Established in 1859, as a merger of the Whigs, Radicals and Peelites, the British Liberal Party and their ideological forerunners won 15 out of a total of 20 parliamentary elections between 1832–1910. Responsible for passing socially progressive legislation domestically, Victorian liberalism can lay claim to being the most significant political ideology of the period. By bringing together aspects of classical social liberalism and liberal free-market conservatism, this specifically Victorian brand of liberalism enabled Britain to take a place at the center of world affairs. Indeed, by the mid-1850s, the emergence of Victorian liberalism had begun to be seen as something of a political necessity, as demonstrated by Thomas Babington Macaulay's The History of England from the Accession of James II (1848–61), a foundational text of Whig historicism, in which Lord Charles Grey's 1832 Reform Bill was characterized as the teleological culmination of British history. But while the liberals styled themselves as progressives and their opponents as reactionaries, Whig history has tended to oversimplify the dynamics of this narrative. In this context, Henry Longueville Mansel's closet drama Phontisterion offers a fascinating glimpse into a contemporary Tory response to the seemingly irresistible rise of Victorian liberalism.
Mansel (1820–1871) was a key figure of Victorian intellectual life, appointed Waynflete Professor of Metaphysical Philosophy in 1859, and succeeding A. P. Stanley as Regius Professor of Ecclesiastic History, before being appointed Dean of St. Paul's in 1868. Partly remembered today for his famous essay on “Sensation Novels,” published in the Fortnightly Review in 1863, Mansel's contemporary reputation rested on his contributions to philosophy and ecclesiastical thought. After publishing a volume of poetry at the age of eighteen, The Demons of the Wind and other Poems (1838), heavily indebted to Romanticism, he had entered St. John's, Oxford, the following year. Graduating with a double first in 1843, he took up residence as Tutor of St. John's, and embarked on an academic career, with his earliest publications focusing on philosophy. He published two works on logic, a textbook, Ars logicae rudimenta (1847), and Prolegomena logica (1851), his contribution to the philosophy of science, as well as the Phrontisterion, before being appointed to the Waynflete Professorship. But it was the invitation to give the annual Bampton Lectures the year beforehand in 1858 that would cement Mansel's place at the heart of contemporary thought. Published under the title of The Limits of Religious Thought, Mansel's lectures were highly controversial. Resting on an argument derived from the Scottish philosopher, Sir William Hamilton, on the problem of the “unconditioned” (which he defines as that which cannot be thought as such, since to think is to condition), Mansel in effect argued in his lectures for a kind of theological agnosticism, on the grounds that the divine is by definition precisely that which escapes the bounds of human understanding.Footnote 2 The lectures prompted fierce criticism, not least from Frederick Denison Maurice, one of the most significant theological voices of the period and a foundational figure in the Christian Socialist movement, who replied in What is Revelation? (1859), a thinly veiled critique of Mansel's position.Footnote 3 To today's readers, what is most striking about both Mansel's argument and the dispute with Maurice is how it anticipates many strands in later twentieth century religious philosophy.
The Phrontisterion, however, dating from the period when Mansel was Fellow of St. John's Hall, predated this controversy, and responded to a very different one: the Prime Minister John Russell's Commission to inquire into the State, Discipline, Studies and Revenues of the University and Colleges of Oxford of 1850. For Mansel, who was “to the backbone a Conservative” (Burgon 1: 216–17),Footnote 4 this Commission seemed emblematic of so many forces that he detested: it brought into a constellation all sorts of local, national and international issues in his mind. Significantly for scholars of the period interested in Victorian liberalism and Tory responses, Mansel throughout associates free trade Radicalism with Whig politics, with the latter deemed corrupt and avaricious, and compromised by the former. Indeed, Mansel was not wholly wrong in associating the contemporary movement towards Oxford reform with the Radical tradition. In the mid-1830s, Baden Powell and James Heywood, incentivized by the Reform Act, had published statistical evidence demonstrating that student numbers were dwindling and that the wealthiest colleges tended to educate the fewest undergraduates.Footnote 5 In the 1840s, the appeals for reformation from the liberals became more frequent, but it was the 1847 general election that proved decisive. Elected to a seat as MP for North Lancashire in 1847, Heywood began a petition for a Commission, campaigning to repeal the thirty-nine Articles, opening Oxford to Dissenters, and to apply German models to the University. Heywood continued to raise the issue in the House,Footnote 6 but in private the topic had caught the attention of the Prime Minister. Russell, who had been a leading figure during the first Reform Act, announced on 23 April 1850 that he would recommend the crown issue a Royal Commission to investigate the State, Discipline, and Studies of the University and of the Colleges.Footnote 7
The eventual Commission comprised something of a who's who of mid-Victorian liberals: Samuel Hinds, Bishop of Norwich, was appointed Chief Commissioner, and A. P. Stanley and Goldwin Smith were appointed Secretary and Assistant Secretary respectively, both then Fellows of University College, with Stanley later made Dean of Westminster in 1864. The other members were A. C. Tait, Thomas Arnold's successor as headmaster of Rugby, then Dean of Carlisle; Francis Jeune, Master of Pembroke; J. L. Dampier, a lawyer; G. H. S. Johnson, Dean of Queen's College; and Powell, by this point Savilian Professor of Geometry. Their remit was broad, but in practice significant areas of investigation were the role of “closed fellowships” at Oxford, the tutorial system, and an educational focus which marginalized subjects such as the natural sciences,Footnote 8 with the final report signed 27 April, 1852. In response, late the following year, Gladstone began drafting a Bill, taking input from Benjamin Jowett, Stanley's close friend and ally, then tutor at Balliol, appointed Regius Professor of Greek in 1855. This Bill would be revised and introduced in the House by Russell on 17 March 1854, before being written into law as the University Reform Act on 22 June.
