Far too often studies in contemporary history have concentrated on national stories and have neglected aspects of comparison and entanglement. This is also the case for the history of anti-fascism during the Second World War within the European contextFootnote 1 , although there exist, fortunately, some exceptions.Footnote 2 The history of anti-fascism between the late 1920s and the mid-1940s is, as Enzo Traverso has stated, mainly a history of exile and cosmopolitanism.Footnote 3 This article does not aim at rewriting the complete history of all anti-fascist groups in these years. Instead, by looking at individual biographies it tries to identify some more general aspects of socialist anti-fascism and starts to fill the gap which Jacques Droz left in 1985 when he ended his History of Anti-Fascism in Europe (Histoire de l'antifascisme en Europe) with the outbreak of the Second World War. Droz argued that from this point on there were no further attempts to create an anti-fascist unity front, only individual resistance. According to Droz, European anti-fascism ended with the Hitler-Stalin-Pact on 23 August 1939 and only started to become a decisive factor in European politics again after 1942.Footnote 4 Anson Rabinbach, who is currently conducting a study into these years, has challenged this view.Footnote 5 In a similar vein, I will argue that although transnational anti-fascism certainly underwent a severe crisis, the common culture, concepts and symbols of the movement nevertheless continued to exist and provided the foundations on which further cooperation could be constructed.Footnote 6
The overall aim of this article is to show the development of transnational anti-fascism in French, German and Italian socialist circles by focusing on the Second World War as a central period of anti-fascist hope and disappointment. It follows selected biographies of roughly two dozen Italian, German and French socialists between 1939 and 1945 who represent different tendencies within their parties and who can all be characterised as active anti-fascists. As we shall see, transnational anti-fascism sometimes meant cooperation with all anti-fascists (including communists) and sometimes cooperation with other socialists (excluding communists). Even within the national groups, socialist responses to this issue were very diverse, and this great variety of opinions amongst socialist anti-fascists made efforts to find transnational responses even more difficult. In order to reveal the transnational dimension of socialist anti-fascism both in discourse and practice different categories shall be considered: historical analyses and projects for the post-war order, acts of solidarity such as mutual aid networks set up by groups and institutions and even more noticeable – though quite limited – forms of collaboration in resistance movements. Thus, it will become clear that both the movement and the networks were essential to anti-fascism and not just aspects of the process; in other words, activists, intellectuals and organisations made anti-fascism with their discourses and practices.Footnote 7
In order to understand how the making of anti-fascism was achieved, the article will first highlight some early aspects of transnational anti-fascism by describing the collaboration within the interwar Labour and Socialist International (LSI), the first personal contacts in exile, the fight for a united people's front with the communists and the engagement on the side of the Republic in the Spanish Civil War, which is usually portrayed as the zenith of transnational anti-fascism. Second, anti-fascist discourse and practice in the socialist milieu during the Second World War will be analysed. This also includes smaller left-socialist groups, which split off from the major socialist parties but became partially reintegrated into the family of democratic socialists after 1945. Third, a very short exploration of socialist anti-fascism in the post-war years will demonstrate that transnational cooperation continued even after the common enemy had been defeated.
Transnational Networks Before 1939
Anti-fascism in Europe came into existence at different times in different countries under different circumstances. Nevertheless, historians should pay more attention than they currently do to the first initiatives taken by European communists and socialists against Italian fascism after Mussolini's March on Rome in October 1922. As Kasper Braskén's article in this special issue shows, responses of the workers’ movement to fascist threats became a major concern before 1933; the anti-fascist commission created by the LSI in 1926 and led by Austrian Julius Deutsch being a case in point.Footnote 8 The European socialists’ perception of Italian fascism in the 1920s and early 1930s underlines the argument according to which fascism was a general menace for socialist aims from the very beginning. When the monument to Giacomo Matteotti was dedicated in 1927 in Brussels, the Italian socialist leader Giuseppe Emanuele Modigliani, the German Social Democratic Party (Sozialdemokratische Partei Deutschlands; SPD) chancellor of the Weimar Republic, Hermann Müller, and the leader of the French Section of the Workers’ International (Section française de l’Internationale ouvrière; SFIO) Léon Blum participated in the inauguration ceremony.Footnote 9 Among the militant voices against fascism was also the Bavarian public prosecutor and SPD member of the Weimar parliament, Wilhelm Hoegner. In his first speech at the Reichstag on 18 October 1930, he defied the Nazis and challenged the National Socialist Georg Strasser, revealing how Italian fascism acted as a model for National Socialism and showing the determination of Social Democrats to defend German democracy against the fascist tyranny of the Führer.Footnote 10
Whereas fascism initially conquered Italy and Germany,Footnote 11 communists and socialists in France succeeded in establishing a Popular Front government against the extreme right and in giving shelter to anti-fascist refugees from Italy and Germany.Footnote 12 This transnational cooperation was clearly intensified when Italian and German socialists went underground or into exile from 1926 and 1933 onwards, respectively.Footnote 13 France soon became one of the preferred destinations for political refugees from Italy, Germany, Austria, the Saarland, the Sudetenland and Spain, who established various forms of cooperation in Paris, the global capital of anti-fascism before 1940.Footnote 14 French socialists, for example, showed solidarity with their Italian comrades by jointly commemorating the assassination of Matteotti in the French capital in 1934.Footnote 15 Even more importantly, former leading SPD politicians such as the Prussian Interior Minister Albert Grzesinski, who regarded himself to be ‘probably the best informed politician among German emigrants in Paris’, took advantage of their knowledge of the Nazi regime to use it against them. Already at an early stage he warned European governments about ‘certain Nazi measures and about the preparations of Nazi Germany to conduct an offensive war’.Footnote 16
