One of the most important minorities in the British colonial empire in Asia consisted of those of mixed European and Asian parentage and/or ancestry, or Eurasians, as they were widely known.Footnote 1 It is perhaps surprising that despite the voluminous literature written about British colonial communities in the East, relatively little scholarly attention has been paid to Eurasians and their histories. A closer examination of the members of this marginalised colonial category is nevertheless crucial as they stood at the problematic boundaries of racial politics and identity, and are therefore vital to our understanding of the tensions of empire. The few existing studies of Eurasians in British Asia have tended to focus on the experiences of Eurasians either before or after the Second World War, neglecting the period of Japanese occupation as a significant epoch in the evolution of these communities.Footnote 2 In reality, if we intend to unravel the multi-layered history of Eurasians in this region, we must examine the critical position of these colonial communities during this tumultuous period. The nuances of their intriguing wartime relationships with both the British and the Japanese also merit serious attention. With these aims in mind, this article will investigate the compelling experiences of Eurasian communities in Japanese-occupied British Asia, with an especial focus on those who were incarcerated by the Japanese in civilian internment camps in Hong Kong and Singapore.
By February 1942, the colonial territories of Hong Kong, Malaya and Singapore had been wrenched from British hands by invading Japanese forces. During the occupation years, the majority of the British and other western civilians in these territories were interned by the conquerors in various camps in the region (such as Stanley in Hong Kong and Changi and Sime Road in Singapore). Within the camps, several key elements of colonial society were thrown into close, fettered proximity for three and a half years: British colonial administrators, business chiefs, wealthy taipans (owners of foreign mercantile establishments), missionaries and the wives of high-ranking colonial officials were forced to co-exist with policemen, prostitutes and clerks. The Japanese had originally decreed that all western ‘enemy aliens’ (such as British, Americans and Dutch civilians) should be held captive in these camps.Footnote 3 As the war progressed, however, these prisoners were eventually joined by other colonial minorities such as Eurasians and Baghdadi Jews whom the Japanese increasingly came to perceive as a threat to their new order, partly as a result of their part-European ancestry or pre-war European connections.Footnote 4 Hundreds of Eurasians were accordingly rounded up and incarcerated by the Japanese in the later stages of the war. By the early months of 1945, Eurasians had formed a significant proportion of total camp populations; of the approximately 3,200 civilians interned at Sime Road, there were said to be about 758 Eurasians in the men's section of the camp, and 299 Eurasians in the women's section.Footnote 5 As this essay will demonstrate, the interactions between the Eurasians and the British in these internment camps provide intriguing insights into the interplay between race, class and gender within European colonial communities under extreme pressure.
Eurasians in pre-war British Asia
To provide the necessary framework for this discussion of Eurasian communities under Japanese occupation, the first pages of this essay will touch upon a number of themes related to the pre-war British colonial context. In the early days of colonial Hong Kong, Eurasians were often found working in lowly positions, either as lighthouse keepers, bookkeepers, or as clerks or interpreters in European firms and government offices.Footnote 6 A capable few such as Robert Ho Tung, however, were employed by British trading houses to act as compradors or intermediaries in their business interactions with Chinese firms in the colony, and were often able to acquire vast fortunes of their own.Footnote 7 The isolation of the Eurasians in Hong Kong appears to have been less acute than elsewhere in British Asia, as a result of the wealth and political influence of these few prominent individuals within the territory. However, they nevertheless occupied a distinct social limbo, being neither European nor Asian. The Eurasians in pre-war Malaya and Singapore formed equally diverse communities but hovered similarly at the uneasy, contested boundaries of racial identity. The subtle stratifications which governed colonial society in Singapore were symbolised at the island's ceremonial centre, the Padang. At one end of this sports field was the exclusively European Singapore Cricket Club (which reputedly modelled itself on the constitution of Merton College Oxford); the Singapore Recreation Club, founded by Eurasians, stood at the other end.Footnote 8 When cricket matches were played, the Europeans and other spectators gathered at opposite sides of the field.Footnote 9
Before the war, the classification of Eurasians as a separate colonial category, with various sub-categories of its own, was a particularly vexing and contentious question for the British authorities. Some British administrators in Hong Kong even regarded Eurasians as a slippery and unnecessary complication to colonial bureaucracy, particularly where race-dependent legislation was concerned. In his 1920 article ‘Some Observations on Race Mixture in Hong Kong’, C.G. Alabaster (a member of the Hong Kong Legislative Council and later attorney-general) even suggested that the colonial government declare “marriage between certain races invalid or a punishable offence”. Prior to 1911, he observed, there was little need for such legislation since the “Eurasian problem did not exist; or perhaps it would be more accurate to say that before that year classification could be effected easily without too close an inquiry into a person's pedigree”. He argued that the Hong Kong Eurasians fell into three distinct groups before 1911: ‘Portuguese Eurasians’ (those who claimed Portuguese background), ‘Chinese Eurasians’ (those who gravitated towards Chinese culture) and ‘British Eurasians’ (those who became westernised). As he noted, however, these racial indicators in terms of names and social lifestyle became increasingly blurred after 1911 as a result of the increasing westernisation of ‘Chinese Eurasians’.Footnote 10 Although Alabaster's suggestion was never adopted by the colonial authorities, his proposal nevertheless implies that it became increasingly impossible for the British to categorise Eurasians in concrete terms. And indeed, the very fact that Eurasians could not be allocated to a “proper niche in the colonial social structure” was a frequent source of disgruntlement to various British administrators.Footnote 11
