As other reviewers suggest, Deirdre McCloskey reads everything, seems to remember everything, and has opinions on everything. She is disarmingly combative, fearless in writing, mixing colloquial expression with academic patois and constantly challenging the reader to keep up with her arguments and reflections, which are amazingly varied. Trained in economics, she refuses to let specialization stop her and races headlong from history to ethics to literature. In short—can there be an “in short” to a long, breathtaking, and exhausting book?—reading her is no less than a liberal education unto itself.
The inner circuity of the argument is sometimes hard to follow, but the essential point is adamant. Throughout western history, especially since the rise and spread of modern capitalism, the bourgeoisie and the market ethic have been assaulted from the left and the right of the political spectrum, particularly by “clerisy.” McCloskey loosely employs the poet Coleridge's term for intellectuals because it was specifically designed for use in industrial and urban settings. Some members of the clerisy were wont to see special moral and cultural qualities in rural life to the point of romanticizing it. Others continually deplored the passing of the landed aristocracy, who, in Mathew Arnold's phrase, had sweetness but not light. Still others, such as Karl Marx, denounced the “idiocy” of rural life, identified with a proletariat of which they had no direct knowledge and advocated an industrial base but also the ultimate destruction of the very classes that had created it. McCloskey may have been a fellow traveler in her earliest years—so she says, believing somewhat in socialist or etatist remedies and perhaps, because she is a pragmatist and accepts the notion of fallen men and women, retaining a mild interest in their current possibilities, but her heart and her soul are with the bourgeoisie, with private initiative and market discipline. She explains why the burghers have received a bad press. She takes on all detractors, exposes their prejudices with bell, book, and fact and points out that the much-maligned middle layers of society have been more responsive to Aristotle's call for the Good Life than any other social group. But so steady and clamorous have been the critics, with clergy denouncing greed, workers charging exploitation, and the clerisy gleefully finding fatal “contradictions,” that members of the bourgeoisie have often reacted like minority groups who blame themselves for any hostility towards them. “American Babbitts save for their children's college education on an impressive scale, educations in which the children are taught to despise the values of their parents” (p. 148).
Who in fact were the members of the clerisy—the “nonaristocratic, cryptopeasant … antibourgeois theorists”—if not the bourgeoisie? In the nineteenth century they “dreamed up” the “failed experiments” of the twentieth (p. 52). Yet who made cities, the amenities and excitement of cities? Who founded and endowed colleges and universities, gave away fortunes to support the arts and excelled at philanthropy? Did the robber barons really “rob,” as Progressive Era American critics charged, or were they simply good deal makers, no more or less sinful than anyone else? Incapable of loving or caring? Nonsense. Fearsomely competitive? That is not particularly bourgeois. Against cooperation? On the contrary. Insensitive to poverty and distress? Sometimes, but not as a rule. Contradictory behavior? Yes, certainly. To be human is to contradict oneself. Vulgar and sordid, supporters of low culture? That is hardly the whole story nor is it enlightening. Neither aristocrats nor peasants are paragons. Guilt-ridden? Well, who is not and so what? McCloskey is not the first to put the positive case; but she does it with such encyclopedic knowledge that disagreeing with her, not impossible, is nevertheless unremitting labor.
“Bourgeois” is a huge category, from “sweating assistant managers to glittering CEOs” (p. 74). But also shop owners and professional men and women, and in some historical instances, yeoman farmers. The common element is the honor of work, which, according to the author, is elevated to the level of a calling. Until the modern era and the dominance of the bourgeoisie and capitalist enterprise as a widespread undertaking, work was considered inferior to fighting and praying. Women and slaves worked, and men sat around and tried to be gentlemen (defined in Augustan England as possessing no visible means of livelihood). Work was not just for getting and spending but more importantly to advance conceptions of a life worth living. And without getting, which entails work, it would be impossible to give or to engage the world, to care about it, to improve it or take care of it. There is more: for without the sustained and systematic effort that we understand by work there can be no creative impulse and no incentive to innovate. These are ambitions that lie at the core of current conceptions of modern society and its survival and separate it from regions of the world where tribalism and feudalism prevail. “Economies grow slowly—or not at all,” McCloskey offers, “when stealing or taxing become simpler ways to wealth than working and selling” (p. 479). Vide the history of Russia. Without work, something meaningful to do in life, there can be no expectations, no future, no hope.
Such thoughts, only roughly intimated in this brief review, are worked out in a series of occasionally abstruse, overly long, and also repetitive discussions of the “bourgeois virtues” of the book's title. This is always an exhilarating but also a wordy book, with numerous mannerisms, side excursions, and self-conscious auto-biographical parentheses. These can be annoying, depending upon the mood of the reader. McCloskey takes on personal friends and teachers and engages in numerous exchanges with authors living and dead. She does so mainly with respect, however. To her great credit neither her jibes nor her wit are insulting, a rather refreshing approach at a time when academic polemics are often disagreeable.
The bourgeois virtues, “nonfungible” because all are necessary (p. 357), are hope, faith, love, justice, courage, temperance, prudence: three Christian and four pagan virtues with lengthy religious, philosophical, and ethical histories and treated by the author within the historical contexts of economic behavior writ large. She maintains that the system of virtues in place for something like two millennia were generally abandoned by the end of the Enlightenment. Machiavelli, Francis Bacon, Hobbes, and Bernard Mandeville chipped away at the system, and Kant and Bentham polished off whatever remained. Such thinkers objected to the past religious and political systems that often incorporated the virtues, and the long-term result was the erection of new virtues, the modern ideologies and social theories inimical not only to the old virtues but to private and market-relevant conduct.
The logic of her arguments is not predictable. So it is another of the qualities of her bold and searching intellect that she works through received conceptions entirely on her own, giving them new twists and turns and pulling all of them together to form a portrait, realistically flawed, of the character of bourgeois life. She calls this “preaching,” admits to advocacy but loses no credibility by it because of the wealth of learning she summons up.
The “hero” of the book is Adam Smith, who understood (created?) the system of bourgeois ethics that did not survive him intact. But as her final challenge, McCloskey preaches “a libertarian version of Aristotelianism,” or “a capitalist version of Pelagianism” or “an anti-Tillichian theological humanism with a dose of economics” (p. 497). This is not a summary of the book but a sample of the terrain needing to be crossed.
