In this important book, the foremost labor historian of the Ottoman Empire treats us to a historical and sociological exploration of the “lives of labor” (p. 6) of the roughly 10,000 workers of the Zonguldak coalfield from the mid-19th century to the end of World War I. Working with original sources of unprecedented richness and detail, Donald Quataert skillfully reconstructs and analyzes the political economy of these Ottoman mines: the size and division of labor of the free and unfree, mostly male workforce; the web of relations between villages and mines; the hewers and carriers who made up the bulk of the villager–miner underground workforce; and the characteristics of the nonlocal, usually above-ground workforce. In meticulous detail, Quataert examines recruitment practices, wages, hours, and working conditions, attempting to recover and reconstruct whatever possible of the working and everyday lives of workers so often ignored in the larger historiography of the region. In so doing, Quataert sheds light on the workings of the Ottoman state and the operations of capital accumulation in Zonguldak and above all contributes to our understanding of changing worlds of labor during a critical period of transformation.
Although many lament that in an age of spiraling inequality and the “new imperialism” postcolonial, subaltern, and cultural studies have lost interest in both material interests and the poor and the disenfranchised alike, few have undertaken research tackling the problem. Rather than being a work of postsubaltern studies, however, Quataert's book reasserts the sturdy virtues of a materially grounded, painstakingly researched labor history that broaches original sources and is informed by questions and problems familiar in a long tradition of social history and Marxian scholarship. Such histories, sometimes accused of “objectivism,” trenchantly assert that those who produce the wealth that the rest of us enjoy deserve a historiography and a recognition usually withheld. They are part and parcel of the dynamics of political economy in general. However, this book is not the last gasp of a dying materialist tradition. Where discomfort with the excesses and sometime elitism of cultural and linguistic determinism is increasingly voiced, it instead signposts how a more materially grounded historiography might be reconstructed.
The book pays attention throughout to an important question in labor history, economic sociology, and historical materialism: the dynamics, meaning, and form of both extraeconomic and economic coercion in the labor regime. Whereas traditional Marxian historiography paid less attention to extraeconomic coercion, considering it a relic of precapitalism, recent attention from David Harvey and others to “accumulation by dispossession” has stirred interest in how overt violence and compulsion play a role in linking labor to capital. Jettisoning teleological assumptions, Quataert carefully explores the “changing mix of unfree and free labor” (p. 7) in the Ottoman mines.
Following the failure of the mines to secure “voluntary” labor in the 1840s and 1850s, the Ottoman state brought in a compulsory rotational labor system implemented by newly co-opted village headmen and others. It involved “massive coercion” (p. 55) and dominated the lives of the villager-miners of the underground workforce from 1867 to 1921. The above-ground workforce came to be mostly composed of “voluntary,” fully proletarianized wage labor, and chronic labor shortages below and above ground were made up by conscripted soldiers—available after universal conscription began in earnest after 1848 and appearing in the mines (mostly above ground) in significant numbers from the late 1860s on (p. 130, 134ff). In this account, labor supplies are not secured automatically but through various arrangements depending on political, economic, and even military contexts—the latter theme playing an important role in Quataert's exposition.
Quataert convincingly establishes that workers suffering extraeconomic coercion under compulsory labor rotation retained links to their villages, were paid less than their fully proletarianized counterparts, and were subject to beatings and worse. He also argues—and here is where more standard Marxian assumptions come into play—that there was something rather “extraordinary” about this “particular hybrid” workforce (pp. 7, 233). Compulsory workers were more vulnerable to capitalist exploitation than their better-organized and more militantly proletarian wage-labor coworkers, who were likely “the engine for improvements” and reforms in the mines (p. 53). These are standard Marxian theses stemming from not fully justifiable assumptions that free wage labor is the norm (other labor regimes are peculiar), that free wage labor constitutes the nucleus of progressive worker activism, and that the superexploitation of rotating workers is a key feature of articulated modes of production (an idea most fully worked out, perhaps, in the work of Claude Meillassoux). Quataert also favorably compares free wage labor enjoying “cash bonuses, decent housing, and medical care” to forced labor suffering “brutal coercion” and “whippings” “under conditions amounting to slavery” (p. 6).
Quataert provides both enough evidence and sufficient clarity about empirical gaps, however, to enable the reader to raise questions about some of these familiar Marxian positions. First is the notion that forced labor is a peculiarity that needs explaining, whereas free wage labor is a normal state that does not rely partly on a particular reading of Marx; it presumes an idealized history of northwest Europe and the United States, to which comparison is made, and involves a lack of comparison to much of Asia, Africa, the Caribbean, Latin America, and the Middle East, past and present. In the context of capitalism, moreover, the idea that free wage labor is indeed “free”—that is, voluntary—has also been questioned.
Second, it is not so clear that the forced labor system was so much worse, taken overall, than the voluntary system. It is made abundantly clear that employers tended to prefer the free wage-labor force to the compulsory, coerced labor force—“unreliable” workers who were difficult to control and to obtain in sufficient numbers, who lacked the requisite work ethic, and who exhibited “decidedly unsubservient and uncapitalist behaviour” (pp. 53, 231). Major mining interests thus tried to break up this compulsory system (p. 231). The state, although concerned about social stability in the context of full proletarianization, appears to have been ready to fall in with employers' interests and their arguments about production and efficiency. Also, the headmen who implemented the compulsory labor system, although they acquired a “chilling” power of “life and death” over their covillagers (p. 130), could also—at least occasionally—be held responsible for their actions and accused, for example, of “impiety” (p. 104). The impersonal supply mechanisms of the market, by contrast, involved no such immediate form of recourse and local politics.
Third, in a tendency familiar in other settings, the workers appear to have resisted full proletarianization at all costs—cleaving to their villages, harvests, festivals, and alternative means of subsistence and production whenever possible. If these worker practices are not to be dismissed as backward or nostalgic, then they can be taken as evidence of what workers preferred—that is to say, they preferred the forms of independence afforded them by the forced labor system in comparison with the fully proletarianized alternative. As Quataert details, workers resisted “being bound more closely to mine work and to a cash nexus”; they said “no” to piecework, insisted on weeklong holidays in Ramadan, continued to leave the mines to harvest, or failed to show up at all (pp. 53, 211–12, 231–32).
Nonetheless, this is not seen by the author as “real” activism, which is instead located among the free wage-labor force, even with the admission that the processes whereby gains in the mines were made by activist free wage labor are actually “largely invisible” (p. 53). By contrast, the gains of having access to fields and harvest are tangible. Moreover, some of the putative improvements in the mines turned out not to be gains at all. Accident rates do not seem to have fallen (“accidents” hardly does justice to the systematic ways in which miners were killed by mining). For example, the new “safety lamps”—designed to reduce deaths from explosions—were actually resisted by workers underground, perhaps because they offered so little illumination (half of a single candle) that they increased the risk of “deaths from rockfalls” (p. 202). Indeed, Quataert does argue that “safety” was in part a program to “educate, discipline, and control” workers (p. 195). In this context, it does not seem far-fetched to suggest that the overt violence deployed in the forced labor regime was as much a sign of the weakness of employers and state in procuring labor as it was a sign of worker misery and brutalization.
Overall, to read Quataert's rich and important book both with and against the grain is to question important assumptions about free and unfree wage labor under capitalism and to throw down the challenge of reconstructing a materially grounded history from below.
