With the beginning of explicitly theoretical approaches to Roman archaeology in the mid-1990s, concepts of identity quickly became instrumental to models of social change that occurred in the wake of Rome's expansion. While this provided a timely response to historical frameworks based on Romanisation, critical voices rightly pointed out that archaeologists were frequently indiscriminate in their use of ‘identities’, thus failing to define how they could contribute to the understanding of cultural processes in the past (see especially M. Pitts, AJA 111 (2007), 693–713). In Ways of Being Roman, Louise Revell judiciously pre-empts such criticisms, offering from the outset a clear definition of how, in her view, different discourses of identity may appear to the archaeologist in the material record of the Western provinces.
Following the review of existing literature on identity in Roman archaeology (1–18), R. structures her main discussion in three pairs of chapters, each of which deals with closely related aspects of identity. These are: Roman ethnicity and poly-ethnicity (19–40, 41–60); provincial elites and non-elites (61–82, 83–104); gender and age (105–26, 127–46); followed by a brief set of conclusions (147–51). In her discussion of specific evidence, R. draws exclusively on previously published material. This is commendable for the most part, not least because the reader is familiar with many of her case studies. In this way, the flow of what is a relatively complex theoretical model is not interrupted by lengthy descriptions. However, greater attention to detail may have been desirable in some places (see below).
The main point of R.’s argument is that ‘identity is both internalised and communicated through the actions of daily living’ (147). It is as evidence for those actions that R. approaches the archaeological record, although it is worth noting that she primarily focuses on architectural remains and Latin inscriptions. Only in a few places — notably her sophisticated interpretation of the Snettisham jeweller's (or, as it turns out, jewellers’) hoard as evidence for non-elite identity (90–2) — does R. engage in detail with other parts of the material record. Surprisingly little space is given to pottery; where R. does discuss ceramic evidence, it tends to be disappointing. For instance, R.’s comparison of Malvern ware and the manufacture at La Graufesenque (94–6) is superficial; and although David Peacock's ethnographic approach to Roman pottery production remains significant within a circumscribed field of study (D. Peacock, Pottery in the Roman World (1982)), it surprises that R. does not refer to essential contributions made in this area more recently. The potential relevance of ethno-archaeological models to R.’s line of inquiry should be singled out here, to which this reviewer has himself drawn attention (e.g., R. Roth, Styling Romanisation (2007), especially 65–102, with exhaustive references) but which the author does not cite.
R.’s practice-based approach to identity in the Roman provinces is not strictly speaking new; yet her achievement in this book is not only to present it in a readable manner but also to tie it into her account of the evidence. Each case study is woven into the theoretically led discussion, and the reader is nowhere at risk of missing the significance of R.’s examples to her overarching argument. It reads well.
Yet this readability comes at a cost. R.’s selection of material culture is not always representative of the record. Following her rather acerbic critique of approaches to Roman culture by ancient historians (1–18), the reader may furthermore be struck by the fact that much of R.’s argument draws on the evidence of inscriptions. However, the author does not provide any translations, let alone transcriptions of the epigraphic evidence. Her apposite comments in relation to the unusual epigraphic habit observed in Britannia notwithstanding (61–82), it is surprising to see a virtual disregard for the substance of the inscriptions on which the author's main argument essentially rests. And although R. asserts that inscriptions are part of Roman material culture — which few historians would now deny — her treatment does not really offer any attempt to appreciate epigraphy in its monumental contexts. In this respect, it is telling that anyone looking for a more in-depth engagement with the pioneering works by Werner Eck in R.’s account would be disappointed.
Peculiar, too, is the fact that — in a work so ostensibly opposed to the study of history through literary sources — R.’s portrayal of Roman elite and non-elite society is based on a very small selection of historical literature that furthermore relates mostly to the Late Republic (especially 61–104). A similar shortcoming is R.’s decision not to discuss the funerary monuments from Neumagen, which represent one of the most complete datasets of provincial iconography in the Western Empire. While she does discuss the Igel-Säule in a rather peremptory fashion — despite R.’s assertions (118–20), this monument represents a very different type of iconography to that found in the Neumagen cemetery — the author regrettably does not engage with the very specific themes of Gallo-Roman iconography for which there is unique evidence in the Moselle region. Again, one might suspect that linguistic predilections were the deciding factor here — although R. is not really concerned with iconology throughout the volume. Yet this should surely be a principal factor in the study of Roman material culture.
To conclude: Ways of Being Roman is a good read. To the present reviewer, it comes across as a cap-stone to the fruitful and exciting debate that was had in the early Theoretical Roman Archaeological Conferences (TRAC). R.’s command of the theory is to be commended, as is her ability to introduce the middle range between the latter and the data. On this basis alone, the book should be required reading for those interested in the culture of the Western provinces. Yet R.’s study also exhibits a serious flaw, and this primarily relates to how she engages with that very dataset. Despite its many merits, Ways of Being Roman also tells the story of an opportunity missed by not taking some important thoughts further, of an express disregard for the Latin (or good translations) — while heavily relying on textual evidence — and of a general sense that this promising endeavour would have resulted in a much better book with another two years of research and writing behind it. Far from the author's fault, however, this may be a sign of our times.
