In Arabs and Iranians in the Islamic Conquest Narrative, Scott Savran explores how Muslim historians, writing primarily during the period 750–1050 in both Arabic and Persian, came to terms with and gave meaning to the Arab conquest of Iran. Savran examines these issues through a study of representations of Arab-Sassanian relations in Islamic historical writing. Early on, the author argues for two primary phases of narrative construction that coincide with two periods of identity formation under the ‘Abbasid Caliphate. The first focuses on the creation of a unified Arab identity which Savran argues was constructed in response to the growing influence of Iranian culture on the ‘Abbasid court and society as well as to counter the Shu‘ubiyya “movement.” In this vein, the “Arab versus ‘ajam” discourse found in descriptions of Arab-Sassanian relations embodied “a dialogue between two competing visions of Islamic civilization,” one modeled off the socially stratified absolute monarchies of Near Eastern empires and the other inspired by the austere egalitarianism of pre-Islamic tribal Arabia. The second phase emerged in the late ninth century, at the outset of the “Iranian Intermezzo,” when historians of Iranian descent integrated pre-Islamic Iranian history into a broader Islamic salvific history by which Iranians could – through conversion to Islam and acknowledging the faults of their Sassanian forbearers – rise again to their rightful place at the front of a world empire.
In chapters 1 and 2, Savran lays out these arguments along with his theoretical approaches and methodologies. He engages the concept of “collective memory” and emphasizes its role in shaping group identity through the writing of historical narratives, invoking the theories of Maurice Halbwacks and Hayden White. In recent years, questions of memory and identity have become increasingly important to the study of the early and medieval Islamic historical tradition and Savran acknowledges the important studies, especially the work of Sarah Bowen Savant on which he relies heavily throughout. Chapters 3 through 7 then explore the representation of specific moments of contact between Arabs and Sassanians as narrated by Muslim historians of the eighth through eleventh centuries. The narratives and anecdotes Savran explores begin with the rise of the Sassanian Empire in the third century and its conflicts with Arabs expanding north into Iraq and Syria and end with the assassination of the last Sassanian Shahanshah Yazdgird III. In each of these chapters, Savran identifies tropes, topoi, and themes related to the contrasting identities of the Arabs (rugged, ascetic, eloquent, etc.) and Iranians (ostentatious, tyrannical, cruel, etc.) and the foreshadowing of the Islamic conquests and the turn (dawla) from Sassanian to Arab Muslim rule.
Although the book begins with an exploration of “collective memory” and related theories, Savran unevenly carries this into chapters 3 through 7, which instead read like a catalogue of anecdotes. It may be worthwhile to note that this book derives largely from the author's 2011 University of Wisconsin dissertation but with a modified focus and framework. The dissertation emphasized the culture and context of historical writing under the ‘Abbasids, a discussion of which covered three full chapters, but in this book, the same discussion has been condensed into one chapter of 33 pages including notes. Instead, Savran has placed the focus on the idea that historical reports of Arab-Sassanian relations are part of the titular “Islamic conquest narrative,” a narrative that begins in the third century, thus reducing the history of the Sassanian Empire down to a kerygmatic narrative prophesizing the inevitable victory of Islam over the Iranians. It is surprising that a book with the Islamic conquests in its title includes only one chapter (7) that addresses the Islamic conquests themselves, primarily through a discussion of the Battle of Qadisiyya and surrounding events.
There are many challenges to Savran's reading of ‘Abbasid-era reports of Sassanian history as pieces of a kerygmatic narrative of the Islamic conquest of Iran. First and foremost is that the reports he analyzes in chapters 3 through 7 do not emerge from the same set of sources or historiographical traditions. Instead they are scattered across several traditions, which may not have been problematic had the concept of two phases of narrative and identity formation been carried into these later chapters, or if more content was devoted to demonstrating how different threads emerged at different times and places and intertwined with each other. The author references the similar language used to describe both Arabs and Iranians in the Greco-Roman tradition, which shows that the dialogue between the Arabs and Iranians relied on a broader set of tropes and images used throughout the Mediterranean. References to similar descriptions of Hephthalites and Turks point further to a broader dialogue between nomadic and settled populations. Towards the end of chapter 7, Savran even shows that a similar language was employed to describe interactions between the Arabs and Romans – albeit in language more appropriate for an Abrahamic rival – and, therefore, attributing this language to a structured kerygmatic conquest narrative focused on Iran appears to be a stretch.
The subject of Savran's book engages historical writing in the ‘Abbasid period, which he addresses well in chapter 2, but it also engages the larger historiographical traditions surrounding the Sassanian Empire, pre-Islamic Arabia, and the Islamic conquests and here the book could benefit from a stronger foundation. Key questions of these fields seem unaddressed. For example, on page two, Savran refers to both the Arab conquests and the Muslim conquests. Each term has its own meaning and nuance and a reader will expect that a book on “the Islamic conquest narrative” would address these meanings and maintain consistent terminology.
The nature of the project itself is very important. Historians of Iran need to spend more time crossing the boundary between Sassanian and Early Islamic history, and, by examining the ways ‘Abbasid-era historians wrote about both topics, Savran is inviting an important discussion about how this past was constructed that should influence the way we approach our sources.
