The 1896 presidential election has drawn considerable interest because it is regarded by many scholars as a defining and realigning election, a confrontation between two competing visions and sets of interests in America. Democrats represented southern and western rural, small-town, agricultural peoples uneasy about the demise of their way of life and angry about the power of eastern railroads and bankers over their lives. Republicans represented eastern and midwestern interests, a coalition of the modern industrial and banking sectors and those tied to the developing urban economy. The conflict between these regional interests was accentuated by battles over the money supply, which played out as the gold versus silver issue. The result was a presidential campaign that reflected conflicts over social change and its consequences. It was also a campaign complicated by each party's effort to appeal to urban workers and by the injection of religious language, which made some uneasy.
The campaign is an important example of the crucial role presidential elections can play as vehicles for articulating different interests and ideas in a democracy. It is not clear, however, that the election itself was defining, nor whether that characterization is necessary for regarding this election as important. This book succeeds admirably in portraying the campaign but unnecessarily relies on the critical realignment framework for interpreting the campaign.
Williams provides a long-needed clear and concise portrait of the 1896 campaign. He reviews the issues of the time, the uncertainty of party positioning, and the strategy of campaigns. The long-term trends of urbanization, industrialization, and immigration were changing America and creating tensions between city dwellers and the rural-small town segment of the nation. There were also clashes over whether to regulate railroads, corporations, and the size of the money supply.
Although conflicts existed, it was not clear just who should represent each party and what position the parties should take on key issues. Williams provides a clear review of the maneuvering for presidential nominations within each party and the debates about policy positioning. Perhaps the most interesting situation was that faced by Democrats. There were internal disagreements over how much to make monetary issues central and who should represent the party. Although subsequent portraits of the election focus on the stark clash between William Jennings Bryan and William McKinley, Bryan and his positions were not the obvious choices early in the presidential nomination process. Although the modern process of campaigning for the nomination can seem endless, it was also lengthy in 1896. Williams indicates just how much advance work was conducted by Bryan to position himself to receive the nomination. Bryan carefully assessed the strength of opinion within state delegations for various positions and the appeal of possible opponents for the nomination. There was also disagreement about how much to emphasize the silver issue. Bryan ultimately outmaneuvered other candidates, saw the money issue as central, and made it the focus of his campaign.
Williams also contrasts the candidates' campaign strategies. Bryan decided to speak all across much of the nation, relying on his rhetorical skills to connect with voters. McKinley chose his famous “front porch” strategy, in which the campaign relied on voters coming to visit the candidate in Canton, Ohio. To present their case to the voters, the Republicans raised $3.5 million (ten times as much as Bryan) and engaged in extensive distribution of literature. For those seeking a clear review of the issues and strategies involved in the 1896 presidential campaign, this is a very valuable book.
If the book has a limitation, it is the presumption that 1896 was a realigning election. This framework presents the campaign and election as more important than just a fundamental debate about the direction of public policy in the nation. However, in recent years there have been challenges to the interpretation that 1896 involved a major shift in voting patterns. There is evidence that the 1896 election results were really not that different from those that came before.Footnote 1 The percentage of the vote won by Bryan in 1896 was 46.7. The percentages won by the party's presidential candidates in prior elections were 48.5 in 1884, 48.6 in 1888, and 48.6 in 1892. As Williams notes of Bryan, “[I]n part, his loss, of course, reflected a continuation of 1894's devastating anti-Democratic trend” (154). In 1894, Democrats lost 125 seats in the House of Representatives but in 1896 they regained 31 seats. There is no doubt that the Democratic Party struggled for years after that change and that the election “shifted power in the Democratic party to the South” (153). It may, however, be more worthwhile to treat 1896 as part of the party's continual learning and adjustment process. As Williams notes, “Bryan had failed clearly to create a constituency among labor” (152). Recognizing this mistake, the party sought in subsequent years to respond with new initiatives.Footnote 2 This suggests more of an ongoing process of presenting the Democratic Party to non-southern voters than the critical realignment perspective presumes.
Research over the last decade has cast doubt on the realignment perspective, which only two decades ago seemed a settled model for tracing American electoral change. This book does not adequately account for the extent and force of these criticisms, but that does not diminish its value. It is a well-written, well-organized, and engaging review of a campaign that presented a debate about fundamental issues and remains of great importance in American political history.
