Wicksell opened the door through which modern economists have escaped from the traditional classical approach that prevented any straightforward attack on the problems connected with employment and stability. (Abba Lerner Reference Lerner1940)
I. PROLOGUE: APPROACHING MACROECONOMICS
Soon after the publication of the first volume of his Lectures in 1901, Knut Wicksell started working on the volume on money and credit. Progress was slow, as Wicksell complained at the time (Gårdlund Reference Gårdlund1958, pp. 219–220). He finished writing the book in the summer of 1905 and had it published early the next year. In the preface, dated February 1906, Wicksell (Reference Wicksell1906, p. iv) stated that it was organized around the same principle he developed in his 1898 Interest and Prices: that is, the connection between the “actual money rate of interest” and the “prevailing real or natural rate on capital.” He called attention, however, to two interrelated modifications in the presentation of the argument. The first was the replacement of the “somewhat too vague and abstract” concept of the natural rate of interest by the notion of the “normal rate of interest,” defined as the rate at which “the demand for new capital is exactly covered by simultaneous saving.” This was accompanied by greater emphasis on the treatment of changes in the general price level “in terms of a simple and easily comprehensible formula of supply and demand for commodities and services” (quoted and translated by Ohlin Reference Ohlin, Wicksell and Kahn1936, p. xiii).
Wicksell’s formulation of monetary theory as the study of the relation between aggregate supply and aggregate demand—and their respective division into the supply of consumption and capital goods on one side, and income spent and saved, on the other—would play a key role in the development of the highly contested macroeconomics of the 1930s and after, in its Keynesian, Austrian, Robertsonian, and Scandinavian versions (see Laidler Reference Laidler1999). As put by Abba Lerner (Reference Lerner1940, p. 581) at the time, Wicksell’s application of the supply and demand mechanism to the economy as a whole, instead of separate industries as in partial analysis, “was novel, even if it does seem, after the event, a fairly obvious thing to try.” One of the inhibitions Wicksell had to overcome in doing that, according to Lerner, was the “impressive Walrasian system of equations which seemed to claim the whole field of general analysis as its own even though it could say nothing particularly useful.” Another obstacle was the classical Say’s law that total supply generates its own demand (ibid.).
Although Wicksell did advance (macro)economics along a path distinct in many aspects from Walrasian general equilibrium, his contributions are better understood if we take into account the Walrasian roots of his approach to the working of markets. Indeed, as pointed out by John Hicks ([1939] Reference Hicks1946, p. 2), Wicksell shared with the economists of the Lausanne school the concern with the study of a complex pattern of interrelations of markets, which informs the method of general equilibrium. Footnote 1 Hicks, together with Oskar Lange (Reference Lange, Lange, McIntyre and Yntena1942, Reference Lange1944) and Don Patinkin ([1956] Reference Patinkin1965) after him, would combine the insights of Léon Walras, Wicksell, and Vilfredo Pareto with John Maynard Keynes’s macroeconomics to develop what has been called the “neo-Walrasian” or “neoclassical synthesis” in economics (see Weintraub Reference Weintraub1979, ch. 4; Backhouse and Boianovsky Reference Backhouse and Boianovsky2013, ch. 3). One important feature of the neo-Walrasian approach, originally introduced by Wicksell and best illustrated by Hicks’s IS-LM model, was the extension of general equilibrium to a monetary economy with a small number of aggregate markets (commodities, labor, money, and bonds).
The prominent role of inflation targeting in current monetary theory and policy has brought back to the agenda some Wicksellian themes. The so-called new neoclassical synthesis is well represented by Michael Woodford (Reference Woodford2003), who refers to Wicksell and the 1930s Wicksellians as sources of inspiration. However—as discussed in detail in a symposium about Woodford’s book, published in JHET in 2006, with contributions by Kevin Hoover, David Laidler, Perry Mehrling, and Mauro Boianovsky and Hans-Michael Trautwein, together with a reply by Woodford—Woodford’s deployment of dynamic stochastic general equilibrium (DSGE) modelling, with its assumptions of complete financial markets and a representative agent, does not square easily with the old Wicksellian view of monetary dynamics (see also Boianovsky and Trautwein Reference Boianovsky, Trautwein, Bateman, Hirai and Marcuzzo2010).
Whereas Pareto departed from Walras by developing a disaggregated general equilibrium system, Wicksell further elaborated on Walras’s notion of aggregate excess market demand functions. He preferred Walras’s approach to William Jevons’s “trading body” concept—similar in many ways to the current “representative agent” idea—which was beset by restrictive aggregation conditions, such as parallel Engel curves for different consumers (Boianovsky Reference Boianovsky2013b, Reference Boianovsky2016). Wicksell’s monetary macroeconomics resulted from his attempt to improve on what he perceived as two shortcomings of Walras’s general equilibrium theory: incomplete treatment of the demand for money and its connection with the banking system and credit, and lack of a concept of capital stressing the time element in the production process. At the same time, by building on Walras’s original framework, Wicksell was influenced by the former’s notions of the tâtonnement by which markets solve the system of equations, and of the zero-profit entrepreneur in equilibrium.
During the process of elaboration of his money Lectures, Wicksell (Reference Wicksell1903, [1904] Reference Wicksell, Chamberlain and Sandelin1999) wrote two articles in which he advanced the changes mentioned above. His 1903 “Obscure Point in the Theory of Money”—regarded by Joseph Schumpeter (Reference Schumpeter1954, p. 1085n9) as “very important” for emphasizing some points that do not stand out so clearly in his books—is available in Swedish only and is seldom mentioned in the literature. The “obscure point” in need of clarification was precisely the concept of excess aggregate demand for output as a whole, called by Wicksell (Reference Wicksell1903, p. 491) “pecuniary” or “monied demand” (in English in the original) for goods. The 1904 article “Monetary Problems of the Future” was a reaction to Karl Helfferich (Reference Helfferich1903), one of the very few contemporary works on money he admired. Wicksell disagreed with Helfferich’s view—relatively common at the time—that economic booms are associated with changes in the “spirit of enterprise” brought about by increased consumption demand and prices. It was in that context that Wicksell put forward the notion that the determinant of the nominal level of activity is not consumption but excess investment, which brought in the idea of a normal rate of interest.
Wicksell ([1906] Reference Wicksell and Classen1935, p. 5; all italics in all quotations are in the original sources) explained that in the first volume of the Lectures he “did not, in principle, take any entrepreneur’s profit, strictly so-called, into consideration,” but assumed instead that it would tend to zero under free competition. That changed in the money volume, where differences between the normal and market rates of interest bring about profits and losses. The zero-profit condition was part of Wicksell’s model of the determination of the optimal size of firms in equilibrium. Entrepreneurs’ profit expectations play an important role in Wicksell’s monetary macroeconomics as determinants of the planned size and number of firms—and therefore of demand for labor—in disequilibrium. As pointed out by Terence Hutchison (Reference Hutchison1998, pp. 62–63), Wicksell distinguished between the perfect knowledge assumption of value theory and the influence of expectations on aggregate economic fluctuations of nominal and real variables in monetary theory. As the first neoclassical economist to produce textbooks on both theories of value and money, Wicksell was confronted with the problem of different methods of analysis in those two fields and how to establish connections between them (Hutchison, op. cit.). Indeed, as observed by Mark Blaug (Reference Blaug1975, p. 48), Wicksell’s monetary economics, “being the macroeconomics of the 19th century, was surprisingly conceived along microeconomic lines.” This was due to his attempt to explain the dynamics of economic aggregates by the behavior of individual agents in their roles as producers and consumers.