The status of Eurasians in Malaya and Singapore was equally anomalous and ambivalent; there was a disconcerting variety of Eurasians who had descended from unions between Europeans and Malay, Chinese or Indian partners. As Christopher Bayly and Tim Harper have noted, “their status was open to doubt and raises some difficulties of terminology”.Footnote 12 It was similarly difficult for the colonial authorities to classify these Eurasian groupings, especially as a large number of them had consciously cultivated Malay, Chinese or Indian identity and vanished back into the larger fabric of the Asian population. As in Hong Kong, outward disdain for Eurasians often reflected deeper class and racial prejudices: many Eurasians in Malaya and Singapore were often of illegitimate birth, with mothers of low social standing. Indeed, unlike a few prominent Hong Kong individuals who were able to amass large fortunes and wield considerable economic and political influence in the territory, the vast majority of Eurasians in Malaya and Singapore appear to have occupied less prominent roles. While most were consigned to subordinate clerical roles in various government offices or banking firms, a number found employment in the colonial military services.Footnote 13 Before the Second World War, there were several Eurasians serving in the Singapore Volunteer Corps as part of the Straits Settlements Volunteer Force, and there was even an all-Eurasian infantry unit.Footnote 14
At the same time, there were significant cleavages and tensions within the Eurasian communities themselves. Economic status and wealth were responsible for delineating critical barriers; by around the turn of the century, many wealthy Hong Kong Eurasians had consciously diverged from their less-affluent counterparts by forming a separate and closely knit clique of their own.Footnote 15 There was also the contentious issue of racial identification. “I was set adrift in a society which could not decide how to accept me”, remarked the Malayan Eurasian C.H. Crabbe. “It did hurt me to see other Eurasians. . . vacillate nervously between the occidental and oriental in them, creating many problems for themselves, and making their lives a misery”.Footnote 16 While some Eurasians in Hong Kong gravitated towards the British community (perhaps as a deliberate method of setting themselves apart from the Chinese), others appear to have felt a need to be more consciously Chinese to legitimise their position as defenders or “exponents of Chinese interests in the colonial context”. Robert Ho Tung's insistence on a Chinese identity (by wearing Chinese dress and claiming Chinese nationality), for instance, may have provided him with a “political foothold in his role as an authentic insider” and “leader of the Chinese community” in his dealings with the British.Footnote 17 This was nevertheless a source of tensions within his household. “I used to feel sorry that he should have thrown in his lot with the Chinese”, wrote his daughter Jean. “Moreover my leanings, for some reason unknown to me, were always towards the British, and none of us looked altogether Chinese in appearance. This complicated situation was therefore a continual source of embarrassment to me”.Footnote 18 Besides tensions created by intra-ethnic but differing conceptions of their heritage, there were also tensions between lighter- and darker-skinned Eurasians, with lighter-coloured Eurasians (a more overt European phenotype) frequently considering themselves ‘superior’ to those of a darker complexion.Footnote 19 Jean Ho Tung's budding romance with Billy Gittins, a fellow Hong-Kong Eurasian, was frowned upon by her parents, with her father dismissing her suitor as being “too dark to be considered handsome”.Footnote 20
General perceptions of the British and other Europeans towards the Eurasians in their midst were often characterised by unease. As Heinrich Arbenz, the Swiss consul in occupied Singapore remarked with some disquiet during the war, Eurasians “are neither quite one nor the other”.Footnote 21 Indeed, Eurasians were frequently regarded as a threat because of their “anomalous and ambivalent social position”.Footnote 22 At the same time, racial mixture was not only commonly regarded as a “colonial transgression”, but the concept often filled the colonial imagination with horrors of racial degeneration, impurity, indolence, and abnormality, as well as fears of “moral and intellectual regression”.Footnote 23 Colonial perceptions of Eurasians were also widely underpinned by sexual dynamics, with Eurasians often associated with (and regarded as the products of) decadent morality. Consequently, the merest hint (or suspicion) of Eurasian blood was sufficient to forestall a young woman's marriage hopes or a young man's career ambitions. Interracial marriages were widely regarded as a “sin against society”; as Vicky Lee has argued, any European employee who challenged the “colonial etiquette by interracial romance was jeopardising not only his career but was also risking ostracism by the European community”.Footnote 24 Lower-class whites were deemed particularly susceptible to dalliances with Asian women, and the progeny of such unions were deemed to be as disreputable as their forebears. In Hong Kong, relations with Asian or Eurasian women often posed a fatal impediment to career progression in the civil service or the great trading houses, and even within the Hong Kong Police Force.Footnote 25 Employees in the Public Works Department (and even prison warders) who had the temerity to marry Eurasians were explicitly barred from residing in government quarters.Footnote 26 Sir Vandeleur Grayburn, the chief of the Hongkong and Shanghai Bank, remained thoroughly disapproving of “marriages to non-British women” among his employees, wishing that “‘as far as possible’ that wives be of British nationality only”. He even remarked firmly in his letters in 1937 that as far as the wives of British executive bank staff were concerned, “foreign, native, half-caste are definitely taboo”.Footnote 27
Indeed, even on the eve of the Second World War, many colonial institutions in British Asia continued to impose laws and rules that reinforced the segregation of the European and non-European communities. Before the war, the Hong Kong born Eurasian Clifford Matthews was refused membership at the Hong Kong Cricket Club because of his racial background. Strikingly, some of these discriminatory practices were evident even at the height of the Japanese onslaught. Despite suffering wounds in the battle for Hong Kong, Matthews was turned away from the Matilda Hospital when he admitted that he was Eurasian on the admission form.Footnote 28 Even at the peak of heavy Japanese sniping and shelling, the segregationist impulse in some Europeans remained evident. Gwen Dew sought refuge from the bombardment inside the Repulse Bay Hotel with other European women, and was stunned to hear a woman who had recently arrived from her home on the Peak declare in a penetrating voice, “What are all these Chinese doing in here? What right have they to be here?”Footnote 29 While it would be wrong to caricature all British residents of Hong Kong as being belligerently racist, it is evident that some individuals continued to display extreme sentiments towards fellow Eurasians and Asians even at the height of crisis.