One of the most direct and efficient ways in which these émigrés showed their transnational anti-fascism was to participate in one of several refugee committees operating in France, the United Kingdom and the United States. German Social Democrats such as Grzesinski and Rudolf Katz worked as secretaries for the advisory committee (Comité Consultatif) for German refugees in the French Ministry of Home Affairs in 1936/37, or of the German Labour Delegation in New York from 1938.Footnote 17 On the French side, Salomon Grumbach, born in Alsace and bilingual, became a pivotal element for German socialists seeking refuge in France. This socialist deputy was also president of the SFIO's commission of immigration and an extraordinarily active member of the french Human Rights League (Ligue Française pour la Défense des Droits de l'Homme et du Citoyen; LDH). He helped, for instance, the German Social Democrat and former mayor of Hamburg, Max Brauer, and many others in finding jobs and travelling to safe countries.Footnote 18 All these anti-fascist activities were high risk – even in the still democratic French Republic. This is shown by the assassination at Bagnoles-de-l'Orne on 9 June 1937 of Carlo and Nello Rosselli – founders and leading members of the Italian liberal socialist movement Justice and Freedom (Giustizia e Libertà) – by the French right-wing extremist group The Cowl (La Cagoule) under orders from the Italian fascist secret service; an act which represented a quite unique ‘transfer of political state criminality’.Footnote 19
Although – or maybe even because – many of them often struggled financially in exile, European socialists never gave up hope and were engaged with groups of political emigrants. Some, such as the Social Democrats Richard Kirn and Ernst Roth, escaped from Saarland after the affiliation with the German Reich in 1935 and published illegal material, either anonymously or under pseudonyms, in Forbach and Strasbourg, just across the German-French border.Footnote 20 Many of them, notably the social democrat Max Braun, contributed to the formation of a German Popular Front together with communists such as Willi Münzenberg, between 1935 and 1938.Footnote 21 However, these mass efforts to establish powerful anti-fascist alliances were a wider European phenomenon, as the French, Italian and Spanish cases show.Footnote 22 In France, for instance, pro-communist socialists such as Jean Zyromski called for unity of action between SFIO and the French Communist Party (Parti communiste français; PCF) from 1934 onwards. Italian socialists in French exile such as Pietro Nenni continued speaking in public against fascism and also fought for the proletariat's unity of action with the Italian Communist Party by signing a cooperation act in autumn 1934.Footnote 23 Even convinced anti-communists such as Brauer hoped to defeat fascism through common effort. This change of heart was facilitated by the fact that the communists abandoned the theory that socialists and social democrats were ‘social fascists’ in 1935.Footnote 24 Grzesinski remarked that ‘the concentration of all enemies of the Nazi regime was a political necessity’ by then. ‘The French comrades also wouldn't have understood a different point of view.’Footnote 25 Therefore, it is not surprising that many European socialists, amongst them Italians such as Nenni and the Rosselli brothers and Germans Willy Brandt and Peter Blachstein, united with communists in fighting fascism in the Spanish Civil War, which may be called the first peak of both transnational fascism and anti-fascism.Footnote 26
Notwithstanding these elements of transnational anti-fascism, one must bear in mind at least four facts that counter-balance the image of a united and harmonious socialist (and communist) action before the outbreak of the Second World War. First, the SPD lost almost all its political and moral credibility within the interwar LSI because of its hesitant policy in the spring of 1933, when it refused to accept a call of the LSI for united action with the German Communist Party (Kommunistische Partei Deutschlands; KPD) and then voted for Hitler's foreign policy declaration (17 May). In the years that followed, the SPD could no longer contribute to and participate in the LSI debates in a substantial way because in the eyes of other European socialists it was discredited by its previous behaviour.Footnote 27 Second, Stalin's Moscow show trials between 1936 and 1938 led to a split within the LSI and to an interruption of the recent rapprochement between socialists and communists following the 1935 Comintern congress.Footnote 28 Third, the fact that Soviet agents persecuted dissidents of the left behind the front lines of the Spanish Civil War confirmed the doubts of many socialists, such as Brauer and Brandt, as well as Spanish socialists themselves, as to whether the communists were really interested in sincere cooperation in the future.Footnote 29 The same goes for the Socialist Youth International (SYI), led by Erich Ollenhauer, which had sent a delegation to Spain in 1937 in order to coordinate solidarity actions with the Communist Youth International (CYI) for the first time. After the Spanish Socialist Youth opted to join the Communist Party, the SYI dissociated itself from the CYI.Footnote 30 And, fourth, the French policy of non-intervention in Spain under the Popular Front government of Léon Blum, who preferred to avoid war at any cost and, by 1937, even stiffened police measures against foreign supporters of Republican Spain, caused great distress within the LSI and all anti-fascist socialists.Footnote 31 In the end, considering the divisions within European socialism and the responsibility of the communists for failures in trust and for the inefficiencies of Popular Fronts, it might be fair to judge that the interwar socialist organisations failed to fulfil their primary task to unite the workers’ movement in order to avoid war, as had the Second International before the First World War.