Besides Walras’s general equilibrium, another important source of influence was Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk’s Austrian capital theory. Wicksell ([1901] Reference Wicksell and Classen1934, p. 101) described his 1893 Value, Capital and Rent as an effort to combine Walras’s theory of exchange and Böhm-Bawerk’s capital theory into a single whole. Aggregation was also a feature of Böhm-Bawerk’s approach, this time in the domain of production instead of exchange, as illustrated by his use of what Schumpeter (Reference Schumpeter1954, pp. 998, 1030) called a “social production function.” As suggested by Schumpeter, Böhm-Bawerk’s method of “macroanalysis” followed on the steps of François Quesnay and David Ricardo, which would be also adopted by Wicksell in his formulation of marginal productivity theory. When presenting his model of the “cumulative process” of price level change in chapter IX of Interest and Prices—sometimes regarded as the first macroeconomic model ever (see, e.g., Hans Brems Reference Brems1986, ch. 8)—Wicksell assumed a purely circulating capital economy producing just one good (or a set of goods with constant relative prices). In chapter 9 (“The Positive Solution”) of part IV of volume II of his Lectures he discussed instead an economy with two groups of goods (consumption and fixed capital goods), which would become standard procedure in macroeconomics after the 1930s. Another significant difference between the two presentations of the cumulative process is the Lectures’ assumption of a saving function positively related to the market rate of interest, a function conspicuously absent from Interest and Prices. As discussed below, this reflected in part Wicksell’s ([1901] Reference Wicksell and Classen1934, pt. III) new approach to saving by an average immortal individual, the only passage in which he came any way close to the notion of a representative agent.
A careful examination of Wicksell’s economics, from the perspective of the issues raised by Walras’s general equilibrium, may shed new light on several aspects of Wicksell’s research agenda, as discussed in the following sections. The distinction between (what we now call) Walras’s law and Say’s law is a case in point. In the same vein, Wicksell’s approach to money demand and bank credit should be seen against the background of Walras’s treatment of indirect exchange (section II). From Wicksell’s standpoint, Walras’s lack of a clear distinction between saving and investment restricted the scope of general equilibrium analysis. Moreover, as pointed out by Wicksell, the debate about the working of a credit economy may be traced back to British classical economists, with their imprecise depiction of the saving-investment process (sections III and IV). Walras’s tâtonnement mechanism, deployed by Wicksell throughout his studies of the determination of relative prices and the price level, proved elusive in his attempted discussion of business cycles and involuntary unemployment, when firms are demand-constrained and wage changes are unable to equilibrate the labor market (see Boianovsky and Trautwein Reference Boianovsky and Trautwein2003). That was associated with Wicksell’s incipient suggestion that in cyclical downturns there may exist no positive rate of interest able to equilibrate saving and investment at full employment. Even if the natural rate is positive, the credit market disequilibrium path depicted by Wicksell’s cumulative process can be hardly described as a purely tâtonnement mechanism of the groping of the market interest rate towards its equilibrium level (section IV). From a broad perspective, although Wicksell’s research program led him to move beyond the limits imposed by Walrasian general equilibrium, his admiration for the construct as a whole is visible in the attempt to integrate some aspects of his monetary macroeconomics with Walras’s framework.
II. TÂTONNEMENT, WALRAS’S LAW, AND SAY’S LAW
As seen by Wicksell ([1893] Reference Wicksell and Frowein1954), there were two alternative versions of the market mechanism, advanced respectively by Jevons ([1871] Reference Jevons1965) and Walras ([1874] Reference Walras and Jaffé1954). Footnote 2 Jevons attempted to formulate utility theory on the basis of the average behavior of an aggregate of individuals called “trading body.” Wicksell argued that this was justified only if the collective marginal utility of such trading body could be made precise, under the very restrictive assumption of linear marginal utilities identical for each individual. Footnote 3 Wicksell supported and elaborated on Walras’s method of constructing market demand as a sum of individual demands expressed as functions of prices only. Walras’s aggregation procedure was immune to Wicksell’s criticism of Jevons, since it is not necessary to aggregate over utilities if excess demand is a function of equilibrium prices as the only independent variables. Under the assumption that there are no disequilibrium transactions at false prices, Walrasian market excess demand functions are not beset by the aggregation problems that affect Jevons’s exchange theory, caused by the effect of asset distribution on individual demand functions (Van Daal and Walker Reference van Daal and Walker1990; Boianovsky Reference Boianovsky2016).
Wicksell ([1893] Reference Wicksell and Frowein1954, pp. 70, 83; [1901] Reference Wicksell and Classen1934, p. 65) assumed that, under “ideal market conditions,” final price equilibrium is established within a “short time for each commodity, in which afterwards the bulk of transactions are done.” He did not use Walras’s French term tâtonnement, but in his account of the determination of relative prices and factor rewards in general equilibrium Wicksell (1901, p. 207; [1901] Reference Wicksell and Classen1934, p. 201) did deploy the equivalent Swedish expression s.k. försöksmetoden [so-called groping method], translated as “trial and error.” The matter was related to Jevons’s “law of indifference” (that there cannot be more than one price for the same commodity at the same time) and how transactions are set up in the exchange process.
Final price equilibrium will not be quickly reached if sellers (owners of a particular commodity) act in a non-competitive way and “hold back their supply at the beginning, thereby forcing up prices, and then afterwards lower them in order to dispose of the remainder of their goods” (Wicksell [1901] Reference Wicksell and Classen1934, p. 52; see also [1893] Reference Wicksell and Frowein1954, p. 70; [1898] Reference Wicksell and Kahn1936, pp. 19–20). In this case, as pointed out by Wicksell (ibid.), there is the danger that some sellers use the opportunity to dispose of their whole stock at this high price, with the result that the others will not be able to sell their goods or can do it only at a price much lower than they would have got if the equilibrium price had been decided by competition from the beginning. Such lower price and losses are caused by the effect of disequilibrium high prices on the income of buyers,
[s]ince the purchasing power of the buyers who had already partially satisfied their needs at the higher price would then be less than it would have been if, from the beginning, they had bought the same quantity at a lower price; or since as a rule there would then remain fewer buyers able to purchase the goods. (ibid.)
If economic agents try to avoid that risk by making agreements about the amounts of commodities to be sold beforehand through the formation of cartels of buyers and sellers, competition is replaced by “isolated exchange” (bilateral bargain for each commodity), with an indeterminate price. Wicksell ([1901] Reference Wicksell and Classen1934, p. 53) decided to disregard this possibility and assume “universal free competition,” so that “as far as genuine[Footnote 4] market transactions are concerned, the relative prices of commodities will more or less rapidly approach a certain equilibrium position, or else oscillate about it.… We may assume, for the sake of simplicity, that this equilibrium price will be reached at the very outset.” Hence, disequilibrium transactions and their effect on asset redistribution and price formation are assumed away. This is similar to Walras (particularly in the fourth [1900] edition of the Elements), although the argument is not exactly the same.
