization is one example. People are relocated to grand-looking houses visible from a highway, yet these are “barely functional” as actual homes, forming a crucial part of state-based “image engineering” improvement projects (p. 251). In addition, surveillance—both state-imposed and self-imposed—limits Tibetans' spatial mobility. Bans on religious activity prevent those on government salaries from visiting temples, and many have difficulties traveling abroad due to the near-impossibility of obtaining passports (pp. 37–38). As a result, worrying about any activity being deemed “political” produces subjects who are “always already guilty.”
Finally, Yeh demonstrates how Tibetans use the tropes of “laziness” and “being spoiled” to produce a different value system of moral and economic development that directly challenges the one promoted by the state (p. 187). By calling themselves “lazy,” they reinforce their economic marginalization, setting themselves further apart from the Han migrant farmers in Tibet, who are seen as part of the state narrative of self-cultivation.
Taming Tibet will reach a broad audience. As its main themes straddle the boundaries of several fields, it will be of interest to geographers, anthropologists, political ecologists, and development studies scholars, as well as scholars of Tibet and China, although undergraduates may have a difficult time with some of the more complex passages that punctuate the otherwise highly readable narrative. Such a book comes at a time—especially since the protests of 2008—when there is a paucity of solid ethnographic and geographical work on the contemporary economic situation in Tibet. In this sense, Yeh's work is cutting-edge within social scientific work in Tibetan studies, for few recent studies have combined these elements in such depth. As development is not the same everywhere, recognizing how it works requires culturally specific understandings of how space is constituted (p. 265). Through this study of Tibetan landscape transformation, Yeh provides us with one of the more critical and interesting recent studies of the legitimization of China's sovereignty.
