No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 23 September 2005
Beatrice Nicolini is assistant professor of the history and institutions of Africa, Faculty of Political Sciences, at Italy's Catholic University of Milan. The premise of her work is that during the first half of the 19th century, Makran, Oman, and Zanzibar constituted a “complex and interwoven system connecting merchandise, people and cultures” (p. 4). This system substantially occurred under the aegis of Sa

id ibn Sultan Al Bu Sa

idi (d. 1856), the famous regional ruler who moved both his political and economic bases from Muscat in Oman to Zanzibar during the 1830s and '40s. The inclusion of not so obvious Makran—roughly, coastal Baluchistan, currently divided between Pakistan and Iran—is intriguing. Nicolini stresses that Arab princes in both Oman and East Africa availed themselves of Baluchi slave and mercenary soldiers.
Also important in part 1 is a discussion of identity in coastal East Africa, the geographic linchpin of the study. Nicolini draws on a wealth of knowledge about eastern Africa to advance the broad scholarly debate about Swahili identity and distinctiveness. The diplomacy of Nicolini's coverage is exemplified by a linguistic observation: “Swahili is a Bantu language, and the term itself a Bantu word, but it derives also from the Arabic sahil, sawahil, belonging to the coasts” (p. 56). A wonderful example of Swahili distinctiveness is domestic architecture: in urban settings, the large, square stone dwellings of cosmopolitan Muslim merchants were equipped with bathing facilities, unlike Middle Eastern or North African towns that typically had public baths (pp. 67–68).
In part 2, Nicolini delves further into the archives, especially the English East India Company records, where she has found unused or underused documents. Part 2 has three chapters, plus a short conclusion. Chapter 4 covers the British obsession with the security of communication lines connecting India and London. Chapter 6 (skipping chapter 5 for the moment) discusses the not very effective Moresby Treaty of 1822 between Sa

id ibn Sultan and British India with regard to the abolition of the slave trade. The chapter also details Sa

id's efforts to placate and convince the British that the ancient custom of slavery was not damaging but, instead, essential to the collective well-being of local society (p. 146). This last chapter also introduces the United States' commercial interests in Zanzibar.
Chapter 5, covering the Swahili coast and particularly Zanzibar, is the heart of the book. Here Nicolini gives effective agency to Swahilis, hinterland Africans, Indians, Baluchis, and Arabs, even though the region was by then coming within the grasp of British dominance. The author describes Swahili slave society in considerable detail and traces a sequence of interrelated changes. Britain's initial attempts to restrict slave trading meant a reduced supply of African slaves. This happened just as the ivory market was growing, requiring laborers. Sa

id ibn Sultan was at that time eliciting heavy investments from merchants of Sind and Kutch to begin his clove plantations in Zanzibar, a labor-intensive project. These situations led to an increased reliance on Baluchi slaves.
Since European perceptions of Sa

id ibn Sultan are an explicit focus of the book, I was surprised by the absence of Sa

id's daughter, Salme. She married a European, took the name Emily Reute, lived as a widow in Germany, and wrote a book about growing up in Zanzibar. Her choices in life suggest types of European–Zanzabari contact beyond diplomatic notes and commercial wrangling.
The inevitable problem with including a large geographic or temporal expanse in a study of this kind is the invitation to specialists of the various subregions to quibble. My quibble has to do with the internal history of Oman and not so much with Europeans. In addition to the pull toward fertile, well-positioned Zanzibar, I (selfishly) would have liked more attention to the push from Oman. Sa

id chose to be an urban merchant prince, forsaking the tribal or religious (Ibadi Islamic) legitimacy of Oman's interior. The Muhawwidun, or Wahhabis, from central Arabia repeatedly threatened southeastern Arabia and, indirectly, the maritime health of Oman. Sa

id may have had as much reason to leave Muscat as he had to choose Zanzibar.
The book's apparatus (including a confusing bibliography and indexes that are too brief) is a bit disappointing and not up to Brill's past standards. In the important introductory pages, in the first twenty-five pages of the text, and again in parts of chapter 5, there is a problem with translation that overlaps with a problem of editing, which occasionally threatens to obscure the author's meaning.
This book should be of interest to all scholars working on the littorals of the western Indian Ocean, particularly those who appreciate a broad geopolitical context. Nicolini's approach is interdisciplinary and successfully so. The portions directly concerned with the Swahili coast are richest in detail and analysis.