The late republican idea of Rome as a city of seven hills (Septimontium) marked only a phase in a long history of topographical symbolism. The identities associated with the city's hills changed over time to suit the priorities of successive ages and dynasties. The papers in this volume, organised roughly by chronological order and with thematic connections between them, illustrate this process across nearly a millennium of history. The collection results from a colloquium held by the Société Internationale des Études Néroniennes (SIEN) in 2015, in preparation for 2016's Neronia X conference on the Palatine, which has now generated a separate volume.
Domenico Palombi's opening chapter concerns the sacra Argeorum, a ritual procession of priests, magistrates and people around twenty-seven sacella within the Servian wall. These rites encompassed much of the early city and offer insights into its urban landscape, though their meaning and origins were obscure even in antiquity. Palombi surveys a huge bibliography and usefully lays out the source material. He considers various attempts to reconcile the number and distribution of the sacella with other forms of ordering of the early city (the four Servian regions, the thirty Romulean curiae) and their possible archaeological and epigraphic traces, arguing that the rites preserve traces of a pre-urban stage of Rome's history. The Varronian city of seven hills, the Palatine preeminent among them, was a long way into the future: the sacra Argeorum offer a view into an archaic topography in which this spatial hierarchy did not yet exist.
Yann Berthelet also considers republican associations of space with religion, revisiting the question of the auguracula for comitia in the Campus Martius and Forum. He argues (against Coarelli) that the magistrate's inauguratio was conducted in the locations of the comitia themselves, rather than from the hills, and distinguished the magistrate as holder of potestas cum auspiciis, a spatio-legal demonstration of the aristocratic character of the republic.
Manuel de Souza examines the role of the Sacer Mons, a little way to the north of the city, in the plebeian secessions of 494 and 449 b.c. In retreating to the edge of the city and withdrawing their military service the plebeians disarmed the patriciate, but were reluctant to break their military oath (sacramentum), giving a religious dimension to the dispute. The persuasive paper argues that the plebeians, without recourse to law, used religio to put the city under an obligation to respect the persons of their tribunes, and marked as sacred the site of this innovation. Sacred oaths and the dedication of an altar to Jupiter on the hill, and sacrifices back in the city, thus marked an essentially religious resolution to the crisis, giving the Mons Sacer its name.
Joëlle Prim considers how historical associations within the city were appropriated and overlaid with new or rival meanings as a political strategy. Memories of the Aventine as a place of populist sedition were neutralised by its integration into the Augustan Septimontium. Horace included it in his Carmen saeculare, and Livy (as in the previous chapter) located the beginnings of the plebeian secession on the Mons Sacer, portraying the Aventine as a place of reconciliation and compromise rather than a territory of conflict. Claudius’ enlargement of the pomerium to include the Aventine marked a further integration, though contested interpretations remained possible. Over time, ‘the essential role of forgetting’ (97) allowed an ideological repositioning of the hill shorn of memories of civil conflict. While it would also be possible to view this evolution in the practical context of a constantly growing city, Prim's focus, like that of the volume as a whole, is on political symbolism and topographical memory.
Clément Chillet asks whether the accumulated ‘symbolic capital’ of the Esquiline as a seat of power led Nero to anchor one end of his palace complex there. It looks for political identities at a ‘district’ or ‘neighbourhood’ (‘quartier’) level, building on Palombi's identification of a neighbourhood of Pompeian supporters in the Carinae to give us a picture of an area where topography seems to have aligned with political groupings. Over time this area acquired other links to people associated with Caesar and his heir. Maecenas’ garden estates transformed the landscape of the hill and accommodated an Augustan intellectual and artistic ‘court’ comparable to Pompey's, setting the scene for Nero's transformations.
The Pincio has never had a claim to membership of the canonical seven hills. A Temple of Fortune, private elite houses and garden pavilions crowned the hill, including a huge Claudian-era theatre-shaped nymphaeum in the Gardens of Lucullus. Vincent Jolivet argues that these buildings were in a ‘dialectic’ relationship with the public buildings of the plain below. The nymphaeum faced directly towards Augustus’ Mausoleum in the Campus Martius, echoing the theatre–Mausoleum relationship at Halicarnassus, and could be interpreted as a gesture of support for or rivalry with the imperial dynasty, or of imperial control after Claudius forced its aristocratic builder to suicide and confiscated the gardens where it stood. Later the loggia of Belisarius’ villa here was oriented on an important new sightline, pointing south to Theodosius’ Basilica of St Paul. The area was later reshaped again by ambitious Cardinals, facing now towards the Vatican.
Olivier Devillers considers Tiberius’ compensation of the victims of a fire on the Caelian Hill in a.d. 27. Tacitus’ record of the emperor's largesse and the Senate's flattering response — it offered to rename the hill the ‘Augustan’ — evokes a regal precedent for an earlier change of name from Querquetulanus to Caelius. Tacitus perhaps draws on the emperor Claudius’ Etruscan history here, bypassing the Senate's search for a republican precedent: thus Tacitus ‘shows … the inadequacy of republican frameworks for the representation of emperors’ (130), and hints that the fire is an ill omen for the disastrous removal of Tiberius to Capri.
Yves Perrin looks at the role of the hills in the spatial organisation of political power during the reign of Nero, seen in the context of an ideological process of topographical and political control initiated by Augustus. He sees in Nero's projects a marked and perhaps surprising respect for the cults and temples of the Capitol, and in particular for Jupiter. Perrin's tour of five of Nero's hills is brief (he refers to the separate work on the Palatine for more detail) but elegant and insightful. Perrin argues that the Domus Aurea did not isolate Nero from the city, as has been claimed, but offered from every side views out over the urban districts which surrounded it, like the royal palaces of Hellenistic cities. He concludes by considering the famous Colossus of Nero, whose head was roughly on a level with the Capitoline Temple of Jupiter, and visible from all over the city and beyond.
The last chapter is a short analysis of Ammianus Marcellinus’ and Claudian's accounts of late antique imperial adventus in Rome and what they tell us about the symbolic importance accorded to the city in fourth-century literature, when understanding of its sacred and political topography was fading under Christian influences. Florence Garambois-Vasquez argues that Ammianus’ account of the Christian emperor Constantius II's adventus in a.d. 357 describes a hollow, triumph-like entry, while Claudian's verse account of Honorius’ adventus of 404 delivers a political view of the emperor's power, acknowledging in ecphrasis the symbolic significance of the Palatine and Capitoline hills.
Inevitably the coverage of the essays in this slim volume is selective, and the focus on ‘the question of the organisation of power, but also of its representation’ (Chillet, 99) elides practical questions about the growth and evolution of the city which surely also underpinned some of the changes charted here. Overall, though, the volume contributes to a growing body of scholarship on the symbolic geography of the city, and its well-chosen examples illuminate a series of interactions between the geography of Rome, real and symbolic, and its history.
