Even though the North Pole has been a remote and inaccessible place for most of human history, it has played an important role in cultural imaginaries, scientific thought and geopolitics for centuries, even millennia. Michael Bravo, senior lecturer in geography at the University of Cambridge and former director of the Scott Polar Research Institute, paints a vivid and multifaceted picture of the history of the North Pole in North Pole: Nature and Culture. Published in Reaktion Books’ Earth Series, North Pole is at once a contribution to historical scholarship and a book intended for a general audience.
Early on, Bravo makes it clear that North Pole ‘does not aim to tell a linear story charting the attempts of successive expeditions to reach the North Pole’ (p. 8). The book traces a longer history and has a wider scope than that, even though it is selective in its account. Bravo also emphasizes the conceptual and philosophical complexities inherent in the history of the North Pole. He repeatedly returns to the ways in which the North Pole has been conceived of as possessing a ‘mysterious power and allure’ (p. 10). Not only has the pole been attractive politically yet elusive scientifically, philosophically and navigationally, it has also been constructed as a place of metaphysical and spiritual importance. In addition, North Pole contains a wealth of beautiful illustrations – 111 in total.
Chapter 1 discusses the roles that the North Pole's celestial counterpart, the Pole Star, plays in the culture of the Inuit of the High Arctic and in ancient Greek culture. This is a valuable element in Bravo's account, detailing ideas and practices of non-Western cultures and thus avoiding the common focus on Western explorers. Chapter 2 discusses cosmographers and mapmakers of the sixteenth century, such as Peter Apian and Gemma Frisius. Particularly illuminating is the discussion of how the cosmographers utilized perspective and instruments to create the sensation of ‘gazing down on the world from the celestial pole’ (p. 51). The construction of this new aerial perspective coincided with European expansionism and imperial ambitions. Chapter 3 goes into the practical and philosophical problems of identifying and locating the North Pole, discussing William Gilbert's magnetic philosophy at length.
In Chapter 4 we approach the more familiar history of polar exploration from the early nineteenth century onward. Bravo discusses the political and economic incentives of reaching the North Pole as compared to finding the North West Passage. Not until the late nineteenth century, with its intensified imperial ambitions and strong nationalist ideologies, did attempts on the North Pole become more than ‘sporadic, one-off events’ (p. 126). Prior to that, reaching the pole was too difficult and dangerous to make sense to most investors and explorers. There were exceptions, though, such as Edward Parry's attempt in 1827. The chapter also emphasizes the importance of the publication of Arctic exploration narratives to gather public support for voyages. Chapter 5 continues the discussion of Arctic narratives but focuses on more speculative and sometimes politically dubious genres and contexts. Bravo shows that the North Pole continually attracted novelists, utopian philosophers and ideologues – from the polar utopia of Margaret Cavendish's The Blazing World (1666), to the Romantic critique of unchecked scientific ambition in Mary Shelley's Frankenstein (1818), to the speculations about the Arctic origins of the ‘Aryan race’ among white supremacists in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.
Chapter 6 brings us into the twentieth century and what has often been recognized as the first successful attempt to reach the North Pole (though this is disputed): Robert Peary's expedition in 1909. In the Victorian era, polar exploration had been constructed as an exceptionally masculine endeavour. Bravo pays particular attention to an article that Peary wrote in 1906, ‘The lure of the North Pole’. Peary presents himself as Heracles battling with Antaeus, thereby accentuating the masculine heroism of the attempt and ‘writing himself into a lineage of heroic imperial predecessors’ (p. 178). Bravo also emphasizes the paradoxical nature of the pole and polar history. On the one hand, the North Pole is a geographical point on Earth; on the other hand, it is a mysterious, sacred place with a transformative power reserved for the initiated few who have made the attempt. The duality of the physical and the metaphysical runs through the history of the North Pole, according to Bravo: ‘That the pole is in the Arctic, but not seamlessly of the Arctic, is the paradox of cosmography that has defined its place in human history since the Renaissance’ (p. 184).
The seventh and final chapter of the book discusses subsequent activities in and representations of the North Pole in the twentieth and twenty-first centuries, from Vilhjalmur Stefansson's attempts to integrate Arctic exploration more thoroughly with Inuit life, to present-day climate impacts in the Arctic and North Pole marathons. This chapter is more scattered than previous chapters, but given the brevity of the book compared to its scope, that is not surprising.
North Pole is a well-researched, engaging, illuminating and accessible book. Bravo's multi-genre, multidiscipline, and multimedia approach is especially welcomed; he strikes a good balance between accounts of scientific and philosophical experiments and speculations, the politics and practicalities of reaching the pole, and media and fictional representations. I also thoroughly appreciated the accounts of Inuit culture and ancient Greek culture in Chapter 1. However, I was left wondering how other non-Western cultures have conceptualized the North Pole. Bravo hints that the pole has ‘long been a powerful symbol as far back as the civilizations of ancient Greece, Egypt, India and Persia’ (p. 10), but – except for Greece – he does not develop this theme. In line with his original approach and eclectic material, Bravo also gives unexpected figures, such as Apian, comparatively much attention – with the consequence that usual characters, such as Peary's rival Frederick Cook, receive little attention. Bravo himself, however, explains in the introduction that North Pole is a short book and that he is necessarily selective. And while North Pole is selective, the comprehensiveness of Bravo's outlook and the attention given to unusual material is refreshing and will give readers familiar with the field new perspectives.
