In many respects Modernism and Opera is a rather old-fashioned book and for that reason also a brave one. At a time when the quest for public pertinence leads to insipid humanities research, it is refreshing to encounter an interdisciplinary project devoted unapologetically to an elite art form. This volume, originally a Modernist Studies Association session, begins with the assumption that “If opera is forever dying in the hope of being reborn, so too is modernism” (4). More substantively, the fundamentally collaborative nature of operatic theatre—above all its problematizing of formal integrity and its capacity to transcend traditional modes of expression—enables an exploration of the aesthetic paradigm that shaped both opera and modernism. In the case of modernist opera, the editors argue, this cultural amalgam is characterized more by family resemblances than definite affinities—a sequence of creative intersections unfolding across time and space. Operatic modernism, conversely, is a destabilizing corollary—less a preoccupation with feminism, imperialism, fascism, nationalism, and religious tradition than a hybridized challenge to established doctrines of high-art austerity and medium-specific purity endorsed by critical precursors such as Theodor W. Adorno and Clement Greenberg.
Multiple instances of literary, dramatic, visual, and musical intermediality might seem to confirm opera as the epitome of modernist artistic praxis. And yet the foundational division between stage and orchestra pit has proved a persistent challenge to negotiating modernist representational reflexivity, on the one hand, and the realism of sound cinema, on the other. The present collection seeks to navigate these fault lines chronologically over the full arc of the long twentieth century through twelve essays arranged in three parts. In Part I, devoted to the era prior to World War I, crises of gender and theatricality are variously anatomized by Matthew Wilson Smith in respect of Kundry's alien corporeality within Wagner's Parsifal (1882); Daniel Albright, with reference to Debussy's autodeconstructive musical response to Maeterlinck's self-canceling dramaturgy in Pelléas et Mélisande (1902); and Klára Móricz, in relation to the examination of spiritual hermeticism rendered more impenetrable by reflexive self-knowledge in the case of the title character in Bartók's Duke Bluebeard's Castle (1918).
Part II addresses the interwar epoch's desire for a renewed rapprochement with history and the cultural repositioning required to advocate for or against nationalist and postnationalist ideological convictions. As Bryan Gilliam recounts, for Richard Strauss and Hugo von Hoffmannsthal, the search for a pan-European identity could be emblematized by staging marriage as a social convention in opposition to Wagnerian romantic redemption. Alban Berg's Wozzeck (1924), by comparison, represents a model of operatic history both retrieved and effaced. Bernadette Meyler observes that Büchner's Woyzeck was readily acknowledged by Adorno to be an anachronistically appropriated vehicle; and yet the latter's repeated critical engagements with the opera show him to have “predicated his understanding of true modernism” (178) on this work.
For Derek Katz, the shifting avant-gardes in interwar Prague, as reflected in Janáček's 1926 opera The Makropulos Case and Karel Čapek's 1921 play of the same title, account for how an emergent Czech nationalist identity was superseded by an internationalized Marxist conception of modernist expression that ultimately rendered both playwright and composer culturally tangential. In the essay that follows, Richard Begam reads Schoenberg's Moses und Aron (1932) as “an extended critique of the Nazi polemic on entartete Kunst, a polemic that identified modernism with antirepresentationalism and antirepresentationalism with the Jew” (232). If the tension between stylistic contingency and unrepresentable idea forms Schoenberg's poetic subtext, then meaning in Gertrude Stein and Virgil Thomson's Four Saints in Three Acts (1934), as Cyrena N. Pondrom explains, is generated by performative action not referential semantics. Intermediality here derives from the supplanting of narrative articulation by tableau sequence as organizing principle—a feature that subsequently inspired intergenerational identification in Philip Glass and Robert Wilson's Einstein on the Beach (1976).
Part III looks to the post-WWII phase when modernist opera became increasingly institutionalized, standardized, and subsidized. The Rake's Progress (1951) exemplifies the first of these normalizing tendencies: Herbert Lindenberger frames the collaboration between celebrated modernist pioneers Stravinsky and Auden as an ironic and formalized engagement with prior epochs, counterbalanced by the notion of tradition as venerable succession. In Irene Morra's reappraisal of Benjamin Britten's Gloriana (1953), however, historical obligation eclipses irony in a state-sponsored commemorative work embodying the contradictions involved in reconciling modernist contemporaneity with Britain's imperialist past. Olivier Messiaen's recuperation of Catholic religious orthodoxy through a progressive musical idiolect might be felt to have an antinomian mission as well. But as Linda and Michael Hutcheon show, his Saint François d'Assise (1983) typifies the modernist paradox wherein “revolutionary aesthetics [are] married to [a] more conservative ideology” (321). In the closing essay Joy H. Calico approaches Kaija Saariaho's multifaceted compositional voice as a touchstone of late modernism. L'Amour de loin (2000), she argues, is defined by sonic flux, yet despite its technical complexity, has been more regarded for its deliberately operatic commitment to emotional evocation and communication.
Like most if not all of the volume's authors, Calico is willing to press the case for “opera's role as midwife to modernism” (344). But does the collection as a whole make good on this belief? Not altogether. For one, the canonical selection of composers and repertoires runs together with a pervasive tendency to mute the shock of the new; it is telling that not until page 322 is there mention of French composer Pierre Boulez's notorious 1967 call to arms that opera houses be blown up as citadels of a monumentalizing heritage culture. Admittedly, the collection might seek to challenge modernism's perennial investment in difficulty and hierarchy in order to tease out more of its mediating ambivalences and compromises. Yet by neglecting issues of voice, body, subjectivity, and above all performance in favor of a composite cultural history grounded in scores and libretti, the book merely adds to what musicologist Carolyn Abbate has termed “the architecture of [opera's] necropolis” (In Search of Opera [2001], ix). Unquestionably the vitality and existential urgency of modernist music theatre is worthy of critical reappraisal. But without a more inventive commitment to its multifarious innovations, recollections, subversions, and transgressions, there remains little prospect of properly envisaging opera under the terms of what Adorno called the “world that is not yet” (Negative Dialectics [1973], 381).