Mansel's position towards the Commission was hostile. As a committed Tory, he was predisposed to dislike the idea of the Commission, the Commissioners themselves, and Russell as its architect. While he gave the Commission evidence, he rejected the idea of university extension and the movement towards the adoption of the Humboldtian model (after Wilhelm von Humboldt) in Oxford.Footnote 9 Fittingly for a man who “stood alone among the men of his time for the brilliancy” of his wit, as John Burgon recalled in 1888 (1: 209),Footnote 10 Mansel's response to the Commission took the form of satire: the Phrontisterion.
The closet drama constitutes an imitation of Aristophanes The Clouds (Νεφέλαι), a play dating from 423 BC, which sees the character Strepsiades worried by his debts, caused by his aristocratic wife's expensive tastes. Opening with Strepsiades sitting up in bed, the father wakes his son, Pheidippides, sleeping beside him, to explain his plan. He asks Pheidippides to enroll in the Phrontisterion or Thinkery, under the tutelage of Socrates, in order to learn the rhetorical skills needed to help beat Strepsiades’ creditors in court. The Clouds satirizes Socrates and his disciples, the former figuring less as the seeker of Truth and Justice in the popular image handed down by Plato, than as simply one more sophist amongst the crowd, one whose clever rhetoric threatens those laws and customs which are essential to the social order. Owing to the poor reputation of the Thinkery, Pheidippides initially refuses, and Strepsiades attempts to enroll instead. Having heard about a number of farcical recent discoveries made by Socrates and his disciples, the philosopher himself descends from the heavens and a Chorus of Clouds sings Socrates’ praises. But Strepsiades fails to live up to either Socrates’ intellectual or moral standards (he is caught masturbating) and is expelled. Pheidippides finally agrees to enter the Thinkery in his father's place, where he hears the agon or formal debate of Right and Wrong Logic, and needless to say, the inferior argument wins the day. But rather than learning the necessary skills to plead his father's case in court, Pheidippides is transformed into an anarchist, a parody of the “good son” that Strepsiades had desired: he beats his father, threatens his mother, and leads a mob to attack the Thinkery. Aristophanes’ comedy offers a stark warning against the threat sophistry poses to the order of society itself.
Mansel's Phrontisterion sees Russell take on the role of Pheidippides-Johnny, forming his plan for the Commission under the watchful eye of his (spiritual) “father,” Strepsiades-Cottonarchicalicocraticus, a “Model Manchester Man,” based in part on Richard Cobden. The Whigs are characterized as the political progeny of the Radical tradition and free-trade forces. In Mansel's drama, it is Oxford which figures as the new Thinkery, which stands here under the influence of the new sophistry of German idealist philosophy, rather than that of Socrates. Mansel's satire follows a similar structure to Aristophanes’ original. As in Old Comedy, we have a prologue in scene one, comprised of dialogue where the scene is set (although Russell as Pheidippides-Johnny has less scruples than his ancient Greek inspiration and agrees to enter the Thinkery himself immediately), a parodos in scene two, where the Chorus arrive and sing, and an agon in scene three, a formal debate between two opposing arguments, here constituting a battle between Whig and Tory ideologies. Notably, however, the Phrontisterion has no equivalent of Aristophanes’ third act, which, by analogy, would suggest the destruction of Oxford. Ultimately, Mansel's drama seeks to raise a last “warning voice” (iii.74) of the Tories in the face of the rise of liberalism.