Transnational Networks in Wartime (1939–1945)
Anti-fascist resistance in wartime included a broad variety of activities such as the production, translation and distribution of pamphlets and leaflets, aid for interned people, the forging of documents, acts of sabotage and armed fighting. Although these activities became even more difficult after France and other continental European countries were occupied by Nazi Germany, going underground had the advantage that the nuances of the previous ideological struggle became less important. The transition from anti-fascism to resistance involved both a narrowing of previous goals and new tactics, notably violence. In this transition period one could say, as historian Alya Aglan has done, that the resistance movements all over Europe focused on the essential dignity of human beings. They also constituted a kind of single bloc with a triple level of expectations referring to the nation, Europe and a peaceful world.Footnote 32 These tensions between the present and the future constitute an exciting research perspective that invites the writing of a comparative and transnational history of resistance movements. In exploring it, this section first gives some names of German, Italian and French socialist anti-fascists involved in civilian and military resistance activities; it then presents a few examples of border-crossing ideas and projects for the post-war period.
When the Spanish Civil War ended and the Second World War broke out, in April and September 1939 respectively, the refugee organisations operating in Paris increased their efforts to provide help for numerous displaced anti-fascists.Footnote 33 Grumbach in particular played a crucial role in rescuing Austrian, German and Spanish emigrants, helping them to become officially recognised as refugees in order ‘to continue their fight against Hitlerism’ and cooperating closely with the Federation of German Émigrés in France (Fédération des Émigrés d'Allemagne en France).Footnote 34 For Italian socialists, the key person in the war years was Blum himself.Footnote 35 Another particularly interesting case of the organisational support offered by transnational anti-fascism is the work of the German Social Democrat journalist Rolf Reventlow, who assisted Italian, Austrian and Czechoslovak trade unions and fought in the Spanish Civil War for the Republican cause along with Austrian Julius Deutsch. After Franco's victory, he escaped to Algeria on a steamboat but was arrested as a German spy. However, a wave of transnational solidarity by Czechoslovak, Austrian, German and Italian socialists managed to secure his release and transfer to a refugee camp in Oran.Footnote 36
After Hitler attacked Belgium, Luxemburg, the Netherlands and France on 10 May 1940 and found a collaborating partner in the Vichy regime, the situation for anti-fascists worsened once again.Footnote 37 The same was true for Norway, from where Brandt and many others had to flee to Sweden in 1940. In France the international socialist organisations collapsed. Some of its members were arrested or killed (like Rudolf Hilferding and Rudolf Breitscheid, two of the most prominent Social Democrats of the Weimar Republic), some managed to hide somewhere in the South, others continued their emigration odyssey in London (as did the SoPaDe, the exile organisation of the SPD) or the United States (the left-socialists Erna and Josef Lang). From 1940 onwards, Germans and Italians no longer had a vote at international socialist meetings. At the last congress in August 1939 in Lille the Swedish secretary of the Socialist Youth had already stated self-critically that the International of the Socialist Youth (ISY) were just an ‘information office’ and that its actions consisted of a mere ‘internationalism of words and congresses’. This approach continued to the ISY's last deed, when it condemned in harsh words the Molotov–Ribbentrop Pact and the Soviet attack on Finland on 27 February 1940.Footnote 38 During the Second World War, with its various periods of occupation, collaboration and resistance, anti-fascism was split off into differing strands by stressing more the ‘antinazisme’ or ‘anti-hitlérisme’ in France and the ‘nazifascismo’ in Italy.Footnote 39 Hence, was Droz right when he ended his history of anti-fascism in Europe in 1939? Certainly, the attempts to establish a programme and, eventually, actions to which all centre-left parties could consent seemed to become impossible once the Soviet communists and Nazi regime had agreed not to attack one another. However, as we have seen, socialists had already withdrawn from common committees and organisations by 1938 due to the increasing Stalinisation of the communist parties. Max Brauer, who had been giving public talks in the United States on Germany and the Nazi regime since 1936 at the behest of the American Jewish Congress, said in one of his speeches on ‘Democracy and Germany's Destiny’ following Germany's invasion of the Soviet Union in 1941 that ‘the war is conducted between totalitarianism and democracy. . . . The problem is that we do not mean the same when we talk or think about democracy. Democracy is an ambiguous expression used by every fascist dictator.’Footnote 40
Brauer's reflection alludes to the sobering fact that, in spite of a common vocabulary, anti-fascists almost never meant the same thing when they talked about ‘democracy’, ‘liberty’ or ‘revolution’.Footnote 41 A good example of the different perception of the present and the distinct expectations for the future were the leading Italian socialists. They regarded fascism as ‘the principal cause of war and reaction’. As Nenni declared in a speech in Paris in December 1939, ‘in the fight against fascism the union of all progressive forces of humanity has to become true’. He considered Stalin's definition of fascism ‘as a reactionary force that tries to preserve the old world by violence’ to be still valuable. However, he did not accept the communist explanation for Moscow's U-turn, which did not talk about anti-fascism but only about anti-capitalism and anti-imperialism. Instead, Nenni declared anti-fascism to be ‘the most positive and concrete form of fight against capitalism and imperialism’, expressing once more the Italian Socialist Party's (Partito Socialista Italiano; PSI) Marxist view on the nature of fascism.Footnote 42 The Italian socialists therefore even voted to maintain the unity of action with the communists and renewed this position in November 1941.Footnote 43
