The insight that nature has a temporal dimension is usually considered to have been one of the most important scientific breakthroughs of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries: geology began acknowledging the enormous age of the earth, natural historians were faced with fossils and in embryology epigenetics finally triumphed over preformationism. Epigenetic theories claimed that during individual development from the fertilized egg to the adult, new structures are emerging and not just unfolding from a preformed state. Biology, which was constituted at the turn from the eighteenth to the nineteenth century as an autonomous science, created a series of concepts such as reproduction, heredity and race that were built upon this temporal dimension of life. In her exciting but sometimes meandering new book, Janina Wellmann puts forward the thesis that notions of time in early biology were not restricted to linear conceptions. She argues compellingly that around 1800 individual development was thought of in terms of rhythmic patterns, movements and representations. Wellmann goes even further in claiming that, between 1760 and 1830, ‘rhythm’ became a central and fundamental epistemic category in a wide range of intellectual and artistic endeavours.
With bravura, Wellmann leads the reader through literary, poetological and musical theory, the history of science and of visual representations. She expounds how the poet Friedrich Gottlieb Klopstock (1724–1803) valorized rhythm as an independent aspect of poetry's expressivity and how Friedrich Hölderlin (1770–1843) and Karl Philipp Moritz (1756–1793) conceived of rhythm as an ordering principle that was common to art and nature. Johann Wolfgang von Goethe's theory of metamorphosis described the individual development of vascular plants as pulsating between phases of expansion and contraction. Goethe, however, understood metamorphosis as a universal principle. Again, it was a principle that brought forth the creations of both art and nature. For Goethe and other thinkers, rhythm was also important because it exhibited regular, law-like patterns, but allowed the expression of variation and the formation of novelties as well. Wellmann identifies the first rhythmic conception of embryonic development in Caspar Friedrich Wolff's path-breaking work on the chicken embryo from 1764. According to the author, Wolff depicts early development as a rhythmic change between fluid and solid phases of the vesicular basic substance of the embryo. Ignaz Döllinger and his students, Heinrich Christian Pander and Karl Ernst von Baer, continued Wolff's work and laid the foundations of modern embryology. Also these scientists used rhythm as an important epistemic concept to explain individual development. Pander employed spatial and temporal patterns of foldings of the germlayers, which successively differentiate the embryo, while von Baer described the formation of the embryo in terms of rhythmic bendings and foldings of membranes. The visual representations of the complex choreography of movements during individual development remind Wellmann of illustrated instruction books devoted to teaching dances or the use of weapons that were widespread in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. The author represents a school which claims that scientists actually think and argue using images and that visual representations are far more than mere illustrations of theories and concepts which are only properly expressed in words or in mathematical terms. Wellmann exemplifies her thesis by pointing out the common visual tools that were utilized to represent both intricate human rhythmic movement patterns and the immensely complex events during embryonic development, which could no longer be described with the help of a linear narrative. In order to overcome this challenge, embryologists, especially von Baer, developed an elaborate blend of image and description. The use of complex visual tools enabled the observer's gaze to wander through the spatial and temporal changes in the developing embryo and to create a three-dimensional sense of the events emerging from a two-dimensional representation. According to the author, the developmental series did not correspond to the chronological order, but showed a rhythmic–periodical order that was inherent to the developing organism.
The sheer amount and diversity of the evidence marshalled by Wellmann in support of her thesis is overwhelming and appears to allow no other conclusion than that rhythm had in fact become a central and widely employed epistemic category by the end of the eighteenth century. However, there are grounds for raising some concerns. After Wellmann's detailed presentation of the way rhythmic conceptions were taken up in poetological and musical theory, in visual representations in instruction books and in embryology, it remains unclear how this concept managed to become so successful and pervasive. The lack of established and enforced disciplinary boundaries is certainly one explanation and it comes as no surprise that persons such as Goethe, Novalis or Hölderlin should have been able to build conceptual bridges between art, literature and the natural sciences. Also Karl Ernst von Baer, Christian Heinrich Pander and Ignaz Döllinger, the leading embryologists of the early nineteenth century, had close contact with August Wilhelm Schlegel and Goethe and this facilitated the circulation of ideas across boundaries. It remains, however, mysterious how the medical doctor and anatomist Caspar Friedrich Wolff, who is not known for his intimate acquaintance with poetry or musical theory, could have been inspired already in the mid-eighteenth century to develop a rhythmic theory of individual development. Wellmann's study thus leaves an important gap. The material or institutional factors that enabled this widespread uptake of ‘rhythm’ as an epistemic category await identification and analysis.
Despite this objection, the author has to be praised for her effort and for putting into focus conceptions of time in the biological sciences. Chronobiology is a thriving modern field of research and to provide a first step to the historical contextualization of the theories and practices of this discipline is a major achievement of the author. This study is also a very welcome addition to the still small corpus of works that deal with pre-Darwinian embryology and should provide a needed stimulus to further work.
