Introduction
Continuing professional development (CPD) and life-long learning are now widely accepted goals of healthcare professions. Although this is perhaps more apparent in the medical profession, most other healthcare professions are in widespread agreement that in order to fulfill their professional requirements, healthcare professionals need to adopt a practice of life-long learning. Continuing professional development is seen as important for a number of reasons. One reason is that the continuing advances in biomedical science and technology mean that new drugs, devices, and procedures are constantly being introduced into healthcare practice, requiring ongoing acquisition of new content knowledge. A second reason for CPD is in response to the recognition that healthcare professionals do not emerge from their initial training with the skills they need for practice already fully mastered. Learning of skills, such as communication with patients, families, and other professionals, is an on-going process. In addition, as clinicians take on more senior roles, they also need to acquire leadership and management skills that were not relevant earlier in their careers.
This emphasis on continuing development of clinical skills and knowledge competence is necessary to equip clinicians to practice effectively in their evolving environment. However, we argue for due attention to continuing development in ethical competence for healthcare professionals. Moreover, we suggest that “ethical mindfulness” is the most appropriate objective for professional ethics education in healthcare and present a personal narrative approach as one way of achieving this.
We begin by sketching the current landscape of CPD for healthcare professionals and claim that the current lack of emphasis on ethics is problematic in a number of ways. We suggest that the goals of CPD in themselves imply that ethics ought to be included in the scope of CPD. We then go on to argue that the most appropriate objective for ethics professional development specifically is to facilitate practitioners becoming “ethically mindful,” that is, being sensitized to, and engaged with, the ethically important moments that arise in everyday practice. We suggest that existing approaches to ethics teaching, such as role modeling and analysis of cases using principles, are inadequate as methods for enabling practitioners’ acquisition of ethical mindfulness. As an alternative, we outline a personal narrative approach that facilitates ethical mindfulness. We have used this approach successfully with healthcare professionals in professional graduate education and suggest it may be useful in a CPD context.
Including Ethics in CPD
The recognition that ongoing learning is essential to good healthcare practice is increasingly widespread.Footnote 1 In the United Kingdom, Europe, North America, and Australia, some type of formal CPD following graduation is either compulsory or a strongly held expectation within the majority of healthcare professions. For example, recent legislation in Australia gives registration boards the power to require CPD as a condition of renewing registration across 12 healthcare professions including medicine, nursing, physiotherapy, psychology, pharmacy, and optometry.Footnote 2 The rationale for the rise of CPD is maintaining competence and improving patient care in the constantly changing healthcare environment and the need for individuals to continue to develop as their experience and responsibilities increase.Footnote 3 This is particularly important considering the limited knowledge and skills that can be acquired in the course of initial training and the challenges of applying theoretical knowledge in the practical context. The Australian Association of Social Work is typical in its position that CPD helps “to ensure that social workers maintain up to date knowledge and skills as the foundation for professional endeavour in all fields of practice.”Footnote 4
The emphasis of CPD in healthcare has been on the development of increasing competence in clinical skills and knowledge. It is curious that ethical competence has been largely omitted from CPD in healthcare. In formal Australian CPD frameworks, ethics is largely absent; see, for example, the Australian Association of Social Workers, the Australian Nursing Federation, and the Royal Australian College of General Practitioners.Footnote 5 There are, of course, exceptions to this trend. Australian doctors in their early postgraduate years, for example, have “ethical practice” as a compulsory element of their CPD framework,Footnote 6 but this is far from standard across healthcare professions and training levels.
The lack of an ethics element is problematic in the context of the overall justification for CPD outlined above. Ethical skills relate directly to the various aspects of the rationale. The set of ethics skills necessary to good healthcare practice changes as technology develops and the practitioner increases in seniority. Different kinds of healthcare scenarios will inevitably be encountered. Similarly, only limited ethics skills can be attained in initial training, and a new range of challenges confronts the practitioner in applying these skills in his or her working context after graduation. The inclusion of ethics as an essential part of healthcare professionals’ initial training indicates the widespread view that ethics is important to healthcare practice. This acknowledgment of the role of ethics, together with the rationale for CPD, suggests that ethics ought to be a component of healthcare professionals’ ongoing learning.
