The subject of this book, the sultanate of Aceh in the 17th century, has been one of the most extensively discussed places and periods in modern scholarship on Southeast Asian Islam. The author has an impressive command of this literature and thus is able to provide a solid introduction to the state of the field of these discussions for nonspecialists. Although bringing together in a single volume materials from a wide array of scattered sources in Acehnese, Malay, Arabic, Dutch, English, and French, the text nevertheless seems to offer rather little that could be considered to be a new contribution to the field. Much material has been previously covered by other scholars—including Lombard (1967), Reid (1979), and Ito (1984)—and all the primary sources used are published editions of relatively well-known texts, the sole exception being a manuscript entitled Safinat al-Hukkam from a personal collection in Banda Aceh. That is an 18th-century text (attributed to Jalal al-Din al-Turasani, a qadi under two successive Acehnese sultans) and mentioned only cursorily in the context of discussions of the legitimacy of female rule.
With such a focus on previously discussed material rather than new sources, readers might expect more extensive critical reinterpretation of the primary sources and their readings by earlier scholars. This aspect of the book, however, remains considerably underdeveloped. For example, the Acehnese epic Hikayat Malem Dagang was first remarked upon by Snouck Hurgronje (The Achenese) I:80–88), and later Leiden manuscripts of this text were edited and discussed in a Dutch dissertation by Cowan (1937). Hadi frames his comments on this narrative within a conversation on Acehnese understandings of jihad and religious conversion, which is something new, intriguing, and with considerable potential for contributing to discussions of the earlier Islamization of Southeast Asia. It is an area of inquiry that in itself deserves to be pursued more intensively in future research. Unfortunately, however, in this book the author does not go far enough in laying out the considerable historiographical and philological problematics involved in reading this text, particularly as he frequently moves between different versions of this narrative in various recensions in constructing his arguments about Acehnese understandings of Islamic identity.
Similarly, another area of possibility that falls short of its promise is in the sections dedicated to comparative analyses. Hadi chooses two main examples of Muslim polities to compare with 17th-century Aceh: the Malay maritime entrepôt of Malacca in the 15th century, and the agrarian Javanese kingdom of Mataram in the 17th. However, he does not provide any reasoned rationale to his readers as to why he chose these two states in particular, rather than others. Those familiar with the broader history of the region might think of other cases that have more obvious points of contact and contrast that would seem to offer points as useful—if not more so—for illuminating comparison: Patani with its own succession of sultanas in the late-16th and early-17th centuries, for example, or Banten as a maritime Muslim state with documented religious offices such as that of qadi in the 17th century, or even Makassar with its own complex interactions with the Portuguese (and later the Dutch) and connections to the Indian Ocean scholarly networks that were so important to the development of Islamic thought in Aceh in the 17th century.
The most problematic aspect of this work, however, is not a matter of particular textual analyses or its choice of comparative cases. Rather it is an issue on the conceptual level in its reified notion of an “Islamic state” and its frequent, unexamined references to an ahistoricized conception of “Islamic orthodoxy” supported only by footnotes to Gibb, Schacht, Lambton, and Ibn Taymiyya. These two essentializations frame the author's discussion of the Islamization of Acehnese society in the 17th century in ways that seem to have an implied télos of some unclarified characterization of a “full Islamic commitment” (p. 90) and the “completely” Islamic nature of Acehnese culture and social institutions (e.g., p. 237, pass.). This becomes especially confusing in the internal contradictions of his discussions of the role of Islamic law in the sultanate, where—after conflating 19th-century colonial observations with earlier textual sources—he concludes that “Islamic law was widely enforced” from several pages commenting on the widespread drinking of alcohol, the frequent application of punishments determined by local custom rather than fiqh, and the formal imposition of royal adat as law (pp. 167–84).
Such argumentation frequently evokes troubling turns of phrase including “unsurprisingly” (p. 93) and “there is every reason to believe” (p. 162) in ways that seem to suggest a direct correspondence between 17th-century Acehnese understandings of “orthodox Islam” and the author's own (but not fully elaborated here) 21st-century conceptions of what comprises an “Islamic state.” In this mode the text repeatedly invokes the notion of an Islamic state sometimes as an abstracted and purportedly uniform model of “the” medieval sultanate (p. 38) without ever really establishing either what this means or why it would even be an important or desirable touchstone to apply to the particular case of 17th-century Aceh.
Despite the conceptual limitations noted above, however, this book is useful as an extension and condensation of the existing literature on this subject, particularly for purposes of comparative study by those working on the history of Muslim societies outside of Southeast Asia.
