No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 July 2005
Wendy Pearlman is one of those rare individuals who are not hidebound by religious, ethnic, or national identities. An American Jewish woman who was raised in a typical fashion, she has demonstrated in Occupied Voices a remarkable empathy with the Palestinian people. She spent six months, from January to June 2000, in the occupied territories and then returned after the outbreak of the al-Aqsa intifada to conduct the interviews that form the substance of this book. During her initial half-year stay, Pearlman experienced firsthand the suffering and frustrations of the Palestinian people, writing that she came to appreciate “that Oslo's contradictions were untenable,” and “the Palestinian people, who were never consulted about Oslo, were being forced to pay the price” (pp. xiv–xv). In her brief introduction, she demonstrates accurate familiarity with virtually every relevant issue, from settlements to closure, water, the role of the United States, and so on.
This, then, is most definitely not the work of an uninformed ingénue, but it is also not the typical political analysis that is so plentiful. Occupied Voices is, instead, a unique book in which, by using the technique of voice and experience, Pearlman allows Palestinians to speak for themselves and relate their own experiences. Occupied Voices' most important contribution to our understanding of the Israeli–Palestinian conflict is its presentation of Palestinians as real human beings and the palpable feel of truth in their stories of the injustices they have sustained at Israel's hands. Put differently, the greatest value of this work is in its humanizing the Palestinians as well as making clear the reality of life under Israeli occupation and the farce of Oslo. This is no small achievement, given the widespread misrepresentations of Palestinians that exist in academe, government, the media, and society at large.
The interviews are divided into three sections, each consisting of six sets of interviews. Pearlman provides background to each interview that concisely contextualizes each story. Part 1 is titled “Generations of Intifada” and presents three generations of Palestinians whose stories situate the al-Aqsa intifada in a long struggle against dispossession and occupation. There is a grandmother activist who warmly recalls sharing holidays with her Jewish neighbors during the British Mandate. There is a mathematics professor who became a refugee when his family was forced to flee their home in 1948.
Part 2 is titled “Loss and Longing” and presents the stories of Palestinians whose lives have been transformed by the violence of the present chapter of the conflict. There is an interview with a mother and sister whose young son/brother was killed by Israeli soldiers. The depth and openness of their grief give the lie to the assertions that Palestinians rejoice when a loved one becomes a “martyr.” A particularly poignant interview in this section comes from a man whose house was bulldozed by Israeli soldiers.
Part 3 is titled “Faces of Everyday Resistance” and, in Pearlman's words, “takes us from these devastating instances of violence [parts 1 and 2] to the more veiled, everyday cruelties of life under military occupation” (p. xxvii). These include stories from a filmmaker, an agricultural engineer, a clinical psychologist, two shop owners, and two members of a theater troupe.
In an epilogue, Pearlman writes about returning to the occupied territories in 2003, the third year of the intifada, and revisiting the people she initially interviewed. She provides the reader with a brief account of how these Palestinians have been personally affected by the ongoing conflict. It is an appropriate and satisfying end to the book.
The underlying message of this collection, Pearlman avers, is that “every Palestinian man, woman, and child in the West Bank and Gaza has a story to tell about how his or her life has been affected by the Israeli occupation in general and the present Intifada in particular…. Together, the occupied voices in this volume issue forth a collective cry for freedom and the right to live with dignity. It should be clear to anyone who, in good faith, allows it to be heard” (p. xxviii). There will be those who condemn this book for being “one-sided,” “unbalanced,” “biased,” and so on. To them I wish to reply that there so many thousands of books telling the Israeli story from so many different perspectives—none of which is “balanced” with the Palestinian viewpoint—that to delegitimize a book that tells the Palestinian story is unreasonable, unfair, and un-American, and violates the most fundamental principle of academic freedom.
Pearlman writes that one of the purposes of this book is to counter prevalent misconceptions in the United States about the Israeli–Palestinian conflict. She has accomplished this objective admirably. All that remains is for it to be read. I recommend Occupied Voices for every level of education, including undergraduates, graduate students, and faculty, as well as for general readers. All will benefit from reading this fine book.