Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-wxvwp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T04:10:11.742Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Wake-induced transition in the low-Reynolds-number flow over a multi-element airfoil

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 March 2021

Jiang-Sheng Wang
Affiliation:
Fluid Mechanics Key Laboratory of Education Ministry, Beijing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Beijing 100191, China
Jin-Jun Wang*
Affiliation:
Fluid Mechanics Key Laboratory of Education Ministry, Beijing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Beijing 100191, China
*
†Email address for correspondence: jjwang@buaa.edu.cn

Abstract

Time-resolved particle image velocimetry and hydrogen bubble visualization are used to investigate the wake-induced transition of a 30P30N multi-element airfoil at a fixed angle of attack of 4° within the stowed chord Reynolds-number range of 1.38 × 104 to 3.05 × 104. A special transition routine, strongly affected by the slat wake, is observed in the confluent boundary layer over the 30P30N airfoil. In particular, the effects of slat-wake-triggered double-secondary vortices on the whole transition process are explored in detail. At the initial transition stage, the strong slat-wake disturbances penetrate the boundary layer of the main element and are then amplified by double-exponential growth to generate double-secondary vortices. Compared to the scenarios of simplified geometries (He et al., J. Fluid Mech., vol. 718, 2013, pp. 116–130; He & Wang, Phys. Fluids, vol. 27, 2015, 024106), the double-exponential growth provides stronger fluctuations for the transition. At the intermediate transition stage, the wake disturbances trigger the three-dimensional destabilization of these secondary vortices by direct injection or indirect induction, leading to Λ vortices. The spanwise wavelength of the consequent Λ vortices is therefore locked on by the wake disturbances. At the late transition stage, the Λ vortices evolve into hairpin vortex packets and finally contribute to an attached turbulent boundary layer above the main element. Throughout the transition process, no obvious separation occurs in the mean flow above the main element, revealing potential aerodynamic benefits.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Side view of PIV measurements. PIV1 and PIV2 focus on the flows around the gap region and the centre part of the main element, respectively. The black boxes denote the fields of view of PIV1 and PIV2.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Plan view of PIV measurements. The black lines denote the laser sheets of PIV3 and PIV4.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Plan view of hydrogen bubble visualization. The horizontal hydrogen bubble curtain is designed to strike the forward stagnation point of the main element and further visualizes the flow structures within the boundary layer of the main element. The distance between the camera and airfoil is longer than indicated by the current sketch.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Mean resultant velocity contours with the superimposition of streamlines: (a) Rec = 1.38 × 104; (b) Rec = 1.83 × 104; (c) Rec = 2.41 × 104; and (d) Rec = 3.05 × 104. The velocities are normalized by U∞. The magenta lines in panel (d) define the sampling positions for the velocity and total kinetic energy profiles in figures 5–8. Although the streamlines in PIV1 have been reported by Wang et al. (2018b), it is relevant to combine them with the streamlines of PIV2 here for an integrated topology of the confluent boundary above the main element.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Mean resultant velocity profiles from PIV1. The profiles in (a–h) are extracted from positions 1–8 in figure 4, respectively. Here YL is the local wall-normal coordinate with the origin located at the airfoil surface. The velocities are normalized by U∞. As Rec increases, the profiles are coloured red, blue, magenta and black.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Mean resultant velocity profiles from PIV2. The profiles in (a–h) are extracted from positions 9–16 in figure 4, respectively. Here YL is the local wall-normal coordinate with the origin located at the airfoil surface. The velocities are normalized by U∞. As Rec increases, the profiles are coloured red, blue, magenta and black.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Total kinetic energy profiles from PIV1. The profiles in (a–h) are extracted from positions 1–8 in figure 4, respectively. Here YL is the local wall-normal coordinate with the origin located at the airfoil surface. The kinetic energy is normalized by the square of U∞. As Rec increases, the profiles are coloured red, blue, magenta and black.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Total kinetic energy profiles from PIV2. The profiles in (a–h) are extracted from positions 9–16 in figure 4, respectively. Here YL is the local wall-normal coordinate with the origin located at the airfoil surface. The kinetic energy is normalized by the square of U∞. As Rec increases, the profiles are coloured red, blue, magenta and black.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Boundary layer parameters above the main element: (a) thickness of the boundary layer and (b) shape factor (H). Here δ is the boundary layer thickness determined by the edge of the boundary layer; δ* is the displacement thickness; θ is the momentum thickness; and Xδ defines the streamwise location of the boundary edge. As Rec increases, the profiles are coloured red, blue, magenta and black. The shape factors of the laminar Blasius boundary layer (H = 2.59) and turbulent boundary layer with zero pressure gradients (H = 1.4) are provided in panel (b) for reference.

