The ReFormations series from the University of Notre Dame Press has published yet another important work of scholarship on early English theatre. The Civic Cycles is challenging reading, not simply on account of its provocative revisionary historicism but also with regard to its acute methodology. Yet readers will undoubtedly be rewarded for their efforts. Examining playtexts from the York and Chester cycle plays in tandem with contemporary urban documents, Rice and Pappano attend to the highly particular and distinct ways that artisans crafted their pageants—and thereby their civic identity. The result, however, is neither limited nor parochial, but a keen, persuasive, and truly diachronic account of the political, economic, and cultural pressures that attended cycle performances in the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries.
Considering its careful attention to primary sources, the book might be forgiven for attaching little weight to the work of other scholars, but in fact it engages profoundly with both long-standing, well-established scholarship and recent contributions to the field. For example, Rice and Pappano replace the traditional dyadic model of civic identity, which opposes artisans and merchants, with a nuanced field of subjectivities that includes master craftsmen as well as enfranchised and “unenfranchised” (8) artisans working as wage laborers or servants. They also lend a rich, new texture to the achievement of dramatic character in cycles as they invite us to reexamine familiar figures like Noah's wife, Judas, Cain, and many others whose artisanal, mercantile, or juridical identities would have been transparent to York and Chester audiences.
Following a lengthy introduction that prepares the reader for the rigorous historical study ahead, the first chapter considers the complex and highly fraught relationship between Corpus Christi processions and the cycle plays, arguing that the opening pageants depicting the fall of the angels dramatically rewrite the hierarchies of the annual procession in ways that are both more favorable to artisanal interests and sharply critical of mayoral authority, even to the point of threatening the civic unity that the feast was intended to celebrate. Chapter 2 studies the search of the wise men for the Christ Child in York's Herod and the Magi in light of the controversial policy of “searching” (83), whereby craft goods were subjected to quality-control inspections by city authorities. Dramatic representation bears witness to the paradoxes of searching: it is a strategy that, depending on its implementation and enforcement, can impose craft distinctions or build artisanal fellowship.
The Civic Cycles hits full stride in Chapters 3, 4, and 5, where the implications of the authors’ more sophisticated account of urban artisanal identity is teased out in distinct ways. The third chapter is illustrative of the book's overarching methodology. A close examination of guild ordinances situates the York “Judas plays” and Cain and Abel in the context of a multifaceted civic culture comprising merchants, artisans, servants, journeymen, and apprentices. Rice and Pappano subsequently read these pageants diachronically across the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries in order to show how these groups distinguished themselves from one another. From this perspective, Judas emerges as an unruly servant who attempts to usurp his master's mercantile privilege by setting up shop for himself, whereas Cain is a figure stigmatized by Tudor vagrancy laws.
Chapter 4's study of women's work in the Chester Whitsun cycle should garner much scholarly attention, particularly as it revisits Mrs. Noah as a worker as well as a wife and mother and argues that the labor of women must be understood in relation to the “mystification” (178) of urban male craft labor over and against tedious, unspecialized agrarian peasant labor. Rice and Pappano, furthermore, challenge the long tradition of seeing Noah's wife as a stereotypical shrew by demonstrating the importance of women's networks in premodern civic life. The fifth and final chapter contrasts the rather hopeful vision of collaboration between merchants and artisans in the York Mercers’ Doomsday with the subversive social satire of the Chester Weavers’ Last Judgment. Many readers will take particular interest in the fascinating account of the changing urban environment of Chester during the 1570s. The book's Epilogue downplays the significance of religious reform, contending, rather, that class dynamics overtook local craft identity and led to the dissolution of civic cycle drama.
Though introduced as a study of both the York and Chester cycles, it might be argued that the authors give more attention to, or are perhaps more comfortable with, the former. Yet scholars familiar with either or both urban dramas will find much here to consider in light of Rice and Pappano's intercyclical study. To highlight one brief example, Chapter 3 contrasts the cycles’ two very different depictions of Judas: the sycophantic yet self-interested servant of the York pageants and the swaggering, greedy merchant we find in the Chester plays. Individual chapters may easily be assigned for reading in graduate-level seminars, and excerpted passages may be illustrative for advanced undergraduates as models of the professional use of documentary evidence in support of literary close reading. Early drama scholars may quibble with individual chapters, but The Civic Cycles is a book that cannot be ignored and may very well remain definitive.
