The focus of this book is on how different theoretical positions and perspectives on ‘race’ have shaped housing and related policy and practice in the UK. Beider reviews key trends and approaches to the problem of ‘race’, cross-party policy ‘solutions’ and housing policy sector responses. This provides a context for the book's central premise, which is to lay the foundations for new ideas and frameworks to develop academic and policy debates on race and housing. It is a timely and thought-provoking text, which contextualises debates on race and government policy responses within shifting and overlapping ideological backdrops. This book is recommended reading for students studying social policy, sociology, housing and politics. It is also a useful reference for academics, practitioners and policy makers.
In chapter 1, Beider establishes the theoretical frameworks which underpin the subsequent chapters. He revisits different perspectives on ‘race’ and delineates these into four chronological yet overlapping strands. First, ‘passive culturalism’ characterised discourse on race in the 1950s and 1960s, and immigration and immigrants, rather than discrimination, were seen as potential threats to social stability. The second theoretical development from the 1960s and 1970s accounted for the existence of power in race relations and the role of conflict between different groups which were becoming evident in housing outcomes. Third, ‘choice and constraint’ theories explain the processes involved in housing-based segregation encompassing power, and a consideration of structure and agency is addressed. Finally, theories of cultural resistance shift the focus and reconceptualise ‘race’ as an analytical concept, where, instead of perceiving it as fixed, the processes of constructing race are taken into account.
Chapter 2 provides a discussion of housing policy and practice and includes a vigorous critique of community cohesion and the role of housing providers. Beider addresses the limitations in the race and housing debate, framing this in terms of a shift from multiculturalism to cohesion to integration, and is critical of this move from progressive to regressive policies on race and housing.
Beider argues that there is a gap in knowledge on white working-class communities and chapter 3 provides a focus on community cohesion and housing from the perspective of such communities. This chapter challenges previous assumptions that the white working classes have benefited from discrimination against new minority groups and suggests that more work is needed on understanding the relationship between class, ‘race’ and culture.
In chapter 4, Beider contextualises the development of the black-led housing sector in terms of the shift in policy towards ‘race’ and highlights that the shifting emphasis on equality generally, rather than race specifically, calls into question the role of black-specific housing organisations. He frames this in terms of questioning whether ‘race’ should be the primary focus in contemporary discussions about equality.
The central focus of chapter 5, and what the book has been building up to, is that new ideas and frameworks are needed to develop academic and policy debates in relation to race, housing and ultimately cohesion. Beider refers to ‘super-diversity’ to describe the changing demography of the UK and argues that debates on race and housing can no longer remain fixed to discourse of the 1950s. New groups and communities have emerged in the UK and this has shifted the parameters of what is now understood by ‘race’. Drawing on structuration theory, Beider argues that super-diversity needs to be considered in the context of choice and constraint. The term ‘recycled racism’ is employed to describe conflicts between established minority and emerging communities, and it is posited that there is an urgent need to explore the relationships between different communities, currently absent in policy and academic debates.
In chapter 6, Beider concludes by suggesting new ideas and directions on how race, housing and community (cohesion) could be developed. Arguing that existing theory and practice use outmoded models of analysis, Beider also highlights challenges and opportunities for researchers in the field. He is emphatic that the idea that ‘race’ is fixed needs to shift and be placed within the context of super-diversity and modern society. Beider's solution is to get beyond ‘race’ and discussions that could be seen as self-interested and to reconfigure BME housing associations as ‘agents of change’ in society. He also argues that it is necessary to find alternative representatives to ‘community leaders’ and to move towards a shared vision of ‘race’, housing and community.
However, a tacit message in this book is that the issues surrounding race, housing and cohesion have not been resolved, and subsuming race into overarching discussions of equality in general, although necessary, could potentially be damaging to the future of discussion on race. An important contribution that Beider's book makes is in highlighting the areas where further debate is needed.