Figure 9

Figure 10.Root-mean-square contours of $v^{tran}$ ($v_{rms}^{tran}/{U_\infty }$): (a) Rec = 1.38 × 104; (b) Rec = 1.83 × 104; (c) Rec = 2.41 × 104; and (d) Rec = 3.05 × 104. The black dots and magenta crosses are located at the local maxima of $v_{rms}^{tran}/{U_\infty }$. The magenta crosses are designed to monitor the local PSDs in the slat wake (cross 1) and in the confluent boundary layer above the main element (crosses 2–9). The black dots are designed to track the fluctuations in the boundary layer above the main element.

Figure 10

Figure 11.Fluctuation tracking along the local maxima of $v_{rms}^{tran}/{U_\infty }$ (black dots of figure 10). As Rec increases, the related results are coloured red, blue, magenta and black. The dashed orange lines denote the fit of $v_{rms}^{tran}/{U_\infty }$ after Rec = 1.83 × 104.

Figure 11

Figure 12.Revisiting of slat-wake-triggered double-secondary vortices at Rec = 1.83 × 104 by VDV: (a) t; (b) t + Δt; (c) t + 2Δt; and (d) t + 3Δt. (e) A zoomed-in view of (d) with the superimposition of fluctuating velocity vectors. Here Δt/T = 0.37, where T is the shedding period of VS; VS denotes the shed vortex of the slat cusp shear layer; and $V_M^1$ and $V_M^2$ denote the two vortices in one topology of double-secondary vortices. The virtual dyes in blue and red are designed to mimic the hydrogen bubble visualization for flow structures of the slat wake and above the main element in Wang et al. (2018b), respectively. The green virtual dye is designed to visualize the flow structures originating from the upper boundary layer of the slat.

Figure 12

Figure 13.Local PSDs of $v^{tran}$ during the formation of double-secondary vortices: (a) Rec = 1.38 × 104; (b) Rec = 1.83 × 104; (c) Rec = 2.41 × 104; and (d) Rec = 3.05 × 104. The PSDs are calculated at crosses 1–6 in figure 10 and remain marked by the same magenta numbers as in figure 10. For clarity, the amplitude of each PSD is amplified step by step by 104 along the streamwise direction. Labels St1, St2 and St3 denote the fundamental frequency, second harmonic and third harmonic, respectively; St0.5 in (c) and St0.36 and St0.66 in (d) denote the subharmonics; and St1.5 and St2.5 in (c) and St1.36 and St1.66 in (d) denote the fractional harmonics. The subscripts of St denote the ratios of peak frequencies to the fundamental frequency. The VF1 and VFS bands contain the fluctuations pertaining to the fundamental frequency and all the frequency peaks, respectively.

Figure 13

Figure 14.Spatial growth of the fluctuations within different frequency bands: (a) Rec = 1.38 × 104; (b) Rec = 1.83 × 104; (c) Rec = 2.41 × 104; and (d) Rec = 3.05 × 104. The fluctuations are extracted from the black dots of figure 10. The red dashed lines denote the exponential fittings. Here S/c represents the curvilinear coordinate located at the local peaks of $v_{rms}^{tran}/{U_\infty }$, and the origin of S/c is defined at the first point of the black dots in figure 10; and X/c shows the streamwise locations of a specific S/c with the coordinates defined in figure 1.

Figure 14

Table 1.The quantitative intervals of VF1 and VFS bands at different Rec.

Figure 15

Figure 15.Hydrogen bubble visualization of the flow structures above the main element at Rec = 1.83 × 104. Panels (a–i) show a time sequence with an interval of Δt/T = 0.35 between two consecutive instants. Label $V_M^1$ denotes one vortex of double-secondary vortices. The bottom left corner of (g) zooms in the pattern of a Λ vortex. Here ${Z_1}$ denotes the local spanwise coordinate with the origin located to the left of the field of view.

Figure 16

Figure 16.Hydrogen bubble visualization of the flow structures above the main element at Rec = 1.38 × 104. Panels (a–i) show a time sequence with an interval of Δt/T = 0.30 between two consecutive instants. Label $V_M^1$ denotes one vortex of double-secondary vortices. The bottom left corner of (g) zooms in the pattern of a Λ vortex. Here ${Z_1}$ denotes the local spanwise coordinate with the origin located to the left of the field of view.

Figure 17

Figure 17.Instantaneous vorticity contours (${\omega _Y}c/{U_\infty }$) of the plan view PIV3 at Rec = 1.83 × 104: (a) overview; and (b) enlarged Λ vortex with the superimposition of velocity vectors in the black box of panel (a). The black line in (a) marks the leading edge of the main element. The flow structures in the slat wake are marked by the magenta box in (a). Here ${Z_2}$ denotes the local spanwise coordinate with the origin located to the left of the field of view.

Figure 18

Figure 18.Global PSDs of streamwise velocity fluctuations from PIV3: (a) Rec = 1.38 × 104; (b) Rec = 1.83 × 104; (c) Rec = 2.41 × 104; and (d) Rec = 3.05 × 104. Label St1 marks the fundamental frequency.