“Ethical Mindfulness” as the Appropriate Aim of Ethics CPD
If it is accepted that ethics should be a necessary component of CPD in healthcare, then it is important to consider what would constitute appropriate ethics content and what would be the most effective and relevant educational strategies to use to deliver it. Within undergraduate healthcare education there is on-going debate over what the appropriate aims of ethics teaching are, whether they are achievable, and what teaching methods best promote them. We propose that CPD ethics training for healthcare professionals should be based in clinical practice and, moreover, focus on the everyday ethical issues that arise in healthcare practice. Too often in healthcare, significance is granted to the “life and death” ethical issues, without sufficient regard to the everyday ethical concerns that suffuse healthcare (and other professional) practice. We argue that even though these “moments” are marked by their everydayness, they are nonetheless ethically significant. It is often these moments of ethical doubt or questioning that keep clinicians awake at night or continue to trouble them long after the actual experience or event in question. This is not evidence of a failure to cope with the stresses of clinical practice, but rather an intuitive recognition of the ethical importance of such moments. In terms of adult learning philosophies, this is the right place to begin CPD ethics education, at the place where the learners are currently situated. It is also the best place in ethical terms, as the skills for dealing with everyday ethical issues need to be in place before clinicians can successfully deal with major life and death issues.
Given all this, we suggest that “ethical mindfulness” is the appropriate objective for ethics education with practicing healthcare professionals. We have outlined the concept of “ethical mindfulness” in detail elsewhere.Footnote 7 In summary, ethical mindfulness is a disposition or way of being, characterized by a number of key features. First, it involves being sensitized to ethically important moments in everyday practice and, second, acknowledging these as significant. It is important to develop an awareness of ethically important moments and, when they occur, to recognize their ethical potential. The third feature involves being able to articulate what is ethically at stake in the given situation, and the fourth feature requires those involved to be reflexive and acknowledge their various standpoints and the inherent limitations of these. The final feature is to be courageous, in the sense of opening one's beliefs and practice to potential critique. Acknowledging agency as a healthcare professional and facing up to ethical problems in one's work is not an easy task, and the difficulty in doing so should not be underestimated.
Ethical mindfulness aligns with CPD's aim of enabling good practice in the changing and challenging healthcare environment. Generally, the focus of CPD is on development of knowledge and skills and, to a lesser extent, attitudes. We suggest that ethical mindfulness encompasses knowledge, skills, and attitudes, but, importantly, there is an added element, a dispositional way of being that can be implemented in an ongoing way. Although amorphous in nature, it is this way of being that makes this concept useful in practice. It is more than learning principles or rules; learning the concepts is relatively easy and can be achieved by junior students. What matters is to be able to act in accordance with general ethical principles in practice. Ethical mindfulness enables the clinician to bridge the theory–practice gap.
Role Modeling
Taking ethical mindfulness as the appropriate goal of ethics education in CPD, the next question is how to best facilitate practitioners becoming ethically mindful. It could perhaps be argued that clinicians develop ethical mindfulness through role modeling processes in their workplaces, making the inclusion of ethics training in formal CPD unnecessary. The transfer of knowledge and competence from master to apprentice via a process of close observation and practice has long been used to teach both clinical skills and professional behavior, including ethics. This mode of ethics teaching relies on the Aristotelian notion of phronesis, or practical wisdom or judgment. As FrankFootnote 8 explains, phronesis is about knowing from experience and repeated practice what you ought to do. It is not about relying on a universal set of principles or predetermined scripts when faced with an ethical problem, but rather about using the wisdom gained through repeated acts of trial and error to know how to act ethically.
However, we suggest that role modeling as a way of promoting ethical mindfulness has significant drawbacks. Its results depend very much on the clinical staff who are the role models; these role models will not all have the same understanding of ethics or attach the same importance to it. Learners see both good and bad practice and have to make their own judgment about which is which, often with little explicit guidance. Less experienced practitioners typically have very little help in the process of interpreting and evaluating what their role models do and say. Also, learners see a lot of practice that they do not necessarily think about in ethical terms and may copy without ever realizing its ethical significance. As a systematic way of promoting ethical mindfulness among clinicians, role modeling is highly problematic.
