The idea of building bridges is not necessarily novel when speaking of political and social interactions. Human beings have always built bridges to keep communities together, communicate with one another, build the common good, engage in business transactions, keep good neighborly relationships, help one another, and even deal with tensions.
What makes a bridge interesting, however, is not the bridge itself or the justification of its existence, as exciting as these are, but the sides that it connects, the context in which it is built, and the effects of the relationships it creates. This is what makes Building Bridges, Not Walls: Nourishing Diverse Cultures in Faith a very interesting study. John Francis Burke offers a compelling vision to assess relationships in the context of US Catholicism, an experience marked by profound expressions of cultural, ethnic, racial, and linguistic diversity.
To understand this work, it is worth taking a brief detour to explore Burke's earlier work Mestizo Democracy: The Politics of Crossing Borders (Texas A&M Press, 2002). In that work, Burke engaged the concept of mestizaje, racial and cultural hybridity, and interpreted it in conversation with the works of US Latino theologians such as Virgilio Elizondo and Roberto Goizueta. He took a rather complex category often used among cultural theorists, theologians, philosophers, and artists, and mined its potential for political theory. Burke did not hesitate to name the immediate context from which he was speaking, namely, his experience as a white, Euro-American Roman Catholic who had crossed borders as a minister and political scientist to work more closely with US Latinos. In the process of crossing cultural, linguistic, and political borders, he was transformed. He saw the potential of that experience for a much wider conversation in the larger US society.
A decade and an half later, Burke returns to his project, this time with a more refined focus: Catholic parishes serving several racial, ethnic, and linguistic groups. These communities are known as “shared parishes” or “multicultural parishes.” Why choose these particular faith communities to advance an argument about bridging diverse communities when one could have studied, say, urban dynamics, national politics, or community organizing efforts among ethnically and racially diverse groups? There is something particular about US Catholicism at this time in history. Catholics constitute the largest church in the United States (about 24 percent of the entire population). About 40 percent of all 17,300-plus Catholic parishes in the country are communities serving more than one language and ethnic/racial group. The largest group transforming the US Catholic experience, namely Latinos, is mostly bilingual and bicultural. In many ways, multicultural Catholic parishes are microcosms of entire neighborhoods through the US geography, especially in urban settings. The more one learns about how these communities interact, the more one can envision practices, commitments, and even policies that shape the lives of people in the midst of diversity.
In chapter 1, Burke begins his analysis by pointing to the transnational nature of Christianity throughout the centuries. Christians have moved across nations and cultures sharing their faith convictions and building communities. This process of cross-pollination demands sharing and embracing cultural practices and convictions. In some cases, entire cultures have been transplanted and imposed. In others, some negotiation takes place, leading to hybrid practices after many decades of negotiation. Catholicism in the United States has always been an immigrant religion. Previous waves of Catholic immigrants from Europe have settled and are now mainstream. A new wave of immigrants, largely from Latin America and Asia, and their children are challenging the status quo of the Euro-American, white Catholic body. While the European Catholics built their own parishes, the current wave does not always have to do that since many of these communities already exist. Consequently, Catholics from different cultural backgrounds often end up sharing the same spaces and the same resources. Burke points to the constant temptation of ethnocentrism that calls for immediate assimilation, usually into predominantly ethnic and cultural models. While the multicultural or shared parish has benefits, it also has internal tensions that cannot be easily dismissed.
Chapter 2 is what one could call a theological chapter. Here Burke asks whether it is possible to foster unity among diversity. He formulates the crux of the problem in this way: “The root of the challenge is that fellow believers often see their culture as a set of characteristics defining their identity as opposed to that of other groups” (51). Burke responds that cultures are not necessarily hermetic and finished products, and proposes the interpretive lens of a “border mentality,” a category he borrows from theologian Justo González. A border mentality acknowledges that cultures are constantly in flux and their boundaries are porous. As a result, there is always room for change and for welcoming the other. From a Christian perspective, unity in diversity is possible when believers are conscious of being a Eucharistic community called to live in communion, in relationship with God who transcends differences, and guided by the Holy Spirit that bestows gifts upon all as part of a New Pentecost. In living their vocation to communion, Catholics model for the entire world a way of being community in which diversity is not a threat but a gift.
In chapter 3 Burke takes a closer look at the Latino presence in the United States. He challenges the assumption that this group is new to the national sociocultural imaginary. He does this with the help of history. Calls for assimilation of Latinos usually assume that they just arrived as immigrants, which often leads to our treating them as intruders. Burke debunks that assumption by pointing to the long history of Latinos in the US territory, a history that began centuries before the country was born. Taking on the East-to-West assimilation paradigm, Burke calls for an acknowledgment that Latinos have been part of the social fabric of this country for centuries. Owning this is a necessary step to understanding ourselves as a diverse society.
Shifting to an exercise of cultural analysis and its implications for US Catholics, chapter 4 uses the image of the iceberg to talk about Catholicism in the United States. The tip of the iceberg reveals only the external dynamics of all the cultural communities that coexist in Catholic parishes. However, we must really understand what is below the iceberg if we are to build solid communities. Burke speaks of two movements or waves: the European-American East-to-West wave and the Latino South-to-North wave. Each wave brings its own set of values as well as limitations. Both waves slowly meet in thousands of Catholic communities. The tensions, celebrations, and transformations taking place because of this encounter are redefining US Catholicism in the twenty-first century.
The last two chapters in Burke's book gather his advice, grounded in his scholarly and ministerial experience, to build faith communities that take diversity not as a threat but as an opportunity. The first step, chapter 5, is to tear down the walls that prevent diverse communities from moving forward. Whether it be language, long-held assumptions, old practices, or simply leaders who refuse to see diversity as an opportunity, the obstacles need to be named and addressed. Then faith communities must build bridges. In chapter 6 Burke invites readers to use the safe spaces and practices that are already part of a Catholic faith tradition that honors diversity. In these communities, intercultural interaction plays a key role. Burke offers three alternatives: an advisory intercultural relations committee, a mutual obligations approach, and a mutual invitation process. No magic formulas here. Just recommendations that can bring diverse groups together, foster communication, and encourage mutual recognition for the good of the larger community.
This is a short and accessible work, yet one filled with good insights and excellent recommendations. Burke has made a very important contribution to the study of US Catholicism in the twenty-first century.
The book is one volume published in English and Spanish. This commitment to printing in two languages evokes the strong influence of English and Spanish upon US Catholicism in our day. However, I found the printing of the text in English on the right page and the equivalent translation in Spanish on the left quite distracting—perhaps because I am bilingual and could not avoid looking for the equivalent on the other page. My recommendation to the publisher for similar works in the future is to print one language first, then the other.
