Unconditional Equality is an effort toward conceptualizing Gandhi's politics by reference to the texts that he composed in his mother tongue, Gujarati. The book has obvious theoretical value since the English translation of Gandhi's works does not seem to be accurate, as the author points out. Hence there exists a gap which is “symptomatic of Gandhi's struggles to think his politics” (vii). On the basis of this claim, Skaria weaves together two major arguments seeking to address the possible gaps in our understanding of Gandhi's “religion of resistance” with reference to satyagraha, the nonviolent means of political struggle in the context of a nationwide campaign against colonialism. First, as satyagraha is driven by abhay (fearlessness), it creates conditions in which the participants imbibe the spirit of self-sacrifice. This argument has two ramifications: on the one hand, those who take part in satyagraha are inspired largely by their instinctive attachment to religion that insists on self-sacrifice for a noble cause; this also refers to the possibility, on the other hand, that individual response is clearly independent of the historical circumstances. The second major argument is about the instrument of satyagraha that Gandhi evolved in the context of his battle for racial equality for Indians in South Africa. Implicit here is a powerful critique of the conventional conceptual articulation of satyagraha in instrumental terms, ignoring its ideological thrust upholding the instinctive popular zeal to challenge political domination but also to fight against injustice in every walk of life. Satyagraha is thus a powerful ideological design contributing to a specific mindset, despite the odds.
Divided neatly into two parts, this book delves into a familiar arena of concern with a multitude of interesting details, culled from the original Gujarati texts. While part 1 dwells on how the idea of satyagraha emerged out of Gandhi's reading of various texts and also interaction with individuals, part 2 provides a threadbare analysis of the mechanism of satyagraha which the author prefers to call “the aneconomies of satyagraha.” This structural division is clearly conventional, although the analysis and also the interpretation of the sources direct us to a different terrain of understanding and conceptualization. Satyagraha is a unique Gandhian gift to individuals struggling for justice which is transcendental in character and spirit. It is therefore not surprising that satyagraha became a rallying point for those fighting for racial equality in the United States or confronting a brutal military junta in Myanmar in recent times.
Besides being an empowering instrument, satyagraha is also a device to purify “the inner self” by taking away the evil influences which, Gandhi believed, are an impediment to realizing truth. This is a unique conceptualization in which Gandhi evolved a model of political mobilization where morality remains a critical pillar of political obligation. Satyagraha thus became a creatively defined instrument of change involving individuals along with a collectivity of which they are part. Satyagraha can also be said to have emerged out of Gandhi's endeavor to synthesize Western liberal values with those which he construed as Indian. Implicit here is the assumption that the texture of satyagraha is not given but context dependent, which provides an explanation as to why the one-size-fits-all formula is inadequate to capture its specific nature. By reiterating some of these assumptions, Skaria underlines the importance of the text-context dialectics in conceptualizing an organically constituted ideology.
There is also a fundamental point that one hardly misses while critically evaluating Gandhi's political inclinations, despite not being always clear in spirit or direction. Skaria is no exception. Notwithstanding his claim that “the gap between the Gujarati and English texts… is symptomatic of Gandhi's struggles to think his politics” (vii), the fact remains that the basic texture of Gandhi's politics is derived from his concern for deifying and defying liberalism which he confronted first in South Africa and later India. One may come across situations which defy explanation in a typical liberal explanatory mold. Nonetheless, it is evident, as the available literature confirms, that Gandhi remains inspired by the Enlightenment philosophy of the British variety which was translated in his various nonviolent struggles that also drew on the fundamental ethos of multiple religions that existed in India. This was also the argument of Louis Fischer in his 1954 work on Gandhi: “ideologically, [Gandhi] stood with one foot in the individualism and nationalism of Europe's nineteenth century, and with the second in the remote age Hindustan's glory and obscurantism” (Gandhi: His Life and Message for the World [New American Library, 1954], 51). The most significant idea that Fischer highlighted is the importance of the individual vis-à-vis the community which is anathema in India's social customs. The other fundamental point integral to Gandhi's politics happens to be the desire “to reach out to and activate the soul of the opponent” (Bhikhu Parekh, Gandhi [Oxford University Press, 1997], 54), which means that for Gandhi a practitioner of satyagraha nurtures no prejudice, ill-will, or selfish motives while pursuing the struggle for change. Satyagraha is therefore characterized as a soul-driven force which derives its sustenance from suffering being inflicted on one's self for persuading the opponent because Gandhi believed that “if you want something really important to be done, you must not merely satisfy the reason, you must move the heart” (M. K. Gandhi, Satyagraha in South Africa [Navajivan, 2006], 105).
So, suffering is what moves the opponent's heart, which means that a satyagrahi begins a dialogue with his adversaries until, as Joan Bondurant argues, “persuasion has carried the conflict into mutually agreeable adjustment” (Conquest of Violence: The Gandhian Philosophy of Conflict [University of California Press, 1971], 197). Gandhi's way, as Erik H. Erickson argues, is that of “a double conversion: the hateful person, by containing his egotistic hate and by learning to love the opponent as human, will confront the opponent with an enveloping technique that will force, or rather permit, him to regain his latent capacity to trust and to love” (Gandhi's Truth: On the Origins of Militant Nonviolence [Norton, 1969], 437). For the Mahatma, the opponent was not to be despised, but treated as a fellow human being who failed to rise above narrow and partisan self-interests because of circumstances. Through his self-suffering, the satyagrahi inculcated a desire for self-examination in the opponent which ultimately instills in him a spirit of genuine good will.
In an otherwise well-written and well-argued book, Skaria makes a familiar point by consulting Gandhi's writings in original Gujarati which however provide neither a radically different perspective nor a substantially unique meaning to what the Mahatma conceptualized as politics. The fundamental pillars of Gandhi's politics remain the Kantian variety of liberalism that sought to creatively comprehend the individual-collective dialectics in the early part of industrial civilization when the notions of equality and freedom were being textured differently in politically volatile circumstances. What is commendable about the effort is the insistence on a context-driven analysis by reference to Gandhi's unique conceptualization of satyagraha which is, at one level, a form of politics with clear indigenous roots and, at another, a political response based upon the fundamental values of Western Enlightenment. The literature on Gandhi's religion of resistance is thus enriched.