Another advantage of Walras’s ([1874] Reference Walras and Jaffé1954, less. 11) approach over Jevons’s was the analysis of the exchange of three or more commodities, a problem Jevons misunderstood. Final price equilibrium can now be reached only through indirect exchange, in the sense that a commodity is taken in exchange, not in order to be consumed but to be again given in exchange. From Wicksell’s perspective ([1893] 1954, pp. 76–82; [1898] 1936, pp. 21–22; [1901] 1934, pp. 63–68; [1906] 1935, pp. 15–23), this marks the beginning of monetary theory (see also Boianovsky Reference Boianovsky1998a, sec. II). Under the assumption that relative prices are correlated and consistent with one another, it cannot be imposed on the analysis that exchange must take place directly, for the problem will then be overdetermined, with more independent equations than unknowns. In a system with n commodities, the number of relative prices is n-1 if prices are expressed in one of them taken as standard of value (numéraire, as called by Walras). Alternatively, prices may be expressed in terms of a measure of value, such as “money,” which is not regarded as one of the objects of consumption but as a medium of exchange accepted by all transactors because it reduces transaction costs (see Niehans Reference Niehans1978, pp. 100–105). If price correlation is not assumed, the number of possible exchange ratios between n commodities will be not n-1 but
${1 \over 2}$
n (n-1), and arbitrage will take place, as explained by Wicksell.
It was in that context that Wicksell discussed what Oskar Lange (Reference Lange, Lange, McIntyre and Yntena1942, p. 50) would later call Walras’s law, in reference to Walras’s ([1874] 1954, sec. 116) original proof that if demand equals supply for n-1 commodities, it does so also for the nth commodity. Wicksell ([1901] Reference Wicksell and Classen1934, pp. 66–67; see also [1893] 1954, pp. 79–80) started from the budget constraint notion that the value of the commodities an individual buys must equal the value of the commodities (s)he sells (that is, the net value of the individual’s excess demands must be zero). He then summed over the budget constraints for all individuals to obtain the aggregate form of the budget constraint, which shows that total demand for all commodities is necessarily equal to total supply at any set of prices. Lange’s demonstration of Walras’s law followed along similar lines. Footnote 5 Wicksell ([1901] Reference Wicksell and Classen1934, p. 67) found that proposition pretty “obvious,” for
if goods are only exchanged for goods (so that money … functions in a merely formal manner) then if the demands for all the commodities with one exception are equal to the existing supplies, the same must apply to the last commodity.… But these n-1 equations are sufficient for the solution of the problem, for all the quantities involved can be expressed in terms of the n-1 relative prices of the commodities.
One main feature of the system discussed above is that it determines the relative prices of commodities only, “not their actual money prices, which must remain quite undetermined” (ibid.). This is a consequence of the assumption that in such an economy the “functions of money are purely formal” (measure of value and medium of exchange), so that any amount of money, no matter how small, is able to perform the exchange process. In order to determine the general price level it is necessary to take into account the role of money as store of value and its velocity of circulation, which brings in the demand function for money. However, as put by Wicksell (Reference Wicksell1903, p. 489), en route to volume II of the Lectures, “the concept of demand for money is extremely obscure and hard to comprehend.” Most people, he suggested, understood that expression as demand for money against bonds in the market for loanable funds. Indeed, the term “money market” usually meant the organized short-term credit market in the economic and financial literature. Footnote 6
For Wicksell, on the other hand, “money market” denoted the supply and demand of cash balances (see, e.g., Interest and Prices, p. 24), as distinguished from the bond market. It was a matter of the exchange value of money against commodities. The main difficulty was to make precise the notion of “velocity of circulation” of money, which made impossible any straightforward application of general economic laws to money. Whereas commodities are demanded for consumption, the “demand for money is something completely different: it is the formation of cash balances, for a longer or shorter period of time”: that is, demand for money in order to keep it instead of spending (Wicksell Reference Wicksell1903, p. 490). As suggested by Charles Rist ([1938] Reference Rist and Degras1940, pp. 349–350), despite Walras’s previous effort, Wicksell was the first economist to fully understand the relevance of the concept of demand for money and to show that it is essentially the converse of the velocity of circulation. Wicksell explained that in a passage similar to the argument previously developed in his 1903 article:
The money [the seller] acquires remains in his hands both as ready money for anticipated future purchases or payments, and as a reserve for unforeseen liabilities. His money thus becomes his means of storing value.… And since the money in his possession cannot, at the same time, serve as a medium of payment or exchange for somebody else, the real limit to the velocity of circulation of money, at any given moment, is to be found here. It is the total individual cash balances which regulates and limits the demand for money, and thereby modifies the value of money. (Wicksell [Reference Wicksell1906] 1935, p. 23)
Wicksell usually studied the determination of the level of prices in the commodity market, instead of the money market. This may be seen as an application of Walras’s law once demand for money is added to the system discussed above (see also Baird Reference Baird1970, pp. 104–105). Excess supply of cash balances in the money market corresponds to excess demand in the commodity market as a whole (assuming for now that there are no bonds). However, the notion that the price level is determined by aggregate excess demand for commodities was anything but obvious. It involved showing how cash balances and the price level influence the demand functions for commodities: that is, a description of the tâtonnement that decides the price level in the several markets of the economy. The concept of aggregate demand for output as a whole was not part of Walras’s framework—which involved aggregation over individuals in each market but not over commodities in different markets—or of neoclassical economics in general. Irving Fisher ([1911] Reference Fisher1913, pp. 180–181), for instance, stated that “supply” and “demand” for commodities could explain relative prices only, not the price level, which was governed exclusively by the quantity theory of money equation (see Boianovsky Reference Boianovsky2013a, p. 220). In the same vein, Walras’s brief discussion of the tâtonnement in the money market (in Wicksell’s sense) did not take into account the mutual interdependence with the tâtonnement taking place in the commodity market. Footnote 7
Wicksell (Reference Wicksell1903, p. 490; [1906] 1935, p. 159) was aware that his proposition—that price level changes can take place only if the demand for all or the most part of commodities is, or is expected to become, of a different magnitude from supply—looked “paradoxical” in view of Jean-Baptiste Say’s classical theory that commodities constitute the demand for other commodities. The notions of demand and supply schedules, originally devised for separate markets at the microeconomic level (where the independence of supply and demand from one another can be taken for granted), could not be transposed to the aggregate domain without changing their meanings. Such a conceptual change was operated by Wicksell, who, in “his somewhat hesitating way that is so engaging, eventually made up his mind to the effect that we need a concept of monetary demand for output as a whole” (Schumpeter Reference Schumpeter1954, p. 1117). That concept held the key to clarify what Wicksell (Reference Wicksell1903) called the “obscure point” in monetary theory. One should, according to Wicksell ([1906] Reference Wicksell and Classen1935, p. 159), investigate the “middle link” in the final exchange of one commodity against another, formed by the “demand of money for goods and the supply of goods against money.” Therefore, “[i]t is the pecuniary demand, the ‘monied demand’ in relation with the supply of commodities, which must be investigated and defined. After the clarification of this concept, the secret to general changes in commodity prices and the value of money will be unveiled” (Wicksell Reference Wicksell1903, p. 491).