Eurasians and the Japanese
Like the British, the Japanese appear to have suffered similar difficulties in categorising the Eurasian communities in their captured territories. As John Dower has suggested, the Japanese had an aversion to racial intermarriages and considered mixed-bloods to be inferior. In the Dutch East Indies, the Japanese found ‘half-breeds’ to be a particularly problematic group and may have even gone as far as to establish “eight different categories for Eurasians, depending on their percentage of European blood”.Footnote 30And indeed, Japanese attitudes towards Eurasians appear to have varied between their occupied territories. Sudden unpredictable changes in official Japanese policy towards Eurasians were also common during the occupation years. In Hong Kong, the Japanese were constantly perplexed by the question of what to do with the Eurasians (especially high-status or wealthy ones) and how to fit them into the hierarchies of the new order. During the early days of the war, the Japanese appear to have encouraged certain Eurasians to take up clerical and secretarial posts in the new administration. In Singapore, for instance, a number of Eurasian girls were employed by the Japanese as “steno typists, telephone operators and as sales girls”.Footnote 31 Some Japanese officials were also interested in using Eurasians (who were conversant in both local dialects and the English language) as informers, plants or recruits to their intelligence services.Footnote 32 Some Eurasians were even granted unexpected privileges by certain Japanese officials, such as additional food supplies.Footnote 33 The Eurasian Farleigh Oehlers, for instance, received gifts of food from a Japanese captain in Singapore.Footnote 34
There is also evidence to suggest that the Japanese may have directly sought to sway Eurasian loyalties in the direction of the new pan-Asiatic order and to inveigle them away from the British side. According to a report prepared by the US Far Eastern Bureau, all members of the Eurasian community in Singapore were summoned by the Japanese authorities in March 1942 and instructed “to forget their Western loyalties and ally themselves with the ‘Asiatic’ cause”.Footnote 35 The Hong Kong News (an English-language wartime propaganda newspaper issued by the Japanese) was quick to remind its Eurasian readers of the discrimination they had endured under British rule, such the meagre levels of ‘native pay’ and other indignities they had suffered before the war.Footnote 36 At the same time, however, many Eurasians were also viewed with suspicion by the Japanese for being potentially pro-British due to their part-European descent. The Eurasians in Singapore, it was reported, were categorically dismissed by some Japanese officials as the community most likely to spread anti-Japanese propaganda and who would “go to church every Sunday and pray for the British to come back”.Footnote 37 The Japanese were convinced, too, that some Eurasians on the island had clandestine access to news broadcasts and were defiantly transmitting information about the progress of the war to the rest of the local population.Footnote 38
The Eurasians in Singapore nevertheless acquired a wartime patron in the form of Mamoru Shinozaki, the head of the Education and later the Welfare Department in Singapore (who was reputed to have a Eurasian mistress himself).Footnote 39 A few of their counterparts in Hong Kong were befriended by a slick-talking Kempeitai officer known as Nakazawa Chikanori (known to the locals as Chick). Chick was said to have attempted to convert a pair of Eurasian sisters, Irene Fincher and Phyllis Bliss, to the Japanese cause by supplying them with food. Both women had belonged to the Gittins clan, a prominent middle-class Hong Kong Eurasian family.Footnote 40 As Emily Hahn observed, Chick attempted to convince the sisters that they “owed their sufferings to England, artfully playing up any latent pride they had in their Chinese blood”. He glibly reminded the sisters of the iniquities of the British during the colonial period, while emphasising the fact that both of them had lost their husbands during the battle for the colony.Footnote 41 Indeed, many Eurasians serving in the Hong Kong Volunteer Defence Corps (HKVDC) were reputed to have made a gallant stand against the Japanese during the campaign for Hong Kong and several of them were killed while in service. The 5th Battalion, an all-Eurasian unit, was even said to have been decimated by the Japanese onslaught.Footnote 42 Some wives of Eurasian soldiers had however alleged that the British authorities had deliberately used the Eurasian units of the HKVDC as cannon fodder “in the front ranks to save the white soldiers”. While Chick was quick to remind the sisters of these allegations, Irene Fincher's response was: “The English have always treated us like that, in peacetime too”.Footnote 43
The Eurasians, being neither Asians nor Europeans, were thus to become in many instances an awkward wartime group whose identities (and sometimes loyalties) were a source of perpetual vexation to the Japanese.Footnote 44 In Hong Kong, the evidence suggests that some Japanese officials were initially against the idea of incarcerating Eurasians at Stanley. Some Eurasian wives, it seems, were prevented from accompanying their husbands into captivity. Indeed, one Kempeitai general was even said to have declared at the outset that all Eurasian and Chinese individuals would be required to leave the internment camp.Footnote 45 But Japanese policy towards Eurasians was far from consistent over the occupation years; while some Eurasians were detained in internment centres, a few were summarily ejected from the Chinese boarding houses and brothels in Hong Kong where the Europeans were first incarcerated. Wenzell Brown recalls how some Eurasians were evicted by Japanese guards: “Rex was mortally afraid of being ejected from the hotel, for to go out into the streets without money or a place of shelter might mean death from starvation or exposure. Soon an order came for the release of all Eurasians and Japanese officials came through the hotel and gave passes to those Eurasians who had reported as British subjects. Rex hid in the toilets until the officials had gone, and then returned to the room apologetically sucking his moustache and bowing and smiling as he resumed his seat on the bed”.Footnote 46
The Eurasians in Malaya and Singapore suffered from similar inconsistencies under their new masters. In April 1942, the Eurasians in Singapore were instructed by the Japanese to report at the Singapore Recreation Club for screening purposes. While most first-generation Eurasians were subsequently interned at Changi, those of second-generation Eurasian parentage were given red badges with white stars and permitted to remain free in the occupied city.Footnote 47 And indeed, the Japanese appear to have made consistent distinctions between first- and second-generation Eurasians throughout the occupation years. It was frequently rumoured at Changi, for instance, that first-generation Eurasians were eligible for repatriation, but second-generation Eurasians were not. The British internee G.C. Allen wrote of a “very strong belief” in the camp that “the British and Japanese governments have concluded an agreement for the exchange of their nationals. . . [which] include Eurasians of the first generation i.e. those who have one European parent”.Footnote 48
