Dominic Symonds's We'll Have Manhattan: The Early Work of Rodgers & Hart covers composer Richard Rodgers and lyricist Lorenz Hart's first decade or so of collaboration: from amateur college and summer camp shows beginning in 1920, to their initial Broadway success, the Garrick Gaieties (1925), and to a forgotten show from 1931 called America's Sweetheart. All sixteen of Rodgers and Hart's Broadway musicals from this period are discussed, with single chapters devoted to four stand-out shows: Dearest Enemy (1925), The Girl Friend (1926), A Connecticut Yankee (1927), and Chee-Chee (1928). Three musicals written for London's West End are discussed as a group. Symonds also considers the pair's first brief foray to Hollywood but the book stops shy of Love Me Tonight (1932), a film musical some scholars hail as the new genre's first masterpiece. A planned second volume will cover Rodgers and Hart in the 1930s and early 1940s, including their best-known shows, such as On Your Toes (1936) and Pal Joey (1940).
Symonds's narrative moves with deliberate pace across an important half decade—1925 to the Crash—when the musical stage saw a definitive stylistic transition made in relation to changes in popular music and dance. A quote from Hart, taken from a 1929 newspaper interview, shows that the pair recognized how social changes and transformations in popular culture were moving in step one with the other: “Now the direct declaration of love in a song is passé. That's because the scene of the big emotional moment in the lives of young people has changed [from around the piano to inside a car]. If the girl plays the piano, she plays jazz. The piano tête-à-tête has gone, and there is a crowd dancing. . . . Words must have a lighter ring to them, but must appeal to the emotions of the dancing couple” (250). The story of how jazz—the contemporary name for syncopated popular music and dance—came to the Broadway stage is perhaps easiest to tell by way of the mid-Twenties musical comedies of George and Ira Gershwin, a team whose breakthroughs in New York and London, from Lady, Be Good! (1924) to Girl Crazy (1930), were almost exactly contemporaneous with Rodgers and Hart's. The Gershwins’ shows yielded an enduring catalog of popular songs that remain at the core of the so-called Great American Songbook, and in recent decades Gershwin tunes have been repeatedly repackaged for Broadway in “new” musicals evoking the 1920s—an acknowledgement that the original shows hosting these songs are un-revivable. By contrast, no “new” Rodgers and Hart shows have appeared, and the team's 1920s output does not, on the whole, contain their most enduring songs—at least to judge from the tunes from this era that have survived as standards. For example, the 1956 Verve double-LP Ella Fitzgerald Sings the Rodgers and Hart Songbook, with thirty-four tunes total, includes only thirteen (30 percent) from before 1931. Albums by noted Rodgers and Hart interpreters tilt strongly towards the pair's post-1932 repertoire: three of twelve songs (25 percent) on Barbara Cook's From the Heart—The Best of Rodgers and Hart (1959) and six of sixteen tunes (38 percent) on Dawn Upshaw Sings Rodgers and Hart (1996) date from the years Symonds covers.
And so, Symonds's book concerns long-forgotten shows and mostly obscure songs by creative figures who went on—in the years to be covered by Symonds's second volume—to make signature works of the musical stage and screen. In this sense, We'll Have Manhattan offers a detailed tale of two young men finding their way on Broadway and successfully writes little-known shows into the history of the American musical. Throughout the book, Symonds—like his subjects as he presents them—strives, in his words, “to recognize the balance between creative license and commercial exigency” (63).
Symonds approaches his subjects’ output along three organizing themes: collaboration (between Rodgers and Hart, with book writer Herbert Fields's consistent contribution noted but not explored in great detail); commercial constraints (framed primarily through the demands of producers and stars); and identity (the least developed strand in the book, mostly a matter of the duo's development of a definitely “American” voice). Symonds is especially informative on the commercial realities of 1920s Broadway: the substantive difference between cabaret and vaudeville shows and “legitimate” productions; the “significant slippage between forms and practices” among the musical genres of the time (109); how stars shaped all the genres on offer. His assessment of how American lyrics sung by British performers were received on the London stage is particularly astute.
As noted, the mid-1920s were a tipping point in musical style, and Symonds charts the lingering influence of European models, especially Gilbert and Sullivan, and emerging American trends, such as the Charleston, in Rodgers and Hart's work. Because Rodgers and Hart, unlike the Gershwins, were not on the cutting edge of these shifts, Symonds is able to isolate up-to-date nuances creeping into their songs and offers compelling evidence that such touches were intentional and strategic. For example, Symonds identifies the pair's agenda in London as “to write songs that were American-sounding to the British audience” (134) and then finds specific musical echoes of the Gershwins’ songs for London in Rodgers and Hart's. The only false note in Symonds’ discussions of Broadway songs and popular culture is his use of the word “gospel” to characterize songs like “Rise n’ Shine” from A Connecticut Yankee. Although numbers like this are clearly related to African American music, their lineage lies with up-tempo spirituals such as “All God's Chillun Got Shoes,” heard on the concert stage in the mid-1920s as sung by Roland Hayes and Paul Robeson. Gospel music as a composed category of black music and an improvisational performance practice grounded in the black church emerged nationally in the latter 1930s and on the Broadway stage as a performed sort of blackness only in the 1970s in shows such as Purlie (1970).
Throughout, Symonds calls Rodgers and Hart “the boys.” (A period source for this usage turns up late in the book, when a New York critic says in 1929, “A couple of boys they were four years ago, fourteen plays and they are grown up” [246].) Symonds's persistent use of “the boys” has two larger effects. First, it contains the male subjects of his narrative within an affectionate and endearing frame, a perhaps unlikely choice given Rodgers's well-known prickliness and Hart's much-discussed inner turmoil—both of which Symonds duly notes. Still, he insists throughout that “both boys had hearts filled with empathy, emotion, and humor” (9). Symonds likes “the boys,” and his evident love for their work gives the book at times a breezy tone. Academic writing on the Broadway musical poses the challenge of simultaneously addressing other scholars (with their disciplinary concerns) and musical theater fans (whose interest in reading about the genre underpins popular and scholarly publication in this area). For this reader, We'll Have Manhattan tilts a bit too far towards appreciative enthusiasm.
Second, calling Rodgers and Hart “boys” suggests that their 1920s efforts are merely preparation for more mature, by implication “man”-made, works to follow. Indeed, the book's final paragraph opens with the statement, “Finally, the boys had grown up” (265). It remains to be seen if Symonds's second volume will position Rodgers and Hart as innovators of the so-called integrated musical in the 1930s—a decade before Rodgers traded Hart for Oscar Hammerstein II and began writing shows such as Oklahoma! (1943), on which the history of the integrated musical has long been hung. The groundwork for such an argument has been laid, alongside a rhetorical connection between the stages of human development—from boyhood to manhood—and the “development” of the musical into a certain sort of aesthetically unified genre. (Leonard Bernstein famously made this argument on his Omnibus television show in the 1950s.) Still, Symonds's careful scholarship always stays close to the specifics of the production moment, and he rigorously grounds each show in its moment (see especially his explanation for why Chee-Chee closed after a short run). In addition, across the book Symonds complicates the historiography of the integrated musical in small ways, noting that “an aspiration toward credible dramatic works for the musical stage was an important element of the Broadway landscape even before the First World War” (23) and tacitly putting the notion of the integrated musical as a more “matured” form in scare quotes.
In whatever way Symonds chooses to frame “the boys’” later work, this first volume stands as a close, near comprehensive reading of a key stretch of years in the work of an important creative team and in the history of the American musical as a commercial genre embedded in the larger realm of popular music and dance.
