As Sabine Hake points out in her remarkable new book, Nazis were on the mind of Oscar academicians, critics, and audiences in the run-up to the 2009 Academy Awards. Reviewers fretted about “Nazi overload” and mused about “Nazis, Nazis everywhere” (p. 3). They had a point. At least six recently released films showcased Nazis or the Holocaust, including Defiance, The Reader, The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, The Boy in the Striped Pajamas, and Valkyrie, and the first three received Oscar awards or nominations. Nor were the connections between film and fascism anything new. The long list of feature films about Nazis, produced by Hollywood but also by western and eastern European studios, stretches back to the early 1940s when the Nazis still held power; it continues to grow. Why do these clichéd figures still strut across our cinema screens and imaginations, committing unspeakable (yet obviously not unrepresentable) atrocities with a callous disregard for democratic values? What accounts for our apparently deep and unceasing fascination with Nazis on film?
The answer, writes Hake, has to do with the ability of the Nazis to serve so well as the evil twin of democracy, the “absolute other” upon which historical and contemporary understandings of democratic subjectivity depend. In a theoretically rich and extensive argument that can barely be summarized in a short review, Hake suggests that feature films are historical laboratories and “veritable archives of feelings about democracy” (p. 28) and that it is now time to unpack them. Representations of Nazis in feature films inspire feelings, emotions, and investments that create “privileged sites in mainstream cinema for the production of political affects” (p. 24). The affects produced in the intertextual connections among audiences, films, and political and ideological contexts in turn “invariably reproduce the dominant discourses of the political,” revealing much about the conflicted state of contemporary democracy (p. 26).
Screen Nazis pursues this general argument in seven chapters that range across national borders from the 1940s to the present; this long transnational frame opens a comparative approach to the history of democratic subjectivity. Each chapter begins with a discussion of methods and goals, followed by a description of the broad national and political context that frames an in-depth discussion of representative films. The first three chapters explore Hollywood productions from the 1940s, West German movies from the 1950s, and East German films from the 1960s and 1970s. During these Cold-War years, Nazis in realist (or socialist realist) films presented a clear enemy-friend binary that cast Nazis as the antidemocratic other—as fascists and/or communists in the west and capitalists in the east. There were some twists. The “contradictory politics of affect” (p. 95) generated by well-known West German films such as The Devil's General (1954) and Canaris (1955) produced western democratic subjectivities but at the same time opened space for identification with the Nazis themselves. The grim faces portrayed in antifascist films made in the GDR in the 1960s and 1970s, according to Hake, reveal a melancholy confrontation with and acknowledgement of this genre's inability to offer viewers any real “emotional sustenance and political meaning” (p. 99).
The book gains traction in the final four chapters, where Hake identifies a key turning point in films about Nazis that dovetails with the hollowing out of democratic politics after the 1960s. Here she engages theoretical work on the post-ideological or post-political crisis of democracy associated with scholars such as Chantal Mouffe, Ernesto Laclau, and Slavoj Zizek. No longer tied to distinct political ideologies, filmic Nazis begin to represent free-floating evil rather than clear “friend-enemy distinction(s)” (p. 134), an early indicator of democratic crisis. Hake opens this argument with an exploration of the thin line separating Italian art films of the 1970s—Seven Beauties (1975); The Night Porter (1974); Salò, or the 120 Days of Sodom (1975)—from the “Naziploitation” films of the same era—e.g., Salon Kitty (1976), SS Extermination Love Camp (1977), The Gestapo's Last Orgy (1976). Both genres exploited the lingering sexual attraction of the Nazis while presenting them as repulsive specters that demand expulsion from the body politic.
The case for the post-political affects produced by film Nazis is well made in a chapter that pairs the all-too-familiar Inglourious Basterds (2009) with the relatively obscure Moloch (1999), an art film by Russian director Alexander Sokurov that portrays the banalities of a day in the life of Hitler and his entourage in 1942 at the Kehlsteinhaus (a mountain chalet close to the infamous Berghof). Both films “reveal the void at the center of the fascist fantasy” (p. 188); the Nazi is now more of a free-floating signifier of evil than an ideological countersign to democracy. The book closes with an analysis of recent heritage films, including four movies about the anti-Nazi resistance (from Norway, Denmark, France, and the Netherlands) and an extensive critique of Downfall (2004), the blockbuster hit about the last days in the Hitler bunker. All display a return to realism in film treatments but not to Cold-War ideological binaries. Rather, these recent films “functioned as a projection screen for pressing contemporary problems” (p. 217), such as the rise of Islamic fundamentalism, the crisis of legitimacy in the European Union, and the normalization of German history. In a gloomy statement on contemporary democracy, Hake concludes that these films reveal the decay of formerly cherished “European” values of secularism, pluralism, and multiculturalism; the substitution of individualism for political collectivism; and the abandonment of universal ethical norms for “an individually felt sense of right and wrong” (p. 220).
Most of the films discussed in the book are readily available online or through Netflix. Reading Hake's analysis and then watching, say, clips from Ilsa, She Wolf of the SS (1975) or streaming the entire Moloch can be a riveting but unsettling and even repugnant ordeal, which confirms her arguments about our abject fascination with the “fascist imaginary in post-fascist cinema” (p. 4)—even as the experience evokes admiration for the tenacious research that went into the book. Whether watching these films supports Hake's arguments about the production of democratic subjectivity is another question. At some point, readers might question the cognitive/affective film theory at the heart of so many of Hake's provocative assertions. The book takes much for granted about the way film supposedly produces affects that build audience subjectivities. Do heritage films—to take just one of Hake's arguments—really testify to the crises of European democracy, as she so skillfully asserts? Accepting this and other interpretations requires a significant leap of faith, since audience reception remains for the most part unexamined.
Relatively minor flaws undermine the book's accessibility. The theoretical discussions can be dense if not opaque, and rereading will reward the nonspecialist. The text is amply illustrated with film stills, but they are so small (barely the size of a thirty-five millimeter frame) as to be almost illegible. Two indices provide lists of films and peoples' names, but not concepts, events, or places. Though Hake thoroughly explains her goals and arguments in the introduction, there is no conclusion to bring the book together. Even so, Screen Nazis sets a very high bar for future research on film and feeling, National Socialism, historical memory, and political culture. The book deserves the widest possible readership—certainly across standard lines that divide historians from scholars of German studies—for its pessimistic explanation of why the Nazis remain prevalent in national cinemas, its theoretical moxie, and its unflinching take on the current state of western democracy.