During the first few years of the occupation, the Eurasians at Stanley and Changi were even occasionally permitted by the Japanese to leave the camps ‘on parole’ if they were able to secure sufficient financial guarantees from non-interned friends or relatives. Forty-three Eurasians including seven women and children were accordingly released from Changi in June 1942, and three individuals were similarly freed from Stanley in February 1943. It seems that even as late as May 1944, some Eurasians at Sime Road were permitted to leave the camp if they could provide evidence of their ability to support themselves on the outside.Footnote 49 However, by the final months of the war, the evidence suggests that the Japanese increasingly came to perceive Eurasians as a threat to their occupation regimes. As the war reached critical heights (and as the likelihood of an Allied invasion mounted), the Japanese began to intern the Eurasians in many of their occupied territories to prevent them from participating in potentially subversive activities or from assisting the Allied forces.Footnote 50 At Sime Road, the internee J.S. Smith noted in his diary that some 800 Eurasians and Baghdadi Jews were brought into the camp in March 1945, and the majority were women and children.Footnote 51
As a result of such uncertain wartime prospects, the Eurasian communities of both Hong Kong and Singapore were subjected to unrelenting anxiety during the occupation years. As most of them were deprived of their usual means of livelihood, several were forced to eke out a meagre existence through farming or the black market. Some of the more opportunistic Eurasians in Hong Kong were able to reconstruct their traditional middleman roles by setting themselves up as “commodity ‘brokers’” for the conquering forces, especially in meeting the Japanese wartime demands for scrap metals and luxury goods.Footnote 52 Emily Hahn wrote of a Eurasian ex-jockey named Victor Vander Needa who turned himself into a “flourishing merchant” by “scouring the town for iron and bronze and aluminium. . . all of which the [Japanese] Navy eagerly grabbed and paid for”.Footnote 53 For the vast majority of Eurasians who remained free in the occupied cities the threat of arrest by the Kempeitai (Japanese military police) was however, a very real one. Many were also stricken by the persistent fear that they could be taken in by the Japanese at any time as forced labour.Footnote 54 The majority of Eurasians in Singapore and Malaya also lacked the buffer of wealth to protect them, unlike some of their wealthier counterparts in Hong Kong.Footnote 55 The Eurasian Farleigh Oehlers felt that “it was important to toe the line” as far as the Japanese authorities were concerned: “You just had to do what you were told to do. What else could you do?”Footnote 56 Indeed, the leaders of the Eurasian communities in Hong Kong, Malaya and Singapore were also aware that any displays of defiance, or even simple acts of misbehaviour, could result in severe reprisals. At the same time, their position as a buffer between the Japanese and their own communities was a highly invidious and controversial one. Charles Paglar, a Eurasian medical practitioner in Malaya and Singapore, was even charged with treason by the British authorities after the war for having taken a leading role in an All-Malaya Eurasian Welfare Association under Japanese auspices.Footnote 57
During the war, some Eurasians in Malaya and Singapore were offered an opportunity by the Japanese to relocate to Bahau, an agricultural settlement scheme in the centre of the Malayan peninsula. This scheme was backed by Mamoru Shinozaki, the self-appointed protector of the Eurasian community who appeared to have been intent on removing as many Eurasians as he possibly could from the threat of arrest by the Kempeitai and the scramble for scarce resources and employment in Singapore. He promised funds for housing and transport for the Eurasian pioneers, as well as initial supplies of food and medicines, and was reported to have “kept to his word to the very best of his ability”. Settler Farleigh Oehlers noted that Shinozaki even made a number of visits to Bahau himself, bringing medicines and other supplies, besides calling at the hospital to “see that things were all right” and to “see what he could do to help”.Footnote 58 Although predominantly Eurasian, the settlement also contained separate areas for Catholics, Protestants and a variety of ‘third nationals’ or ‘neutrals’ who were keen to get out of the occupied cities – there were Danish and Swedish nationals and even a couple of White Russians.Footnote 59 The Eurasians in Singapore were torn between remaining in the city and migrating to “the promised land” of Bahau; many who went did so in the belief that it was a means of escape from an urban hotbed of fear and suspicion.Footnote 60 The Bahau pioneers were expected to till the land and grow their own crops; while the Japanese initially demanded that they plant cotton, there was a real need for food crops such as tapioca and sweet potato. However, a lack of top soil, planting tools, and the arid nature of the land made agriculture a Herculean task. “Many Eurasians were disillusioned”, commented a member of their community, “Bahau was supposed to be a utopia but turned out to be a trap”.Footnote 61 Highly malaria-prone, the inhospitable nature of the land also began to prove a severe trial for the settlers. By April 1944, the first Eurasians in Bahau began to perish from malaria, beriberi, dysentery and other endemic diseases. Although Shinozaki did his best to “boost morale”, the grim spectre of death continuously haunted the settlement. According to one estimate, a quarter of the Eurasian population of 2,000 eventually died.Footnote 62
Eurasians and the internment camps
When balanced against these prevailing alternatives, there is much evidence to suggest that internment was regarded by many Eurasians as a more viable form of protection and survival. Farleigh Oehlers was informed by an internee that he would have been “much better off” in camp than at the settlement in Bahau, and commented that he eventually became convinced of the wisdom of these words.Footnote 63 The Eurasian doctor John van Cuylenberg similarly felt that “those civilians whom the Japanese had interned at Changi Jail and Sime Road Camp were better off than those who were outside barbed wire, for none of us knew what the day or the morrow would bring in its wake. . . the hazards outside were infinitely greater, everybody being permeated with fear”.Footnote 64 Indeed, a number of civilians even “insisted on being interned” out of the conviction that the camps were havens of comparative safety, and that they would not have to worry about the necessities of daily existence if they were interned (this latter line of reasoning, felt the Chinese doctor Li Shu-Fan, was quite “sound when the internment camps were comparatively tolerable in the beginning”).Footnote 65 Jean Gittins, the daughter of the plutocrat Robert Ho Tung, voluntarily submitted herself to internment at Stanley, never quite perceiving herself as a captive but more as a British subject seeking protection from the outside.Footnote 66 At Changi, the internee Lucia Bach remarked that many “young and pretty” girls sought refuge in the camp from the predatory advances of Japanese soldiers as “there was a great belief outside the camp that we were well fed and well protected”.Footnote 67 It is striking to note that many Eurasians at Changi who were given an opportunity by the Japanese to leave the camp on parole expressed considerable fear and uncertainty about their prospects in the occupied city.Footnote 68 In May 1942, the British internee J.S. Smith observed in his diary, “two cell mates (Eurasian). . . informed that they must go out on Sunday on parole – very upset about it”.Footnote 69