Wicksell originally wrote the expression “monied demand”—or “moneyed demand for all kinds of goods” ([1898] 1936, p. 96)—in English. Arthur Marget ([1942] Reference Marget1966, p. 95) suggested that it was Wicksell’s own creation. Wicksell may have been the first to use it in the sense of aggregate effective demand for commodities and services, but he was probably inspired by classical British economists like Thomas Joplin (Reference Joplin1828, p. 38), who referred to the “monied demand for corn.” Lange (Reference Lange, Lange, McIntyre and Yntena1942, p. 66) quoted from Wicksell’s ([1906] Reference Wicksell and Classen1935, pp. 159–160) remark that “any theory of money worthy of the name” must be able to show how the pecuniary demand for commodities and services differs from aggregate supply. He imputed to Wicksell the origins of the interpretation—developed by Lange in his essay—of Say’s law as a statement about the necessary identity between aggregate demand and supply, and its implication that money is just a medium of exchange, as individuals are always satisfied with the existing amount of money and never wish to hold less or more. As pointed out by Lange (Reference Lange, Lange, McIntyre and Yntena1942, p. 63), this means that excess demand functions for commodities are homogenous of degree zero, in the sense that a proportional change of all prices does not affect the quantities demanded or offered. The price level is, therefore, indeterminate under Lange’s interpretation of Say’s law. This is the same result obtained by Wicksell ([1901] 1934, pp. 66–68) in his treatment of indirect exchange and Walras’s law discussed above.
Lange (Reference Lange, Lange, McIntyre and Yntena1942, p. 66) interpreted Wicksell’s ([1906] Reference Wicksell and Classen1935, p. 159) observation—that total demand and supply must be equal only “ultimately” but may differ “in the first place”—as meaning that the stability conditions of the system are satisfied, in the sense that the economy tends towards equilibrium through the process of price change. Footnote 8 This is related to Wicksell’s interpretation of the tâtonnement as discussed above. In fact, Say’s law implied the valid assertion that falling prices and economic downswings cannot be causally explained by an abundance of commodities relative to consumers’ income, as in underconsumption and overproduction theories (Wicksell [1907] Reference Wicksell and Uhr1953, p. 60; see also Schumpeter Reference Schumpeter1954, p. 618). Wicksell ([1925] Reference Wicksell and Norberg1936, p. 213) acknowledged as much in his comment that “it is impossible, at one and the same time, to be both rich and poor, to have goods to sell and yet lack the means wherewith to buy other goods.… Goods always set up a demand for other goods, as J. B. Say long ago demonstrated.” Clearly, Wicksell’s concept of aggregate demand did not entail rejection of Say’s law in toto.
III. MONEY, PROFIT, AND THE RATE OF INTEREST
A substantial part of Wicksell’s ([1898] Reference Wicksell and Kahn1936, p. 1) research agenda in monetary macroeconomics dealt with the determination and changes of the price level, which were supposed to exert a “profound and far-reaching” influence on economic instability and income distribution. According to Wicksell ([1898] Reference Wicksell and Kahn1936, p. 18), neoclassical economics, founded by Jevons, Walras, and Carl Menger, had illuminated the theory of relative prices of commodities, but not the theory of the value of money, despite the fact those authors had entered “fairly deeply” into monetary issues. Wicksell did not find that surprising, for the theory of relative prices was based on the conception of marginal utility, which played “practically no part” in the determination of the average price level. Money as such “has no marginal utility,” since it is not intended for consumption. It has only an indirect marginal utility derived from the utility of the commodities it can buy, “but this depends in turn on the exchange value of the money itself and it thus does not itself regulate the latter” (Wicksell [Reference Wicksell1906] 1935, p. 200; see also 1903, p. 487). With the partial exception of Walras’s encaisse désirée, neoclassical economists did not contemplate the idea of including money in the utility function. Wicksell ([1898] Reference Wicksell and Kahn1936, p. 18), however, asserted that Walras’s exposition consisted “fundamentally of nothing more than a mathematical version of the quantity theory … there is no substantial development or extension of the theory itself.” Wicksell ([1899] 1999, p. 179) was of the opinion that Walras’s general equilibrium system made him the “greatest synthesist of his time,” but as an “analytical thinker” Walras’s only outstanding contribution was his theory of value and exchange. Footnote 9
Wicksell’s harsh opinion was probably prompted by his perception that Walras did not provide an explanation of the mechanism of determination of the price level by the interaction between money and commodity markets. Moreover, Walras’s demand for money function was not based, in contrast with Wicksell’s ([1898] Reference Wicksell and Kahn1936, ch. 6) own construction, on the notion that individuals hold money as a reserve against unexpected discrepancies between payments and receipts. Such an assessment was put forward by Patinkin ([1956] Reference Patinkin1965, p. 564), who pointed to the “irony” that Wicksell, who provided a cash balance approach that could have led to the application of utility analysis to money, did not do so, while Walras, who lacked such framework, did. Footnote 10 Be as it may, monetary theory would have to wait until Hicks’s contributions in the 1930s in order to experience a “marginal revolution.” From the point of view of the quantity theory of money, Wicksell’s ([1898] Reference Wicksell and Kahn1936, pp. 39–40) main contribution was to extend Walras’s tâtonnement to the determination of the price level. He did that by discussing how changes in cash balances affect aggregate excess demand functions for commodities and lead to proportional changes in prices. Footnote 11 Patinkin would call the tâtonnement that determines the price level the “real balance effect” and turn it into the focal point of his own monetary theory based on the money-in-the-utility-function (see also Boianovsky Reference Boianovsky1998a).
The novelty represented by Wicksell’s 1898 introduction of (what we now call) the real balance effect is well illustrated by Salomon Altmann’s (Reference Altmann and Schmoller1908, pp. 44–45) survey of German monetary theory at the beginning of the twentieth century. Altmann referred to Wicksell as the “great logician” who was able to find the “Ariadne thread” in the confusion between the determinants of relative and money prices that prevailed in the economic literature at the time. Altmann was attracted to Wicksell’s argument that, in an economy without credit, price level alterations are caused by the effect of cash balances changes on excess demand for commodities. Ludwig von Mises (Reference Mises1912), however, was not convinced, and charged economists for dealing only with the causes of a change in the equilibrium level of prices instead of the conditions for this equilibrium position itself. As it is well known, Mises tried to find the answer by an historical regression to the time when the value of money corresponded to the value of a commodity that has utility in some way other than as money—that is, “money is a ghost of gold,” as Mises’s position would be later described in the literature. Against Mises, Wicksell ([1914] Reference Wicksell, Chamberlain and Sandelin1999, pp. 221–222) argued that “the whole business is quite simple. Assuming a general cash economy, it is obviously the necessary level of cash holdings that limits the demand for money and thereby (indirectly) the level of commodity prices.” In a fully developed credit economy (in which every payment occurs by means of changes entered in the bank books and where the measure of value is the unit in which bank accounts are kept), on the other hand, “price equilibrium could readily obtain at any level of prices.”
Wicksell’s dissatisfaction with Walras’s monetary theory was mainly related to the need to incorporate credit and the banking sector into the analysis. In an economy with bonds, a larger amount of cash balances will bring about not just an increase in the demand for commodities but also in the demand for bonds (or supply of loanable funds). As pointed out by Wicksell (1903, p. 500), the latter becomes particularly important in economies in which the main form of demand for cash is represented by centralized bank reserves instead of individual cash balances. At this point, Wicksell shifted the focus of his discussion of monetary theory from an exchange economy with a money market to a production economy with money and credit markets (see also Baird Reference Baird1970 for Wicksell’s successive monetary models). The setting is still Walrasian, in the sense that the production process is discussed as a circular flow formed by the markets for commodities and for productive services, where entrepreneurs appear as buyers of productive services and sellers of commodities.