Case Studies and Principles
Acknowledging that some formalized ethics CPD is necessary in light of the problems with role modeling, it could be argued that the teaching approach that is standard in much undergraduate teaching, analyzing cases using ethical principles, would be appropriate for teaching ethical mindfulness at the level of CPD. A key feature in most formal health ethics teaching is the use of the midlevel principles of autonomy, nonmaleficence, beneficence, and justice as the basis for ethical decisionmaking.Footnote 9 To ensure that these principles are not divorced from the specificities of the clinical settings in which they are to be applied, case studies are often employed to teach these ethical principles. The case study usually acts as a tool with which to illustrate an ethical principle or to elicit the development of ethical reflection and reasoning. In the literature on teaching ethics there is considerable discussion about the preferred method of using case studies. The conventional use of case studies in teaching ethics involves identifying the key ethical issue(s), listing the options deemed most relevant and applicable to reach a solution, and using the tools of philosophical argument to explicate the ethical pros and cons of each option, thus reaching a preferred action.Footnote 10 Not confined to teaching medical students, the extensive use of case studies in ethics teaching encompasses a number of healthcare disciplines at undergraduate and postgraduate levels, as well as at the level of professional ethics training. There are numerous examples of the use of case studies in ethics teaching, including the European Biomedical Ethics Practitioner Education Project (EBEPE), which has produced case study materials for healthcare ethics education,Footnote 11 as well as examples in nursing educationFootnote 12 and gerontology and geriatrics.Footnote 13
It might seem that using more complex cases and encouraging a more nuanced analysis than is typical at the undergraduate level would be an effective way of educating health professionals to become ethically mindful. However, analyzing cases using principles, no matter how well it is done, fails as a way of promoting ethical mindfulness because of the gap between ethical reasoning in the classroom and actual ethical practice. A practitioner can be skilled in the former while still lacking the perspective necessary for the latter. Ethical practice requires the ability both to recognize everyday ethical issues in one's work and to implement one's ethical decisions under the inevitable organizational constraints and cultural pressures to conform. Neither of these abilities is promoted by simply developing critical reasoning skills. Focusing exclusively on learning and applying principles is not an effective way of sensitizing practitioners to ethically important moments or of encouraging courageous reflection about their own standpoint and agency. In the next section, we outline an alternative approach, a narrative approach, that we suggest can better promote ethical mindfulness among healthcare professionals.
Use of Narratives in Ethics Education
Narratives have been employed in ethics education in the healthcare professions since the early 1970s. Although we note the distinctions made in structural linguistics between “story” and “narrative,” we follow the lead of many others in this field and use these two terms interchangeably. This narrative trend in health ethics education has taken two main forms; first is the use of literary texts and second is the use of personal narratives. The use of literary texts has been most pronounced in medical education where it is often referred to as “medical humanities” or “narrative medicine.” However, literary texts have been used in other healthcare education, most notably in nursing.Footnote 14 The type of literature used in the teaching of ethics has included fictional works, medical autobiographies, drama, film, and poetry. Charon,Footnote 15 writing about narrative medicine in the United States, points to the widespread growth in the use of literature in medical education. Literature in medical education was first introduced in U.S. medical schools in the early 1970s, and the field has continued to flourish.Footnote 16 There are now dedicated journals and websites in addition to specialist sections in professional ethics and healthcare organizations devoted to narrative medicine; for example, the journals Literature and Medicine, based in the United States, and Medical Humanities, based in the United Kingdom, are devoted to scholarly publications on literature and medicine and healthcare more broadly. The Society for Health and Human Values, now a section of the American Society of Bioethics, became the foundation for many endeavors in narrative medicine in the United States.
What constitutes “good” literature in narrative medicine, and whether it is actually readable by those from a wide range of cultural and language backgrounds, is a critique often aimed at narrative medicine.Footnote 17 On the other hand, there are considerable and expanding resources available to teach ethics using literature to healthcare practitioners. These include anthologies, journals, bibliographies, and electronic databases and websites.Footnote 18 In addition, there has been considerable discussion regarding the most appropriate and effective methods to teach ethics using literary texts in healthcare. Numerous approaches have been proposed to enable readers to gain both critical narrative competence and develop ethical empathy.Footnote 19 These approaches have also been combined in innovative ways as a means of both teaching ethics content and introducing readers to narrative approaches.