Other Eurasians, however, sought refuge within the internment camps for a variety of other reasons. Some Eurasians who entered the camps were convinced by rumours of civilian exchanges that they could eventually be repatriated to Europe if they acquired internee status. Jean Gittins, for instance, was certain that by being interned at Stanley she would be among those eligible to be repatriated.Footnote 70 A number of Eurasian women also entered the camps simply to avoid being separated from their European husbands.Footnote 71 Others were convinced that their children would fare better in internment, especially after it was rumoured outside the camps that the captive European civilians were receiving bountiful food rations. There may have indeed been some justification to this view, especially during the very early days of the war when supplies were relatively adequate. At Changi, the British internee John Hayter observed that the Eurasian children of the Harris family looked “very much fitter” after six weeks of internment, and concluded “there is no doubt that children are much better looked after at Changi than they can ever be outside”.Footnote 72 Such seemingly opportunistic behaviour was nevertheless resented by various inmates of the camp; as the American Freddy Bloom bitterly commented in her Changi diary:
Some of these Eurasians are charming but the majority are not and say they are married to British soldiers (some with no more proof than a couple of half-white children). One woman has not seen her husband for five years yet claims the protection of this Camp. I am surprised at the Nipponese allowing them to stay, for it is such an obvious ramp. Here they get better food, quarters and care than they ever had and all for nothing. The better food applies at least to those with children for they (we have almost sixty children from tiny infants up to nine years old) get all the extras that are ever brought in – fruits, buns, etc. – today they had eggs.Footnote 73
Some Eurasians, in contrast, remained very much opposed to the idea of being interned as enemy aliens. A few of them even deftly capitalised on the fluidity of their racial identities to escape internment. Patrick Hardie, a Eurasian in Singapore, promptly “called himself a Malay” upon the arrival of the Japanese forces to avoid incarceration at Changi.Footnote 74 When the western civilians in Hong Kong were rounded up by the Japanese for incarceration, Fincher and Bliss remarked to Emily Hahn with “indescribable bitterness” that “only pure Englishwomen were sent away” when an evacuation scheme was instituted by the colonial authorities before the outbreak of war. However, as they noted with some relish, “now only pure Englishwomen are being interned”. Fincher also reacted in resolute fashion when Emily Hahn questioned why she did not prefer to be interned by the Japanese in view of the increasing scarcity of food supplies in the occupied city:
“But you look English,” I said. “The Japanese would intern you if you wanted them to – I know lots of Eurasians who chose to go into Stanley”.
Irene stuck out her lip. “I'm Eurasian”, she said. “I won't go where I'm not supposed to”.Footnote 75
Irene Fincher's intriguing reply to Hahn may be interpreted on a number of levels. At one level, her statement “I'm Eurasian, I won't go where I'm not supposed to” may simply reflect the fact that she took a certain measure of pride in her Eurasian identity and wished to reiterate this sentiment. But on another level, her words may also suggest a deeper feeling of resentment, especially in terms of being excluded from a viable source of wartime protection.Footnote 76 Indeed, as Irene's sister-in-law Jean Gittins eventually concluded, the prospect of internment did indeed offer “a hope of survival” to many beleaguered civilians in Hong Kong; “at the very least they would be housed and fed”.Footnote 77
Eurasians and the British in confinement
In one of the ironies of war, British elites who had vigorously defended policies of racial exclusion before the war were incarcerated with the very racial elements they had previously held at length. As in pre-war colonial society, it was difficult for the interned British to accommodate the Eurasians within the social structures of internment with ease. One issue which proved particularly contentious to both the British and the Eurasians within the camps was the slippery question of racial classification. In June 1942, the male internees’ newspaper Changi Guardian published an article on camp statistics in which the Eurasians within the camp were classified under the heading ‘Other Nationals’. This categorisation quickly provoked an indignant response among several Eurasians in the camp who had considered themselves British subjects and accordingly “felt that the description of non-Britishers applied to them. . . was unjust”. The newspaper was consequently compelled to issue a statement to reassure the Eurasians that “this was the classification ordered by the Nipponese and that there was no intention on the part of the Camp authorities of hurting their feelings. We hope that this explanation will clear away any misconception held by those Eurasians who rightly consider themselves true British subjects”.Footnote 78
For many of the captive British, daily intimate contact with Eurasians was highly disconcerting, especially in the context of pre-war colonial discourses which had frequently interpreted Eurasians as a form of degeneration, transgression, adulteration and impurity. Quite a few of them were convinced that Eurasians suffered from innumerable emotional maladies and anxieties. Before the war, it was also widely held among some expatriates that Eurasians often attempted to “compensate for a deep feeling of inferiority by displaying their importance relative to both Europeans and Asians”.Footnote 79 Such perceptions and stereotypes of Eurasian behaviour were crystallised in various uneasy patterns of social interaction within the internment camps. “Very often [the Eurasian] is offended and insulted by both European and Chinese because of this mixture of blood”, remarked the British internee Lancelot Forster at Stanley, “and so he becomes either openly resentful or permanently depressed, for he has a sense of inferiority”. Forster's personal observations on the behaviour of Ernest Brown (a Eurasian youth at Stanley) suggest that these stereotypes of Eurasians continued to prevail during internment:
Ernest was convinced he was not inferior and was determined that he would demonstrate his abilities against the European whenever he had the chance. . . He remembered the insults and ignored the kindnesses he had experienced at the hands of Europeans probably because the former were much more numerous. He therefore approached, at first, all Europeans in this resentful spirit, never disarming opposition but always provoking it in order to confirm his rooted belief that the hand of the white man was against him. . . So it was in a boxing competition which was staged for youths in the early days of the camp. There he came up against a white youth who was bigger than he was. One could see by a glint in his eye that he was out, if not for a kill, at least for a knock-out blow. He succeeded in winning the fight which to him was the symbol of his struggle against Europeans in general.Footnote 80