Figure 19

Figure 19.FMD modes of the fundamental frequencies in figure 18: (a) Rec = 1.38 × 104; (b) Rec = 1.83 × 104; (c) Rec = 2.41 × 104; and (d) Rec = 3.05 × 104. Only the mode of streamwise velocity fluctuations is provided here. The pattern of Λ vortices is marked by the magenta ellipse in (b). The black lines mark the leading edge of the main element. Here ${Z_2}$ denotes the local spanwise coordinate with the origin located to the left of the field of view.

Figure 20

Figure 20.The TPC contours of PIV3: (a) Rec = 1.38 × 104; (b) Rec = 1.83 × 104; (c) Rec = 2.41 × 104; and (d) Rec = 3.05 × 104. The magenta dashed lines represent the reference positions for the TPC. The lines located at X/c = 0 and X/c = 0.2 are designed to extract the spanwise wavelengths of the slat wake (S-W) and Λ vortices (Λ-V), respectively. Here ${Z_2}$ denotes the local spanwise coordinate with the origin located to the left of the field of view.

Figure 21

Figure 21.The TPC profiles extracted from the reference positions of figure 20: (a) Rec = 1.38 × 104; (b) Rec = 1.83 × 104; (c) Rec = 2.41 × 104; and (d) Rec = 3.05 × 104. The profiles in the slat wake (S-W) and the profiles related to the Λ vortices (Λ-V) are denoted by black lines with dots and blue lines with upward-pointing triangles, respectively. The minima of R are marked by red crosses. Here ${Z_2}$ denotes the local spanwise coordinate with the origin located to the left of the field of view.

Figure 22

Table 2.Normalized spanwise wavelengths (by c) at different Rec values.

Figure 23

Figure 22.Wake-triggered three-dimensional instability of secondary vortices at Rec = 1.83 × 104. Panels (a,c,e,g) and (b,d,f,h) are two time sequences with Δt/T = 0.37. Panels (a,c,e,g) show the indirect induction of the slat wake for triggering the three-dimensional instability. Panels (b,d,f,h) show the direct injection of the slat wake to trigger the three-dimensional instability. Here VS denotes the shed vortex of the slat cusp shear layer; and $V_M^1$ and $V_M^2$ denote the two vortices in one topology of double-secondary vortices.

Figure 24

Figure 23.Wake-triggered three-dimensional instability of secondary vortices: (a,b) Rec = 1.38 × 104; (c,d) Rec = 2.41 × 104; and (e,f) Rec = 3.05 × 104. Panels (a,c,e) show the indirect induction of the slat wake for triggering the three-dimensional instability. Panels (b,d,f) show the direct injection of the slat wake for triggering the three-dimensional instability. Here VS denotes the shed vortex of the slat cusp shear layer; and $V_M^1$ and $V_M^2$ denote the two vortices in one topology of double-secondary vortices.

Figure 25

Figure 24.Local PSDs of $v^{tran}$ at the late stage of the transitional confluent boundary layer: (a) Rec = 1.38 × 104; (b) Rec = 1.83 × 104; (c) Rec = 2.41 × 104; and (d) Rec = 3.05 × 104. The PSDs are calculated at crosses 7–9 of figure 10 and remain marked by the same magenta numbers as in figure 10. For clarity, the amplitude of each PSD is amplified step by step by 104 along the streamwise direction. Labels St1 and St2 denote the fundamental frequency and second harmonic, respectively.

Figure 26

Figure 25.Hairpin vortex packets revealed by FTLEs: (a) Rec = 1.38 × 104; (b) Rec = 1.83 × 104; (c) Rec = 2.41 × 104; and (d) Rec = 3.05 × 104.

Figure 27

Figure 26.The generation process of a typical hairpin vortex packet at Rec = 1.83 × 104. Panels (a–d) show a time sequence with Δt/T = 0.55. Arrows A, D and E mark three original hairpin vortices. Arrows B and C mark two hairpin vortices reproduced by A. Arrows F and G mark two hairpin vortices reproduced by E.

Figure 28

Figure 27.POD modes of streamwise velocity fluctuations around the centre part of the main element (PIV4): (a) Rec = 1.38 × 104; (b) Rec = 1.83 × 104; (c) Rec = 2.41 × 104; and (d) Rec = 3.05 × 104. Only the first mode is provided at each Rec. Here ${Z_3}$ denotes the local spanwise coordinate with the origin located to the left of the field of view.

Figure 29

Figure 28.Sketch of the wake-induced transition over the main element. The hairpin-like vortices in the slat wake are highlighted in Wang et al. (2018b). Aiming at a clear depiction of the flow physics above the main element, only three cycles of wake vortices are provided in the upper sketch. Notably, these wake vortices are convected downstream after being formed. The slat in the lower sketch is moved upstream for a clear depiction of the flow physics above the main element.