On 1 July 1997, British Hong Kong—including Hong Kong Island, Kowloon, and the New Territories—was formally transferred from British possession to the People’s Republic of China (PRC). According to the Sino-British Joint Declaration and the Hong Kong Basic Law, the area of Hong Kong would be renamed the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region (SAR), it would be granted a considerable amount of autonomy from PRC central government control during a transitional period under the “One China, two systems” principle, and the majority of international conventions applying to Hong Kong prior to 1 July 1997 would remain in force. The terms of the transfer were met with joy by some, trepidation by others. Yet for lawyers, policy-makers, and international organizations these terms engendered confusion, much of which remains today, over the true nature of Hong Kong’s autonomy and its status in international law. Wong’s book, Autonomy and Protection of Fundamental Rights in the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region attempts to address this confusion in two ways. First, Wong contextualizes Hong Kong’s status vis-à-vis the PRC and the international community within the greater legal and political discourse on concepts of sovereignty and self-determination. Second, by interrogating the nature of the “One China, two systems” policy through an examination of the status of individual rights derived from international and domestic legislation, Wong illustrates the problematic interplay between the PRC central government and the “independent” legal system of Hong Kong.
Chapter one briefly surveys the piecemeal nature of the British government’s acquisition of the territories of Hong Kong. In particular, Wong focuses on the sociopolitical conditions under which the Qing Dynasty government signed the three treaties ceding sovereignty of the region. Such background is obviously important for understanding the debate over Hong Kong’s status; however, at only eight pages, its efficacy is quite limited. A more thorough examination of the language of the treaties might have provided a better context for the later debates between Britain and the PRC over Hong Kong’s post-handover status. Chapter two briefly analyses these debates and then moves on to consider the effect of the handover on the status of Hong Kong in international law. Wong argues that, due to the principle of “One China, two systems”, the Hong Kong SAR’s autonomy does not fit well within any traditional concepts of international law. This unique nature is predicated on the fact that its autonomy is derived internationally from the Sino-British Joint Declaration and other pre-1997 conventions and domestically from PRC constitutional law. Hong Kong is technically a constitutive part of the PRC, yet it retains considerable authority to engage in international agreements related to commerce, trade, etc. Wong concludes that the Hong Kong SAR cannot be considered a “primary subject of international law but is instead a derivative or secondary subject, possessing a limited range of rights and duties valid vis-à-vis those other entities which have accepted its limited international personality” (p. 45). Chapter three considers Hong Kong’s right to self-determination and its continued autonomy within the contexts of international policies, primarily emanating from the United Nations, towards decolonized territories, as well as domestic policies between the PRC central government and the Hong Kong SAR. It is held that Hong Kong’s autonomy is less secure than typically thought, primarily due to the wording of the Sino-British Joint Declaration which merely binds China and Britain to ensure the perpetuation of Hong Kong’s “autonomy arrangements”, not its right to autonomy. Chapters four and five examine the status of international and domestic laws in Hong Kong after the handover. Of particular interest to chapter four is the status of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) and the International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights (ICESCR). By virtue of Hong Kong’s status as a dependent territory of the UK, Britain’s ratification of the two covenants in 1976 made them enforceable in Hong Kong. Furthermore, the PRC agreed to allow these covenants to remain in force after the handover, even though the PRC itself had yet to ratify the ICCPR. For Wong, this illustrates a case for the potential for human rights treaties to remain effective even through future sovereignty exchanges. Finally, chapter five examines the relationship between the domestic legal system of the PRC and the autonomous, common law legal system of Hong Kong, with particular reference to the protection of individual rights. Wong finds that the PRC has for the most part abided by the terms of the Sino-British Joint Declaration and the Hong Kong Basic Law. It has allowed for a separate legal system to remain operable, and domestic PRC legislation is, unless outlined in the Basic Law, not applicable to Hong Kong residents. Wong notes that one caveat to this is the power held by the Standing Committee of National People’s Congress to interpret the Hong Kong Basic Law, and by extension the scope of individual rights in Hong Kong.
In summary, Wong’s book provides a very useful analysis of the current legal status of Hong Kong in terms of both international law and domestic law. In so doing, Wong illustrates how the conceptual structure and functional dynamics of the Hong Kong SAR both problematizes traditional conceptions of autonomy in international law and offers potentially new categories.