Once Nazi Germany had occupied northern France and found a partner in Pétain's Vichy government, the fight against fascism became even more existential: thousands of political emigrants trying to save their lives and fleeing to other countries and continents often had few opportunities to participate in the discourse about anti-fascism. If they managed to establish themselves more or less comfortably in Britain, the United States or elsewhere, they usually tried to re-involve themselves in national and transnational groups.Footnote 44 When Nazi Germany also occupied southern France in 1942 not all international socialists managed to escape to safer countries via Spain or Portugal.Footnote 45 Those who decided to stay in occupied and collaborationist France took great risks because they had to get official documents with false names and depended on the trust and benevolence of the French who were against Vichy. Despite the SoPaDe's official policy to refuse armed resistance, fearing as it did the development of a new stab-in-the-back myth (Dolchstoßlegende) some German socialists worked closely with French anti-fascists and took up arms to fight Vichy and the Nazis. Those who were not capable of taking up arms could still contribute to the fight as service providers (news, arms, food) or in civil resistance groups such as Anti-German Work (Travail Anti-Allemand; TA) and the Free German Committee for the West (Comité Allemagne Libre pour l'Ouest; CALPO).Footnote 46
Among the approximately 400 German Social Democrats hiding in southern and south-western France who had managed to escape the Gestapo and Vichy collaborators, 214 were from the Saarland, on the German-French-Luxembourgish border. Those who took up arms often had fighting experience from the Spanish Civil War or even from the First World War.Footnote 47 We know that several German Social Democrats were members of the French Snipers and Partisans (Francs-Tireurs et Partisans Français; FTPF), founded in 1941 in the south-west, and at least twenty of them participated in civilian groups, including, for example Franz Glauben and his wife, who hid Jews in their apartment. Franz Glauben Jr was one of the first Germans to join the resistance (Maquis) in the Cévennes. Other socialists performed functions in the Secret Army (Armée Secrète; AS), founded in the autumn of 1942, including Julius Schneider, who served as captain of the resistance camp at Sigonce. When the different armed resistance groups united in the spring of 1944 to form the French Forces of the Interior (Forces Françaises de l‘Intérieur; FFI), again more than twenty-five Saarland Social Democrats were amongst them.Footnote 48 An extraordinarily revealing example of a German anti-fascist Social Democrat in exile is that of Ernst Roth who, due to his activity as a member of the Reichstag, was persecuted by the Gestapo after March 1933. Before the war broke out, he led an illegal aid organisation of victims of German fascism and published anti-fascist material in Strasbourg. Between September 1939 and January 1940, he was interned in the camps of Mirecourt and Harchéchamp before serving in the French foreign legion in Marrakech. Although he did not receive any support from other comrades or rescue organisations, he managed to survive with his family thanks to false documents in the Vaucluse between 1942 and 1944. In October 1944, he became an officer within a group of FTPF and fought in the armed resistance.Footnote 49
By 1943, when the decline of the Third Reich became increasingly apparent, anti-fascist resistance entered a new phase in which the positive fight for a better future for the nation states of Europe, the Continent as a whole and the wider world displaced the purely negative fight against Nazi Germany and its allies. The goal was now not only to relieve the countries of the occupying power but also to unchain society from bureaucratic and police despotism in order to establish democracy and individual liberties. When Ollenhauer wrote to his Saarland comrade Ernst Roth in Paris from London on 17 April 1945 that ‘the war and with it the whole dirty Nazi trick is coming to an end’,Footnote 50 numerous plans for a democratic and federative Europe, for re-founding a Socialist International and for cooperating with socialist sister parties had been prepared.Footnote 51 Wilhelm Hoegner, for example, one of the progressive thinkers of future socialist cooperation, was not allowed to work as a politician, lawyer or journalist in Switzerland. Therefore, he wrote fiction and poetry, corresponded with exiled politicians in Switzerland and France and collaborated clandestinely with the SPD's executive in exile.Footnote 52 Only from 1943 onwards did the envoy of the American Office of Strategic Services (OSS), Allan W. Dulles, employ Hoegner to draft laws and constitutions for a democratic Bavarian and all-German post-war state. In a lively debate with social democratic and Catholic personalities from the Weimar Republic such as Otto Braun, Heinrich Ritzel and Josef Wirth, Hoegner co-founded the working group The Democratic Germany (Das Demokratische Deutschland) which drew up a twenty-two page document outlining a future German political order. It embedded Germany within Europe and placed upon it responsibility for the war and the crimes of the Nazi-regime, yet denied the collective guilt of the German people.Footnote 53
