One of several new and exciting areas of Ottoman studies lies at the interface between things “Greek” and “Ottoman.” Researchers can take this area in a number of directions, one of which is to explore the politics, economies, and communities of “Greek lands” in the Ottoman period. The latter formulation can often invite anachronism: for instance, referring to “Ottoman Greece” as if such a totality existed in the Ottoman period, without discussion of why Western Thrace became “Greece” while Moldavia or western Anatolia did not. But in the case of Crete it has led to very productive and prolific scholarship. Referring to “Ottoman Crete,” after all, is a much sounder enterprise because the boundaries of the island did not change over time and its name does not refer to one or another state or nation. Exploring “Ottoman Crete” holds the potential of mapping out the contours of Ottoman governance on multiple levels. Because of its complicated history and the wealth of Ottoman documents on it, the island can be a veritable laboratory for the student of the middle and later centuries of Ottoman history.
While a previous generation of Greek scholars such as Elizabeth Zachariadou, Vassilis Demetriades, and Nikos Stavrinides worked on and published Greek translations of Ottoman sources for Crete and other areas for decades, Molly Greene essentially introduced Ottoman Crete to the English-speaking world with her A Shared World: Christians and Muslims in the Early Modern Mediterranean (Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 2000). Antonis Anastasopoulos’ collected volume is the latest installment of a highly useful conference series on Ottoman History, “Halcyon Days in Crete,” sponsored by the University of Rethymno's Program of Turkish Studies at the Institute of Mediterranean Studies. In its preface, Anastasopoulos dedicates the work to Zachariadou and Demetriades, who were also instrumental in setting up the Program of Turkish Studies at Rethymno, and discusses the ways in which these fifteen contributions systematically develop many of the issues laid out in Molly Greene's book. The titles of the volume's first four sections reveal what these issues are: “Land Regime and Agricultural Production,” “Muslims and Christians in Ottoman Crete,” “State Policies and Their Impact on Crete,” and “Sources for Ottoman Crete.” The contributors, which include many giants of Ottoman studies (such as Suraiya Faroqhi and Gilles Veinstein), offer highly substantive engagements with a range of Ottoman and non-Ottoman sources, many of which have never been used before. Svetlana Ivanova, for instance, provides an illuminating survey of the many types of Ottoman documents on Crete that can be found in the Oriental Department of the Saints Cyril and Methodius National Library in Sofia—the result of a decision made in the 1930s by Turkish Republican authorities to sell off a large section of the Ottoman archives to Bulgaria as scrap paper. This sale to Bulgaria, as Ivanova points out, is a widely told anecdote among Ottoman historians, but the actual contents of the archive have rarely been discussed in detail.
Section 5, “Beyond Crete,” consists of Tülay Artan's in-depth case study of a fascinating kind of Cretan “diaspora”: the dynasty and land holdings of Ali Agaki of Crete on the Datça peninsula of western Anatolia as well as the folklore surrounding him. Considering the amount of research it entailed and the range of issues with which it deals, this contribution could almost have stood as a separate volume. Among the most interesting facets of Artan's piece is her attempt to approach the Ottoman state from the perspective of the local elites, who often did not make it into Ottoman documents. Reading “in” from the outside, she uses material evidence such as remnants of residential and religious structures as well as inscriptions and local artifacts to contextualize the Ottoman sources. While this contribution is not about Ottoman Crete itself, it is very thought provoking in terms of the multiple connections made and remade between so many localities, including Crete, throughout the Ottoman period.
Other contributions elucidate the local conditions on Ottoman Crete, including population figures (a work by Makiel Kiel and others on the town of Sphakia in Ottoman census records), the land system (Eugenia Kermeli's work on the mid-17th century), and Muslim–Christian relations (Elias Kolovos’ article on intermarriage in mid-17th-century rural Crete). Several authors explore the relationship between Crete and the Ottoman center. The most striking of these is Suraiya Faroqhi's discussion of 18th-century reforms in Ottoman Crete and Marinos Sariyannis’ anatomy of two janissary rebellions in the 17th and 18th centuries and their aftermath.
Taken together, these contributions constitute an important step forward in the exploration of Ottoman Crete, both for itself and as a case study for many issues of Ottoman governance in the middle centuries of the empire's history. The reader truly gets the sense that all of the volume's contributors are pursuing a common research agenda, giving coherence to the work. The book engenders no small amount of optimism in those readers curious about what has long constituted a dark age in scholarship on Crete and so many other localities that were once part of Ottoman domains.
