Kathleen M. Gough's Kinship and Performance in the Black and Green Atlantic is a novel addition to a field that demands novelty. Gough's work on Irish and African-American contact on both sides of the Atlantic enters into a crowd of celebrated studies, among them: Theodore W. Allen's The Invention of the White Race; Noel Ignatiev's How the Irish Became White; Fionnghuala Sweeney's Frederick Douglass and the Atlantic World. All of these works contend with serious gaps in the historical record that subtly dictate the lines of inquiry that can be followed from this set of materials. The obstacles of the archive have prompted these scholars to make innovative use of what material survives to understand the complex and sometimes contradictory relationships between the Irish and African Americans.
The ambition of this book can be noted by the nimble use of theories drawn from a wide array of literary fields. The author borrows from Gordon Tesky, Fred Moton, Eric Williams, Joseph Roach, and Erasmus to construct her argument about what she terms “haptic allegories”: “the tactile and kinesthetic gestures that move both subjects and objects across the historiographical stage-surface” (8). This hermeneutic strategy allows the author to read cross-temporally through a variety of media and forms of expression including architecture, literature, and stage performance. Gough's particular concern is for female actors within accounts of the so-called Black and Green Atlantic. She locates her book as a corrective to the problem Gough sees as pervasive within the main course of scholarship on the Black and Green Atlantic, namely, that women are “everywhere present in, and yet rarely relevant to, the circum-Atlantic exchange of ideas” (9). Women as metaphors or surrogates for thinking about origins and suffering are ubiquitous; women who have meaning within themselves appear in the archive with far less frequency. The stakes of Gough's work are to test the power of drama theory to render visible the “absent presence” (166) of the female body in the documents of the Black and Green Atlantic.
The primary example of her investigation, one to which she returns throughout the text, is Frederick Douglass's speaking tour through Britain in 1845. Gough discusses how Douglass produced a “theater of slavery” (33) by showing audiences the sorts of tools used to torture slaves. Gough fixes her attention on the brutal whipping his Aunt Hester received at the hands of her slave master, which he witnessed as a young boy, the recounting of which was often the climax of Douglass's performances. Douglass, in his Narrative of the Life, describes the transformation within himself that came from seeing this as crossing a “blood-stained gate, the entrance to the hell of slavery” (Boston: Anti-Slavery Office, 1849, 6). Here one can see how Douglass evokes the absent bodies of slaves through his use of the tools of enslavement, but also uses the story of Aunt Hester solely as way of generating meaning. The story says less about the life of Aunt Hester than it does about the meaning of slavery that Douglass wished to convey to the audience. Gough contends that through her reading of “haptic allegories” one can render these women more than just metaphors that convey meaning but are, in and of themselves, meaningless.
She uses Douglass's speaking tour and his story about Aunt Hester as a prompt to a much broader set of questions about the evolution of Irish and black relations, up to a recent spate of legislation that negatively and disproportionately affects the rights of African immigrants in Ireland. To encompass such a broad swath of time, Gough structures the book around “flashpoints” (7) in Black and Green Atlantic history: 1830–65, 1870–1900, 1900–30, 1955–70, and the 2000s. This is perhaps the most challenging component of her work in that it demands that the reader not see the contacts and conflicts of the nineteenth century between African Americans and the Irish as an end, but as a beginning of exchanges that continue to be renegotiated. Moreover, the historical perspective underscores Gough's arguments about how one locates women within this field that so frequently focuses on the male perspective. Gough's insistence that we need to think differently about the actors of this history is necessarily coupled with a historical approach that can enable that type of reading. Kinship and Performance in the Black and Green Atlantic is “a dramaturgy of the figure of woman in movement” that allows us to read “the figure of woman” as a social actor across time (13).
There are a few obscure choices and omissions in the text that make the strong research seem incomplete. For example, Gough prefaces each chapter with imagined interactions between the characters she will be discussing. In so doing, the author follows in the footsteps of Saidiya Hartman, who interweaves narrative with scholarly research in her Lose Your Mother. Whereas Hartman articulates the necessary interdependence of the personal and professional in confronting the many silences her project presented, Gough's reasons for departing from traditional forms of evidence are less clear. She argues that she does not want to focus on recovering and analyzing the intentions of “actual” (17) social actors. Instead, she wishes to look at recurrences of acts across time. Such a theoretical apparatus is convincing for a cross-temporal work of dramatic theory, however, for by inserting her own recurrence within the text, Gough intervenes in the corpus of materials she is seeking to uncover. One also wonders why she does not spend more time on the journey and some of the particularly fruitful images of women within them. Because of the attention she affords to the story of Aunt Hester, Gough might well include the modern dramatization of this through the recurring character of Aunt Ester in August Wilson's play cycle. Wilson uses this character in his own depiction of the Middle Passage. Moreover, there are many types of performance that Gough could have addressed within her work that may have been productive to consider. Musical performance, for example, might have been a valuable point of contact among Ireland, America, and Africa. However, this seems to be far beyond the ambit of Gough's interest. These wrinkles within Gough's work bespeak the ambition of the project and the number of different directions future work in this field might take.
