The publication of Jane Hathaway's “Problems of Periodization in Ottoman History: The Fifteenth through Eighteenth Centuries” (Turkish Studies Association Bulletin 20 [1996]: 25–31) served as a critical intervention in a field desperately seeking an alternative narrative arc to golden ageism and decline, and her subsequent collaborative work since then has opened new frameworks for analysis. Hathaway's latest edited volume, The Arab Lands in the Ottoman Era, further embodies this commitment, as the collected essays productively challenge dominant paradigms for Ottoman imperial history and introduce multiple vantage points from which to reenvision the meaning of the book's title: what is “Arab” and when does the “Ottoman Era” end?
The volume emerged from a conference held at the University of Minnesota in honor of Caesar Farah, and the range of Professor Farah's own research interests—19th-century Yemen, Mamluk-era textual traditions, and Islamic discursive transformations—is reflected in the book's geographical breadth and topical diversity. However, it is the scholar's commitment to exploring the “checkered relationship” between Arabs and Ottomans that stands as the true inspiration for this volume. Each contributing essay explores interactions between imperial and regional histories, revealing the unwieldy mobility of both analytic categories and historical realities and providing the reader with refreshing and unexpected insights. Typical binaries of center and province, of Ottoman peripheralization in the face of new global capitalism, of Sunni and Shiʿi, of state and society, of artisan or pilgrim and merchant, or even of Arab nationalism and Ottoman colonization crumble into the manifold vectors of: negotiated trade and historiographic tensions in the Yemen and Indian Ocean (G. Rex Smith, Samer Traboulsi, Giancarlo Casale); Mamluk versus kul-centric interpretations of post-conquest Ottoman Egypt (Jane Hathaway); dramatic linguistic duels in an already deeply heterogeneous Egyptian Sufi landscape and new boundaries between “Turk” and “Arab” (Erik S. Ohlander); Russian religious pilgrimage ideals transformed into antiquarian sensibilities (Svetlana Kirillina); Maghribi hajjis and ʿulamaʾ who intervened in the spiritual and political norms of Ottoman Egypt and the Hijaz and thereby reshaped their own regional commitments (Vladimir Orlov); fez commerce between Tunis and Istanbul and the amorphous boundaries between immigrant tradesmen and guild members (Suraiya Faroqhi); durable trade routes to the East and intensive distributive networks indicating a resilient 18th-century Syrian market economy, or a dynamic agricultural geography mapped by indigenous voices in the 20th century (Rhoads Murphey and Samir Seikaly); and musical intervals of the maqam system (itself neither Arab nor Ottoman) wafting across time and space to the shores of North America and surviving in new social networks that embody lost imperial cultural horizons on university campuses (Kay Hardy Campbell).
This is a heady list, to be sure, and exemplifies both the unique qualities of this volume and the more comprehensive challenges faced by edited collections. It is a rather routine act, in review formats, to comment on the potential unevenness and lack of cohesion in texts that bundle together multiple essays (in this case, eleven and an introduction) and thus multiple voices with distinct stylistic and methodological frames. In some small measure this is true here, as the essays range in content from what amounts to briefly annotated lists of historical texts or musical notations, to short exercises in single-case analysis, to comparative textual criticism or reflective commentary on entrenched historiographical biases (the “hobby horses” of imperial Ottoman history, as Rhoads Murphey amusingly labeled these unyielding paradigms). Yet, as Hathaway's introduction indicates, it is beneficial for the reader to look upon the wide-ranging volume as a compendium of current research and an effort, via its placement within the University of Minnesota's Studies in Early Modern History series, to depart from the isolationist impulse of the Ottoman studies field.
First, the broad range of sources deployed throughout the volume indicates the resourcefulness of scholars dedicated to questions concerning interstitial life—the in-between of social experience, political action, mercantile programs, and ideological expectations. Imperial financial registers, correspondence issued from the imperial council to provincial leaders, court records, hagiographies, biographical dictionaries, newspapers, notational systems, travelogues, and jurisprudential treatises all loop through the pages and present a striking view of the rich textual terrain produced across the Ottoman period. Still, only Murphey and Faroqhi briefly reference architectural features (the shift from religious to commercial buildings in Aleppo and the construction of a Tunisian lonja in Istanbul, respectively) and material and visual approaches to imperial dynamics remain outside of this otherwise impressive sweep.
Second, the wide geographic (the Yemen, Egypt, the Maghrib, Greater Syria, Istanbul, Indian Ocean dynamics, and even Russian aspirations) and chronological (exploring continuities between pre- and post-Ottoman conquest dynamics, and encompassing dynamics that span the 16th to the 21st centuries) sweep trumps the linguistic chauvinism or regional nationalisms that have subtly influenced Arab/Ottoman relationships for quite some time. Yet at no point are the terms “Arab” and “Turk” or “Ottoman” fully explored either as historical categories or as mechanisms for reproducing a divide that many of the experiences analyzed in the essays seem to subvert. Ohlander uses the scare quotes, thereby indicating a self-consciousness about the terminology, and corporate partnerships between imperial and provincial actors emerge as both a frame and a subject of analysis throughout the text, but the reader is left without a fully realized exploration of (or reinvestment in) the constructed nature of this terminology. Notions of the “other,” as a somewhat facile theoretical stance, often stand in for a firm engagement with these issues.
Third, and perhaps most strikingly, the essays as a whole represent a combined move against key metanarratives in the broader field of Ottoman studies. Joining a wave of publications intent on “re-mapping” both the shape and trajectory of the Ottoman Empire, the authors included in The Arab Lands in the Ottoman Era assert key historiographic points. There were indeed state-directed and coordinated programs of investment with long-term commercial objectives in both the 16th and the late 18th centuries; there were moments in which the Ottomans were core exporters of military technology in the Indian Ocean region, especially. The authors further demonstrate in productive ways that the intensification of regional and overland trade undermines theories of economic peripheralization; guild dynamics were diffuse and porous with artisans, merchants, and immigrants together creating a nexus between long-distance traders and retail distributors; intellectual diffusion was circular, not unidirectional, and language itself became a topos in the construction of authority between rival religious and political ideologies. Finally, perhaps the strongest assertion from the volume as a whole is that the 18th century was a period of vibrant creativity and re-investment and not an abyss between pinnacle and decline. Overall, then, two main threads emerge from the essays: an opening of the Ottoman “economic mind” from a closed circle of rigid provisionism and a willingness to hold in the balance regional commitments with imperial identities so as to bridge the gap in often episodic treatments of Ottoman provincial history. One key tension remains, and is perhaps best articulated in the difference between Faroqhi and Murphey's methodological strategies. When faced with a dearth of sources about a particular issue (say, Maghribi immigration to Istanbul or the manufacturing of raw silk in Aleppo), do we change our research questions or read the sources in a different way? It is precisely this question that renders the volume meaningful for a range of audiences, specialist and student alike, as a general survey of the state of the field, and a rare chance to see exploratory research evolve before our eyes. An agenda for the future, then, might be to more clearly redefine the categories we use to interrogate past paradigms and thus begin to fulfill the aspirations contained within these disparate essays.