At the same time, it should be emphasised that the operative structures of British-Eurasian interaction in the camps were frequently and critically underpinned by sexual undercurrents. Even within the camps, the image of Eurasian females remained irrevocably intertwined with the notion of moral laxity.Footnote 81 Wenzell Brown's uneasy description of his encounter with the indubitable Lucy Reynolds at Stanley is highly revealing: “Lucy was Hong Kong's leading madame. The fame of her brothel had spread over the world. British civil servants in Delhi speak reminiscently of Lucy's Eurasian girls. In Wapping or Limehouse, in Shanghai or Cairo or Caracas, Lucy Reynolds brings a twinkle into the eyes of the knowing”.Footnote 82 Even during internment, Eurasians were frequently equated with sexual permissiveness; it was frequently rumoured, for instance, that certain Eurasian women were having sexual relationships with their Japanese guards in return for food and other camp privileges. As a Changi internee commented in his diary: “some of the women are visited at night by the Japs and there is a racket called a match factory in which some of the less desirable of the women work”.Footnote 83 When the Changi internees were eventually moved to new camp premises at Sime Road, some of the buildings within the camp were even known as ‘Brothel Houses’, in reference to the sexual contact which was rumoured to have occurred in these huts between women internees and their guards.Footnote 84 The Stanley internee Joseph Alsop similarly wrote of the existence of a “camp bordello” where “three Eurasian women sold their favours for things to eat”.Footnote 85
Such British impressions of Eurasian profligacy and licentiousness were reinforced by a number of actual sexual scandals which occurred in the camps, especially with regard to a case involving the double taboo of underage homosexuality. In November 1944, a Eurasian at Sime Road was charged for “interfering” with a Eurasian boy (under the age of fifteen) in his hut. The man was pronounced guilty of “‘grossly indecent’ practices” by the camp disciplinary committee and sentenced to “three months deprivation of privileges, three months extra heavy fatigues under police supervision, and three weeks solitary confinement”.Footnote 86 From these camp records surveyed, it is apparent that the Eurasians continued to be associated with some of the strongest taboos of colonial society even during captivity.
Also, for British communities suddenly forced to confront the problem of Eurasians at close, intimate quarters, the presence of numerous Asian mistresses and their Eurasian children in the camps (which were considerably more than official pre-war statistics suggested) was a disturbing reality. Gladys Tompkins remarked that there were several Malay women at Changi who had been interned “as British wives and were known as Mrs. So and So, which must have made few nasty tangles. The ‘Malay Keeps’ would never have been known in ordinary life, but because of internment their presence came to the surface”.Footnote 87 Some interned British women even began composing moral recriminations in their diaries against the men who had fathered the Eurasian children in their midst. As one of them complained, “if only there had been only British women in the Camp, we should have been a very select crowd, but the crowds of coloured wives and their offspring make me very disgruntled with our British men”. Footnote 88 Constance Sleep, similarly felt that it was “very deplorable that so many of our men” had contracted mixed marriages with Asians or Eurasians. As she remarked, “in most of the cases in Camp, I am sure there have been no legal marriages. . . I do despise the European men who are responsible for bringing [these Eurasians] into the world”.Footnote 89 The issue, at Stanley, of whether Chinese and Eurasians should remain in the camp or not, was discussed at various meetings of the Temporary Camp Committee (later the British Communal Council). From these discussions, the contrasting sentiments held by the British internees became apparent; while some open-minded liberals may have taken a relatively benign view of the Eurasians in their midst, the Eurasian presence in the camp remained a highly contentious issue for others.Footnote 90 John Stericker, the Stanley camp secretary, wrote with some cynicism as to how the issue was eventually resolved: “And so, the Chinese stayed, the Eurasians stayed and the dogs stayed, as did overcrowding, and shortage of fuel, food and everything else”.Footnote 91
Although it was impossible for the British to remain physically aloof from Eurasians during internment, it is intriguing to note that issues of sexual and racial management continued to be subtly linked to internal structures of British rule and control. At Stanley, the interned Police Commissioner John Pennefather-Evans remained thoroughly disapproving of mixed marriages between European policemen and “Orientals and Eurasians” within the camp. He explained that this resulted from the “low standards of morality” of these lower-class Asian women and because of the “difficulty of housing mixed partners in European quarters without causing dissatisfaction”. This type of Asiatic wife tends to “lower the social status of the Police as a whole”, he insisted, and “should a police officer marry without official approval he should be required to leave the Police Service within six months”.Footnote 92 In November 1944, Pennefather-Evans even threatened an interned police sergeant named Morrison with dismissal from the police force if he married a woman at Stanley who was “strongly suspected to be Eurasian”, despite her claims of pure European parentage. “The C.P. is adamant”, commented the Colonial Secretary Franklin Gimson in his camp diary, “that if the marriage takes place the Sergeant cannot remain in the Police Force”. Gimson's personal sympathies were strongly with the beleaguered sergeant. As he later speculated in his diary, “if Morrison were to place his case before the Secretary of State, the marriage would indeed be permitted together with his retention in the Police Force”. But Pennefather-Evans refused to budge from his stance, and the sergeant was given six months to prove that his fiancée's family were of “pure Portuguese descent”.Footnote 93 From this episode, it may be argued that methods of sexual control were linked to various frameworks of British self-governance within the internment camps. As before the war, it was through a subtle policing of sexual relations and the prohibition of interracial marriages that subordinate Europeans were kept in line and racial boundaries were preserved in the camps.Footnote 94
Internment did, however, mark a shift in some British perceptions towards the Eurasians in their midst. As Lancelot Forster noted at Stanley, there were several “socially minded” Eurasians “who helped in the camp work. . . and mingled on equal and easy terms with everyone”.Footnote 95 One of these was a resourceful young Eurasian dental mechanic who quickly set up a makeshift ‘dental office’ in the camp with the instruments and materials that he had managed to salvage from his office after the outbreak of hostilities. Soon “he was making dentures, fillings and yanking teeth at no charge”, although some interned American dentists continually griped about him not having a licence to practise before the war.Footnote 96 Due to their bilingual abilities, some Eurasians were invaluable to resistance efforts within the camps. Jean Gittins, for instance, was involved several times in the translation of messages from English into Chinese for underground operations at Stanley.Footnote 97 Among the inmates of the camps, too, were a number of Eurasian women (often married to lower-class Europeans) who had entered the camps voluntarily to be with their spouses.Footnote 98 As the months passed, some of the more discerning expatriates began to view these devoted Eurasian women in an altogether different light, and in some cases, to “draw close to them for the first time”.Footnote 99 Some interned European women also appeared to have taken a number of Eurasian orphans under their wing. Sheila Allen, the Eurasian daughter of an Australian mining engineer and his Malayan wife, entered Changi aged seventeen and kept an engaging chronicle of camp affairs. She describes a number of close solidarities and relationships within the camp despite the underlying tensions, and was herself frequently invited by a number of British women to take ‘elevenses’ with them.Footnote 100