Italian socialists in exile also prepared programmes for the post-fascist period and increased their efforts in 1943, when the Americans landed on Sicily and fascist Italy agreed to an armistice. Nazi Germany then occupied northern and central Italy and established the puppet Republic of Salò.Footnote 54 Many Italians were forced to work in the German military industry or became prisoners of war, grievances that led Italian socialists to address Nenni and ask him to solve this problem. In these letters, Nenni's comrades opted for an alliance of all democratic parties and for a cooperation of all ‘anti-German, anti-fascist and anti-monarchist’ forces.Footnote 55 As ‘supporters of the holy war against all fascisms’, Italian socialists favoured defeat over lifelong slavery after a German victory.Footnote 56 They also were aware that after twenty-two years of fascist crimes and support for the fascist regime Italy had few friends in the world. Therefore, the Italian people were to unite behind those two parties that had always fought fascism: the Italian Socialist Party of Proletarian Unity (Partito Socialista Italiano di Unità Proletaria; PSIUP) and the Italian Communist Party (Partito Comunista Italiano; PCI).Footnote 57
Even though plans for a more peaceful world after the war were more often national than transnational, there is good evidence for border- and party-crossing activities as early as 1941. In this very year, communist Altiero Spinelli and socialists Ernesto Rossi and Eugenio Colorni, who had been placed under confinement on a little island in the Gulf of Gaeta, drafted the famous Manifesto of Ventotene, considered one of the first documents of European integration. By criticising the failure of nation states, they drew up some guidelines for the ‘United States of Europe’ and would find an echo in resistance movements all over the continent.Footnote 58 Transnational efforts accelerated when the Italian European federalists, founded in August 1943 in Milan and represented by Rossi and Spinelli, contacted their French comrades with connections to the socialist André Ferrat, who had set up a committee for the European federation in July of the very same year in Lyon. Thanks to the neutral position of Switzerland, the hospitality of the Dutch reform theologian Willem Visser't Hooft and the mediation of the journalist François Bondy, several clandestine meetings took place in Visser't Hooft's house in Geneva from the autumn of 1943 onwards.Footnote 59
Of particular interest from a transnational point of view are the four conferences held between March and July 1944 in Geneva, attended by anti-fascist representatives from nine countries. Those delegates of the French, Danish, Norwegian, Dutch, Polish, Czech, Yugoslav, Italian and German resistance movements elaborated a common programme for a constitution of a federal Europe into which a denazified Germany should be integrated. They consisted of democratic liberals, socialists and communists from fascist or occupied countries, who were all willing to abandon the dogma of complete national sovereignty. Sharing common ideals and numerous anti-fascist experiences, many had known each other since the pre-war period or had made contact in resistance movements. Among the approximately fifteen participants Bondy represented the French socialists, whereas Hanna Bertholet (International Socialist Militant League, Internationaler Sozialistischer Kampfbund) and Hilda Monte (New Beginning, Neu Beginnen) spoke in the name of German socialists. Referring to resistance values such as fraternity, victimhood, suffering and fighting, their programme provided for a European government, army and legislation. They even set up a provisory committee in Geneva and published a single edition of the review The Federalist Europe (L'Europe fédéraliste) in 1944 and, under a different name, a document collection entitled The Europe of Tomorrow (L'Europe de demain). The European federalists believed themselves to have a moral claim to participate in the European reconstruction process side by side with the victorious powers. However, the Normandy landings in June 1944 already indicated that national liberation came before European integration. Therefore, it is little surprise that the Federalist Congress in Paris in March 1945 was hardly noticed by the international community. In the end, even if many people sympathised with federalist ideas, after the end of the war the Geneva activists found themselves a tiny minority out of step with the priorities of the time.Footnote 60
Even if wartime transnational contacts were not abundant, one could give two more examples in which socialists, besides other anti-fascist groups, were involved. Among these there are little known activities such as those of the socialist resistance group European Union (Europäische Union), which was particularly active in Berlin 1942–43, offering rescue for forced labour, prisoners of war and Jews within the Third Reich and calling for the unification of all European anti-fascists and for re-establishing human rights.Footnote 61 Better known is the Buchenwald Manifesto of 13 April 1945 written by detained German, Austrian, Belgian, Czech, French, Dutch and Polish socialists, which named as prerequisites of a peaceful European community French–German and German–Polish cooperation as well as the integration of Germany into the Anglo–American cultural sphere.Footnote 62 And there are continuities reaching from the war years to the post-war period. The clandestinely organised Italian socialists (PSIUP), for instance, borrowed internationalist principles and the idea of a European federation in their party programme from such federalist conferences.Footnote 63
