Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T19:03:02.667Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Scoring The President: Myth and Politics in John Williams's JFK and Nixon

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  10 November 2015

Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Throughout his career, John Williams has set the musical tone for the American presidency, most elaborately with his scores for Oliver Stone's controversial films JFK (1991) and Nixon (1995). While invested in capturing the character of these commanders in chief through musical codes, Williams's soundtracks are equally engaged in the act of the evocation and telling of “history.” Specifically, they construct a tragic myth of 1960s America in which the promise represented by JFK is destroyed from without, and Nixon from within, both by the malevolent forces of the military-industrial complex. In considering the thematic and dramatic means by which Williams paints his orchestral portraits, I reveal the extent to which music supports Stone's paranoiac narratives, especially in cases where the director's collage-like visual aesthetic puts pressure on the otherwise nostalgic traits of Williams's default tonal style.

I offer a music-analytical approach to JFK and Nixon informed by interviews, studies of political mythology and paranoia, and musicological appraisals of Williams's music. Stone's 1960s-as-lapsarian-metanarrative positions Kennedy as a romanticized absence, an image of the fabular fallen King, and Williams renders him as a public recollection rather than a human being with interiority. Nixon, by contrast, is a tragic antihero, consumed by dark forces of history and an abundance of ambivalent thematic material. Particular attention is paid to the dismantling of Kennedy's noble leitmotif during JFK’s prologue and motorcade sequence and to the near-fascistic musical accompaniment of Nixon's speeches. Having demonstrated the active role these scores play, I conclude that Williams's music constitutes an authoring of history in a strong, albeit postmodern, sense, consistent with but independent from Stone's screenplay.

Information

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © The Society for American Music 2015 
Figure 0

Figure 1.Anthony Hopkins as US President Richard Nixon confronting JFK in Nixon (1995, Cinergi Pictures Entertainment, Inc.), directed by Oliver Stone and produced by Dan Halsted, Eric Hamburg, Richard Rutowski, Oliver Stone, Clayton Townsend, and Andrew G. Vajna.

Figure 1

Example 1.Music for Nixon's confrontation with JFK from Nixon (1995, Cinergi Pictures Entertainment, Inc.), directed by Oliver Stone and produced by Dan Halsted, Eric Hamburg, Richard Rutowski, Oliver Stone, Clayton Townsend, and Andrew G. Vajna. Musical score by John Williams. Transcription by author.

Figure 2

Example 2.The Drummer's Salute. From Nixon (1995, Cinergi Pictures Entertainment, Inc.), directed by Oliver Stone and produced by Dan Halsted, Eric Hamburg, Richard Rutowski, Oliver Stone, Clayton Townsend, and Andrew G. Vajna. Musical score by John Williams. Transcription by author.

Figure 3

Example 3a.Heroic Materials—“Garrison Family Theme.” From JFK (1991, Le studio canal and Regency Pictures), directed by Oliver Stone and produced by Oliver Stone, Arnon Milchan, and A. Kitman Ho. Musical score by John Williams. Transcription by author.

Figure 4

Example 3b.Heroic Materials—“Arlington.” From JFK (1991, Le studio canal and Regency Pictures), directed by Oliver Stone and produced by Oliver Stone, Arnon Milchan, and A. Kitman Ho. Musical score by John Williams. Transcription by author.

Figure 5

Example 3c.Heroic Materials—“Prologue”/“Theme from JFK” (conflated from several variants). From JFK (1991, Le studio canal and Regency Pictures), directed by Oliver Stone and produced by Oliver Stone, Arnon Milchan, and A. Kitman Ho. Musical score by John Williams. Transcription by author.

Figure 6

Example 3d.Beast Materials—“The Conspirators” particles. From JFK (1991, Le studio canal and Regency Pictures), directed by Oliver Stone and produced by Oliver Stone, Arnon Milchan, and A. Kitman Ho. Musical score by John Williams. Transcriptions by author.

Figure 7

Example 3e.Beast Materials—“The Motorcade.” From JFK (1991, Le studio canal and Regency Pictures), directed by Oliver Stone and produced by Oliver Stone, Arnon Milchan, and A. Kitman Ho. Musical score by John Williams. Transcription by author.

Figure 8

Example 3f.Beast Materials—“Garrison’s Obsession.” From JFK (1991, Le studio canal and Regency Pictures), directed by Oliver Stone and produced by Oliver Stone, Arnon Milchan, and A. Kitman Ho. Musical score by John Williams. Transcription by author.

Figure 9

Table 1.Musical structure of JFK, first ten minutes.

Figure 10

Example 4.Themes and motifs in Nixon (1995, Cinergi Pictures Entertainment, Inc.), directed by Oliver Stone and produced by Dan Halsted, Eric Hamburg, Richard Rutowski, Oliver Stone, Clayton Townsend, and Andrew G. Vajna. Musical score by John Williams. Transcriptions by author.

Figure 11

Table 2.Musical structure of Nixon, “Miami Convention, 1968.”

Figure 12

Example 5.Climax of “Miami Convention, 1968.” From Nixon (1995, Cinergi Pictures Entertainment, Inc.), directed by Oliver Stone and produced by Dan Halsted, Eric Hamburg, Richard Rutowski, Oliver Stone, Clayton Townsend, and Andrew G. Vajna. Musical score by John Williams. Transcription by author.