Wicksell ([1893] Reference Wicksell and Frowein1954, pp. 94–95) agreed with Walras’s ([1874] 1954, sec. 188) hypothesis that competition cancels out the profit of entrepreneurs, who are just compensated for their work of managing the enterprise as other workers are. He disagreed, however, with Walras’s (ibid.) attempt to render the theory of production symmetrical with the previous solution to the theory of exchange, as if it was an exchange between productive services. Footnote 12 Walras’s mistake, from Wicksell’s ([1893] Reference Wicksell and Frowein1954, p. 93) standpoint, was to overlook the significance of time and capital in production—captured by John Stuart Mill’s well-known dictum that “demand for commodities is not demand for labour,” which Walras ([1874] 1954, sec. 363) rejected. Production, argued Wicksell, will “never be like the simple market; it consists rather of a series of acts of exchange performed at different times” comprising the whole period from the beginning of production to the sale of commodities.
Wicksell ([1898] Reference Wicksell and Kahn1936, ch. IX-B) carried to the model of the cumulative process his general notion of a production period in which the market for productive services (mainly labor) is cleared before the commodity market in a succession of equilibria (see Siven Reference Siven1997). Since workers buy the output of consumption goods from the previous period, the costs for goods sold during a certain period and the income used to purchase the same goods are independent from one another. A dynamic change, caused by a difference between the “natural” (expected marginal productivity of capital) and the market rates of interest, makes this potential discrepancy between consumers’ outlay and cost to appear, as observed by Erik Lundberg (1937] Reference Lundberg1964, pp. 53–54) in the first detailed comment about Wicksell’s cumulative process model.
This may illuminate Wicksell’s ([1898] Reference Wicksell and Kahn1936, pp. 44–45) discussion of Thomas Tooke’s (Reference Tooke1844, p. 124) thesis that “as the cost of production is the limiting principle of supply, so the aggregate of money incomes devoted to expenditure for consumption is the determining and limiting principle of demand.” Tooke argued that income determines prices, but it can also be said that prices determine income. As expressed by Wicksell, “since almost every adult is a producer … costs of production and money incomes are really only two different aspects of the same thing, and the sum of each must be equal to the sum of the prices of all the goods (and services) produced and consumed.” This is a statement of the basic identity of national income accounting, which may be also viewed from the perspective of Walras’s circular flow. Wicksell maintained that, although Tooke’s thesis may look like reasoning in circle, it did provide a starting point for the determination of the price level. Wicksell would clarify in his cumulative process that the prices to which both costs and incomes are necessarily equal are the cost-prices, not the prices determined as a result of the effect of the disbursement of incomes upon goods offered for sale (see also Marget [1938] Reference Marget1966, pp. 130–131). The difference between prices and costs so defined constitutes the pure profit of the entrepreneur, which is zero in equilibrium.
Wicksell’s ([1901] Reference Wicksell and Classen1934, pp. 124–133) solution to the so-called exhaustion problem in marginal productivity theory provided the foundations of his theory of profit. Exhaustion of the product by remunerating productive factors by their marginal productivities was seen as a condition of equilibrium, corresponding to the point at which the production function becomes tangent to a linearly homogenous function. According to Wicksell, the market mechanism produces this condition in long-run equilibrium. Perfect competition assures that all firms produce at the point of minimum average cost, where the average cost curve is horizontal and marginal equals average cost. Therefore, factor shares behave as if the production functions were linear-homogenous, which implies exhaustion of the product and zero entrepreneur profit. As explained by Wicksell (p. 130), “if, even when the firms have reached the optimum scale, they are still numerous enough for perfect competition to be maintained, then wages and rent must be forced up to the point where the entrepreneur’s profit becomes zero, either because new entrepreneurs enter the industry, or because those already engaged in it will establish more than one concern each.” With firms at optimal size, entrepreneurs make no profit or loss. From non-homogenous production function for the individual firms, as shown by Wicksell, a linear-homogeneous function is obtained for the competitive industry as whole. Such demonstration, regarded by Jürg Niehans (Reference Niehans1990, p. 253) as Wicksell’s “most brilliant analytical achievement,” provided a justification for the use of linear-homogeneous production functions at the aggregate level and made the size of firms determinate under perfect competition.
Wicksell carried to his monetary economics the concept of zero-profit entrepreneurs in long-period competitive equilibrium. But he now took into account the crucial influence of disequilibrium profits brought about by the difference between the natural and market rates of interest. The discussion about the effects of such disequilibrium on the market for productive factors and on the planned size of firms is analogous to the argument developed in his theory of value. If banks lend at a rate of interest below the natural rate,
[t]he economic equilibrium of the system is ipso facto disturbed. If prices remain unchanged, entrepreneurs will in the first instance obtain a surplus profit (at the cost of capitalists) over and above their real entrepreneur profit or wage.… They will inevitably be induced to extend their businesses in order to exploit the favourable turn of events. And the number of people becoming entrepreneurs will be abnormally increased. As a consequence, the demand for labour services, raw materials and goods in general will be increased, and the prices of commodities must rise. (Wicksell [1898] Reference Wicksell and Kahn1936, pp. 105–106)
Wicksell assumed in his capital theory that entrepreneurs decide their investment plans according to the maximization of the internal rate of return. This means that both the “horizontal” and “vertical” dimensions of capital structure are determined only by the ratio between the prices of inputs and outputs. A reduction of the market interest will not directly affect the capital intensity of the economy (its production or investment period), but it will cause entrepreneurs to attempt to expand their scale of operation in order to take advantage of extra profits. Wicksell ([1914] Reference Wicksell, Chamberlain and Sandelin1999, pp. 222–223) accordingly criticized Mises’s (Reference Mises1912) argument that a lower market rate of interest brings about a lengthening of the production period, followed by a reduction in the natural rate. A cheaper rate of interest “will not induce [the entrepreneur] to lengthen his period of production; instead, he will calmly pocket the difference as additional profit. But a lower rate of interest will certainly encourage him to expand his business” (see also Boianovsky Reference Boianovsky1995, pp. 394–395).
Wicksell ([1889] Reference Wicksell, Boianovsky and Trautwein2001, pp. 513–514) had already made that clear in his first draft of the cumulative process, when he stated that, under those circumstances, entrepreneurs “tend to expand existing enterprises, to establish new ones, or to continue with old enterprises that otherwise would have been terminated.” It is essentially a matter of a tendency, since an actual expansion of production may be prevented if productive factors are fully employed. Footnote 13 “The tendency, however, will always be there, and it will produce an increased monetary demand for raw materials, tools, labour, land and productive forces and thereby directly or indirectly push all wages and prices in an upward direction” (ibid.). And vice versa if the bank rate is higher than the natural rate of interest, with ensuing entrepreneurs’ losses and contraction of economic activity. Interestingly enough, the term “pecuniary demand” appears already in Wicksell’s first formulation of his monetary theory.
The ability of the banking system as a whole to set the market rate of interest and affect deposit creation and credit supply (“virtual velocity of money”) means that the money market and the capital market (credit market) will be “one and the same, not only in popular opinion and speech but also to a large extent in reality.” The consequence is that monetary institutions may “exert considerable influence, either by stimulating or retarding [real Footnote 14 ] economic life,” a power they may also use in order to prevent cumulative changes of price level caused by oscillations of the natural rate of interest vis-à-vis the market rate (Wicksell [Reference Wicksell1906] 1935, pp. 26–27).