Considering the desperate and fragmented state of European socialism, Willy Brandt had recognised as early as 1943 the necessity of rebuilding a Socialist International (SI) which included an international organisation of the trade unions. He requested the British Labour Party to take the initiative and not to limit the SI to European countries.Footnote 64 Among the Italian socialists organised into the Giacomo Matteotti group in London, Riccardo Luzzatto, who had excellent connections to Labour politicians, urged his British comrades to revive internationalism.Footnote 65 Labour responded positively. Not only did the president of the International Socialists Group Harold Laski participate in a commemoration ceremony for the victims of Nazi terror in London, but he also declared in December 1944 that a new way of socialist cooperation for democracy in post-war Europe had to be elaborated.Footnote 66
Laski's declaration occurred during the Labour Party Congress in London from 11 to 15 December, in which several international delegations participated. Among these, and apart from the British Labour party, only the Swiss and the French delegation seemed to be well prepared and made specific proposals about refoundation of the SI. The French representatives Daniel Mayer, André Philip, Vincent Auriol and Salomon Grumbach actively cooperated in matters of aid for prisoners of war.Footnote 67 Regarding the German question and an eventual cooperation with German groups in France French socialists were more reluctant, but agreed not to block contact with these groups in general. On a higher level, the group of international socialists, consisting of forty-two delegates from twelve countries, met again in London in March 1945. The SFIO enjoyed a great reputation among the other delegates, presented thoroughly prepared studies and placed Auriol on the SI reconstruction committee. While the Italian socialist leader Nenni expressed his confidence in German socialism, Grumbach was elected into the subcommittee for German affairs.Footnote 68
The cooperation with socialist sister parties began in France immediately after the liberation of the territory in 1944. That this was possible was due to at least two major circumstances: first, the active participation of some international, amongst them even a few German, socialists in the French resistance movement and, second, the personal networks of French Jewish socialists and German Social Democrats. Roth, Glauben and Günter Markscheffel were also among the most active representatives and founding members of a new group of German Social Democrats in France in March 1945. Although Paris obviously became the central seat of this association, with Roth as president and Markscheffel as secretary, there were also regional groups in Grenoble, Toulouse and Lyon. The latter was headed by Glauben who, at the same time, acted as elected secretary of the Federation of Foreign Socialist Groups in France (Fédération des Groupes Socialistes Étrangers en France; FGSE), Rhône Section, and, in spring 1945, became a member of the SFIO (almost all FGSE-members did). This federation of foreign socialist groups (Spain, Austria, Hungary, Poland, Italy and Germany) continued the pre-1940 work of the Matteotti-Committee under the auspices of the SFIO.Footnote 69
Of some importance to the future international socialist cooperation was the Labour politician John Hynd's visit to Paris on 28 March 1945 for a FGSE-reunion, in which he reflected on the categorisation of foreigners in France as resistance fighters or collaborators. In the summary of Hynd's speech it becomes clear that ‘he also remembered that the real resistance champions against fascism and Hitlerism in all countries were the workers organised in trade unions and socialist movements. The working class was in the vanguard of the battle and contributed significantly to the final victory.’ The FGSE unanimously voted for a resolution in which it confirmed ‘its desire to continue the fight against fascism and Hitlerism in all its forms’. They thought ‘that a socialist cannot be regarded as enemy’ and stressed ‘the fact that socialists had not participated in government in any fascist country.’Footnote 70 This opinion was not undisputed, and harmony amongst international socialists was not always as perfect as it seemed. When the news about the return of Léon Blum from Buchenwald in spring 1945 spread, everybody congratulated each other. Many French socialists shared Hynd's opinion that a future international socialist cooperation had to also include German Social Democrats. Victor Faye, however, journalist of the socialist newspaper Lyon-Libre, gave a speech in June of that year in which he attacked the Weimar SPD and the German Social Democrats in exile in the strongest possible terms and said that German Nazi victims had fallen in ‘cowardice and shame’.Footnote 71
Outlook: Transnational Cooperation after 1945
In the first years after the end of the war there was still a broad anti-fascist consensus about central issues such as democracy, peace, liberty and the need for cross-party cooperation. This is best shown by the grassroots movements that proliferated almost everywhere before, during and immediately after liberation. In May 1944, the Resistance (Resistenza) organisation in Piedmont signed the Saretto agreement with the United Resistance Movements (Mouvements unis de la Résistance) of the Marseille region in which both sides underlined solidarity, democratic liberties and social justice in a free European community.Footnote 72 The amazing variety of debate and experimentation in the French and Italian Liberation Committees and in the German Anti-Fascist Committees underline how important it is to leave behind binary descriptions of totalitarian communism here and democratic socialism there.Footnote 73 As far as the relations of socialists to their European sister parties are concerned, one should remember that efforts were undertaken not only before the SPD was officially allowed to organise itself again as a political party in October 1945, but even before the Second World War had come to an end. The international group of democratic socialists in Stockholm, together with Willy Brandt, expressed its desire to re-establish international socialist cooperation already by the end of 1944.Footnote 74 Moreover, in May 1945 Pietro Nenni regarded it as the primary task of European socialism to avoid the emergence of two competing political blocs.Footnote 75
