The title of this paper is intended to act as a reminder of the epochal work of Hartog and Rhodes, An Examination of Examinations and An Examination of Examiners, first published in 1935. It will be worth while to refer to some of the details. They took several essay answers to examination questions, typed them out and handed them out for marking to a number of examiners. The wide range of marks sometimes given to the same answer was astonishing; from distinction to failure. Six months later they gave the same answer to the same examiners and asked them to mark them. The discrepancies between the marks given on the two occasions by the same examiner were equally large and equally astonishing. In one part of their investigations they had written out a model essay to provide the examiners with a standard; by accident, this essay was included with all the others and was marked by the examiners in the same way and with the same results. This work may be regarded as being a watershed in the history of the technique of examinations, but its significance has penetrated very little into the consciousness of the academic world. As for medical examinations, it was only when Hartog and Rhodes’s work was repeated and their findings rediscovered after World War II that they began to have any influence.