It is assumed throughout that the entrepreneurs’ aggregate demand for loanable funds is a continuous negative function of the bank or market rate of interest. Differently from individual functions, aggregate market demand functions tend to be continuous because of the “law of large numbers,” as argued by both Wicksell and Walras in their respective presentations of demand functions in exchange theory (see Boianovsky Reference Boianovsky2016). Firms are heterogeneous, in the sense that there are businesses to which a change of the market rate of interest is of “very little consequence,” while there are others in regard to which such change is the “decisive factor” (Wicksell [1898] Reference Wicksell and Kahn1936, p. 89). Some enterprises are on the point of expanding their activities; others are about to restrict them. In all such cases an easing or tightening of credit may be the “last drop which causes the vessel to overflow, so that the plans which have been worked out are brought into execution” (see Wicksell [1893] Reference Wicksell and Frowein1954, p. 85, for a similar passage about market demand functions for commodities as a sum of individual functions).
Wicksell’s treatment of the saving (or supply of loanable funds) function is not as straightforward as his discussion of the aggregate investment function. In the closing pages of his Value, Capital and Rent, Wicksell considered the possibility of following Walras’s ([1874] Reference Walras and Jaffé1954, less. 23) approach to aggregate savings as a positive function of the market rate of interest, “provided we keep in mind that a rise in the rate of interest can not only give cause for an increase of savings, but can also, in certain circumstances, have the contrary effect” (Wicksell [1983] Reference Wicksell and Frowein1954, p. 165n2). Moreover, added Wicksell, the influence of population growth should be taken into account, as the number of children in a family is of much greater importance for the formation or consumption of capital than the level of interest. He left matters at that, until the publication of volume I of his Lectures, which included a chapter on capital accumulation and savings. The saving function was not discussed in Interest and Prices, as Wicksell’s argument in that book did not depend on any particular form of that function. The “natural rate of interest” was then defined by the marginal return of lengthening the production process, as the general equilibrium solution of an economy without money and with constant capital supply, along the lines of Value, Capital and Rent. When presenting his model of the cumulative process, Wicksell ([1898] Reference Wicksell and Kahn1936, p. 154) observed that “whether capitalists, whose incomes have diminished as a result of the fall in the deposit rate, will be able or willing to save the same amount as before is a separate question which need not concern us here.”
Wicksell ([1906] Reference Wicksell and Classen1935, p. 193) defined the “normal rate of interest” as the value of the market rate at which “the demand for loan capital and the supply of savings exactly agree.” Savings are now described, as a rule, as a positive function of the market rate of interest (pp. 193, 194), and the possibility that a lower rate may stimulate saving is regarded as an unlikely “exception” (p. 205). This reflected in part Wicksell’s ([1901] Reference Wicksell and Classen1934, pt. III) discussion of savings in volume I of the Lectures, where he referred again to the complex influence of population growth, age structure, and (what we now call) the substitution and income effects of changes in interest rate. Wicksell redefined capital accumulation and saving in terms of the intertemporal utility function for an “average individual, or rather for society as a whole, regarded as an individual who never ages or dies” (p. 209).
The problem tackled by Wicksell is close to Frank Ramsey’s (Reference Ramsey1928) later mathematical formulation of the optimal accumulation and growth path for society, with similar conclusions (Boianovsky Reference Boianovsky1998b). This may be regarded as an early use of the representative agent notion. Wicksell ([1893] Reference Wicksell and Frowein1954) had criticized Jevons’s concept of “trading bodies” because of the problematic aggregation of average or collective utility for all its members. However, such misgivings did not seem to affect Wicksell’s suggested approach to capital accumulation by an average immortal individual with an economy-wide intertemporal utility function maximized subject to an aggregate production function constraint (see Boianovsky Reference Boianovsky2016). The saving schedule presented in part III of the first volume of the Lectures is a macroeconomic general equilibrium function, in the sense that it encapsulates the effects of capital accumulation on the marginal productivity of capital and on permanent consumption for the economy as a whole (with given technology and population). It is a depiction of a capital-deepening process under monetary equilibrium and a normal rate of interest along the optimal accumulation path, differently from the investment-saving imbalance featured in the second volume.
IV. INVESTMENT, SAVING, AND ECONOMIC FLUCTUATIONS
Wicksell’s discussion of nominal income changes was based on the treatment of the “market for commodities” formed by the aggregate of consumption goods with constant relative prices. As he observed while presenting the model of the cumulative process, “we have been making the implicit assumption that the relative values of commodities in exchange remain unaltered.” As a matter of fact, relative prices are affected by changes in conditions of production, and in their turn influence such conditions. “The only scientific method of dealing with the problem consists in paying simultaneous regard to all these factors, in the manner first demonstrated very clearly by Léon Walras” (Wicksell [1898] Reference Wicksell and Kahn1936, p. 132). Despite paying respect to Walras, it was clear to Wicksell that relative price changes of consumption goods were not relevant to the theory of monetary macroeconomics, even if very important in practice, as shown by the construction of index numbers of prices discussed in the second chapter of Interest and Prices. Wicksell ([1901] Reference Wicksell and Classen1934, pp. 103, 197) made the same assumption in his theory of production and distribution, developed for a “single commodity (or for several commodities whose relative prices are given).” Footnote 15
Wicksell used in his marginal productivity theory a “macromodel methodology,” as put by Paul Samuelson (Reference Samuelson, Eatwell, Milgate and Newman1987, p. 909), in which a simple general equilibrium for society is envisaged with a single good and its production function, often of the Cobb–Douglas linear homogenous type. Schumpeter (Reference Schumpeter1954, p. 998), who believed the notion of production function applied to individual industries only, commented that “Wicksell reasoned on a social production function without displaying any symptoms of critical discomfort,” a comment he extended to John Maynard Keynes and macroeconomics in general. Indeed, Wicksell ([1898] Reference Wicksell and Kahn1936, ch. IX) may have originated the macroeconomic practice of imagining an economy producing a single good whose physical output and price are expressed as single numbers (Brems Reference Brems1986, p. 283). In particular, the relative prices of two goods x and y will be constant if their production costs stand in given proportion. This will be the case if the respective production functions are linear homogeneous, with an ensuing linear transformation curve. Such conditions are implicit if an aggregate production function is deployed (see also Leijonhufvud Reference Leijonhufvud1968, pp. 117–119).
In volume II of the Lectures, as part of the new concept of a “normal rate of interest,” Wicksell reasoned with an aggregate economy producing two kinds of goods (consumption and capital) instead of just one. The macroeconomic literature on “intertemporal coordination” failures—particularly by Swedish economists such as the members of the so-called Stockholm school of economics in the 1930s and Axel Leijonhufvud (Reference Leijonhufvud1968, Reference Leijonhufvud1981)—has taken Wicksell’s Lectures on money as its starting point. Alternatively, Wicksell’s cumulative process may be interpreted as the first description in the literature of the simultaneous tâtonnement in the commodity and bond markets through which the interest rate converges to its equilibrium (“normal”) level, as claimed by Patinkin ([1956] Reference Patinkin1965, ch. X.3). However, the state of disequilibrium in the bond market throughout the cumulative process makes it quite different from the tâtonnement with no false prices deployed in Wicksell’s value theory.