Immediately after the war Morgan Philipps, secretary general of the British Labour Party, congratulated Nenni and the ‘Socialist comrades throughout Italy’ with ‘deep joy and gratitude’ that Italy finally had managed to deliver itself ‘from the Nazi yoke’. He looked ‘forward with confidence and hope to our close and fruitful collaboration in building a new Socialist International’.Footnote 76 Further correspondence between Nenni and the British Foreign Secretary Ernest Bevin stresses how important Labour was for reconstructing socialist ties in the post-war period.Footnote 77 While parts of the French SFIO clearly expressed their mistrust in German Social Democrats, the British Labour Party instead regarded the SPD's development with reserved sympathy. The highly decorated former British Army officer and promising new Labour politician Denis Healey wrote to Ollenhauer and Heine in January 1946, stating that, ‘the British Labour Party is watching with interest and satisfaction the progress of the S.P.D. in building up a progressive and democratic alternative to the Nazi neurosis in Germany. It considers that the existence of a strong democratic socialist party in Germany is essential to the peace of Europe.’Footnote 78 Thus, the anti-fascist wartime networks of Ollenhauer and other German Social Democrats in London were still helpful for eventual post-war cooperation between the SPD and Labour.
However, European Second International socialism was definitely no stronghold of anti-fascist forces, as the support of the British Labour Party for the brutal military intervention against the Greek anti-fascist movement in December 1944 shows. The attitude of the most important European socialist party was not much better with regard to the Spanish question either, when Labour abstained from any action in favour of the Republicans or from taking an anti-Franco stance.Footnote 79 If the most influential party of Second International socialism took such positions what could the other socialist sister parties do without Labour support? They could try to rely more heavily on individual relations instead of official party cooperation, of course. While this had happened already in the Labour-SPD case, the relation between the SFIO and the SPD depended even more on personal networks. Max Brauer, by this time again mayor of Hamburg, remembered in his speech at the SPD's political rally in August 1946 that, in ‘1933 when the majority of the refugees of the Reich went to France, we found a man who was on hand with help and advice for us. That was the speaker of today, our friend Grumbach. (‘Bravo!’ applause).’Footnote 80 On the French side, despite the Holocaust, three Jewish socialists – Blum, Grumbach and Mayer – had excellent contacts with German Social Democrats and were highly interested in normalising the difficult relations of both parties after three wars in the previous seventy-five years.
Schumacher himself announced in August 1945 that ‘the policy of [German] social democracy is self-consciously internationalist’.Footnote 81 He confirmed this attitude by writing a letter to Mayer in January 1946 in which he hoped for a personal meeting soon after.Footnote 82 The Committee of the International Socialist Conference (COMISCO) invited the SPD as a guest to join the international socialist conference in June 1947 in Zurich. Regarded with great distrust and confronted with the collective guilt thesis by European socialists, the German Social Democratic Party was still not admitted as a full member to the conference. This happened only after having shown its credibility with a liaison committee at the next International Socialist Conference in Antwerp at the end of the year. From that moment on the SPD again became a central member of the international socialist community and had good relations with all European socialist parties – it is no accident that the refoundation of the SI took place in 1951 in Frankfurt.Footnote 83
Broadening the perspective of socialist parties away from the question of the SI, one can find several other forms of transnational cooperation. There was, for instance, the problem of German anti-fascist prisoners of war in France, in which Markscheffel acted as an intermediate agent between the SFIO and the SPD thanks to his privileged access to Mayer.Footnote 84 The major socialist parties such as Labour, the SFIO, the PSIUP and the SPD also invited each other to take part in their respective congressesFootnote 85 and to write in each other's newspapers and journals reflecting, for example, on the nature of fascism.Footnote 86 They cooperated in the restoration of Karl Marx's birthplace in Trier by setting up an international committee.Footnote 87 Political-humanitarian networks such as Erna and Josef Lang's American Aid for the Victims of Fascism in Germany (Amerikanische Hilfe für die Opfer des Faschismus in Deutschland) or the International Rescue and Relief Committee (IRRC) continued in the first post-war years to promote the idea of international solidarity.Footnote 88 One of its members of staff, the left-socialist and future MP of the SPD for Hamburg, Peter Blachstein, wrote an article about the IRRC in 1947 in which he expressed his gratitude for it having provided help for democratic anti-fascists from many countries before and after the war and praised it as a symbol of international solidarity.Footnote 89