Using Personal Narratives in Ethics Education
One facet of using narratives in ethics education is the use of personal narratives. In some ways, personal narratives can be seen as an extension of the use of literary texts, in the sense that both employ written texts in which ethics is embedded. However, we see them as different in significant aspects. In particular, the point we emphasize is the value of also writing personal narratives, rather than reading narratives written by others. This is a relatively new area in healthcare education where practitioners and patients, sometimes together, write personal narratives about their healthcare experiences.
These personal narratives come in a variety of forms. Charon explores different genres of narrative writing in medicine; these include medical fiction, lay expositions, medical autobiographies, medical practice stories, and writing exercises in medical training.Footnote 20 Charon suggests that each of these categories has its own literary origins, aims, strategies, and intended outcomes, as well as having particular ethical considerations, especially in terms of confidentiality and privacy.Footnote 21 Medical fiction comprises fictional works often written by medical practitioners, based on their doctoring experiences but fictionalized to express literary aesthetic qualities. Lay expositions are texts written by healthcare practitioners or patients about the personal experience of having particular medical conditions. Medical autobiographies are texts written by medical practitioners about their experiences of studying or practicing medicine; these texts include authors’ reflections on their transformations into doctors, the challenges they have met, as well as the joys of practicing medicine. Stories from practice are usually written by practitioners for other practitioners; the intended audience are therefore insiders. Finally, writing exercises in medical training include such methods as journal keeping, where reactions and feelings are noted, often as part of a process of inner dialogue and reflection. Although Charon limits her discussion to medical practitioners and students, these genres are equally applicable to other healthcare professionals.Footnote 22
The primary focus of these genres of personal narratives is the story. Here we emphasize Nelson's definition of narrative ethics where she “accords a central role to stories, not merely employing them as illustrations, examples, or ways of testing our intuitions regarding moral theories or principles, but regarding them as necessary means to some moral end.”Footnote 23 An important related underlying premise here is the claim that we are narrative selves. As Hunter says: “Human life is pervaded by narrative: we read and tell and listen to stories, we watch them unfold in art, ritual, and social life; we perform them ourselves; they give form and meaning to our daily existence.”Footnote 24 This emphasis on the narrative self and the central role of stories serves as an important foundation to our argument that the personal narratives approach offers a useful way to promote ethical mindfulness.
Using a “Personal Narrative Approach” to Promote Ethical Mindfulness
We have proposed that ethical mindfulness ought to be the goal of ethics education in the CPD context; now we suggest that the personal narrative approach is useful in achieving this goal. In this section, we identify the key features of the personal narrative approach as we have used it in practice and show how the personal narrative approach can promote ethical mindfulness. We have successfully used the personal narrative approach in practice in both individual and small group contexts, working with health practitioners from a range of disciplines and levels of clinical experience. Our account is based on these teaching experiences.
Although the narrative as an end-product has value, in the personal narrative approach we attribute equal significance to the processes of storytelling and engagement with the narratives. We argue that it is in telling and engaging with personal narratives that ethical learning occurs. The process of storytelling here is not just about telling a story for the sake of it, but rather its aim is to explore the meaning of the experiences and to enable a process of ethical reflection. Likewise, engagement with a narrative written or told by another person promotes ethical reflection. Here we discuss the value of the approach for both storytellers and for those who engage with the story.
Self-Reflective Questions for Storytellers
In the personal narrative approach, the narratives written by practitioners are personal ones, rather than fictional narratives. In our teaching, practitioners are requested to write personal narratives about an ethical situation in which they were a participant. This need not be an ethical event of life-and-death proportions; in fact, participants are instructed to consider “ethically important moments” they have encountered in their everyday healthcare practice. Interestingly in our experience we have found that although some participants write of recent events, they more commonly write of events from many years ago. These are events that have continued to trouble them and persisted in making them feel unsettled. Whatever event is chosen, a crucial feature of the personal narrative approach is that the narratives are written or told in the first person, rather than in the objective and detached passive voice that is the hallmark of clinical case presentations. The use of the first person requires storytellers to immerse themselves in the story, to own it for themselves as their story. This also tends to elicit a similar response from the audience as they become caught up in the story and hence facilitates a process of engagement with the narrative and ethical reflection by others. However, ethical reflection does not necessarily occur spontaneously, nor is it intuitively obvious how to do it. To enable and facilitate ethical reflection, we have formulated a set of questions to guide storytellers in the process of ethical reflection. Following their writing of the story, storytellers are encouraged to ask themselves:
• Why have I chosen to tell this story?