In that context, Wicksell’s first task was to clarify the meaning of investment and saving. When announcing the changes introduced in volume II of the Lectures (as compared to Interest and Prices), Wicksell (Reference Wicksell1906, p. iv) called attention to his treatment of
[t]he character of saving as involving diminished consumption in the present and thereby diminished demand for present goods, which should normally go hand in hand with the diminished supply thereof which results from the circumstance that a certain quantity of labour and natural resources is drawn away from the production of present goods and is directed instead toward the future. (quoted and translated by Marget [1938] Reference Marget1966, p. 496n28)
This represented a different perspective from the classical approach of Smith, Mill, and others that savings immediately furnish other persons (workers) with consumption goods renounced by capitalist savers (Smith’s so-called saving-is-spending theorem). The benefits that saving confers “only become visible in the future time, when, thanks to those savings, the production of society is increased” (Wicksell [Reference Wicksell1906] 1934, p. 12). Contrary to the classical view, there is normally no concrete saving such as a deferred accumulated store of consumption goods, since those goods are not actually produced. Such process of transference of productive factors, entailed by the savers’ decision to abstain from spending a part of their income, “presupposes an adaptability and degree of foresight in the reorganization of production which is far from existing in reality” (ibid., p. 193). Footnote 16 But this was of “secondary importance” in comparison with the main phenomenon represented by the coordination between the decisions to allocate production between consumption and capital goods on one side, and the division of income between spending and saving on the other. Wicksell departed not just from the classical framework, but also from Walras’s lack of analytical distinction between the money (credit) and capital markets and tendency to treat saving and investment as identical magnitudes (see, e.g., Schumpeter Reference Schumpeter1954, p. 1016; Patinkin [1956] Reference Patinkin1965, p. 563).
Wicksell ([1904] Reference Wicksell, Chamberlain and Sandelin1999, pp. 28–29) initially introduced the saving-investment framework as a reaction to Helfferich’s (Reference Helfferich1903) discussion of the role of consumption in economic fluctuations. He disputed the latter’s view that a boom is initiated by the decision of individuals to “live beyond their means and demand goods and services in greater quantities than justified by their incomes up to this point.” Wicksell argued that the determinant element is investment demand (as influenced by the expected real rate of return on capital), not consumption, which depends endogenously on income generated in the system. Moreover, it is not a matter of higher investment per se, but excess investment in relation to savings. If the increased demand for investment is accompanied by diminished consumer demand by savers, there will be no excess demand for goods and services and increasing nominal activity level. However, if, because of the role of banks in the credit market, the market rate of interest is lower than the real rate of return, “the pecuniary demand for goods will grow in one quarter without any corresponding simultaneous reduction, as a result of increased saving and voluntary diminished consumption, in some other quarter” (ibid.).
A central feature of Wicksell’s discussion of price level movements—which gives them their cumulative character—is the assumption that the elasticity of price expectations is unity, in the sense that a change in current prices is expected to change future prices in the same proportion. Since the price ratios between all current prices and all expected prices are unchanged, there is no opportunity for substitution and the system can be in equilibrium at any level of money prices, as pointed out by Hicks ([1939] Reference Hicks1946, pp. 254–255). Blaug (Reference Blaug1997, p. 625) criticized Wicksell for thinking that this was peculiar to monetary equilibrium. According to Blaug, if, every time we demanded more bread, not only its spot price but also its expected price were to rise, equilibrium in the bread market could never be established. But this overlooks the fact that, differently from individual markets, price changes will be accompanied by income changes in the same direction in the case of aggregate markets. Wicksell emphasized from the very beginning the difference between relative prices and money prices concerning the influence of expectations.
The average level of commodity prices will to some extent depend on nothing but the general opinion of the public or of the merchant class.… In this regard we need to pay attention to the fundamental difference between the relative values of exchange and the concrete level of money prices of commodities. In many cases, the price of a single commodity or a group of commodities can also rise or fall, simply following a widespread opinion that it will rise or fall. But the resulting mismatch of supply and demand will subsequently push the price back to its normal equilibrium position. This is not the case when we speak of money prices. (Wicksell [1889] Reference Wicksell, Boianovsky and Trautwein2001, p. 512)
Wicksell usually defined the natural or normal rates of interest as the “expected” rate of return on capital. He went as far as suggesting that it remains “in a way indifferent” whether an increase of the rate of return is “actual or only in the general opinion of businessmen” as a whole (Wicksell Reference Wicksell1897, p. 241). However, if only some businessmen entertain such expectations, their mistake is revealed when their increased borrowings and wage payments do not lead to a proportional rise in sales (see also Lundberg [1937] Reference Lundberg1964, pp. 54–55).
The commodity and labor markets clear at any moment in Wicksell’s cumulative process, as prices are determined by the same tâtonnement mechanism featured in his theory of value (see also Leijonhufvud Reference Leijonhufvud1968, p. 321n9; Siven Reference Siven1997). Footnote 17 This is consistent with Wicksell’s interpretation of Say’s law discussed above. Wicksell ([1907] Reference Wicksell and Uhr1953, p. 60), however, did consider the possibility of general overproduction in the cyclical downswing, when “production exceeds current effective demand.” This would bring stocks of commodities into the picture, which he had assumed away in his cumulative process. The so-called general overproduction—defined as excess supply of labor and capital in certain sectors without any compensating excess demand in other areas—is a completely different phenomenon from partial overproduction. “To deny the possibility of that phenomenon is of no avail, as it manifests itself in real life with a force that is only too apparent” (Wicksell [1908] Reference Wicksell, Chamberlain and Sandelin1997, p. 255).
From a methodological standpoint, the relation between general and partial overproduction was the same as the distinction between changes in the price level in monetary economics and movements of relative prices in value theory. Wicksell criticized, in an unpublished manuscript about economic crisis drafted in 1908, the temptation to interpret a general crisis as simply the sum, “the chance conjunction,” of a number of partial crises in different sectors of the economy. The problem confronting incipient macroeconomics at the time, as seen by Wicksell (ibid.), was the “apparent paradox” of a “sudden paralysis of business activity and entrepreneurial spirit, without any detectable corresponding upswing” in other parts of the economy—a break in Walras’s law as it seemed.
Wicksell approached the matter as an extension of his saving-investment framework originally devised to study cumulative price level changes, but now under the implicit assumption that there may be no positive normal rate of interest able to equilibrate the commodity market at full employment—that is, an existence problem, in the language of general equilibrium theory. Footnote 18 This may be caused by a fall in the rate of technical progress (one of the main determinants of the natural rate of interest). “If these technical improvements are already in operation and no others are available … there will come a period of depression; people will not venture to the capital which is now being accumulated in such a fixed form, but will retain it as far as possible in a liquid, available form” (Wicksell [Reference Wicksell1906] 1935, p. 212). Such alternative liquid form corresponds to the accumulation of unsold stocks of commodities, which may under certain circumstances lead to output contraction and unemployment caused by an aggregate demand constraint that is not relaxed by falling prices and wages (see also Boianovsky Reference Boianovsky1995, sec. 4).