The Phrontisterion is a forgotten classic, but during the period it was highly regarded, apparently “too well known to require praise or comment” by the late 1880s (Burgon 1: 178). In 1872, Augustus de Morgan called the satire an “inimitable imitation” (358), and it was also popular, going through four editions by the end of the year of the Commission's Report in 1852.Footnote 11It would also have an afterlife, the satire proving malleable to other contexts.Footnote 12 In the latter half of the nineteenth century, Mansel's drama claimed its place in contemporary literary history: it would partially inspire Lewis Carroll's Oxford satire The Dynamics of a Parti-cle (1865), and elements of the parados of the second scene would be plagiarized by Rudyard Kipling in his early poem “O Baal, Hear Us!” (1888)Footnote 13 Indeed, so well-known was the Phrontisterion that an anonymous author in 1890 would recall that “many Oxford men of that date knew [it] by heart” (“Reminiscences” 347). George Saintsbury included the drama in full in his volume of Political Verse for the Pocket Library of English Literature (1891),Footnote 14 and the text's reputation survived into the early twentieth century, republished as an appendix in Benjamin Bickley Rodgers’ edition of The Clouds of Aristophanes (1916), and as one of George Stuart Gordon's Three Oxford Ironies (1927).Footnote 15
Rife with intertextual puns and literary allusions, Mansel was reputed by Henry William Chandler (1828–89), his friend and successor as Waynflete Professor of Moral and Metaphysical Philosophy, to have known “most of the best passages of the best English, Latin, and Greek poets by heart. It seemed as if he had merely to read a thing with attention to retain it for an indefinite time” (Quoted Burgon 1: 222). The drama will be of interest to Victorianists working on mid-century portrayals of liberalism and Russell's Whig government, Tory responses to the rise of liberalism, literary historians of Victorian satire, historians of Victorian Anglo-German relations, higher educational policy or politics, and historians interested in Victorian Oxford.
The text is based on the sixth edition of 1867, the last version which the author made alterations to before his death. This was the copy that Mansel himself had in his library at the time of his death (Gordon 45). I note the differences between this and other available editions in my commentary.Footnote 16 Mansel's own footnotes to the text, which are infrequent, are distinguished by his initials, H. L. M.
SCENES FROM AN UNFINISHED DRAMA, ENTITLED PHRONTISTERION, OR, OXFORD IN THE 19TH CENTURY.Footnote 1
Καὶ οἱ μὲν λῃσταὶ αὑτοὺς ποριστὰς καλοῦσι νῦν· διὸ ἔξεστι λέγειν τὸν ἀδικήσαντα μὲν ἁμαρτάνειν, τὸν δ᾽ ἁμαρτάνοντα ἀδικῆσαι, καὶ τὸν κλέψαντα καὶ λαβεῖν καὶ πορίσασθαι.
Aristotle, Rhetoric, III.2.1405aFootnote 2
Lucio. Thou concludest like the sanctimonious pirate, that went to sea with the ten commandments, but scraped one out of the table.
2 Gent. Thou shalt not steal?
Lucio. Ay, that he razed.
2 Gent. Why, ’twas a commandment to command the captain and all the rest from their functions; they put forth to steal.
Shakespeare, Measure for Measure, 1.2.7–14
DRAMATIS PERSONÆ.
STREPSIADES-COTTONARCHICALICOCRATICUS. The Model Manchester Man. Footnote 3
PHEIDIPPIDES-JOHNNY. The Model Minister, a compound, as his name implies, of parsimony and chivalry, a great public benefactor, but prefers doing it at other people's expense. Footnote 4
SECRETARY TO THE COMMISSION.Footnote 5
COMMISSIONER-SOCRATES. The Model Instructor of Youth. Footnote 6
CHORUS OF CLOUDY PROFESSORS.
JUST DISCOURSE. A Bigot.
UNJUST DISCOURSE. A Liberal.
SCENE I.
COTTONARCHOCALICOCRATICUS in bed, soliloquizing.
JOHNNY in truckle-bed, asleep.

SCENE II.
Front of the Room in Downing Street.
JOHNNY enters and knocks. THE SECRETARY OF THE COMMISSION opens. Footnote 53

―――
HYMN TO THE INFINITE BY THE FULL CHORUS.Footnote 112

―――


