An old saw among professional wrestling fans says that the form's popularity is cyclical, cresting and falling across its sordid history—from a boom in the 1950s as wrestling proved an inexpensive option for early television networks, to the Hulkamania of the 1980s, to the Monday Night Wars of the 1990s. If that is true, the same could be said for scholarly interest in wrestling as well: it took more than forty years after Roland Barthes's “World of Wrestling” for Sharon Mazer to define the field of professional wrestling studies in the late 1990s with Professional Wrestling: Sport and Spectacle and nearly another decade before the volume Steel Chair to the Head (ed. Nicholas Sammond) gave pro wrestling studies the imprimatur of a major university press and showed the range of disciplinary perspectives through which wrestling might be (forgive the pun) grappled. But in the intervening years, as Eero Laine writes in Professional Wrestling and the Commercial Stage, the field has exploded, with the establishment of a Professional Wrestling Studies Association, dozens of articles, a dedicated journal, and at least two book-length works each year since 2016 (7).
In such a context, it seems difficult to sustain the claim that wrestling remains undertheorized, a claim that indeed seems to animate Laine's volume. Yet Laine is in many ways correct: the academy still does not, on the whole, take wrestling seriously; much extant wrestling scholarship is so widely scattered across disciplines so as to present challenges for synthesis; and—though he phrases this idea delicately—some of the scholarship seems obvious, or at least incomplete. He notes, for instance, the problem of reducing the complexity of “kayfabe” (the term given to the illusion of professional wrestling as an authentic athletic competition) to a binary of truth versus fiction; he seems ambivalent about the insights of scholarship linking wrestling to Donald Trump, because of course politics is like professional wrestling (“which is in some ways to say that of course politics is theatrical” [8]); he is skeptical, also, of the trap of studying popular culture by “search[ing] for and find[ing] immense truths about human nature . . . in the heart of popular or disposable forms of art” (3).
Laine's deceptively simple argument in Professional Wrestling and the Commercial Stage is that theatre studies ought to take wrestling seriously, if not on its own merits then at least as an exemplar of commercial, what he terms “productive,” theatre (21). In this, he suggests, the study of professional wrestling might be likened to the rise of musical theatre studies, perhaps lagging only a decade behind (5). But Laine, even as he identifies himself as a fan, is not interested in centering wrestling per se; instead, he is interested in its value as an “outsider example,” an “omission that reinforces the form” (4). In other words, Laine contends that what professional wrestling openly displays—the labor of performers, the links between characters and actors, the relationship between audience and performance, the profit motive—might direct us to what commercial theatre, conventionally imagined, obfuscates. What does the performed (but often still genuine) pain of wrestling tell us about the physical labor of theatrical performance generally? How might we understand the role of commercial interests in theatrical storylines? What is industry leader WWE (World Wrestling Entertainment) but a “publicly traded, transnational theatre company?” (4).
Taking a broadly Marxian approach, each chapter of Laine's monograph takes up an element of professional wrestling that has resonances with or implications for the study of commercial theatre. The opening chapter examines the circulation and sale of theatrical performances as a productive “good,” despite their ephemerality; a second chapter, perhaps the monograph's most inventive, turns criticism of wrestling's regressive storylines on its head by positing wrestling's problems with racism and misogyny as theatrical problems rather than problems with the wrestling form itself. Laine makes this case by examining two plays (The Elaborate Entrance of Chad Deity and Trafford Tanzi) that cast actors as professional wrestlers (and require them to wrestle rather than stage fight) to conclude that nearly all claims made against wrestling could be made against theatre. The interplay of form and content continues in the third chapter with an exploration of hardcore wrestling (where performers inflict real pain in the service of staged competition) as a site for examining the labor of performance generally, a focus likewise picked up in a fourth chapter that examines the overlap of a wrestler's character and self. Considering how wrestlers' bodies are simultaneously their own and not, “perform[ing] doubly as themselves and as the corporately owned likeness that bears an almost identical resemblance to them” (81) requires us to reckon with similar situations—different in degree, not kind—in which bodies are put to use (as when hired actors paint themselves to become the Blue Man Group) and made salable products. A final chapter considers WWE as a stock theatre company in two, punning senses—one, as a stock theatre troupe, traveling and performing shows from a repertoire; and two, as a publicly traded company with shareholders. WWE's transparency as a commercial enterprise invites questions about the relationship between live theatre and global capital. How do financial markets impact theatrical product, and vice versa?
Professional Wrestling and the Commercial Stage is a slim volume, which makes it more remarkable both that Laine covers so much territory and how adeptly he explains professional wrestling to noninitiates without alienating fellow travelers; his exploration of kayfabe (26–32), for instance, is perhaps the richest I have encountered in the literature of wrestling. Laine is, too, nearly encyclopedic in his grasp of the field's contours, capable of mining and synthesizing a century of disparate work in disparate fields.
But the book's value is greater even than a state of the discipline address because it intervenes in, enriches, and ties together key threads: from kayfabe, to debates about form versus content, to the relationship between wrestlers and their audience(s). Lucid and thoughtfully structured, Laine's monograph is a welcome contribution to a (yes, still) nascent field that poses a provocation: What if we have been thinking about professional wrestling all wrong? What if its abuses and its carny bona fides are not what make it undeserving of study? What if those criticisms are precisely why it is worth studying—laying bare, as Laine writes, “the extractive and exploitative business of global, financial capital” (108)?