• How did I decide how to frame this story? How did I decide where to start and end this story? How did I decide on who and what are included or excluded in the story?
• How have I cast myself and the other characters in the story?
• What are the key “ethically important moments” in the story?
• What is ethically at stake here, and for whom?
• How has the process of writing this story prompted me to think differently of the event or experience?
The aim of these self-reflective questions is to prompt and guide a process of ethical reflection. It is through this process of self-reflection that we suggest storytellers can move toward the goal of ethical mindfulness. Too often the focus is on the story as product; these self-reflective questions aid in redressing the balance to also address the processes of storytelling. These questions serve to highlight the narrative aspects of storytelling while at the same time focusing attention on what is ethically at stake in the story. Significantly, the final question draws attention to how writing the story may potentially lead to a different perspective or interpretation of the event.
Interpretative Trigger Questions for Listeners or Readers of Stories
We also emphasize a focus on the processes of engagement of listeners or readers of stories. We have suggested a number of interpretative trigger questions to assist in this process of ethical engagement, which are discussed and illustrated in more detail elsewhere.Footnote 25 These interpretative trigger questions are adapted from NelsonFootnote 26 and are classified as naming, sideways, and forward-looking questions.
• What are the key ethical elements in the story?
• How do they relate to one another?
Naming questions
• How has the story been cast? What is the narrative frame, time, and plot?
• What are the turning points in the story where things could have gone differently?
• Does the story work toward a particular ending, or is it an open unfolding? Is the ending expected?
• How has the narrator cast him- or herself and the other characters? Why is the narrator telling the story in this particular way?
• What are the key “ethically important moments” in the story?
• What is ethically at stake here, and for whom?
• What has been left out of the narrative? Whose voice is not being heard?
• What other possible versions of the story does this story resist or oppose?
Sideways-looking questions
• What does this story tell us that would not otherwise be heard?
• How can engaging with this story lead to greater ethical mindfulness in healthcare practice?
Forward-looking questions
These questions serve as interpretative triggers, rather than as a set of rigid questions that need to be considered in a particular order or in a fixed way. Not all questions will necessarily be useful for all narratives. What is important here is for those engaging with the narratives to be open to what is prompted by these questions.
It is important to note that we are not suggesting that there is a right or wrong reading of a story or that either the self-reflective questions or the interpretative trigger questions should be used in an evaluative sense. This is in sharp contrast to other methods proposed, such as Carson’s, where students’ stories are used as a base for teaching ethics.Footnote 27 In Carson's approach, students are asked to reflect and write about a professional situation where they faced an ethical dilemma or conflict. Each student reads his or her story to the group and the group discusses the issues raised in the story. Each student is then asked to write about the same situation but this time from the perspective of the person with whom he or she had the conflict. The aim is then to try and validate one or both accounts by searching the relevant theoretical and empirical literature. Students are then asked to judge “which of the two stories is the better choice and the more real?”Footnote 28 We do not accept the notion that one version of a story is more “real” or more “true” than another version, and we are not looking for participants to tell the definitive or genuine version of their stories. Rather, the underlying premise of our approach is that valuable insights into ethical values, personal motivations, and worldviews and assumptions about meaning and significance are revealed in the way that people frame stories of their own experiences. Once revealed, these form the basis for reflection and questioning, out of which practical ethical awareness, learning, and skills arise.
How the Personal Narrative Approach Promotes Ethical Mindfulness within CPD
The framework of CPD has primarily centered on continuing development of professional knowledge and skills and, to some extent, attitudes. The triad of knowledge, skills, and attitudes is a well-known organizing schema within healthcare education, particularly at the undergraduate level. We have argued for greater focus on ethics within the CPD setting, not just for increasing knowledge, skills, and appropriate attitudes, but, moreover, as a way of promoting a dispositional way of being. We are advocating for an emphasis on ethical practice that results in not just a higher level of knowledge and skills but also a reflexive approach where there is ethical awareness and sensitivity and self-insight into what it means to be an ethical practitioner. We believe that ethical mindfulness can provide knowledge, skills, and attitudes and, in addition, this novel yet slippery notion of ethical insight that translates into practice.
