Global justice theorists, both past and presently, tend to raise questions concerning individuals in the abstract, either connected to a particular nation (nationalist theorists), or as citizens of the world (cosmopolitan theorists). Little attention has been paid to how gender relates to global justice in general and to the prospects of particular individuals. In Gender and Global Justice, Alison M. Jaggar has brought together eight theorists (including herself) in order to consider the role gender disparity plays in global justice. While the collection does not have specific sections dedicated to particular questions, the eight chapters can be loosely divided into four themes: i) how traditional theories of justice are inadequate due to the lack of discussion concerning gender; ii) how the transnational migration of women labourers intensifies global gender injustice; iii) how global gender injustice exacerbates low health outcomes for women; and iv) how current tax and resource management might be changed to help diminish global gender injustice. Through these four general themes the theorists come together, not only to highlight how and why global injustice affects women disproportionately, but also to propose solutions to the glaring problems that are often dismissed and even ignored.
In her chapter, Jaggar argues that, by recognizing the social construction of transnational gender disparities, and their connection to the current global order, we will be better equipped to begin assessing these disparities and establishing who is responsible for fixing them. Hye-Ryoung Kang argues that, rather than relying on nationalist or cosmopolitan theories, we should be developing a theory of justice in which women can form transnational collectives as a way of bringing their concerns to the forefront. Both these chapters highlight the inadequacy of current theories of global justice.
Eva Feder Kittay looks at the extensive migration of women who preform ‘care work’ and argues that because the ‘self’ is relational, both care-givers and dependents have a right to care for/be cared for by particular others. Following this she further argues that, in part, the gender injustice caused by migrant care work should be mitigated by sending nations providing help (in some form) to caregivers so that they do not feel that transnational care work is their only option. Rachel Silvey continues the discussion of gender injustice and migrant workers. She considers how geographies (spaces and places) affect gender injustice and the difficulties that arise in allocating responsibilities to both sending- and receiving-nations with respect to workers’ rights. She then argues that the framework of human rights within nation-state boundaries no longer addresses major concerns of global (gender) justice. Both of these chapters highlight the inadequacy of traditional thinking about workers’ rights when dealing with migrant workers, especially care-givers.
Abigail Gosselin argues, through an analysis of socio-economic and hermenutical structural injustices, that women are at high risk of developing certain mental disorders such as postpartum depression and eating disorders. In an effort to address the high risk of mental disorders for women around the world, she argues that we must begin to recognize how these structural injustices are in the background of the social consciousness concerning mental health, and that there are probable links between the structural injustices and the prevalence of these disorders. Linda Martín Alcoff continues the discussion on women’s health by considering how the concepts surrounding sexual violence around the world are not only descriptive and referential, but are also constituting, engendering, and inciting. Focusing on cultural understandings of ‘consent’, ‘honour’, and ‘victim’, she argues that it is unlikely that we will ever have transnational agreement on how to classify and address sexual violence. Nonetheless, she argues, a transcultural discussion is needed in order to develop an understanding of sexual violence around the world. Both of these chapters go far in highlighting how language affects our understanding of women’s health and how transcultural understanding is necessary for the amelioration of women’s poor health outcomes.
Gillian Brock argues that current taxation and accounting arrangements contribute significantly to current global gender injustice. Through different taxation regimes and regulations, the current harms may be mitigated. While such regimes and regulations may not, initially, be unanimously adopted, she argues that partial and gradual adoption has the potential to significantly increase gender justice globally. In the final chapter, Scott Wisor argues that, through feminist assessment and reform, the current ‘natural resource curse’ may be mitigated. There seems to be a causal link between the export of natural resources by developing countries and their current levels of gender injustice. Through feminist inspired reforms, he argues, certain checks and balances may be put in place that decrease current levels of gender injustice. These last two chapters make significant contributions to possible ways of ameliorating global gender injustice.
I find the way in which these authors have collaboratively addressed both some of the causes of global gender injustice, and some possible fixes, refreshing. The collection of papers is not only enlightening—highlighting concerns that have not traditionally been recognized—but the book ends on a (somewhat) uplifting note, pointing us in at least one direction for substantial change. Of course further work is necessary if we are to have a deeper understanding of how gender injustice effects general global injustice. An important move, as highlighted by several of the authors, is that we need to get away from ideal theories of justice, and work towards global justice, both general and gendered, with an eye towards non-ideal, and practical, theories.
