Concentrating on the relationship between local rulers and British officials, Miriam Joyce's book traces the political evolution of the British protected Gulf shaykhdoms between 1960 and 1969, and thus the background to Britain's withdrawal from the region in 1971. This momentous decade ended the process of British decolonization in the Middle East after World War II and ushered in the formation of a constellation of Arab states whose strategic and economic importance was to grow exponentially in the years to come. The narrative and structure of Ruling Shaikhs and Her Majesty's Government follow a strict chronological order. The first five chapters (“The Trucial States,” “Qatar,” “Bahrain,” “Kuwait,” and “Oman”) describe developments between 1960 and 1967, followed by two chapters dealing with 1968 and 1969 (“1968: Year of Decision” and “Countdown to Withdrawal,” respectively), the latter detailing the failed negotiations for the formation of a regional confederation inclusive of the seven trucial states, Qatar and Bahrain. A short conclusion (pp. 144–48) follows the blueprint of earlier chapters concentrating on events leading up to the independence of Bahrain in July 1971 and the formation of the United Arab Emirates in December of the same year.
Despite the chronological arrangement, the author's choice of periodization is neither self-explanatory nor particularly convincing. The rationale is not obvious either in the body of the book or in the introduction and conclusion. The year 1960 is a puzzling starting date, particularly when considering later developments in regional politics that were closely connected with the emergence of “progressive” Arab regimes in the 1950s and had a destabilizing effect on British and shaykh power in the region. Equally puzzling, the decision to end the book rather abruptly in 1969 hinders an effective interpretation (or reinterpretation) of the circumstances that led to the departure of the Great Britain from the region two years later.
Joyce has made full use of diplomatic records, mainly British Foreign Office materials complemented with some sources from the American National Archives. The general inadequacy of the textual and contextual interpretation of the documentation makes Joyce's prose reminiscent of a Foreign Office précis. Naturally, the resulting account is generally sympathetic to the British government and is populated by a dense patchwork of voices and events. Although this gives the reader a first-hand appreciation of a variety of important issues that made up the daily routine of Gulf politics (from the significant to the banal), the preponderance of anecdotes make it difficult to grasp the overall thread of Joyce's argument. Thus, there is little or no contextualization of the political trends in the region in the 1950s and 1960s, and their discussion is hampered by the author's excessive reliance on her detailed reading of primary sources. For instance, the impact of Arab nationalism on Gulf rulers, which is crucial to an understanding of their political strategy vis-à-vis the representatives of the British government, is not elaborated in any meaningful way. Joyce gives no background on the activities of the leaders of the Committee of National Union in Bahrain, the most influential grass roots political organization of the 1950s, which is mentioned only in passing (pp. 55–56). Similarly, the author glosses over the Dhofar Liberation Front in Oman (p. 99). Secondary materials are used very sparingly, mostly in the introduction, and there is no bibliography. Although academic literature dealing with the period is not extensive, its critical reading (at least in the introduction) could have guided the thematic development of the book.
As suggested by the title, Ruling Shaikhs and Her Majesty's Government is also concerned with the other side of the imperial equation, local political actors. The author's portrayal of leading shaykhs is characterized by clichés and easy generalizations, largely because British judgments are taken at face value. The subtext of Joyce's characterization is much the same throughout the book. In parts it emerges more clearly as in the case of Saqr bin Muhammad al-Qasimi, “the intelligent and thoughtful ruler of Ras al-Khayma” (p. 13), whose interest in development projects curried favor with British and foreign observers alike. As scholars involved in the region know very well, it is extremely difficult to access first-hand documentation from the Arab side, if it is available at all. However, Gulf political culture deserves some scrutiny and more consideration. What British officials interpreted as naivety, ignorance, or conservatism was consistent with mechanisms of power politics that regulated indigenous political structures and relations within the ruling families.
In sum, this book offers very little as a reinterpretation of the reasons why Great Britain left the region, especially from the perspective of local rulers. For the reasons stated above, it is unsuitable for a general and student readership. The former will not grasp the significance of events in a larger context; the latter will be exposed to uncritical historical writing. Specialists on the region may find some useful information on the beginnings of American inroads into the Gulf, and firsthand materials on the rhetoric of development that permeated British policy at the onset of oil modernization, a topic that so far has been neglected. Entrusting local shaykhs with the welfare of their subjects through the redistribution of wealth was the last manifestation of the old “mission civilisatrice” of the empire while also responding to Britain's pressing need of disengagement from the region.