Earlier, we discussed five features of ethical mindfulness: being sensitized to ethically important moments, acknowledging these as significant, articulating what is ethically at stake, being reflexive and having the courage to be open to critique, and self-questioning. Of these, we suggest that the personal narrative approach is particularly useful in promoting reflexivity. It does this in two ways: first, through the discipline of storytelling and, second, through the process of engaging with the story. Underpinning the personal narrative approach is the “discipline of storytelling,” which refers to the intellectual work that goes into producing a narrative. It is a reflexive engagement that requires the narrator to recall, reflect, organize, and write. Asking healthcare practitioners to write about an issue of ethical importance involves a process of situating themselves in the narrative and taking ownership of the story. Writing yourself into the story and using the first person avoids the urge to distance yourself and put on the mantle of the objective observer. Healthcare practitioners are taught from their early formative years to be objective and detached. Using the personal narrative approach requires unlearning this, a process that many find difficult. Reflecting on the process of storytelling and using the self-reflective questions encourages reflexivity; it encourages storytellers to see how they have shaped the narrative and to be aware that it could have been told differently. It also encourages a questioning as to why the people and the events in the story have been portrayed in this way and leads to an awareness of unarticulated values and a possible reconsidering of assumptions. The process of telling one's own story and then reflecting on it is one of the ways in which the personal narrative approach encourages ethical mindfulness.
Ethical mindfulness is also promoted, though in somewhat different ways, by the employment of the interpretative trigger questions to reflect on narratives written or told by others. In particular, the sideways-looking questions promote a process of self-questioning and reflexive positioning. This encourages examining a particular situation from different perspectives and questioning what may have been a primary instinctive response. Posing the naming questions and articulating what is ethically at stake requires a building on of prior knowledge of ethical principles and adds a clinical component and reflection. The naming questions require review and reflection on the ethical principles relevant to this situation, but also require being able to identify what these principles are within a complex clinical setting. The forward-looking questions require the courage of self-questioning and opening oneself to critique. As a narrator, asking how I have cast myself in the story requires a considerable degree of introspection and, in some cases, courage to be open to matters that may be easier left unexamined. Furthermore, asking how it could have been otherwise can be challenging both in terms of reflexive positioning but also in informing future ethical practice. Being sensitized to ethically important moments and acknowledging these as significant is a process that occurs through ongoing engagement with one's own narratives as well as the narratives of others.
Conclusion
The inclusion of ethics in CPD in healthcare is paramount. We argue that ethical mindfulness is an appropriate and achievable goal for ethics in CPD. For healthcare practitioners who have been exposed to clinical practice and are undertaking CPD, it is important to use an approach that is grounded in clinical experience. It is here that ethical problems will arise, mostly as everyday ethically important moments; this serves as an obvious substrate for learning. The personal narrative approach offers an innovative and useful way that requires reflection and critical engagement. The approach incorporates furthering previous learning of ethics knowledge, developing skills of narration, analysis, and reflection, and, importantly, ethical engagement, while at the same time developing a dispositional way of being that will transcend the immediate situation into future clinical practice. Using the personal narrative approach to develop ethical mindfulness offers flexibility; it can be adapted to differing ethical situations in various settings; it is applicable to different healthcare professions at different levels of seniority; and, in addition, it can be used in interprofessional settings, for both individuals and groups. The personal narrative approach does not rely on the ethics expert or role model; rather it uses narratives that are personally meaningful as a basis for ethical learning that promotes continuous reflection and reflexivity.
One of the major challenges of the personal narrative approach is whether it can be employed in the busy world of healthcare practice. For the approach to be effective and meaningful, it requires time for storytelling and reflection. Anyone who works in healthcare knows that time is scarce. It is not the kind of approach that can be squeezed in between patient consultations or procedures. The discipline of storytelling does require time, as does ethical engagement with a narrative. However, as we have found from our experience in graduate education, the time devoted to the personal narrative approach is personally enriching and, importantly, leads to a sense of ethical mindfulness that continues to be useful beyond the immediate engagement with the narrative. CPD is about life-long learning; it is about continuous development of knowledge, skills, and attitudes. Ethical mindfulness not only integrates knowledge, skills, and attitudes, but it adds value to these. With the appropriate time commitment and personal investment, it offers the potential of furthering ethical healthcare practice.