Wicksell did not, however, elaborate that in sufficient detail or mention the potential incompatibility with his general tâtonnement assumption inherited from Walras, as the business cycle remained an “enigma” in his monetary macroeconomics research agenda. Moreover, in his review of Gustav Cassel’s 1918 restatement of general equilibrium analysis, Wicksell ([1919] Reference Wicksell and Classen1934, p. 228) pointed out critically that “the ‘simultaneous equations’ are no guarantee that any ‘variable’ cannot assume the value nil, even if we are discussing so important a social factor as wages.” This was explored by the general equilibrium literature of the 1930s, which replaced the equations of supply and demand of each factor by inequalities and introduced the “rule of free goods” (see also Boianovsky and Trautwein Reference Boianovsky and Trautwein2003, p. 421).
V. EPILOGUE: WALRAS, BÖHM-BAWERK, AND WICKSELL’S MACROECONOMICS
Wicksellian economist Erik Lindahl (1939, pp. 51–52) was apparently the first to use the term “macro-economic” to describe the study of the interrelation between aggregate variables, in contrast with “micro-economic” investigation (Velupillai Reference Velupillai2008). Footnote 19 During Wicksell’s time, Böhm-Bawerk ([1889] Reference Böhm-Bawerk and Smart1891, p. 105) distinguished between the “microcosm” and the “macrocosm,” meaning the relation of men to external goods (individual demand functions) and the relation between men in the market, respectively. The Austrian economist did not use “macrocosm” in the sense of aggregate economic variables as in “macroeconomics.” In any event, Böhm-Bawerk reacted negatively to Wicksell’s Geldzins und Güterpreise. In correspondence with Wicksell of 30 May 1898, he rejected Wicksell’s “paradoxical” conclusion that a reduction of the bank rate of interest brings about a cumulative increase of the price level (Hennings Reference Hennings1997, p. 242). Schumpeter (Reference Schumpeter1954, p. 1118n4), a student of Böhm-Bawerk’s, recalled the latter’s reaction, in his Vienna lectures, to Wicksell’s cumulative process: “Wicksell must have been dreaming when he wrote that.”
Walras’s reaction to Geldzins und Güterpreise was cold, if not as negative as Böhm-Bawerk’s. The book is not mentioned in the fourth (1900) edition of Walras’s Elements. This is understandable, in view of Wicksell’s low opinion of Walras’s own monetary economics, expressed in the 1898 book and elsewhere. In his correspondence with Walras, however, Wicksell wrote that his monetary theory “ne se sépare que d’une nuance de la vôtre, et en peut être regardée comme une derivation plus ou moins directe” (letter of 26 August 1898; Gårdlund Reference Gårdlund1958, pp. 334–335). Footnote 20 Wicksell sent a copy of Geldzins und Güterpreise to Walras, who acknowledged receipt and informed that “je vais lire avec soin” Footnote 21 in order to get acquainted with Wicksell’s position regarding the problem of the value of money. Nevertheless, Walras did not emit an opinion about Wicksell’s monetary theory and plans to stabilize the price level. In his reply, Wicksell again modestly presented his own monetary framework as just a derivation of Walras’s. But at the same time he called attention to two differences between his approach and Walras’s: the ability of banks to set the market rate of interest and the concept of the natural rate of interest as an expression of the unavoidable changes in the economic situation (letters of 17 and 30 October 1898, from Walras and from Wicksell, respectively; Gårdlund, pp. 336–337). Then again, these new concepts pointed the way to the macroeconomic approach that Wicksell would further develop in the second volume of his Lectures.
As shown above, Wicksell’s way to macroeconomics should be interpreted against the background of Walrasian general equilibrium, which provided the foundation of Wicksell’s approach to economic theory. Wicksell ([1904] Reference Wicksell and Lindahl1958, p. 62) greatly admired classical economists (especially David Ricardo) and their method of investigation, against the criticism of the German Historical School. At the same time, he criticized Ricardian economics for considering “no other connection between [economic phenomena] than that of cause and effect, while we have learnt (especially since Walras) to regard them as a whole group of interrelated logical relationships, a system of forces in equilibrium, whether the equilibrium is of the static or dynamic (kinetic) sort” (ibid.). “Dynamic equilibrium” pertained mostly to growth economics, a topic only marginally discussed by Walras and Wicksell but tackled upfront by Cassel (see Boianovsky Reference Boianovsky, Boianovsky and Hoover2009).
Wicksell kept, for most of his discussion of monetary matters, the tâtonnement mechanism of price determination in both commodity and factor markets. The very organization of the economic discourse around different kinds of markets, and the corresponding role of the entrepreneur, reflected Walras’s influence. Wicksell, however, parted company with Walras in the treatment of the interaction between the “monetary” and “real” domains of the economy, particularly in connection with the time dimension of the production process and the determination of the market rate of interest. In particular, Wicksell’s interpretation of the dynamics of the credit market, with a price (interest rate) distinct from its equilibrium value, did not fit into the Walrasian tâtonnement mold. Likewise, Wicksell’s marginal productivity theory and its role in the interpretation of entrepreneur’s profits in an economy with a sequence of markets added a new dimension to Walras’s general equilibrium. In order to bring that out, Wicksell introduced a macroeconomic way of reasoning, which may be understood as an extension of general equilibrium to an economy with a small number of aggregate markets for commodities, labor, money, and bonds interacting with one another through time.
An important part of modern macroeconomics is built on Walrasian general equilibrium. Footnote 22 However, as pointed out by Robert Solow (Reference Solow and Bridel2011), this does not include DSGE (Dynamic Stochastic General Equilibrium) models, which are based on the representative agent concept. As discussed above, the representative agent has a limited role in Wicksell’s framework, restricted to the study of the savings function in monetary equilibrium. Pareto ([1896–97] Reference Pareto1964, vol. II, ch. 4 on economic crises) was Wicksell’s only contemporary who attempted a formal interpretation of economic fluctuations based on the optimizing behavior of a representative agent, whose consumption and saving oscillate cyclically (see Boianovsky Reference Boianovsky2013b). Wicksell ([1907] Reference Wicksell and Uhr1953, pp. 59–60) observed that, in Pareto’s model, “if perchance the behaviour of many individuals is influenced in the same direction, then the consequence would be a wave-like movement in the aggregate.” However, the main problem (apart from some mathematical mistakes) with Pareto’s approach, in Wicksell’s view, was the assumption that the “individual or society can forecast the future with certainty,” for this precludes either consumption or saving from exceeding their proper measure and causing reactions.
With the partial exception of chapter IX of Interest and Prices, Wicksell ([1898] Reference Wicksell and Kahn1936) made no use in his monetary macroeconomics of the “mathematical method” he deployed extensively in his discussion of the theories of value and distribution. Walras ([1874] Reference Wicksell and Frowein1954, pt. VI), on the other hand, applied mathematics to his treatment of monetary theory, although, from Wicksell’s perspective, that did not take Walras beyond the traditional quantity theory of money. Wicksell’s verbal style opened the field to efforts to clarify the meaning of his macroeconomic concepts in the 1930s and later. Patinkin’s attempt to incorporate money into general equilibrium was one such effort. However, it gradually became clear that the standard general equilibrium model with a full set of Arrow–Debreu markets could not accommodate money with a positive exchange value (see Hahn Reference Hahn, Hahn and Brechling1965). In the same vein, Wicksell’s path-breaking investigations of the influence of expectations, the non-neutrality of money, and economic fluctuations along the capital accumulation path penetrated directly or indirectly the agenda of macroeconomics in its several versions.