Such enlightened attitudes were however, far from widespread, and the majority of the captive British appear to have clung to the discriminatory attitudes they had held to before the war. Indeed, it may be argued that the Eurasian presence in the camps was largely regarded by the British internees as an aggravating burden to be borne grudgingly. This could perhaps be attributed to the stunning reversal of colonial privilege within the camps. While the combined shock of defeat and internment had toppled the British from their position of social dominance, the Eurasians were still able to retain their intermediary privileges of resorting to their outside Asian connections.Footnote 101 Many Eurasian internees at Stanley like Jean Gittins, for instance, received food parcels from friends and relatives in town on a regular basis. At Changi, many interned Eurasians were also comparatively well equipped in terms of basic possessions and other necessities, having entered the camps at a later date. Indeed, camp tensions were often rooted in the fact that racial rules of privilege were completely overturned by the war, and it was tremendously difficult for the British and other western civilians to come to terms with these harsh realities. However, it should be emphasised that the wartime privileges enjoyed by the Eurasians nevertheless came at a price, as their middleman activities were often regarded with suspicion by both the Japanese and the British. While the Eurasians on the outside were frequently accused by the Japanese of harbouring pro-British attitudes, the Eurasians in the camps were often suspected by their British inmates of spying for the Japanese. Of possible informers within Stanley, remarked a report in March 1942, “three Japanese women who were interned as British subjects and a number of Eurasians were naturally suspected”.Footnote 102
Also, in captive communities impelled by a critical and perpetual shortage of food, medicines and other necessities, the interned Eurasians were often criticised by their European inmates for taking up space and resources which they did not rightfully deserve. As L.A. Collyer commented, much resentment in the Stanley camp often stemmed out of “sheer envy” between the ‘haves’ and the ‘have nots’.Footnote 103 Quite a number of British internees at Stanley, for instance, were said to have remarked that “were it not for the many Eurasians in the camp there would be sufficient food for them”.Footnote 104 Considerable resentment, too, was provoked by the very sight of parcels which the Eurasians were getting from their friends and relatives in town; one man was said to have received so many parcels he developed a hernia from carrying them up the hill to his room.Footnote 105 Comparatively few internees enjoyed these occasional calorific windfalls from the outside; statistics suggest that of the 4,722 parcels received between September to December 1943, 79 per cent of these parcels were addressed to only 240 individuals, a figure less than 10 per cent of the camp population.Footnote 106 Also, as parcel recipients were “nearly always the same persons”, “a good deal of jealousy” quickly ensued among the less privileged.Footnote 107 Indeed, such parcels from the outside frequently made a difference to the health of the inmates; according to one camp statistic, regular parcel recipients at Stanley weighed an average of 16 lbs (7.3 kilograms) more than their less-fortunate counterparts by January 1945.Footnote 108 The Eurasian Jean Gittins was accordingly prompted to observe:
Racial discrimination had by no means moderated in the face of general adversity, and some people were too bigoted to understand that the food was provided, not in a lump quantity, but rationed by the Japanese according to the number of mouths to be fed. Then there were those, who, failing to get parcels themselves, became increasingly jealous of those who did. They were envious not of the large business houses whose parcels came regularly and had to be paid for at the end of the war – the main target of their resentment was again the Eurasian community whose relatives in town sent parcels from sheer solicitude and often at much personal sacrifice.Footnote 109
Of all the social groups within the camps, the European women appear to have been particularly vocal in their antipathy towards the Eurasians in their midst. In a significant proportion of white female narratives surveyed in this study, the language used to describe Eurasians was often strong. At Changi, where males and females were incarcerated in separate sections of the camp, such hostility may have stemmed from the fact that it was the white women who were compelled to bear the brunt of Eurasian company in their section of the camp. In April 1944, C.P. Ambler observed in his diary that “in a total of some 550/600 women and children the ‘white population’ numbers about 80”.Footnote 110 By the final months of the war, as the internee Ernest Hodgkin noted in his diary, white women may have even been outnumbered by Eurasian women and children by a factor of “ten to one”.Footnote 111 One male internee observed that “life in the women's camp cannot be very pleasant as the 200 or so Europeans are swamped out by Eurasian and Asiatic women and children, quarrels are constantly starting, and fights are not unknown”.Footnote 112
But anecdotal evidence suggests that even the more respectable elements of the white female community (and even educated and politically conscious women) displayed an unrestrained contempt for the Eurasians in their midst. In March 1945, the arrival of about three hundred Eurasians in the Sime Road women's section elicited a storm of bristling antipathy among the British women already in the camp. Katherine de Moubray, the wife of the British advisor to the Malay state of Terengganu, described the arrivals in strong terms as “the most incredible cases – as Freddy [Bloom] says, if these are samples of Japan's worst enemies in Singapore God help us!”. The newly arrived Eurasians were regarded by several British women as an unwelcome and irritating intrusion, as well as a source of more work in the camp. A number of British women, wrote de Moubray, were in despair, feeling that this was “the last straw to an intolerable life (Kathleen Toussaint: ‘Death would be better’).” Considerable jealousy, too, was generated among some British women by the discovery that many Eurasians possessed a considerable amount of equipment and stores and had generally been better fed on the outside. “Most of them got a rude shock at our food”, exclaimed de Moubray, “so we needn't feel that we have to make any sacrifices for them”. Incredulous reports also began circulating among the British women about a newly arrived Eurasian internee “asking for the [fridge] in which to keep her Anchor butter!” and a “dame who came up to Eleanor [Hopkins] with a fowl cleaned but unplucked, and presented it to her say [sic.]: ‘I've just killed this chicken, can the head cook have it cooked for my supper!’” Footnote 113 In many instances, class biases were often intertwined with racial prejudices. The comments of the British internee Constance Sleep are revealing in this context:
believe me, most of [the Eurasians] are liabilities in the Camp. They either won't or can't take their share of running of the Camp. . . Our funds have to pay for milk, eggs and fruit provided for these people. . . I'm afraid I feel bitter about it, and about the men in the camp who are the begetters of these Eurasian children. Actually the majority of these children have lived in native villages all their lives, and have never been accustomed to such food – I personally know of one mother in the Camp who regularly puts the milk down the toilet, and sells the eggs – she herself told me that her children had never had it before, and that they did not like either milk or eggs. And as she herself said, “What to do, man?”Footnote 114
The tensions between white and Eurasian women in the camps thus offer an illuminating perspective on the clashes of bodily habits and practices which occurred during internment. At Changi, many captive British women regarded the Asiatic food preferences of their Eurasian inmates with significant disdain. At the same time, the Eurasians’ devaluation of food so highly prized by Europeans, such as milk and eggs, was a highly contentious issue for the British women. Thus, when Red Cross condensed milk rations were received at the women's section at Changi, controversy quickly ensued over how the supplies should be distributed – and to whom. At Stanley, a report prepared by a female British internee on educational activities conducted in the camp even lamented that the “lack of physical stamina noticed in many [Eurasian] children” indicates “a need for parental education in food values”.Footnote 115 Many Eurasians, for their part, regarded the culinary ineptitudes of their British inmates with disdain. Indeed, the evidence suggests that it was the Eurasian captives who often made the best out of meagre and unpalatable camp rations. As a British POW admitted, the Eurasians at the Changi barracks knew how to cook rice, unlike the British who made a mess out of it: while the British threw fish heads away, while the Eurasians “collected these and they were eating very much better”.Footnote 116
Some European women at Changi were also convinced that they were regularly besieged by the bodily indiscretions of their Eurasian inmates. The perceived ‘filthiness’ of some interned Eurasian women, in particular, was a source of consternation to the white women at Changi, and was believed to reflect an intrinsic racial weakness. “The Eurasians with children were put into the few European cells, as they were roomier and had running water”, complained the American journalist Freddy Bloom. “In the short time we are here they have made them incredibly dirty. Cleaning squads can do little as the women refuse to move even temporarily during cleaning”.Footnote 117 It may thus be argued that internment had effectively placed many Europeans into unaccustomed and uncontrolled intimacy to the “undomesticated bodies” of Eurasians for the first time, and that the bodily traumas of incarceration were aggravated by an underlying racial dimension.Footnote 118
In analysing the tensions between white and Eurasian women in the camps, it may be argued that the limits of white female empathy were sorely tested by the tribulations and challenges of internment. While proponents of the school of ‘maternal imperialism’ have suggested that white women may have displayed “more sympathetic, positive and affectionate attitudes towards the various resident Asian races than do many of their contemporary male counterparts”, the evidence suggests that this sense of affinity between white and Asian women often broke down under the pressures of internment.Footnote 119 In particular, the elevated status of European women had often crumbled away in the camps, along with their pre-war racial privileges, and they were compelled to compete with numerous Eurasian women for daily necessities. Also, it should be emphasised that the British women in the camps were constantly haunted by the spectre of decline and deterioration during the wartime years. As Eurasians were often regarded as the literal embodiment of degeneration in pre-war colonial discourses, their very presence (and sheer physical proximity) in the camps may have sharpened these fears and led to a significant hardening of racial attitudes during internment. While some were bound to their own racial intolerance, others may have been largely insecure and jealous of the privileges the Eurasians were getting. It may be argued that interned white women were often responsible for racial cleavages within the camps, and especially as far relationships with Eurasians were concerned.
Conclusion
According to the central argument of this essay, the Eurasian communities of British Asia were in many instances an awkward group within the colonial empire whose identities (and sometimes loyalties) were a source of perpetual vexation to both the British and the Japanese. While the British suffered acute difficulties in categorising the Eurasians before the war, it was equally difficult for the Japanese to fit the Eurasians into the hierarchies of their new order. Official Japanese policies towards Eurasians accordingly varied between colonies and between different periods during the occupation years. However, by the end of the war, the Japanese came to increasingly regard the Eurasians as a threat to their occupation regimes, and many Eurasians were accordingly rounded up and incarcerated in civilian internment camps. For many Eurasians, the occupation years were a highly traumatic period. While some attempted to recreate their traditional intermediary roles between the conquering forces and the Asian populations, a few of them voluntarily entered the civilian camps as they were convinced that internment offered a more viable form of protection and survival. However, their communities remained stranded between worlds during the occupation period, both inside and outside the internment camps. Indeed, many Eurasian individuals were regarded with suspicion by both the Japanese and the British for potentially collaborating with the opposing side.
At the same time, the evidence from internment also provides a compelling perspective to the racial barriers which governed colonial communities both before and during the Second World War. Various tensions and feuds of the pre-war era were reproduced (and even magnified) within the camps, and illustrate the stratified nature of pre-war British colonial society in the East – its racial chasms, social feuds and ingrained snobberies. Even within the internment camps, the brusque insularity of elite British communities and other factors such as latent racism prevented the full acceptance of Eurasians within British circles. Many Eurasians accordingly remained on the social fringes of the interned communities. Unlike the British, however, several Eurasian captives were able to draw on their traditional intermediary privileges and the resources provided by a wider colonial network during the period. As the war progressed and as conditions worsened, the Eurasians were increasingly able to assert themselves as a group within the camps and threaten the hierarchies of privilege which were once the exclusive preserve of pre-war elite British communities. However, as this article suggests, they were nevertheless isolated by their European inmates who continued to associate their presence with fears of physical degeneration and moral laxity. Indeed, even during the turmoil and upheaval of Japanese occupation, the Eurasians of British Asia remained a marginalised colonial category that straddled racial boundaries and embodied the uneasy nature of colonial encounters.