Besides actual party politics, European socialists cooperated actively in shaping the memory of anti-fascism.Footnote 90 Although, as Fritz Heine once declared of the immediate post-war years, many German Social Democrats ‘had no sense for history’Footnote 91 and were thus rarely interested in commemorating the past, fortunately, for most of the exiles who took leading positions within the SPD after 1945 this is not the whole truth. Whether it was to deliver speeches at commemorating ceremoniesFootnote 92 or to collect anti-fascist material for documentary and publication purposesFootnote 93 socialists showed the world that anti-fascism was a transnational phenomenon, even if they tended increasingly to exclude the communists. In 1947, Blachstein praised the historic essay Fascism: Its Creation and Development (Der Faschismus: seine Entstehung und seine Entwicklung), written by the Italian socialist Ignazio Silone and first published in Swiss exile in 1934, as a programme for the democratic reconstruction after the fascist disaster.Footnote 94 Blachstein and Brandt also continued to remember their experiences in the Spanish Civil War and took great interest in supporting the Spanish Socialist party in exile politically, morally and financially wherever they could.Footnote 95 And when national interest groups of former persecuted socialists such as the Working Group of Formerly Persecuted Socialists (Arbeitsgemeinschaft ehemals verfolgter Sozialdemokraten; AvS) met, they also used to invite socialists from other European countries, as happened on 8 May 1948 in Hamburg when commemorating the end of the Second World War in Europe.Footnote 96
Conclusion
Reflecting on anti-fascism should always involve an effort to evaluate its positive and negative aspects. As history has shown, anti-fascists were neither capable of defining precisely the nature and limits of fascism nor of overcoming the working class split of 1920. Even the temptation for young and fresh social-liberal groups such as Italy's Justice and Freedom, Germany's New Beginning and others to leave behind the ideological impasse into which socialists and communists had manoeuvred themselves failed. The human face and heroic readiness to make sacrifices was spoiled by many mistakes and misjudgements, as Jacques Droz put it.Footnote 97 This is also true for the history of socialist anti-fascism during the Second World War on which this paper has focused. Despite the pre-war attempts to establish a people's front, collective efforts towards cooperation between socialist parties can be found only after 1942, and increasingly around 1945. It took until the early 1940s before different groups in Great Britain, Sweden or the United States tried to work together more closely and regularly. In Max Brauer's opinion, ‘the German Nazi-emigration from 1933 to 1945 at large was not fully aware of its mission and thus has not achieved a very positive result’.Footnote 98
However, to talk only about a failure of political emigration in this period easily overlooks various moments and achievements of socialist anti-fascism. By revisiting the biographies of those people discussed in this article, who had spent most of the period between 1926/1933 and 1945 in exile, it soon becomes clear that they contributed considerably to a transnational anti-fascism, even in the most difficult years of war. Their transnational networks worked more on a personal than on an official party level. They are rarely known or often forgotten, even in the most recent literature.Footnote 99 Of course, anti-fascism was not only made and practiced in exile but also underground, in the streets or within parliaments. However, it was in exile that anti-fascists could easily establish transnational forms of cooperation, concentrated as they were in cities such as Paris, London or New York. Even if the less positive aspects of this story – the failure of international socialism to defeat fascism in cooperation with other democratic forces – might carry more weight in terms of Realpolitik, why should the extraordinary efforts of a relatively small number of socialist anti-fascists in wartime be neglected?
This question might be even more justified if the continuities of transnational networks before and after 1945 are taken into account. Whether anti-fascist émigrés who returned to their home countries after the war had to face great mistrust, as was often the case in Germany, or whether they were welcomed warmly by the vast majority of the population as in France and Italy, many of them played a central role in the democratic reconstruction of their national states.Footnote 100 It is surely the case that each national resistance movement followed different patterns and traditions in its respective country. But their contribution to the pre-history of European integration was considerable in the mid- and long term, particularly in Italy and Germany, even though their proclamations such as the famous ‘Partisans of all Europe, unite!’ (Partigiani di tutta l'Europa, unitevi!) had a rather limited effect on the Allied victory powers.Footnote 101
Anti-fascism was definitely pushed to the back of many socialist minds by anti-communism and anti-totalitarianism at the beginning of the Cold War. In fact, this trend had started much earlier, during the Spanish Civil War and especially after the Hitler-Stalin Pact of 1939. But in 1947 even convinced socialist anti-fascists changed the discourse and partially repressed the memory of anti-fascism because it did not correspond with the Zeitgeist. Of course, there were exceptions such as Italy, where the post-war democratic republic based on an all-party agreement, according to which not only communists and socialists but also liberals and Christian democrats had fought actively against Nazism and fascism and thus had contributed to the country's ‘second Risorgimento’ and resistance. However, even in Italy socialists never spoke with one voice because they had different ideas what terms such as ‘liberty’, ‘emancipation’ and ‘democracy’ meant. Maybe these ambiguities are the best explanation for why a comparative and transnational European (or even global) history of anti-fascism after 1945 still remains to be written.
